Posts: 1,963
Threads: 80
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
26
It's a no from me.
Sam seems to have lost the passion he had for the game. To me he has looked like a man who has underestimated the job and overestimated his powers in the modern game. A game that's moved on tactically since he's been away. A lot of players have not taken to his personality or methods and it's not a happy camp. Pretty poisonous in fact.
The rebuild job next year needs a man with energy and drive and new ideas. Sam feels like yesterday's man.
Posts: 17,074
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
02-15-2021, 09:42 AM
(This post was last modified: 02-15-2021, 09:53 AM by Derek Hardballs.)
(02-14-2021, 11:23 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (02-14-2021, 09:51 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (02-14-2021, 09:35 PM)TETLEY74 Wrote: (02-14-2021, 09:13 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (02-14-2021, 08:10 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: You are very much a misguided romantic. Stay in the Championship past the parachute payments and say hello to Blues as our new blueprint for failure perhaps even Sunderland or Ipswich as we slowly fall away to 90s shitedom again. Good luck enjoying those days again.
I genuinely don’t care if I’m honest Derek. If we stay in the Championship long we end up turning into a side that fights to survive at all costs at that level, before dropping into League One where we may well win games again.
I do not want to spend every weekend spending 90 minutes hoping the opposition won’t score on the off chance we may get a break and nick it and every conversation being about how this is the only way we can play to be successful.
We are one of 25 or so teams that will spend our entire history bouncing between 10th in the PL and the top 6 of League One regardless of who manages us. We aren’t going to win anything major and we aren’t going to ever regularly achieve anything other than a few years in the top flight watching out best players sold on. I’d much rather just enjoy the bloody day out regardless of division we’re in.
This, I just want to enjoy match days at the Hawthorns, experince the thrill and pleasure of us scoring goals and see us win games and personally don't care what league we're in. If I want to follow a team thats successful and wins things I wouldn't be supporting the Albion, but I do cause they're in my blood and I'll support them what ever league were in because that's what true fans do. That's not to say I don't want them to see us successful I do but I unless we are suddenly taken over by a mulit billionaire with money to burn it ain't going to happen.
My son in law supports Oxford utd and I've Been to see them at home about 4 times I've seen them win and loose, there's only about 6 or 7k there but the general atmosphere was fantastic, they know theyre never going to win the prem, storm Europe or win the FA CUP they know what they are but still are passionate about their club, that's how football should be.
Yeah it was great just before Megson arrived with a half empty stadium, getting thumped by Crewe, South End, Stockport etc... this harking back to some halcyon days where a few diehards enjoyed their day out regardless of how shit we were is really not a place o want the club to return anytime soon. Romantic, tosh not born out by personal experience where fans regularly booed the club off the pitch and tickets at local schools couldn’t even be given away for free!
No one was saying it was great, but it’s no different to seeing 4-5,000 empty seats under Pulis watching Huddersfield wallop us at home in the PL.
Some people watch sport because they want to win and see their team at the highest level at any cost, and I understand why they do, however several years of Pulis made me reevaluate and realise given we are unlikely to actually ever win more than a third of our games at the highest level, and unlikely to ever win a major cup, and the fact I don’t really get any more joy from beating Man United or Liverpool than any other team, what’s the point of pushing to be in the PL at all costs? And I really don’t care if the average bloke on the street in China or Nigeria know our club or not.
I want to support a team I feel connected to, that I feel represents the area me and my family come from and share those values. I want to see a side that enjoys playing football and the fans enjoy watching and supporting and one that goes into games believing it can compete and win by doing more than lining up on their goal goal line and lobbing a ball into the penalty box whenever they get a throw in or freekick within 50 yards of the opposition box.
The 90s were shite for the club and the nostalgia is simply down to being young and carefree at a great time to be in your teens and early 20s. We were going bust with the players bringing in their own food! I think it was reported we were losing 30k either a day or week in the clubs dark ages. You might not care and the 11-13k who attended many of which are no longer with us may have not minded, but clearly they did given the protests and general antipathy towards the club. Not wanting to compete at the top of the game simply damages the club, financially and on the pitch. It’s a short sighted attitude that as long as you’re entertained you’re happy... great until we are financially crippled and it’s just you and Josh watching us play Halesowen Town in the Dog and Duck Unibond league. I exaggerate but I’d rather not be also rana in the Championship or trying to get out the old third decision again playing pretty football.
(02-15-2021, 09:41 AM)richbaggie Wrote: It's a no from me.
Sam seems to have lost the passion he had for the game. To me he has looked like a man who has underestimated the job and overestimated his powers in the modern game. A game that's moved on tactically since he's been away. A lot of players have not taken to his personality or methods and it's not a happy camp. Pretty poisonous in fact.
The rebuild job next year needs a man with energy and drive and new ideas. Sam feels like yesterday's man.
The players who are moaning should remind themselves of the form they have shown for twelve months. Bilic was lovely I’m sure to the players and yet the poor results stretch back to this time last year. Players always moan and bitch when they aren’t picking up results that’s just what they do. Next season will see new players and a new league where it will see it far easier to pick up points and suddenly that poisonous atmosphere will disappear as the players get their egos rubbed.
Posts: 5,322
Threads: 356
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
More I think about it, the less I would want him here next season.
The football model that made him successful, seems to me be a thing of the past. The club with the benevolent owner who allows the manager a budget way beyond what the club can actually afford. Both Bolton and Blackburn are examples of that, there is no prospect of a generous owner being able to find football clubs to live beyond their means indefinitely.
These days, clubs like ours need to be self sufficient. Developing players both homegrown and bought in, who can generate funds to re invest in the club, is the way to go.
I don't think Allardyce is the man for this type of management.
As a short term solution fine, but it needs to be short term.
Posts: 1,963
Threads: 80
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
26
(02-15-2021, 09:42 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (02-14-2021, 11:23 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (02-14-2021, 09:51 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (02-14-2021, 09:35 PM)TETLEY74 Wrote: (02-14-2021, 09:13 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: I genuinely don’t care if I’m honest Derek. If we stay in the Championship long we end up turning into a side that fights to survive at all costs at that level, before dropping into League One where we may well win games again.
I do not want to spend every weekend spending 90 minutes hoping the opposition won’t score on the off chance we may get a break and nick it and every conversation being about how this is the only way we can play to be successful.
We are one of 25 or so teams that will spend our entire history bouncing between 10th in the PL and the top 6 of League One regardless of who manages us. We aren’t going to win anything major and we aren’t going to ever regularly achieve anything other than a few years in the top flight watching out best players sold on. I’d much rather just enjoy the bloody day out regardless of division we’re in.
This, I just want to enjoy match days at the Hawthorns, experince the thrill and pleasure of us scoring goals and see us win games and personally don't care what league we're in. If I want to follow a team thats successful and wins things I wouldn't be supporting the Albion, but I do cause they're in my blood and I'll support them what ever league were in because that's what true fans do. That's not to say I don't want them to see us successful I do but I unless we are suddenly taken over by a mulit billionaire with money to burn it ain't going to happen.
My son in law supports Oxford utd and I've Been to see them at home about 4 times I've seen them win and loose, there's only about 6 or 7k there but the general atmosphere was fantastic, they know theyre never going to win the prem, storm Europe or win the FA CUP they know what they are but still are passionate about their club, that's how football should be.
Yeah it was great just before Megson arrived with a half empty stadium, getting thumped by Crewe, South End, Stockport etc... this harking back to some halcyon days where a few diehards enjoyed their day out regardless of how shit we were is really not a place o want the club to return anytime soon. Romantic, tosh not born out by personal experience where fans regularly booed the club off the pitch and tickets at local schools couldn’t even be given away for free!
No one was saying it was great, but it’s no different to seeing 4-5,000 empty seats under Pulis watching Huddersfield wallop us at home in the PL.
Some people watch sport because they want to win and see their team at the highest level at any cost, and I understand why they do, however several years of Pulis made me reevaluate and realise given we are unlikely to actually ever win more than a third of our games at the highest level, and unlikely to ever win a major cup, and the fact I don’t really get any more joy from beating Man United or Liverpool than any other team, what’s the point of pushing to be in the PL at all costs? And I really don’t care if the average bloke on the street in China or Nigeria know our club or not.
I want to support a team I feel connected to, that I feel represents the area me and my family come from and share those values. I want to see a side that enjoys playing football and the fans enjoy watching and supporting and one that goes into games believing it can compete and win by doing more than lining up on their goal goal line and lobbing a ball into the penalty box whenever they get a throw in or freekick within 50 yards of the opposition box.
The 90s were shite for the club and the nostalgia is simply down to being young and carefree at a great time to be in your teens and early 20s. We were going bust with the players bringing in their own food! I think it was reported we were losing 30k either a day or week in the clubs dark ages. You might not care and the 11-13k who attended many of which are no longer with us may have not minded, but clearly they did given the protests and general antipathy towards the club. Not wanting to compete at the top of the game simply damages the club, financially and on the pitch. It’s a short sighted attitude that as long as you’re entertained you’re happy... great until we are financially crippled and it’s just you and Josh watching us play Halesowen Town in the Dog and Duck Unibond league. I exaggerate but I’d rather not be also rana in the Championship or trying to get out the old third decision again playing pretty football.
(02-15-2021, 09:41 AM)richbaggie Wrote: It's a no from me.
Sam seems to have lost the passion he had for the game. To me he has looked like a man who has underestimated the job and overestimated his powers in the modern game. A game that's moved on tactically since he's been away. A lot of players have not taken to his personality or methods and it's not a happy camp. Pretty poisonous in fact.
The rebuild job next year needs a man with energy and drive and new ideas. Sam feels like yesterday's man.
The players who are moaning should remind themselves of the form they have shown for twelve months. Bilic was lovely I’m sure to the players and yet the poor results stretch back to this time last year. Players always moan and bitch when they aren’t picking up results that’s just what they do. Next season will see new players and a new league where it will see it far easier to pick up points and suddenly that poisonous atmosphere will disappear as the players get their egos rubbed.
Agree with all that Derek.
However, a manager has to be held with respect to be able to manage effectively. Doesn't have to be liked, but definitely has to be respected.
There is little of that and that's a big problem.
Posts: 17,074
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(02-15-2021, 10:01 AM)richbaggie Wrote: (02-15-2021, 09:42 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (02-14-2021, 11:23 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (02-14-2021, 09:51 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (02-14-2021, 09:35 PM)TETLEY74 Wrote: This, I just want to enjoy match days at the Hawthorns, experince the thrill and pleasure of us scoring goals and see us win games and personally don't care what league we're in. If I want to follow a team thats successful and wins things I wouldn't be supporting the Albion, but I do cause they're in my blood and I'll support them what ever league were in because that's what true fans do. That's not to say I don't want them to see us successful I do but I unless we are suddenly taken over by a mulit billionaire with money to burn it ain't going to happen.
My son in law supports Oxford utd and I've Been to see them at home about 4 times I've seen them win and loose, there's only about 6 or 7k there but the general atmosphere was fantastic, they know theyre never going to win the prem, storm Europe or win the FA CUP they know what they are but still are passionate about their club, that's how football should be.
Yeah it was great just before Megson arrived with a half empty stadium, getting thumped by Crewe, South End, Stockport etc... this harking back to some halcyon days where a few diehards enjoyed their day out regardless of how shit we were is really not a place o want the club to return anytime soon. Romantic, tosh not born out by personal experience where fans regularly booed the club off the pitch and tickets at local schools couldn’t even be given away for free!
No one was saying it was great, but it’s no different to seeing 4-5,000 empty seats under Pulis watching Huddersfield wallop us at home in the PL.
Some people watch sport because they want to win and see their team at the highest level at any cost, and I understand why they do, however several years of Pulis made me reevaluate and realise given we are unlikely to actually ever win more than a third of our games at the highest level, and unlikely to ever win a major cup, and the fact I don’t really get any more joy from beating Man United or Liverpool than any other team, what’s the point of pushing to be in the PL at all costs? And I really don’t care if the average bloke on the street in China or Nigeria know our club or not.
I want to support a team I feel connected to, that I feel represents the area me and my family come from and share those values. I want to see a side that enjoys playing football and the fans enjoy watching and supporting and one that goes into games believing it can compete and win by doing more than lining up on their goal goal line and lobbing a ball into the penalty box whenever they get a throw in or freekick within 50 yards of the opposition box.
The 90s were shite for the club and the nostalgia is simply down to being young and carefree at a great time to be in your teens and early 20s. We were going bust with the players bringing in their own food! I think it was reported we were losing 30k either a day or week in the clubs dark ages. You might not care and the 11-13k who attended many of which are no longer with us may have not minded, but clearly they did given the protests and general antipathy towards the club. Not wanting to compete at the top of the game simply damages the club, financially and on the pitch. It’s a short sighted attitude that as long as you’re entertained you’re happy... great until we are financially crippled and it’s just you and Josh watching us play Halesowen Town in the Dog and Duck Unibond league. I exaggerate but I’d rather not be also rana in the Championship or trying to get out the old third decision again playing pretty football.
(02-15-2021, 09:41 AM)richbaggie Wrote: It's a no from me.
Sam seems to have lost the passion he had for the game. To me he has looked like a man who has underestimated the job and overestimated his powers in the modern game. A game that's moved on tactically since he's been away. A lot of players have not taken to his personality or methods and it's not a happy camp. Pretty poisonous in fact.
The rebuild job next year needs a man with energy and drive and new ideas. Sam feels like yesterday's man.
The players who are moaning should remind themselves of the form they have shown for twelve months. Bilic was lovely I’m sure to the players and yet the poor results stretch back to this time last year. Players always moan and bitch when they aren’t picking up results that’s just what they do. Next season will see new players and a new league where it will see it far easier to pick up points and suddenly that poisonous atmosphere will disappear as the players get their egos rubbed.
Agree with all that Derek.
However, a manager has to be held with respect to be able to manage effectively. Doesn't have to be liked, but definitely has to be respected.
There is little of that and that's a big problem.
I would argue that says a lot about the character of some of our players rather than the manager. What have many of them achieved compared Allardyce? They got Bilic sacked, many look completely out of their depth in the Prem and nearly bottled promotion. Perhaps it’s the players who need to moan about themselves and not give themselves so much respect?
Posts: 1,963
Threads: 80
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
26
(02-15-2021, 10:17 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (02-15-2021, 10:01 AM)richbaggie Wrote: (02-15-2021, 09:42 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (02-14-2021, 11:23 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (02-14-2021, 09:51 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Yeah it was great just before Megson arrived with a half empty stadium, getting thumped by Crewe, South End, Stockport etc... this harking back to some halcyon days where a few diehards enjoyed their day out regardless of how shit we were is really not a place o want the club to return anytime soon. Romantic, tosh not born out by personal experience where fans regularly booed the club off the pitch and tickets at local schools couldn’t even be given away for free!
No one was saying it was great, but it’s no different to seeing 4-5,000 empty seats under Pulis watching Huddersfield wallop us at home in the PL.
Some people watch sport because they want to win and see their team at the highest level at any cost, and I understand why they do, however several years of Pulis made me reevaluate and realise given we are unlikely to actually ever win more than a third of our games at the highest level, and unlikely to ever win a major cup, and the fact I don’t really get any more joy from beating Man United or Liverpool than any other team, what’s the point of pushing to be in the PL at all costs? And I really don’t care if the average bloke on the street in China or Nigeria know our club or not.
I want to support a team I feel connected to, that I feel represents the area me and my family come from and share those values. I want to see a side that enjoys playing football and the fans enjoy watching and supporting and one that goes into games believing it can compete and win by doing more than lining up on their goal goal line and lobbing a ball into the penalty box whenever they get a throw in or freekick within 50 yards of the opposition box.
The 90s were shite for the club and the nostalgia is simply down to being young and carefree at a great time to be in your teens and early 20s. We were going bust with the players bringing in their own food! I think it was reported we were losing 30k either a day or week in the clubs dark ages. You might not care and the 11-13k who attended many of which are no longer with us may have not minded, but clearly they did given the protests and general antipathy towards the club. Not wanting to compete at the top of the game simply damages the club, financially and on the pitch. It’s a short sighted attitude that as long as you’re entertained you’re happy... great until we are financially crippled and it’s just you and Josh watching us play Halesowen Town in the Dog and Duck Unibond league. I exaggerate but I’d rather not be also rana in the Championship or trying to get out the old third decision again playing pretty football.
(02-15-2021, 09:41 AM)richbaggie Wrote: It's a no from me.
Sam seems to have lost the passion he had for the game. To me he has looked like a man who has underestimated the job and overestimated his powers in the modern game. A game that's moved on tactically since he's been away. A lot of players have not taken to his personality or methods and it's not a happy camp. Pretty poisonous in fact.
The rebuild job next year needs a man with energy and drive and new ideas. Sam feels like yesterday's man.
The players who are moaning should remind themselves of the form they have shown for twelve months. Bilic was lovely I’m sure to the players and yet the poor results stretch back to this time last year. Players always moan and bitch when they aren’t picking up results that’s just what they do. Next season will see new players and a new league where it will see it far easier to pick up points and suddenly that poisonous atmosphere will disappear as the players get their egos rubbed.
Agree with all that Derek.
However, a manager has to be held with respect to be able to manage effectively. Doesn't have to be liked, but definitely has to be respected.
There is little of that and that's a big problem.
I would argue that says a lot about the character of some of our players rather than the manager. What have many of them achieved compared Allardyce? They got Bilic sacked, many look completely out of their depth in the Prem and nearly bottled promotion. Perhaps it’s the players who need to moan about themselves and not give themselves so much respect?
Once again I don't disagree although I don't think it's healthy that vast swathes think the man in charge is a bit of a twat. The only way around that is for the manager to completely gut the squad and get his own men in.
My original post very much stands about Sam's appetite for all this. His age, his heart issues and the pandemic all seem to have taken away the passion he clearly used to have.
Posts: 10,272
Threads: 694
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
I think this thread is premature. Can we wait and see before deciding our view.
Based on so far, we've been awful under him, but he's got his blokes in now so let's see.
Posts: 10,866
Threads: 497
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
23
(02-15-2021, 11:15 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: I think this thread is premature. Can we wait and see before deciding our view.
Based on so far, we've been awful under him, but he's got his blokes in now so let's see.
This.
Posts: 17,074
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
02-15-2021, 11:23 AM
(This post was last modified: 02-15-2021, 11:26 AM by Derek Hardballs.)
(02-15-2021, 10:25 AM)richbaggie Wrote: (02-15-2021, 10:17 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (02-15-2021, 10:01 AM)richbaggie Wrote: (02-15-2021, 09:42 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (02-14-2021, 11:23 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: No one was saying it was great, but it’s no different to seeing 4-5,000 empty seats under Pulis watching Huddersfield wallop us at home in the PL.
Some people watch sport because they want to win and see their team at the highest level at any cost, and I understand why they do, however several years of Pulis made me reevaluate and realise given we are unlikely to actually ever win more than a third of our games at the highest level, and unlikely to ever win a major cup, and the fact I don’t really get any more joy from beating Man United or Liverpool than any other team, what’s the point of pushing to be in the PL at all costs? And I really don’t care if the average bloke on the street in China or Nigeria know our club or not.
I want to support a team I feel connected to, that I feel represents the area me and my family come from and share those values. I want to see a side that enjoys playing football and the fans enjoy watching and supporting and one that goes into games believing it can compete and win by doing more than lining up on their goal goal line and lobbing a ball into the penalty box whenever they get a throw in or freekick within 50 yards of the opposition box.
The 90s were shite for the club and the nostalgia is simply down to being young and carefree at a great time to be in your teens and early 20s. We were going bust with the players bringing in their own food! I think it was reported we were losing 30k either a day or week in the clubs dark ages. You might not care and the 11-13k who attended many of which are no longer with us may have not minded, but clearly they did given the protests and general antipathy towards the club. Not wanting to compete at the top of the game simply damages the club, financially and on the pitch. It’s a short sighted attitude that as long as you’re entertained you’re happy... great until we are financially crippled and it’s just you and Josh watching us play Halesowen Town in the Dog and Duck Unibond league. I exaggerate but I’d rather not be also rana in the Championship or trying to get out the old third decision again playing pretty football.
(02-15-2021, 09:41 AM)richbaggie Wrote: It's a no from me.
Sam seems to have lost the passion he had for the game. To me he has looked like a man who has underestimated the job and overestimated his powers in the modern game. A game that's moved on tactically since he's been away. A lot of players have not taken to his personality or methods and it's not a happy camp. Pretty poisonous in fact.
The rebuild job next year needs a man with energy and drive and new ideas. Sam feels like yesterday's man.
The players who are moaning should remind themselves of the form they have shown for twelve months. Bilic was lovely I’m sure to the players and yet the poor results stretch back to this time last year. Players always moan and bitch when they aren’t picking up results that’s just what they do. Next season will see new players and a new league where it will see it far easier to pick up points and suddenly that poisonous atmosphere will disappear as the players get their egos rubbed.
Agree with all that Derek.
However, a manager has to be held with respect to be able to manage effectively. Doesn't have to be liked, but definitely has to be respected.
There is little of that and that's a big problem.
I would argue that says a lot about the character of some of our players rather than the manager. What have many of them achieved compared Allardyce? They got Bilic sacked, many look completely out of their depth in the Prem and nearly bottled promotion. Perhaps it’s the players who need to moan about themselves and not give themselves so much respect?
Once again I don't disagree although I don't think it's healthy that vast swathes think the man in charge is a bit of a twat. The only way around that is for the manager to completely gut the squad and get his own men in.
My original post very much stands about Sam's appetite for all this. His age, his heart issues and the pandemic all seem to have taken away the passion he clearly used to have.
I would happily gut and rebuild the squad, it's flimsy, lacks leadership, controlled aggression, organisation and defensive discipline. No surprise that the entire midfield was dropped bar Pereira on Saturday and we looked a lot better for it. I'm not sure you can judge passion or interest properly given the circumstances of the pandemic and empty stadia etc. I doubt he will want to go out of the game with a whimper but we shall see.
My main reason for wanting him to stay is I think he's a good bet to get us back up with a better balanced team for a scrap to survive the subsequent season. I also want the club sold to an owner that has some ambition for the club and that's a lot easier to achieve in the Prem than out of it given the OTT money Lai and co spent buying us. I don't believe in projects or long term visions when you have an owner who wants out if the rumours of a sale are true. I cannot see how a club like ourselves can be both self sufficient and be competitive without the parachute money that yo-yoing enables us. I read and listen to people say bring through the youth, build a squad etc but our best players get poached for peanuts and we will be left with the next rung of players who may be good enough to bobble around the Championship but certainly not the Prem take Harper and Leko as perfect examples. The same with these 'young hungry mangers' who are complete gambles when we aren't in a position to gamble away our future at this time. It may mean we hit the jackpot it may mean we are on our uppers in three season's time. You can argue that's the case with any manager but you have to minimise the risk when we are potentially at such a crossroads in our clubs history.
(02-15-2021, 11:15 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: I think this thread is premature. Can we wait and see before deciding our view.
Based on so far, we've been awful under him, but he's got his blokes in now so let's see.
Of course it is and I'm being a tad provocative in a very dull season  That said if you gave me the choice between Allardyce and Appleton next season given our circumstances I would choose the former. I have always thought our squad wasn't good enough for the Prem so whatever happens between now and the end of the season in terms of our form doesn't unduly concern me.
Posts: 13,569
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
We've gone from 3 points off 17th to 12 points of 17th in 11 games under him, performances seem worse, and he's not managed a Championship side in 9 years when he hardly pulled up trees with West Ham. No thank you.
|