Blame the people. Jeez. Just what they want. Majority of people had a Christmas unrecognisable to previous years. To suggest that 2 days at Christmas is the reason for the rise in cases is frankly a bit silly. The seasonal spike in respiratory cases has played out just like previous years with a drop 2nd week in Jan.
But it's those pesky minority that have screwed it all up. Come on
Posts: 8,954
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
02-14-2021, 04:03 PM
(This post was last modified: 02-14-2021, 04:04 PM by baggy1.)
(02-14-2021, 03:22 PM)woodman Wrote: Blame the people. Jeez. Just what they want. Majority of people had a Christmas unrecognisable to previous years. To suggest that 2 days at Christmas is the reason for the rise in cases is frankly a bit silly. The seasonal spike in respiratory cases has played out just like previous years with a drop 2nd week in Jan.
But it's those pesky minority that have screwed it all up. Come on
Read the above post about lockdowns and the timing before you go with the 'it's just the normal winter' bollox. The amount of people that are saying it's seasonal are the same people that were saying it's gone back in September. We had 5.6k more deaths than average in the 4th week of Jan, 5.4k in the 3rd week, 4.2k in the 2nd and 5.6k in the 1st, what's this bollox about the normal 2nd week of Jan?
And still no actual solutions, I'll ask again, what would you have done differently from September onwards?
Posts: 17,074
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
02-14-2021, 04:16 PM
(This post was last modified: 02-14-2021, 05:07 PM by Derek Hardballs.)
(02-14-2021, 04:03 PM)baggy1 Wrote: (02-14-2021, 03:22 PM)woodman Wrote: Blame the people. Jeez. Just what they want. Majority of people had a Christmas unrecognisable to previous years. To suggest that 2 days at Christmas is the reason for the rise in cases is frankly a bit silly. The seasonal spike in respiratory cases has played out just like previous years with a drop 2nd week in Jan.
But it's those pesky minority that have screwed it all up. Come on
Read the above post about lockdowns and the timing before you go with the 'it's just the normal winter' bollox. The amount of people that are saying it's seasonal are the same people that were saying it's gone back in September. We had 5.6k more deaths than average in the 4th week of Jan, 5.4k in the 3rd week, 4.2k in the 2nd and 5.6k in the 1st, what's this bollox about the normal 2nd week of Jan?
And still no actual solutions, I'll ask again, what would you have done differently from September onwards?
Do you really want this uncannily similar debate to the one you had with Billy Basset before Christmas? It’s the same ludicrous arguments dressed up in an odd mixture of don’t insult me, I just want a debate, I’m cleverer / more perceptive than you and ignoring anything that was inconvenient to the facts presented by reliable sources.
Posts: 8,954
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
I know Dekka, after the past few months of it I like to highlight the little one liners hidden away in the posts when they arise though. It is depressingly similar though and Woody / Billy want to debate the points without being shut down but seem incredibly unable to debate those same points when given the opportunity.
Posts: 3,488
Threads: 101
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
5
The liquidator Wrote:baggy1 Wrote:And still no actual solutions to the problem Woody, there are some points in there where it does surprise me that you don't join up the dots. How can an opposition party have any power if they don't have any MPs to vote against the govt, and you seem to have little idea about the points Starmer has raised (futile as it is); MPs have always taken expert opinion on what to do both procedurally and in specific situations - can you really imagine Gavin Williamson making decisions based on his gut feeling and overriding expert opinion; fuck me, Hancock has made out he decided to order extra vaccines early because he saw it in a film, i suspect there may be a bit of make believe in that decision to act unilaterally.
You ask for debate and at the first sign of one you whinge about the nasty man calling me nasty names. And if you think that anybody thinks that we won't have long term problems from the decisions made then you are mistaken, we are all aware of the issues around public and private finances, long term health issues (both physical and mental), and know it is going to be painful, but you don't have any solutions to these problems or are able to suggest the better way of doing things.
The reason we are here in another lockdown is because of the shambles right at the start which caused more problems than it solved. The govt basically said we'll be ok we're British, and then it blew up in their faces. And then when they got it under control they rolled the dice again to try and win back some of what they lost in the 1st wave, and lost again. And then to top it off they decided that when it was obvious we were heading for record hospitalisations they decided to let everyone have a couple of days off for Christmas.
What would you have done differently from September onwards?
On the Xmas thing baggy 1 NOBODY forced anyone to break the rules or meet up.... I had a choice too we didn't as a family so others made that decision to put their family at risk.... Some refuse to take personal responsibility and just put it back on the government and say they said we could do it.... Its a easy way out of taking personal responsibility
Exactly why this cowardly government should have led and locked down and not given them a choice or the big build up - we are in a global pandemic so we need clarity and leadership yet we have never had much of either.
The Christmas shame killed and maimed tens of thousands.
Not sure what the problems are with someone just joining in with the discussion who has a different point of view. I think I've provided a number of pts that I believe are valid, you've basically ignored most of what I've said. You may not agree but as I said on another thread closing down debate is seen as de rigour along with the labelling.
From my short time here I think you've jumped on someone who has asked a few different questions with the same single pov. I'm in the US at the moment and state by state things are very different and provides a different perspective. NPIs across the board provide many different datasets on what has hasn't worked.
Obviously you guys have this thread all sewn up so I think I'll stop and discuss it else where with some more open minded folk.
Be seeing you
Posts: 17,074
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(02-14-2021, 05:48 PM)woodman Wrote: Not sure what the problems are with someone just joining in with the discussion who has a different point of view. I think I've provided a number of pts that I believe are valid, you've basically ignored most of what I've said. You may not agree but as I said on another thread closing down debate is seen as de rigour along with the labelling.
From my short time here I think you've jumped on someone who has asked a few different questions with the same single pov. I'm in the US at the moment and state by state things are very different and provides a different perspective. NPIs across the board provide many different datasets on what has hasn't worked.
Obviously you guys have this thread all sewn up so I think I'll stop and discuss it else where with some more open minded folk.
Be seeing you
You aren’t providing anything to back your opinions up with and you aren’t answering any questions.
Posts: 8,954
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
(02-14-2021, 05:48 PM)woodman Wrote: Not sure what the problems are with someone just joining in with the discussion who has a different point of view. I think I've provided a number of pts that I believe are valid, you've basically ignored most of what I've said. You may not agree but as I said on another thread closing down debate is seen as de rigour along with the labelling.
From my short time here I think you've jumped on someone who has asked a few different questions with the same single pov. I'm in the US at the moment and state by state things are very different and provides a different perspective. NPIs across the board provide many different datasets on what has hasn't worked.
Obviously you guys have this thread all sewn up so I think I'll stop and discuss it else where with some more open minded folk.
Be seeing you
Are you having trouble sleeping - you seem to post on threads in the middle of the night for someone in the States. Strange thing I've noticed is that using my work vpn I can look like I'm posting from Chicago, mad isn't it.
You cried when you were shut down and when given the opportunity to debate you say you have an opinion based on, well that's not clear, but you seem to ignore facts. The problem is that this isn't a debate on should Livermore play or not, this is a debate about why people are acting stupidly which is causing deaths, so when you show complete ignorance of reality and then vaguely mention other opinions based on research that you don't seem to be forthcoming with it does make you look a little daft.
Anyway it's been interesting listening to someone who seems to think that this is normal for this time of year, it reaffirms my view that people will always see what they want to see.
Posts: 1,058
Threads: 51
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
3
Was there a Christmas spike due to mixing? Might not be that simple.
‘However, a closer look at the numbers suggests this trend was already happening and was probably caused by the new, more infectious variant of the virus rather than increased contact between people’.
‘the sharp increases seen between the 20 and 30 December cannot be attributed to the holiday.
In the first few days of 2021, cases continued to rise at the same pace as before Christmas…’
‘"I actually can't see any convincing evidence that Christmas actually did anything to make things worse at all, but trying to prove it definitely, one way or another, is not necessarily that easy," says Paul Hunter, a professor at the University of East Anglia's medical school.
His mathematical modelling suggests cases have increased in line with trends that were happening before households starting mixing over Christmas.’
‘The spread of the new, more infectious variant across the country which would result in spikes regardless of Christmas bubbles.’
Unless, of course, these are the experts we shouldn’t believe. !
www.bbc.co.uk/news/55669736
Posts: 8,954
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
02-15-2021, 09:41 AM
(This post was last modified: 02-15-2021, 09:44 AM by baggy1.)
It's an interesting and debatable point JOK, but there is one thing that is definite, there was an increase in cases happening well before Christmas that we could see clearly. The govt were determined to give everyone Christmas, Boris didn't want the headlines of being the grinch. I'd even said on here that we would hit the same peak as April around Christmas day. So whereas the lockdown should have happened well before Christmas, it was delayed until 6th Jan - that was a mistake that didn't need to be made because we had lessons from the 1st wave.
So the debate shouldn't be 'Did Christmas make a shit situation worse or not', it should be 'why didn't we try and avoid the shit situation in the 1st place'. Relaxing rules with nearly 20k in hospital is stupid. If we'd have locked down mid December we'd have kept the peak of hospitalisations down below 23k, the govt let it keep rising due to inaction and peak at around 34k.
|