Posts: 4,043
Threads: 149
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
10
(02-12-2021, 02:32 PM)strawman Wrote: (02-12-2021, 01:58 PM)hudds Wrote: (02-12-2021, 01:15 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (02-12-2021, 01:05 PM)baggy1 Wrote: What the fuck are you on about, you start by telling us to "Pay your tax drones" which implies we just go along brainlessly with the rules and pay taxes blindly, whilst you, on the other hand, are somehow superior as you don't agree with, or do, that. You show yourself up to be a right fucking nugget at times.
Somehow superior? No.
Just one of maybe two or three people on here who don't expect the country's problems to be solved by the state continually dipping its hand in my pocket. That doesn't render me superior, it just illustrates that I don't think the state is a benign force in my life and certainly not in my wallet.
There have been plenty of posters on here who've often stated they'd happily pay more tax. That's a far more morally-superior-on-point statement to make. But I doubt any of them have actually ever written an additional cheque to HMRC.
You can't pay more tax than you are legally obliged to pay so you can't simply "write another cheque to HMRC". It would be bounced (or if paid on line, reimbursed). You can pay more on the "on "account" of course, but the end of year declaration is what you have to pay.
The issue really is whether one uses tax avoidance (legal) and to what extent. The other thing is that one could vote for a party that proposed tax increases in the manifesto.
I pay more tax than I could probably avoid. FWIW.
I believe you can still make donations via the Commissioners for the Reduction of the National Debt and the Donations and Bequests Account unless that has also been cancelled I didn't know about that. I'll send a tenner.
Things for me that we have learned this year:
- We have no clear long term plan on how to handle our ageing population and their health
- The needs of the elderly and infirm always come before the needs of the young and healthy
- The NHS has been run into the ground for the last 10 years reducing bed numbers and ICU places, doctors and nurses to such an extent we now can't cope with a respiratory virus
- All the money we've spunked for no good reason means the future growth of our young/climate sectors/technological change etc will now be put on hold
- Our political framework is so broken it's a disgrace. Career politicians will do almost anything through the PR machine to feed us a bunch of half truths and lies
- The opposition parties have been without question the most useless set of pandering tossers who simply have not the power or the ability to hold the govt to account
- We've left a political framework, the EU, to enable us to vote people into power who can make decisions we want, but as we've seen there are 100s of faceless scientists and bureaucrats who we didn't elect making all the decisions.
- Covid has given a large section of the public a pedestal on which they can spout their holier than thou shite as if their view is somehow more worth of discussion than others
- The govt and our tech friends have set the precedent for removing freedom of speech from our democracy (such as it is). The handcuffing of Ofcom, twitter/FB etc
- Social media is a thread of unhappy, unconstructive nonsense. Without them the world would be a happier place.
- The majority have completely lost perspective due to the media frenzy cooked up and this frenzy will not go away. Our response to the next virus/thing will be as equally frenzied, perspectiveless, undemocratic and out of proportion
- Paper currency will end soon
- People's lack of responsibility for their own health - I'm talking lifestyle choices here - and passing that burden onto society has amplified the affect of the virus - until people stop shoving crap down their throats and do some more exercise things will only get worse. But then McDonalds can stay open but Covid safe gyms can't.....
Posts: 8,954
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
(02-12-2021, 03:26 PM)woodman Wrote: Things for me that we have learned this year:
- We have no clear long term plan on how to handle our ageing population and their health -
True, very hit and miss with care homes due to underfunded regulators not having the resource to check up on the condition.
- The needs of the elderly and infirm always come before the needs of the young and healthy -
A bit simplistic and naive if you don't mind me saying, it's been explained many times about how protecting the NHS from being overrun by the pandemic means that less people die and that it isn't only the elderly in hospital. Lockdown is a last measure only in place because of the complete failure of government to have been prepared and resourced, and the reactionary way the pandemic has been handled. There literally is no other choice.
- The NHS has been run into the ground for the last 10 years reducing bed numbers and ICU places, doctors and nurses to such an extent we now can't cope with a respiratory virus
- As much as I agree with the run into the ground part, the majority of the world hasn't been able to cope with coronavirus, this isn't unique to the UK.
- All the money we've spunked for no good reason means the future growth of our young/climate sectors/technological change etc will now be put on hold
- Agree, some of the spend on PPE and dodgy contracts has been incredulous.
- Our political framework is so broken it's a disgrace. Career politicians will do almost anything through the PR machine to feed us a bunch of half truths and lies -
Agree, the warnings were there with Brexit, but it seems that is what the public want.
- The opposition parties have been without question the most useless set of pandering tossers who simply have not the power or the ability to hold the govt to account -
Again, a bit naive, the opposition only has any power when they can force issues through votes. Because the Tory majority is so big then they are powerless and again this is what the public wanted. Starmer has raised many issues over public spending, called for early (and therefore shorter) lockdowns, and challenged the cabinet on many points, but without the threat of being able to block any govt vote the cabinet can just giggle away and say and do what they want.
- We've left a political framework, the EU, to enable us to vote people into power who can make decisions we want, but as we've seen there are 100s of faceless scientists and bureaucrats who we didn't elect making all the decisions. -
A complete misunderstanding of how the country has always worked. None of the cabinet are experts in their field and they will always take advice on what to do, this may be from chosen specialists or career under-secretaries and department advisors. That's always been the way, you've probably not come across it before.
- Covid has given a large section of the public a pedestal on which they can spout their holier than thou shite as if their view is somehow more worth of discussion than others -
When the discussion becomes repetitive nonsense that has been shown to be wrong in understanding and by what has subsequently happened (e.g. Yeadon: The virus has gone now, We have herd immunity) then they will get shut down - people are wise to the bullshit now.
- The govt and our tech friends have set the precedent for removing freedom of speech from our democracy (such as it is). The handcuffing of Ofcom, twitter/FB etc
- Paranoia, sorry but if you think the gvt have any control over Twitter and Facebook again that is just naive.
- Social media is a thread of unhappy, unconstructive nonsense. Without them the world would be a happier place.
- Agreed
- The majority have completely lost perspective due to the media frenzy cooked up and this frenzy will not go away. Our response to the next virus/thing will be as equally frenzied, perspectiveless, undemocratic and out of proportion -
I would say that the majority of the population, although weary, agree with the approach. This is shown through general compliance, which indicates that your undemocratic point is based more on your personal viewpoint and not the majority of the population.
- Paper currency will end soon
- Possibly, banks have been pushing that for a while and it takes away an avenue for criminals to operate so the authorities may go down that route. Soon is a subjective term, I can't see it happening in the next decade.
- People's lack of responsibility for their own health - I'm talking lifestyle choices here - and passing that burden onto society has amplified the affect of the virus - until people stop shoving crap down their throats and do some more exercise things will only get worse. But then McDonalds can stay open but Covid safe gyms can't.....
- I would generally agree, however you have to look at history for the reasons. I'm in my early 50s and remember smoking being allowed anywhere, anyone older than me will have been part of a generation that were told smoking was ok, that generation will disappear gradually. And phraseology is interesting in your second part, why not covid safe McDonalds allowed as well as covid safe gyms. I do agree that there should be better education but the eaters of crap are todays smokers of yesteryear, that takes education and time.
Some reasonable points in there woody and then some where you completely misunderstand what has happened.
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
(02-12-2021, 05:45 PM)baggy1 Wrote: (02-12-2021, 03:26 PM)woodman Wrote: Paper currency will end soon
- Possibly, banks have been pushing that for a while and it takes away an avenue for criminals to operate so the authorities may go down that route. Soon is a subjective term, I can't see it happening in the next decade.
Some reasonable points in there woody and then some where you completely misunderstand what has happened.
I think you've completely missed who the greatest beneficiaries of the demise of paper currency would be baggy1.
Posts: 17,074
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(02-12-2021, 05:45 PM)baggy1 Wrote: (02-12-2021, 03:26 PM)woodman Wrote: Things for me that we have learned this year:
- We have no clear long term plan on how to handle our ageing population and their health -
True, very hit and miss with care homes due to underfunded regulators not having the resource to check up on the condition.
- The needs of the elderly and infirm always come before the needs of the young and healthy -
A bit simplistic and naive if you don't mind me saying, it's been explained many times about how protecting the NHS from being overrun by the pandemic means that less people die and that it isn't only the elderly in hospital. Lockdown is a last measure only in place because of the complete failure of government to have been prepared and resourced, and the reactionary way the pandemic has been handled. There literally is no other choice.
- The NHS has been run into the ground for the last 10 years reducing bed numbers and ICU places, doctors and nurses to such an extent we now can't cope with a respiratory virus
- As much as I agree with the run into the ground part, the majority of the world hasn't been able to cope with coronavirus, this isn't unique to the UK.
- All the money we've spunked for no good reason means the future growth of our young/climate sectors/technological change etc will now be put on hold
- Agree, some of the spend on PPE and dodgy contracts has been incredulous.
- Our political framework is so broken it's a disgrace. Career politicians will do almost anything through the PR machine to feed us a bunch of half truths and lies -
Agree, the warnings were there with Brexit, but it seems that is what the public want.
- The opposition parties have been without question the most useless set of pandering tossers who simply have not the power or the ability to hold the govt to account -
Again, a bit naive, the opposition only has any power when they can force issues through votes. Because the Tory majority is so big then they are powerless and again this is what the public wanted. Starmer has raised many issues over public spending, called for early (and therefore shorter) lockdowns, and challenged the cabinet on many points, but without the threat of being able to block any govt vote the cabinet can just giggle away and say and do what they want.
- We've left a political framework, the EU, to enable us to vote people into power who can make decisions we want, but as we've seen there are 100s of faceless scientists and bureaucrats who we didn't elect making all the decisions. -
A complete misunderstanding of how the country has always worked. None of the cabinet are experts in their field and they will always take advice on what to do, this may be from chosen specialists or career under-secretaries and department advisors. That's always been the way, you've probably not come across it before.
- Covid has given a large section of the public a pedestal on which they can spout their holier than thou shite as if their view is somehow more worth of discussion than others -
When the discussion becomes repetitive nonsense that has been shown to be wrong in understanding and by what has subsequently happened (e.g. Yeadon: The virus has gone now, We have herd immunity) then they will get shut down - people are wise to the bullshit now.
- The govt and our tech friends have set the precedent for removing freedom of speech from our democracy (such as it is). The handcuffing of Ofcom, twitter/FB etc
- Paranoia, sorry but if you think the gvt have any control over Twitter and Facebook again that is just naive.
- Social media is a thread of unhappy, unconstructive nonsense. Without them the world would be a happier place.
- Agreed
- The majority have completely lost perspective due to the media frenzy cooked up and this frenzy will not go away. Our response to the next virus/thing will be as equally frenzied, perspectiveless, undemocratic and out of proportion -
I would say that the majority of the population, although weary, agree with the approach. This is shown through general compliance, which indicates that your undemocratic point is based more on your personal viewpoint and not the majority of the population.
- Paper currency will end soon
- Possibly, banks have been pushing that for a while and it takes away an avenue for criminals to operate so the authorities may go down that route. Soon is a subjective term, I can't see it happening in the next decade.
- People's lack of responsibility for their own health - I'm talking lifestyle choices here - and passing that burden onto society has amplified the affect of the virus - until people stop shoving crap down their throats and do some more exercise things will only get worse. But then McDonalds can stay open but Covid safe gyms can't.....
- I would generally agree, however you have to look at history for the reasons. I'm in my early 50s and remember smoking being allowed anywhere, anyone older than me will have been part of a generation that were told smoking was ok, that generation will disappear gradually. And phraseology is interesting in your second part, why not covid safe McDonalds allowed as well as covid safe gyms. I do agree that there should be better education but the eaters of crap are todays smokers of yesteryear, that takes education and time.
Some reasonable points in there woody and then some where you completely misunderstand what has happened.
I certainly don't misunderstand. Some of your rebuttals about naivety or misunderstanding could equally be levelled against your view. Difference is I wouldn't suggest that you are naive or you misunderstand things. I believe you think that way and that's absolutely fine.
Again as I said before when the first response of anyone in a debate is to personalise it as a way as to discredit the person rather than the view is typical of where we are now and for me is deeply problematic. Dogma, repetitive messaging, personalisation and tagging people with labels is what Brexit and Covid has given us I'm happy with the way I conduct myself.
As for some of your pts I think the main area you could think about are how when put under complete strain through Brexit, Covid and the lack of clear opposition the flaws that exist in the system, like any system, become exposed more clearly for what they are even if they've always existed. When those flaws become fissures we get poor decision making, lack of perspective, reductive politics and poor motives and ethics.
All of these we have seen and why the one liners that I've posted may not be perfectly worded but hit home.
Unfortunately for all of us the long term impact of the last 12 mths , and I'm not taking about covid health, will be felt for years to come and most not all of what has happened will have negative consequences for us all.
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
Protheroe Wrote:baggy1 Wrote:woodman Wrote:Paper currency will end soon
- Possibly, banks have been pushing that for a while and it takes away an avenue for criminals to operate so the authorities may go down that route. Soon is a subjective term, I can't see it happening in the next decade.
Some reasonable points in there woody and then some where you completely misunderstand what has happened.
I think you've completely missed who the greatest beneficiaries of the demise of paper currency would be baggy1.
You might need to explain who they are, to me anyway! (I don't fancy a world with all that crypto nonsense as the new stock exchange).
Posts: 1,058
Threads: 51
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
3
(02-13-2021, 11:59 AM)woodman Wrote: (02-12-2021, 03:26 PM)woodman Wrote: We've left a political framework, the EU, to enable us to vote people into power who can make decisions we want, but as we've seen there are 100s of faceless scientists and bureaucrats who we didn't elect making all the decisions. -
- People's lack of responsibility for their own health ... until people stop shoving crap down their throats and do some more exercise things will only get worse. But then McDonalds can stay open but Covid safe gyms can't.....
Again as I said before when the first response of anyone in a debate is to personalise it as a way as to discredit the person rather than the view is typical of where we are now and for me is deeply problematic.
Who are these people we could “Vote into power” in the E.U.? You could only vote for MEPs. The power and decision making processes are in the hands of unelected officials. Also, politicians are not put into office to “do what we want” but supposedly do what is best for us. People want to stuff themselves with “Covid friendly” McDonalds” is that a good thing? What is our parliamentary democracy then, if not to vote in people into power?
How is B1 supposed to counter any of your views without referring to your ‘personal’ jottings? If you are suggesting he is belittling you, in this instance, I believe you are mistaken.
Posts: 13,569
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
(02-13-2021, 02:00 PM)JOK Wrote: (02-13-2021, 11:59 AM)woodman Wrote: (02-12-2021, 03:26 PM)woodman Wrote: We've left a political framework, the EU, to enable us to vote people into power who can make decisions we want, but as we've seen there are 100s of faceless scientists and bureaucrats who we didn't elect making all the decisions. -
- People's lack of responsibility for their own health ... until people stop shoving crap down their throats and do some more exercise things will only get worse. But then McDonalds can stay open but Covid safe gyms can't.....
Again as I said before when the first response of anyone in a debate is to personalise it as a way as to discredit the person rather than the view is typical of where we are now and for me is deeply problematic.
Who are these people we could “Vote into power” in the E.U.? You could only vote for MEPs. The power and decision making processes are in the hands of unelected officials.
The power and decisions are made in the Council, i.e. the governments of the European Union members, and ratified, scrutinised or blocked by the Parliament, which is directly elected.
People seriously overestimate how much sway the Commission has, they're a glorified Civil Service. They are there to hold members to account and draft legislation, not make decisions. If I wanted something done at EU level the Commission would be the last place I'd ask. I'd lobby the Council or I'd engage with bodies within their relative competencies first.
(02-13-2021, 02:00 PM)JOK Wrote: (02-13-2021, 11:59 AM)woodman Wrote: (02-12-2021, 03:26 PM)woodman Wrote: We've left a political framework, the EU, to enable us to vote people into power who can make decisions we want, but as we've seen there are 100s of faceless scientists and bureaucrats who we didn't elect making all the decisions. -
- People's lack of responsibility for their own health ... until people stop shoving crap down their throats and do some more exercise things will only get worse. But then McDonalds can stay open but Covid safe gyms can't.....
Again as I said before when the first response of anyone in a debate is to personalise it as a way as to discredit the person rather than the view is typical of where we are now and for me is deeply problematic.
Who are these people we could “Vote into power” in the E.U.? You could only vote for MEPs. The power and decision making processes are in the hands of unelected officials. Also, politicians are not put into office to “do what we want” but supposedly do what is best for us. People want to stuff themselves with “Covid friendly” McDonalds” is that a good thing? What is our parliamentary democracy then, if not to vote in people into power?
How is B1 supposed to counter any of your views without referring to your ‘personal’ jottings? If you are suggesting he is belittling you, in this instance, I believe you are mistaken.
My point was that our sovereignty was supposed to be what we would claw back through Brexit. Ok actuality we've given it to another bunch of unelected power hungry bureaucrats who have no accountability to the public whatsoever.
As for B1 he can say what he likes but starting with naive and misunderstood in a bunch of quick one liners is basically a kop out. The blinkers are on before people take time to consider. Response immediately follows stimulus. B1 is no different to many now who seem to think they now have a pulpit to inculcate from when actually we should all be able to debate healthily without fear of being labelled a remainer, covidiot, lockdown fanitic , lockdown denier. It's so facile. Short time on this forum shows me it's rife here too. No surprise.
|