The license fee
Fantastic post
Reply
Agree with much of what you say.

Putting aside the politics of the Beeb I dont see why a mixed income situation wouldnt work. Some channels/stations could be subscription, some take advertising and some neither being funded by the other 2 methods.
Most of BBC output is in direct competion with commercial channels and can hardly be described as public service broadcasting.
Reply
(02-09-2021, 08:23 PM)Fulham Fallout Wrote: Anyhow.....

There are no letters “s” in the word “licence”.

(02-09-2021, 08:19 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Woke the new ‘it’s political correctness gone mad’ term used by the same people that also use the word snowflake and the terms cancel culture. They seem oblivious to their wish to cancel things they don’t like such as a lot of the output of the BBC. Or trying to stop the National Trust erm telling the history of a building and its owners both good and bad.

What they really want like a subscription algorithm to Netflix is their own little echochamber, that doesn’t rock the boat with what they believe, what they like or what they think.

(02-09-2021, 06:58 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(02-09-2021, 06:03 PM)LIMABAGGIE Wrote: BBC is Woke garbage and needs to be tossed to the toilet of History.

Definition of “woke” - alert to injustice in society, especially racism..

Makes you wonder why people like Lima would have a problem with that...

Lima also seems to be antilockdown, pro Covid conspiracy theory...

Don’t get me started on the cunts that work for National Trust.
Oi! I volunteer for National Trust. And I'm not a cunt.
Reply
(02-09-2021, 11:15 PM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote:
(02-09-2021, 08:23 PM)Fulham Fallout Wrote: Anyhow.....

There are no letters “s” in the word “licence”.

(02-09-2021, 08:19 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Woke the new ‘it’s political correctness gone mad’ term used by the same people that also use the word snowflake and the terms cancel culture. They seem oblivious to their wish to cancel things they don’t like such as a lot of the output of the BBC. Or trying to stop the National Trust erm telling the history of a building and its owners both good and bad.

What they really want like a subscription algorithm to Netflix is their own little echochamber, that doesn’t rock the boat with what they believe, what they like or what they think.

(02-09-2021, 06:58 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(02-09-2021, 06:03 PM)LIMABAGGIE Wrote: BBC is Woke garbage and needs to be tossed to the toilet of History.

Definition of “woke” - alert to injustice in society, especially racism..

Makes you wonder why people like Lima would have a problem with that...

Lima also seems to be antilockdown, pro Covid conspiracy theory...

Don’t get me started on the cunts that work for National Trust.
Oi! I volunteer for National Trust. And I'm not a cunt.

I think a few on here volunteer for the National Front.

In all seriousness, what's wrong with National Trust employees? We're some of them female and Polish and complained about you leering?
Reply
(02-09-2021, 08:53 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(02-09-2021, 08:07 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(02-09-2021, 07:23 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: The BBC is involved with the commercial sector, you do realise that right? In fact, all the "woke" programming that you don't like is derived directly from BBC Studios (which is profitable despite being hamstrung by the government) and private commercial partners that BBC Studios holds a stake in. It's literally the public service stuff that the license fee needs to cover. And they've been working with HBO, Disney and Amazon to produce programming through BBC Studios who are also pretty big commercial entities, not sure you've heard of them.

It's the public service requirements that the BBC needs to cover by law that the license fee covers.

Calm the fuck down. When have I ever complained about "woke programming"? Sanitised, meaningless, half a story news coverage yes, but I've never used the word "woke".

If the BBC needs the license fee to cover public service programming then why does it need so many channels? So many radio stations? So much online content that it's completely hollowed out local journalism?

It's like every other subsidised behemoth. It grows like an ameoba into the deepest darkest recesses of broadcasting crowding out everything it comes across.

Great news about BBC Studios (and Worldwide - yes I am aware) - they culd be spun off so the BBC can concentrate on its core duty eh?.....

You're complaining about the Beeb's programming, shows commissioned by the BBC in recent times have been insanely popular and award winning. Fleabag, Killing Eve, Peaky Blinders, Normal People, Line of Duty, Good Omens, A Teacher, The Night Manager etc. Then there's stuff like Taskmaster or Traces that were done through BBC Studios via UKTV Play.

Worldwide is covered by Studios, and given that BBC Studios' profit effectively subsidises the public service obligation of the BBC as a whole I think spinning them off would be stupid as the license fee would go up to cover the shortfall from the commercial arm which would still be needed to cover public service obligations.

As for "many channels and radio stations", what? Four, News 24, CBBC and CBeebies are all obvious so I don't need explain why they're public service broadcasting. Alba is for Scots Gaelic language programming and then the license fee also goes to S4C with their agreement with BBC Cymru, minority protected language programming is definitely a public service. Radio 3 and Radio 6 are for arts and culture, the former for older stuff and the latter for newer stuff and I think it's again pretty obvious how preservation and growth of domestic culture is a public service with music having as much a need for preservation and growth than architecture. Radio 4 Longwave is needed for long distance broadcasting which is why it has the shipping forecast. Then there's minority language radio stations which do the same as the TV channels, and local radio which is a local service with news, radio and current affairs that may be relevant to local residents but would never be broadcast in national news especially with time constraints. Don't think I need to spell out why World Service is classed a public service. And then there's BBC News as a whole. That's what the license fee covers, and that's where the cuts have been focused (see BBC Three anywhere?). That's how much the public service obligation has grown and evolved. I don't watch Scottish Gaelic or Welsh stuff, nor do I listen to classical music or jazz but I understand why it's important to ensure they're broadcast.

That leaves us with BBC One, BBC Two, Radio 1, Radio 2, Radio 4 and Radio 5. Radio 5 needs to be there otherwise Talksport will have a monopoly on commercial sports radio which isn't good and the other 5 are the things watched and listened to the most so cutting them is damn near impossible.

And local journalism has been hollowed out due to the unprofitably of newspapers and the monopoly of Reach PLC, not the BBC which is oftentimes the last place that local news is aired. One of my local papers has essentially folded after the Mirror bought them and decided to solely focus on Coventry as the towns and villages south of Coventry are unprofitable, that's not the BBCs fault. And if not for the BBC local news a local family wouldn't have been able to lobby the government over a child needing to get medicine that was banned due to stupid American politics to help save his life.
Terrific post, Borin.
What I'd say...if I had your stamina!

I'd add that I doubt very much that those who claim they don't use any BBC service are correct.
Reply
(02-09-2021, 10:12 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(02-09-2021, 09:13 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(02-09-2021, 08:31 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(02-09-2021, 08:19 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Woke the new ‘it’s political correctness gone mad’ term used by the same people that also use the word snowflake and the terms cancel culture. They seem oblivious to their wish to cancel things they don’t like such as a lot of the output of the BBC. Or trying to stop the National Trust erm telling the history of a building and its owners both good and bad.

What they really want like a subscription algorithm to Netflix is their own little echochamber, that doesn’t rock the boat with what they believe or what they think.

(02-09-2021, 06:58 PM)Duffers Wrote: Definition of “woke” - alert to injustice in society, especially racism..

Makes you wonder why people like Lima would have a problem with that...

Lima also seems to be antilockdown, pro Covid conspiracy theory...

And here you go again, pigeonholing people into groups.

I don’t want to cancel the bbc, I just don’t believe in a licence fee for it. My dislike of the licence fee does not mean I want to cancel the national trust’s explanation of history. I don’t buy Netflix for an echo chamber, I occasionally subscribe to binge watch a series for a month. Most people are not in these ‘groups’ of opinion DH. You sound like someone from the far right, obsessed with pigeonholing people. It’s frankly weird.

I never said you did. The reply was to others like Lima who did use the term Woke and others who use the term snowflake and cancel culture on here.

How does criticising those who can’t see their own hypocrisy with regards to wanting to shut down an establishment or completely change it because they don’t like what it either stands for or produces or both and use silly terms like cancel culture and woke make me sound far right?

(02-09-2021, 08:39 PM)woodman Wrote: BBC ITV and Sky news have been shown up for what they are over the last year. Just the political voice of whatever party or paper pays the most to their cronies.

Disgraceful scaremongering in the last year, no objective expression , poor journalism and facile reporting..

All of them can be disbanded for all.I.care they have been shown up.for what they really are at a time when we needed them most.

What have they been scaremongering about?

Silly terms like woke? You literally discussed it’s meaning above as awareness of social injustices... now it’s a silly term? Which is it?

I said your tendency to pigeonhole people into groups is like someone from the far right. That’s what they do. And your post above literally describes people who use the words woke and cancel culture as the same people who... etc etc, listing things about the national trust etc. That’s pigeonholing people into a type. Just because they think some aspects of life have gone a bit ‘woke’.

In terms of my personal feelings, I was using this as an example that people can strongly dislike the tv licence but it doesn’t mean I want to cancel the bbc, as ‘these types’ do, according to you.

On the wider point of ‘wokeness’, what I would say is this (this probably gets the thread moved to the politics board!). The example someone gave earlier about a BBC writer being asked to put social justice themes in their writings is an example of how the bbc has gone. Their output is very focussed on identity politics. That’s not the main reason I’ve gone off the bbc, I just think it’s become dumbed down, and I don’t think the licence works for reasons I’ve mentioned above. However, I do think it’s gone overboard on identity politics (as has sky etc, the beeb ain’t the only one, far from it). The vast majority of people want a fairer society. I’m a labour voter who has very strong views on properly funding the nhs, public services, fairer taxation. I think I’d agree with you on many of these types of point. I do however think that equality through identity politics has gone some way to masking the largest inequality in this country - class and wealth. And I believe when wokeness is too prevalent, it serves to divide, not bring people together. It emphasises differences, rather than bringing us together on our common traits. That’s not to say it’s bad, but it can go too far IMO. It’s a complex subject and it’s important to understand that perspectives of minorities are unique in their circumstances, but I do believe it has become the primary focus of achieving a more equal society, whereas class is the biggest factor, by a mile.

Many people dislike wokeness for this reason (see Jonathan pie videos, he explains it better than I ever could), and unfortunately people who say this(see Lima above) instantly get digs of racism thrown at them. That’s a nonsense. The bbc IMO are way too obsessed with identity politics, but they’re no different to sky and c4 etc, that’s not my reason for disliking the licence. I say that because I believe it can become divisive, and do more harm than good in some circumstances.

I also believe a large proportion of working class traditional labour voters have been completely disillusioned by identity politics, for the reasons I’ve described above (class being put to one side by left wing politics focussing on identity politics). They want a fairer society whether you’re a white middle class bloke or a trans woman. But they know that living in a shit area with a shit education is their biggest disadvantage, not which gender they shag or what colour they are. Again, that’s not to say these factors should be ignored, they shouldn’t. But I do believe there is too much emphasis on identity politics rather than class. And if folk who think things have gone too woke are simply dismissed as racists.... well, it only serves to divide further. I don’t know Lima, but I know for sure that many many people think the bbc and other media are too woke, and it’s not because they’re a ‘certain type’ who complain about the national trust etc etc..... often it’s for the right reasons - wanting a fairer society, and they believe that too much identity politics can do more harm than good.

Impressive. This quick Pie special on woke sums up how I know many feel.
https://twitter.com/jonathanpienews/stat...48000?s=21
Reply
I'd like to suggest a fee for posters that use multiple quotes. My eyes are bleeding.
Reply
(02-09-2021, 08:51 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(02-09-2021, 08:47 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(02-09-2021, 08:38 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Is this where I post #defund the BBC whilst getting a stiffy at the thought of Fox ahem sorry GB News channel? A channel I’m sure that will be impartial and tell the truth.

Huge fan of the BBC myself. Quality TV, which leads the world.

Issue is its news reporting, which is alienating many. The stories are truthful, but many complain of giving the spotlight on left of centre/extreme liberal stories. I can see why they get such criticism.
However, the world would be a far far poorer place without the Beeb.

The news reporting annoys both the left and right which suggests in general it’s probably just about getting the balance right. It suffers imo from client journalism that simply passes on what the government says without scrutiny far more than ‘extreme liberal stories’. However if anyone thinks that news outlets like GB News will be in someway better then I point you to Fox News, Trump and the damage they did / do to the US.

No, there is more criticism from the centre-right than the left. Every BBC employee/ex-employee who has spoken on its cultue has said it has a left bias. See, for example, Peter Sissons, Jeff Randall, Andrew Marr, John Humphrys.

As for there being less cohesion if we didn't watch events like the World Cup on a ntaional broadcaster, what a ridiculous assertion. It would make no difference.
Reply
I’m not really going to comment too much on the last few posts or it will end up on the politics board... there are some sensitive souls or snowflakes Wink on here who get very upset when you inevitably at some point stray.

No one has said that the BBC doesn’t have its problems. It clearly does have problems as all large organisations have. However class and wealth inequalities are not going to be highlighted, talked about or recognised by inevitably dumbing down the BBC by making it chase commercial advertisement or making it too expensive for the working class you mention by making it subscription only. All you do is make inequality worse. The only people who benefit from the demise of the BBC are those media owners and politicians who would seek to act against the interests of bridging the gap between the rich and poor. They already divide and conquer by blaming organisations set up to support the working class... this year alone the media outside of the BBC particularly Printed and Radio media have blamed NHS workers, Unions, Teachers for where we are with the pandemic.

Arguing about Wokism is convenient nonsense for us all to squabble amongst ourselves about whilst inequality continues. That isn’t going to get any better by defunding the BBC.!

(02-09-2021, 11:51 PM)Bortolazzi's Barnet Wrote:
(02-09-2021, 08:51 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(02-09-2021, 08:47 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(02-09-2021, 08:38 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Is this where I post #defund the BBC whilst getting a stiffy at the thought of Fox ahem sorry GB News channel? A channel I’m sure that will be impartial and tell the truth.

Huge fan of the BBC myself. Quality TV, which leads the world.

Issue is its news reporting, which is alienating many. The stories are truthful, but many complain of giving the spotlight on left of centre/extreme liberal stories. I can see why they get such criticism.
However, the world would be a far far poorer place without the Beeb.

The news reporting annoys both the left and right which suggests in general it’s probably just about getting the balance right. It suffers imo from client journalism that simply passes on what the government says without scrutiny far more than ‘extreme liberal stories’. However if anyone thinks that news outlets like GB News will be in someway better then I point you to Fox News, Trump and the damage they did / do to the US.

No, there is more criticism from the centre-right than the left. Every BBC employee/ex-employee who has spoken on its cultue has said it has a left bias. See, for example, Peter Sissons, Jeff Randall, Andrew Marr, John Humphrys.

As for there being less cohesion if we didn't watch events like the World Cup on a ntaional broadcaster, what a ridiculous assertion. It would make no difference.

You really think the games would be watched in the same numbers if it was subscription only for the World Cup or Olympics?
Reply
You say you won't comment when pinned by some excellent posts. Seems that your argument may be as facile as the BBCs reporting.

"The only people who benefit from the demise of the BBC are those media owners and politicians who would seek to act against the interests of bridging the gap between the rich and poor"

If you really believe this is true then I'm afraid you've not a clue how the BBC editorial works. And over the last 12 months the puppets of big business and govt have had their sticky hands all over the BBC and other maintstream outlets.

The concept that if the BBC wasn't there would somehow mean some loss of liberty or demise of the fight for the working class person is frankly so out of date it's untrue. The internet provides you with your own special media echo chamber no matter what it is so you'll always be able to find it. And as for the non journalistic programming they do some good things but the concept that there would be some form of loss if they didn't is ridiculous.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: