Posts: 3,034
Threads: 20
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
8
(02-08-2021, 02:35 PM)MancBaggie Wrote: (02-07-2021, 12:01 PM)mickeypearce Wrote: On a side note, what a great win for the West Indies, hit 395 in the fourth innings to win a test match.
Great chase - even against that moderate Bangla attack.
Outstanding Test and series win for Pakistan against the Saffers too - great Test match that swung all the way
Yeah good couple of tests. A real shame the SA vs Aussie series is off. Would have been an interesting series.
Posts: 7,971
Threads: 254
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
(02-08-2021, 12:30 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: (02-08-2021, 12:27 PM)Fido Wrote: (02-08-2021, 12:26 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: (02-08-2021, 12:20 PM)Ossian Wrote: (02-08-2021, 11:55 AM)wba13 Wrote: I told you the cheating has started, if that would have been any Indian player the on field would have been not and the review would not have been overturned. Tomorrow if it comes to LBW we will have to take 2 extra wickets because they will find away to give them not out. This has always happened on the subcontinent when there were no neutral umpires. Call me a cynic if you like but it will happen in this series.
Might be worth reflecting on the fact that you're posting on a messageboard where there are often complaints about unbalanced officiating (on and off the pitch), sometimes bordering on outright corruption.
"Always (happens) on the subcontinent" comes across as xenophobic, particularly when you factor in the old saying about glass houses.
It doesn't come across as xenophobic in the slightest, it was exactly how it was prior to neutral umpires. Matches in India and Pakistan were noted for dodgy umpires. Ask Mike Gatting.
I think if we throw in Shakoor Rana that is taking things to the extreme! I'll have to have another look at that LBW for Bess though later as that doesn't seem to make any sense.
Yes that was the extreme, you're right - but there was a build up of frustration from Gatting at regularly getting shafted by umpires at the time. But to point out the history of dodgy umpires in certain countries is not xenophobic. New Zealand was the same prior to neutral umpires. There's plenty of evidence of this, and was the reason neutral umpires came in. Nothing xenophobic about it in the slightest.
Spot on about NZ - appalling umpiring that was so bad it reeked of bias. The Aussies of course had "honest" Darrell Hair
There's 2 sides to the rest of the argument - and India and Pakistan had plenty of ropey decisions when they used to tour England in the days before neutral umpires. In fact, the one thing Gatt and Imran Khan agreed upon in the 80s was the need for neutrality.
The Shakoor Rana issue goes back to Pakistan's tour of England in 1982 and the umpiring of a certain David Constant. Even the England players were embarrassed by his antics/ chronic bias.
Posts: 974
Threads: 11
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
2
(02-08-2021, 10:39 AM)Poppy’s dad Wrote: (02-08-2021, 10:34 AM)Lillwall's left foot Wrote: Nice to see that Cricket also has it's fair share of pant wetting. England have ground out another 50 runs, wore the pitch some more and still have a day plus to bowl India out. But it's waaah waaah declaration.
There was a plan and they've carried it out. Down to the bowlers now.
Let’s hope you are right mate, but if the nightmare scenario does happen will you be gracious enough to admit you were completely wrong ? Just one other point, the plan was to get bowled out ??
Nightmare scenario was to give a batting side with a top seven averaging over 40 the time to actually win the game. And yep the plan appeared to be to bat out.
My post wasn't directed at your good self by the way, I'd just come off social media platforms where they were absolutely howling.
Posts: 228
Threads: 58
Joined: May 2019
Reputation:
0
(02-08-2021, 03:00 PM)Lillwall's left foot Wrote: (02-08-2021, 10:39 AM)Poppy’s dad Wrote: (02-08-2021, 10:34 AM)Lillwall's left foot Wrote: Nice to see that Cricket also has it's fair share of pant wetting. England have ground out another 50 runs, wore the pitch some more and still have a day plus to bowl India out. But it's waaah waaah declaration.
There was a plan and they've carried it out. Down to the bowlers now.
Let’s hope you are right mate, but if the nightmare scenario does happen will you be gracious enough to admit you were completely wrong ? Just one other point, the plan was to get bowled out ??
Nightmare scenario was to give a batting side with a top seven averaging over 40 the time to actually win the game. And yep the plan appeared to be to bat out.
My post wasn't directed at your good self by the way, I'd just come off social media platforms where they were absolutely howling. Alarm is set for four in the AM, it’s going to be tough but I would like to think we can create 9 chances in a full days play on that pitch, Leach & Bess are under pressure to bowl the Indian team out but I guess that’s why they are there, any wickets the seamers pick up will be a massive bonus, saw that Shane Warne has put his twopennth worth in by saying we were too cautious, I still think the ten overs after Pope got out was a period of mindless cricket, Bess was kicking the ball away !! We could have had a swipe, been all out sooner but with an extra 25 runs on the board !! Oh well as you say hindsight is a wonderful thing, let’s hope we are celebrating a great win tomorrow.
Posts: 1,777
Threads: 5
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
4
02-08-2021, 04:30 PM
(This post was last modified: 02-08-2021, 04:38 PM by ElbowGrease1973.)
(02-08-2021, 03:30 PM)Poppy’s dad Wrote: (02-08-2021, 03:00 PM)Lillwall's left foot Wrote: (02-08-2021, 10:39 AM)Poppy’s dad Wrote: (02-08-2021, 10:34 AM)Lillwall's left foot Wrote: Nice to see that Cricket also has it's fair share of pant wetting. England have ground out another 50 runs, wore the pitch some more and still have a day plus to bowl India out. But it's waaah waaah declaration.
There was a plan and they've carried it out. Down to the bowlers now.
Let’s hope you are right mate, but if the nightmare scenario does happen will you be gracious enough to admit you were completely wrong ? Just one other point, the plan was to get bowled out ??
Nightmare scenario was to give a batting side with a top seven averaging over 40 the time to actually win the game. And yep the plan appeared to be to bat out.
My post wasn't directed at your good self by the way, I'd just come off social media platforms where they were absolutely howling. Alarm is set for four in the AM, it’s going to be tough but I would like to think we can create 9 chances in a full days play on that pitch, Leach & Bess are under pressure to bowl the Indian team out but I guess that’s why they are there, any wickets the seamers pick up will be a massive bonus, saw that Shane Warne has put his twopennth worth in by saying we were too cautious, I still think the ten overs after Pope got out was a period of mindless cricket, Bess was kicking the ball away !! We could have had a swipe, been all out sooner but with an extra 25 runs on the board !! Oh well as you say hindsight is a wonderful thing, let’s hope we are celebrating a great win tomorrow. I'm with you. If we were intent on batting until there were 10 - 15 overs left in the day, then why did Buttler & Stokes attack so much? Keep your wicket and your best batsmen in. It just feels a mixed up approach, and I still struggle to see the value in wasting that last hour. If we get the remaining 9 wickets tomorrow though, it's all justified. Should be an intriguing days play, with all results still possible.
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
ElbowGrease1973 Wrote:Poppy’s dad Wrote:Lillwall's left foot Wrote:Poppy’s dad Wrote:Lillwall's left foot Wrote:Nice to see that Cricket also has it's fair share of pant wetting. England have ground out another 50 runs, wore the pitch some more and still have a day plus to bowl India out. But it's waaah waaah declaration.
There was a plan and they've carried it out. Down to the bowlers now.
Let’s hope you are right mate, but if the nightmare scenario does happen will you be gracious enough to admit you were completely wrong ? Just one other point, the plan was to get bowled out ??
Nightmare scenario was to give a batting side with a top seven averaging over 40 the time to actually win the game. And yep the plan appeared to be to bat out.
My post wasn't directed at your good self by the way, I'd just come off social media platforms where they were absolutely howling. Alarm is set for four in the AM, it’s going to be tough but I would like to think we can create 9 chances in a full days play on that pitch, Leach & Bess are under pressure to bowl the Indian team out but I guess that’s why they are there, any wickets the seamers pick up will be a massive bonus, saw that Shane Warne has put his twopennth worth in by saying we were too cautious, I still think the ten overs after Pope got out was a period of mindless cricket, Bess was kicking the ball away !! We could have had a swipe, been all out sooner but with an extra 25 runs on the board !! Oh well as you say hindsight is a wonderful thing, let’s hope we are celebrating a great win tomorrow. I'm with you. If we were intent on batting until there were 10 - 15 overs left in the day, then why did Buttler & Stokes attack so much? Keep your wicket and your best batsmen in. It just feels a mixed up approach, and I still struggle to see the value in wasting that last hour. If we get the remaining 9 wickets tomorrow though, it's all justified. Should be an intriguing days play, with all results still possible. I still say the golden rule is Do not lose. Having the tail enders have a swipe is no actual guarantee of anything and we could well be looking at a more even game. As it is the pressure is now on the hosts and even with their impressive batting line up, there is nothing like pressure to force mistakes. I'm comfortable with where we are.
Posts: 228
Threads: 58
Joined: May 2019
Reputation:
0
(02-08-2021, 05:38 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: ElbowGrease1973 Wrote:Poppy’s dad Wrote:Lillwall's left foot Wrote:Poppy’s dad Wrote:Let’s hope you are right mate, but if the nightmare scenario does happen will you be gracious enough to admit you were completely wrong ? Just one other point, the plan was to get bowled out ??
Nightmare scenario was to give a batting side with a top seven averaging over 40 the time to actually win the game. And yep the plan appeared to be to bat out.
My post wasn't directed at your good self by the way, I'd just come off social media platforms where they were absolutely howling. Alarm is set for four in the AM, it’s going to be tough but I would like to think we can create 9 chances in a full days play on that pitch, Leach & Bess are under pressure to bowl the Indian team out but I guess that’s why they are there, any wickets the seamers pick up will be a massive bonus, saw that Shane Warne has put his twopennth worth in by saying we were too cautious, I still think the ten overs after Pope got out was a period of mindless cricket, Bess was kicking the ball away !! We could have had a swipe, been all out sooner but with an extra 25 runs on the board !! Oh well as you say hindsight is a wonderful thing, let’s hope we are celebrating a great win tomorrow. I'm with you. If we were intent on batting until there were 10 - 15 overs left in the day, then why did Buttler & Stokes attack so much? Keep your wicket and your best batsmen in. It just feels a mixed up approach, and I still struggle to see the value in wasting that last hour. If we get the remaining 9 wickets tomorrow though, it's all justified. Should be an intriguing days play, with all results still possible. I still say the golden rule is Do not lose. Having the tail enders have a swipe is no actual guarantee of anything and we could well be looking at a more even game. As it is the pressure is now on the hosts and even with their impressive batting line up, there is nothing like pressure to force mistakes. I'm comfortable with where we are. I think if anyone had said we would be in this position on Friday we probably wouldn’t have believed it, the morning session will be crucial, if we can nip two or three out then we are in the box seat, expect a lot of time wasting tactics from the home team, be interesting how root juggles his bowlers, I’d start with Anderson and Leach, Kholi is the prize wicket but I think Pujara will be the wicket that will be the hardest again.
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
Poppy’s dad Wrote:Tom Joad Wrote:ElbowGrease1973 Wrote:Poppy’s dad Wrote:Lillwall's left foot Wrote:Nightmare scenario was to give a batting side with a top seven averaging over 40 the time to actually win the game. And yep the plan appeared to be to bat out.
My post wasn't directed at your good self by the way, I'd just come off social media platforms where they were absolutely howling. Alarm is set for four in the AM, it’s going to be tough but I would like to think we can create 9 chances in a full days play on that pitch, Leach & Bess are under pressure to bowl the Indian team out but I guess that’s why they are there, any wickets the seamers pick up will be a massive bonus, saw that Shane Warne has put his twopennth worth in by saying we were too cautious, I still think the ten overs after Pope got out was a period of mindless cricket, Bess was kicking the ball away !! We could have had a swipe, been all out sooner but with an extra 25 runs on the board !! Oh well as you say hindsight is a wonderful thing, let’s hope we are celebrating a great win tomorrow. I'm with you. If we were intent on batting until there were 10 - 15 overs left in the day, then why did Buttler & Stokes attack so much? Keep your wicket and your best batsmen in. It just feels a mixed up approach, and I still struggle to see the value in wasting that last hour. If we get the remaining 9 wickets tomorrow though, it's all justified. Should be an intriguing days play, with all results still possible. I still say the golden rule is Do not lose. Having the tail enders have a swipe is no actual guarantee of anything and we could well be looking at a more even game. As it is the pressure is now on the hosts and even with their impressive batting line up, there is nothing like pressure to force mistakes. I'm comfortable with where we are. I think if anyone had said we would be in this position on Friday we probably wouldn’t have believed it, the morning session will be crucial, if we can nip two or three out then we are in the box seat, expect a lot of time wasting tactics from the home team, be interesting how root juggles his bowlers, I’d start with Anderson and Leach, Kholi is the prize wicket but I think Pujara will be the wicket that will be the hardest again. Hard to call, they all bat well! I didn't see the runs coming from where they did in their 1st innings!
Posts: 228
Threads: 58
Joined: May 2019
Reputation:
0
(02-08-2021, 05:38 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: ElbowGrease1973 Wrote:Poppy’s dad Wrote:Lillwall's left foot Wrote:Poppy’s dad Wrote:Let’s hope you are right mate, but if the nightmare scenario does happen will you be gracious enough to admit you were completely wrong ? Just one other point, the plan was to get bowled out ??
Nightmare scenario was to give a batting side with a top seven averaging over 40 the time to actually win the game. And yep the plan appeared to be to bat out.
My post wasn't directed at your good self by the way, I'd just come off social media platforms where they were absolutely howling. Alarm is set for four in the AM, it’s going to be tough but I would like to think we can create 9 chances in a full days play on that pitch, Leach & Bess are under pressure to bowl the Indian team out but I guess that’s why they are there, any wickets the seamers pick up will be a massive bonus, saw that Shane Warne has put his twopennth worth in by saying we were too cautious, I still think the ten overs after Pope got out was a period of mindless cricket, Bess was kicking the ball away !! We could have had a swipe, been all out sooner but with an extra 25 runs on the board !! Oh well as you say hindsight is a wonderful thing, let’s hope we are celebrating a great win tomorrow. I'm with you. If we were intent on batting until there were 10 - 15 overs left in the day, then why did Buttler & Stokes attack so much? Keep your wicket and your best batsmen in. It just feels a mixed up approach, and I still struggle to see the value in wasting that last hour. If we get the remaining 9 wickets tomorrow though, it's all justified. Should be an intriguing days play, with all results still possible. I still say the golden rule is Do not lose. Having the tail enders have a swipe is no actual guarantee of anything and we could well be looking at a more even game. As it is the pressure is now on the hosts and even with their impressive batting line up, there is nothing like pressure to force mistakes. I'm comfortable with where we are. I think if anyone had said we would be in this position on Friday we probably wouldn’t have believed it, the morning session will be crucial, if we can nip two or three out then we are in the box seat, expect a lot of time wasting tactics from the home team, be interesting how root juggles his bowlers, I’d start with Anderson and Leach, Kholi is the prize wicket but I think Pujara will be the wicket that will be the hardest again.
Posts: 3,280
Threads: 99
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
13
Phew. We were lucky. Just the 40+ overs to spare
|