Posts: 8,125
Threads: 201
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
55
02-08-2021, 04:15 PM
(This post was last modified: 02-08-2021, 04:30 PM by HawkingsHalfpint.)
If Bilic had too much say, Dowling should have exercised control. Classic case of tail wagging the dog otherwise, and after all he sacked BD for the same not all that long ago.
The likes of Grady, Grant et al. may come good. But this season is a waste of their talent, confidence, asset value, and the carried cost in them being here. We all knew Grant would struggle without someone establish to feed off and learn from. If Bilic couldn’t see this, then it was up to Dowling to guide/steer his man better.
There are the transfer calamities mentioned by other posters above, plus Hegazi being replaced by a shite has-been. The disharmony in whomever’s squad it is is there for all to observe.
Then there is the questionable manner (and timing) of the last two dismissals, both of which were roundly frowned upon; and of course the controversial incumbent whose appointment has not only divided a loyal but finite fanbase, but abjectly failed as a survival project.
Three managers failing in an impossible brief suggests to me that the brief isn’t right. And who defines the role? If the parameters that Dowling himself has to work within are unfair, then it is his responsibility to make a case for different ones, rather than installing a turnstile at the head coach’s office. After all, he’s the constant factor here.
Either that, or BD - just like Bilic - should never have been sacked for failing to achieve the impossible.
Posts: 10,436
Threads: 427
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
IMHO it's time for Luke to move on.
He has been instrumental in far to many failures - Players and Managers.
He has a large support team (17) to ensure we get things right, salary, contracts, clauses, etc but it appears to be lets be kind and say lacking at every level, time after time if we believe the rumours.
I'm trying to think of which signings have actually made a step up and a contribution over and above what we paid for them. Errr ? the only one that comes to mind is Townsend. Our loans have easily been better then our perms, why is that?
This is not just a money issue, other clubs pick up 1 or 2 players a season, where we simply don't.
This is a direct reflection on Luke and his team, a new man with vision and footballing knowledge within the game is needed.
I would certainly go for someone like Marc Overmars or even Gary Megson.
Posts: 4,217
Threads: 169
Joined: Jan 2019
(02-08-2021, 03:02 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Dowling wanted a defensive midfielder and the full backs changed, also wanted to buy other strikers rather than Grant who he felt was unsuited and too expensive.
Bilic had way too much say in the summer, and look where it got us. Dowling maybe messed up buying Grady, but that may yet come good.
He doesn't want to play for us birdy..... In the words of the text grady is still being a pussy that is word for word on the text message.
Posts: 290
Threads: 11
Joined: Jan 2021
This is a hard question.
I am quite confident that these signings in January are BS and not those put forward by LD, so what is the point of him essentially given that it has been suggested that KG was a signing SB insisted on too. I personally didn't like the way KG went on strike at the terriers in effect and I certainly wasn't happy with the length of his contract, but that was to spread the payments and therefore essential, I don't know.
If we now are allowing managers to pick their signings, I see no point in keeping him, as he seems to concentrate his attention to the uk transfer market when there bargains out there to he had.
However, if Appy comes when we are relegated then they could work together because of their friendship.
To be honest I don't know what remit LD has been given as I was under the impression that we brought in this system to recommend 5 players for a position we needed to fill to a manager (but the manager decides) and to prevent too much upheaval when one manager leaves and takes his team with him.
In relation to the youth set up I thought changing the youth player entrance was a good idea as it gave them something to aspire too, but other than that and replacing staff when they have left, I have not seen any improvement there too.
On balance I would see who the next manager.
Posts: 1,372
Threads: 13
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
2
Hopefully some tough lessons have been learned for Luke this season on the importance of squad balance and maybe not allowing free reign for the manager to pick the targets. If we sack him who above him is qualified to pick his replacement? He's made some bad signings, and made some good ones. With a restrictive budget that is always going to be the case. I can't recall a transfer window where many were unhappy with the deals, quite the opposite if anything.
Posts: 527
Threads: 0
Joined: Dec 2020
Reputation:
4
Seems like a thankless task to me. The manager gets the praise for the good ones and Dowling gets blamed for the bad ones, even if the manager chose them.
Posts: 489
Threads: 24
Joined: Nov 2019
Reputation:
0
02-08-2021, 05:33 PM
(This post was last modified: 02-08-2021, 05:34 PM by Crossbar11.)
(02-08-2021, 05:22 PM)Dial M for Mick Wrote: Seems like a thankless task to me. The manager gets the praise for the good ones and Dowling gets blamed for the bad ones, even if the manager chose them.
Not the case , I'd have Dowling gone but he can spot a lower league player . Ajayi was his I believe .
Posts: 290
Threads: 11
Joined: Jan 2021
He has has had a couple of strong willed managers in SB and SA and maybe a more understanding relationship with someone like Appy could work.
I am concerned that he let Hegazi go and he only the fullbacks and a DM was needed in the defence was so avarge last season.
We spent very little in the summer of the season we went went up. So on balance given the amount of out of contract players like Gibbs, I would stick with him.
But, I would really embrace anyone who did come in and implement the Moneyball system or if finances don't allow fucking stalk the bees scouts.
Toney instead of Grant is what most wanted (both were possible if Charlie said I'm far too fat for prem & fucked off earlier), but we ended up with the wrong one (I haven't given up on KG btw and just hope he cost £12m down and not the rumoured £16m) I can see Toney now selling for around £25m at least.
Posts: 17,077
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
Arf I love this model of working... we spend feck all, we do badly manager is blamed, then sacked, then when results still don’t pick up we want the next manager and DoF to be sacked as well. What a sound blueprint for success! Ffs this board at times!
Posts: 3,775
Threads: 73
Joined: May 2020
(02-08-2021, 11:04 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (02-08-2021, 10:39 AM)Squid Wrote: (02-08-2021, 08:03 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: We had the smallest budget to use on the Prem. it’s not his fault that we are shopping at Quick Save whilst others are going to Harrods for their weekly shop.
Stop looking for blame we are where we are because we don’t have the resources to compete. The owners never said they would spend millions that we didn’t generate as a club so just accept unless we do sell to new owners that will then as the Prem evolves further yoyoing is looking increasingly likely to be the best we can do.
I did say a few years ago when idiots were talking about ‘next levels’ whilst we were sitting 8th -11th in the Prem that was likely to be the best we can achieve without an investor who will spend beyond the clubs resources. Nothing has changed for us but the Prem has become even more about money and the only thing that might change that a little is erm Brexit, but even then it’ll help widen the gap not bridge it between the rich clubs and the rest.
We've also made some shocking decisions on the way. The key one being not replacing Pulis at the end of 16/17 when it was clear his heart was no longer in the role (to put it kindly). Instead the inevitable happened and we then appointed the worst of all worlds: Pardew. So a team which needn't have been relegated, was. Not only that, we didn't sack Pardew, but allowed him to leave by mutual consent.
Hindsight, but if the club could have grilled Darren Moore a bit about his choice of assistant and averted that on the grounds of common sense, that would have been great too.
As for this season, we may have indeed always been relegated, but the fact is there seems to have been endless squabbles in the summer as opposed to constructing a coherent team. From the players we have, two different managers have struggled to name their best team and that is damning.
Furthermore, relegation is one thing, but to narrowly avoid breaking Derby's record is quite another. I think we definitely should be expecting more than that and that it's quite right to question the role of various senior figures in the club, including Dowling.
Well said.
Dowling shoulders part of the blame for constructing such an unbalanced squad, especially given how even the most deluded fan could see the inadequacies when the window closed.
Poor planning, poor expectation setting, squad disharmony, lack of fitness, lack of organisation... all of these have nothing to do with budgets
(02-08-2021, 06:03 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Arf I love this model of working... we spend feck all, we do badly manager is blamed, then sacked, then when results still don’t pick up we want the next manager and DoF to be sacked as well. What a sound blueprint for success! Ffs this board at times!
I have also laughed at this long and hard.
|