Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
02-07-2021, 11:06 PM
(This post was last modified: 02-07-2021, 11:50 PM by Squid.)
We got rid of Hammond after 16/7 and went into the close season with Terrano, who promptly sacked off Foster and Big Dave's phonebook. We have the latter to thank for Harvey Barnes and Gayle (both of whom he personally persuaded to come to the club) and presumably, he scouted Townsend too, who actually turned out to be a very good buy.
If we get rid of Dowling, either we need to recruit a new DoF (who may not come cheap) and Head Coach and hope they work well together, or just hope the new manager has a very good idea of who he wants in his team.
If we keep Dowling, it would make even more sense to bring in Appleton, as they've both worked together in the past and hopefully would have a unified vision of the team. While Dowling deserves his share of the blame for last summer's activity, he can get a deal over the line, which is a valuable skill to have.
However, I'm not convinced on the DoF model. It can work well, but ultimately, the manager should pick the players, as it's his neck on the line.
Posts: 9,321
Threads: 720
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
9
(02-07-2021, 11:06 PM)Squid Wrote: We got rid of Hammond after 16/7 and went into the close season with Terrano, who promptly sacked off Foster and Big Dave's phonebook. We have the latter to thank for Harvey Barnes and Gayle (both of whom he personally persuaded to come to the club) and presumably, he scouted Townsend too, who actually turned out to be a very good buy.
If we get rid of Dowling, either we need to recruit a new DoF (who may not come cheap) and Head Coach and hope they work well together, or just hope the new manager has a very good idea of who he wants in his team.
If we keep Dowling, it would make even more sense to bring in Appleton, as they've both worked together in the past and hopefully would have a unified vision of the team. While Dowling deserves his share of the blame for last summer's activity, he can get a deal over the line, which is a valuable skill to have.
However, I'm not convinced on the DoF model. It can work well, but ultimately, the manager should pick the players, as it's his neck on the line.
It's a decision for the summer in light of the outcome of the season. What if we get enough points to stay up? I mean you never know, but Burnley may not win another game - who knows?
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
It all depends on how much power Hammond holds. Who had the say last August? Was it a mish mash of Slav plus Dowling? Looks like that to me and both were competing to fill the same positions to the neglect of the other areas. This January it looks like BFS has spent what there was on what he wanted. A club with our limits needs a clear plan. The lack of direction was obvious.
Posts: 1,459
Threads: 169
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
1
After every transfer window has closed since Dowling has been here I have been pleased with the deals he has done. He has maximised a small budget excellently imo.
Many will attack him with the Grady signing ‘vanity project’ I have heard it called. Find me someone who didn’t think it was a great deal at the time.
Posts: 17,083
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
02-08-2021, 08:03 AM
(This post was last modified: 02-08-2021, 08:11 AM by Derek Hardballs.)
We had the smallest budget to use on the Prem. it’s not his fault that we are shopping at Quick Save whilst others are going to Harrods for their weekly shop.
Stop looking for blame we are where we are because we don’t have the resources to compete. The owners never said they would spend millions that we didn’t generate as a club so just accept unless we do sell to new owners that will then as the Prem evolves further yoyoing is looking increasingly likely to be the best we can do.
I did say a few years ago when idiots were talking about ‘next levels’ whilst we were sitting 8th -11th in the Prem that was likely to be the best we can achieve without an investor who will spend beyond the clubs resources. Nothing has changed for us but the Prem has become even more about money and the only thing that might change that a little is erm Brexit, but even then it’ll help widen the gap not bridge it between the rich clubs and the rest.
Posts: 3,109
Threads: 184
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
02-08-2021, 08:08 AM
(This post was last modified: 02-08-2021, 08:13 AM by ColliersWoodBaggie.)
Brexit may not change much. It will mean seasoned international class players from EU countries will be snapped up, but their value will rise and this will make the market for them smaller (i.e. bigger or richer clubs). Albion et al will be needing to scout outside the E.U. and I can see more African, Turkish and South American players being scouted and bought.
(02-08-2021, 08:03 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: We had the smallest budget to use on the Prem. it’s not his fault that we are shopping at Quick Save whilst others are going to Harrods for their weekly shop.
Stop looking for blame we are where we are because we don’t have the resources to compete. The owners never said they would spend millions that we didn’t generate as a club so just accept unless we do sell to new owners that will then as the Prem evolves further yoyoing is looking increasingly likely to be the best we can do.
I did say a few years ago when idiots were talking about ‘next levels’ whilst we were sitting 8th -11th in the Prem that was likely to be the best we can achieve without an investor who will spend beyond the clubs resources. Nothing has changed for us but the Prem has become even more about money and the only thing that might change that a little is erm Brexit.
Good pint here. However, astute scouting and good coaching can lift a small budget (Burnley), but how long you sustain it is always an issue. When we were mid table, JP should have pushed the boat out a bit and also sold us in 2012/13 - when we were in a better position than later on. Clarke, wasn't the long term answer, but I felt that was a better squad than the Pulis one which finished 10th. Maybe, partly because we had a bit more about us under Clarke than TP and we still had the Ashworth model in place. We blew the chance to kick on a bit as we stayed motionless off the pitch, leading to Mel, AFI and TP needing to save us and try and push us up a bit with his brand.
Posts: 1,396
Threads: 87
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
7
(02-08-2021, 06:45 AM)B36baggie Wrote: After every transfer window has closed since Dowling has been here I have been pleased with the deals he has done. He has maximised a small budget excellently imo.
Many will attack him with the Grady signing ‘vanity project’ I have heard it called. Find me someone who didn’t think it was a great deal at the time.
Exactly. Imagine if we hadn’t signed him and he went somewhere else. Then it would have been about how we failed to persuade him to come here and he’d be worth double in a year
Posts: 3,109
Threads: 184
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
It's all hindsight. But we did need defenders. Ivanovic has been a huge disappointment.
Posts: 13,262
Threads: 468
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
45
(02-08-2021, 08:03 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: We had the smallest budget to use on the Prem. it’s not his fault that we are shopping at Quick Save whilst others are going to Harrods for their weekly shop.
Stop looking for blame we are where we are because we don’t have the resources to compete. The owners never said they would spend millions that we didn’t generate as a club so just accept unless we do sell to new owners that will then as the Prem evolves further yoyoing is looking increasingly likely to be the best we can do.
I did say a few years ago when idiots were talking about ‘next levels’ whilst we were sitting 8th -11th in the Prem that was likely to be the best we can achieve without an investor who will spend beyond the clubs resources. Nothing has changed for us but the Prem has become even more about money and the only thing that might change that a little is erm Brexit, but even then it’ll help widen the gap not bridge it between the rich clubs and the rest.
You weren't the only one banging this drum, whilst I was banging my head against the wall as others dreamed of a football utopia.
"Well, Leicester did it so why can't we?!?!" urgh
Posts: 19,497
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(02-08-2021, 09:16 AM)ColliersWoodBaggie Wrote: It's all hindsight. But we did need defenders. Ivanovic has been a huge disappointment.
Don’t think it needs hindsight to realise that. In fairness Slav wanted to prioritise fullbacks but we just couldn’t get a deal done for anyone, and the Diangana transfer restricted the pool of players available to us. Not getting Robinson was a real blow.
Ultimately we needed to do a lot of business this summer and our handling of a limited budget could have been better.
Dowling blowing our whole budget on Grady was a mistake, but Slav’s insistence on Ivanovic and Krovinovic when they just weren’t up to it was a huge error of judgment.
Grant - whilst looking garbage so far - was the best available option given our measly budget. £16m is a lot of cash, but the way it’s structured means there just weren’t many alternatives.
|