Livermore / Big Sam / The Future
#1
I know i've stated on here before, my opinions on Livermore. But i'm just going to outline a few things for my reasonings. It doesn't take a rocket scientist to work out that Jake is really, really, exceptionally bad at passing the ball. A quick look across Opta Stats and WhoScored and you can see that is his pass completion ratio is pretty much rock bottom for midfielders in the Premier League. Another telling thing to look at is his profile on WhoScored.. it outlines all players strengths and weaknesses. Under Jakes strengths, it says 'Player has no significant strengths'. Under weaknesses it says Passing, Discipline. Then under it says Style of Play, which reads 'Commits fouls often'. 

On his Premier League profile..
2016/17 season - 8 wins , 22 losses, 37 appearances.
2017/18 season - 6 wins , 16 losses, 34 appearances.
We all know how many games we've lost this season & he's been pretty much at the heart of it, most of the time.

I know i got some pelters the other day for my comment about him doing his media duties, but i stand by my opinion that he should hand over the captains armband to Bartley & have a break or even better, leave the club. It just grinds my gears how he plays this 'leader' and he seems to like having the 'captain' role, but he talks the talk & never walks the walk. Have we had a worse captain in recent memory? Not in my mind, no.

Since he joined the club & been a regular in the side, we've been on a steady decline & i'm not pinning it all his door, but it's not a coincidence, that we've got a useless midfielder in the centre of the park who offers absolutely zero that we've lost a lot more games than we've won. I really do believe that our centre halves aren't confident passing the ball into livermore & sawyers & IF that is the case, that's really damaging & would explain why we see lot's of nothing balls punted up the pitch into nobody. Also the defenders were playing those nothing forward balls under Slav too, so it's not just a Big Sam issue. Remember before he rocked up we had Claudio who always showed for the ball & Fletcher too, both very good at receiving the ball & popping it off with success. Now i think they panic, coz a lot of the time Jake doesn't even show for the ball, he just shouts & points as to where he thinks it should go, rather than taking responsibility. People have been slagging Sam off, but i really don't believe he says to the players 'Launch it aimlessly'. When he does want them to play it long, i'd imagine he'd want them to playing a decent long pass, with quality.

Now, i know Sawyers has been having a nightmare & he shouldn't be playing, but i do honestly believe that he suits a possession based style & team. If Sawyers had better players around him, in a dominating team, he'd be playing much better. Whereas Livermore, even the first half of last season, he was still misplacing passes, putting his team mates in danger by playing balls too short & reacting stupidly to situations & making daft challenges. He's let us down so many times that i've lost count.

Snodgrass,  a Big Sam signing has been decent & even though last night was a shambles, he's still a good addition & i'd like to see Sam given the chance with his own players. I'm sorry but these lot he's inherited ain't good enough at all & it starts with the captain. A lot of them have been bottle jobs & cowards that have had it far too easy under Slav. They've allowed themselves to become unfit, again something that is wholly unprofessional.

So my final thought is, wether we go down or not, i want Sam to stay. I think he should be allowed to rebuild as he's a decent manager. You don't get the England job if you're shit at your job. It's very easy to have a dislike toward the guy because of his dingle connection & because so many people had almost an emotional attachment to Slav, but he's a good manager & when given the tools, always does a decent job. This what annoys with Albion fans at times, there's a lack of balance & realism in what we want & expect. Sam went to Everton & did a great job with some pretty big egos. West Ham fans are on the delusion level of Villa fans, he got them promoted & because they weren't playing the 'West Ham Way', they hounded him out, yet they were finishing mid table every season under him. That's where we are, every now and then we may have a great season like we did under Clarke or Roy & finish in the top 10, but the reality is, that when we are in the premier league, we're always going to be mid table / lower half & fighting, just like a lot of teams. We can all cry for somebody 'progressive and young' but once they start losing a few games, we're all back to slagging him off & wanting the next shiny new manager off the shelf. Or once said new young manager gets us up, they're always going to struggle when the players aren't good enough. The vitriol towards Sam just doesn't sit right with me as he's been dealt a poor hand.

I'm still positive, i love the albion, we may get out of this, but going down and rebuilding won't break my heart either, i just want us fans to keep our feet on the ground. One thing i used to love about us is how humble we were, but it seems to have got lost after a few decent seasons in the premier league...
Reply
#2
Neither Livermore nor Allardyce should have any involvement in our future.
Reply
#3
(02-03-2021, 08:40 PM)Everything Zin Wrote: Neither Livermore nor Allardyce should have any involvement in our future.

Agreed.

Can't see anyone taking Livermore off us though.
Reply
#4
(02-03-2021, 08:45 PM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote:
(02-03-2021, 08:40 PM)Everything Zin Wrote: Neither Livermore nor Allardyce should have any involvement in our future.

Agreed.

Can't see anyone taking Livermore off us though.

It's a worry for sure.

A key question to ask yourself, if we go down, what players would other premier league teams want from us? When Norwich went down & even the most recent time we got relegated, we had players that other premier league teams would want. At this moment, we have maybe 3? Grady (Potentially), Periera, Johnstone. That's very telling.

(02-03-2021, 08:55 PM)coxy134 Wrote: Agree with all of that. Except Fletcher I always thought passing wise often gave the ball away.

We have lacked a captain on the pitch for a while, I kept asking last night where is Livermore far to slow?

Ye you're right. I do remember that too to be fair. He started to get worse worse with his passing, but started really brightly.
Reply
#5
Agree with all of that. Except Fletcher I always thought passing wise often gave the ball away.

We have lacked a captain on the pitch for a while, I kept asking last night where is Livermore far to slow?
Reply
#6
Livermore needs to go, I agree. He did well for us last season, but he looked a broken man by the end of it and we could have offloaded him in the summer. Yes, he's on a contract but telling people they won't be in the squad usually helps.

By all accounts, he's a lovely bloke and very popular in the dressing room, but that is not any reason to keep him.

As for Sam, we won't have the money to pay him in the Championship, hence the break clause.
Reply
#7
(02-03-2021, 09:24 PM)Squid Wrote: Livermore needs to go, I agree. He did well for us last season, but he looked a broken man by the end of it and we could have offloaded him in the summer. Yes, he's on a contract but telling people they won't be in the squad usually helps.

By all accounts, he's a lovely bloke and very popular in the dressing room, but that is not any reason to keep him.

As for Sam, we won't have the money to pay him in the Championship, hence the break clause.

Who on Earth wanted him in the summer?!?
Reply
#8
(02-03-2021, 09:39 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(02-03-2021, 09:24 PM)Squid Wrote: Livermore needs to go, I agree. He did well for us last season, but he looked a broken man by the end of it and we could have offloaded him in the summer. Yes, he's on a contract but telling people they won't be in the squad usually helps.

By all accounts, he's a lovely bloke and very popular in the dressing room, but that is not any reason to keep him.

As for Sam, we won't have the money to pay him in the Championship, hence the break clause.

Who on Earth wanted him in the summer?!?

He had just captained his team to the Premier League, someone in the Championship would have taken him off our hands.
Reply
#9
i think livermore has the right attitude but his body is letting him down.

hes going backwards at a rate of knots and will not recover.

id hate to see allardyce in charge of us next year.
Reply
#10
(02-03-2021, 09:42 PM)Squid Wrote:
(02-03-2021, 09:39 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(02-03-2021, 09:24 PM)Squid Wrote: Livermore needs to go, I agree. He did well for us last season, but he looked a broken man by the end of it and we could have offloaded him in the summer. Yes, he's on a contract but telling people they won't be in the squad usually helps.

By all accounts, he's a lovely bloke and very popular in the dressing room, but that is not any reason to keep him.

As for Sam, we won't have the money to pay him in the Championship, hence the break clause.

Who on Earth wanted him in the summer?!?

He had just captained his team to the Premier League, someone in the Championship would have taken him off our hands.

Exactly.  There’s several sizeable clubs in the Championship who would pay £2m to £3m for him - although there really is no money around currently.  That’s in “normal” times.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: