Gibbs and Livermore
#1
Made this point on the match thread, but feel it needs discussing further.

For me they have been our two worst performers this season. People can complain about Furlong, Sawyers, Grant etc, but those guys are all Championship standard players trying to step up. Now it’s looking increasingly like most of our squad haven’t got what it takes to step up, which is to a degree forgivable.

Gibbs and Livermore don’t have that excuse, they’ve spent most of their careers in the Premier League. They’ve played for big clubs, played in Europe, played for England... they have experience and should be setting the example for the other players to follow. They’ve as bad, if not worse, than all the others. Piss poor performances, stupid red cards costing us matches, a general look as if they would rather be anywhere else...

They’ve stank the club out all season.
Reply
#2
One thing with Livermore at least he keeps going and doesn't hide , don't get me started on that other tosser who IS capable of so much better .
Reply
#3
Crossbar11 Wrote:One thing with Livermore at least he keeps going and doesn't hide , don't get me started on that other tosser who IS capable of so much better .

This is true. Jake tries, whether he's good enough or not is another matter. Gibbs just winds me up, he is capable of so much better. Why didn't he just ping that cross in at the end FFS?
Reply
#4
Also to add Livermore did the press for our 2nd goal .
Reply
#5
(01-30-2021, 08:06 PM)Duffers Wrote: Made this point on the match thread, but feel it needs discussing further.

For me they have been our two worst performers this season. People can complain about Furlong, Sawyers, Grant etc, but those guys are all Championship standard players trying to step up. Now it’s looking increasingly like most of our squad haven’t got what it takes to step up, which is to a degree forgivable.

Gibbs and Livermore don’t have that excuse, they’ve spent most of their careers in the Premier League. They’ve played for big clubs, played in Europe, played for England... they have experience and should be setting the example for the other players to follow. They’ve as bad, if not worse, than all the others. Piss poor performances, stupid red cards costing us matches, a general look as if they would rather be anywhere else...

They’ve stank the club out all season.

I disagree though I can understand why you might come to the conclusion. 

The fact is they're 3 yrs downstream on what were already declining careers. 

Gibbs's actions at Everton were incredibly stupid but also incredibly out of character ( a moment of madness - we've all had them)  but sadly it's almost totally disrupted his season and his persistent injuries and their consequences have caught up with him.  

We all get frustrated with the players,  but I do believe Jake does his very best when he pulls on the shirt.  I may be wrong, it has been known!
Reply
#6
The four seasons that Gibbs has been with us have been largely unsuccessful and it is no coincidence whatsoever IMO.
Reply
#7
(01-30-2021, 08:21 PM)Hopalong Wrote:
(01-30-2021, 08:06 PM)Duffers Wrote: Made this point on the match thread, but feel it needs discussing further.

For me they have been our two worst performers this season. People can complain about Furlong, Sawyers, Grant etc, but those guys are all Championship standard players trying to step up. Now it’s looking increasingly like most of our squad haven’t got what it takes to step up, which is to a degree forgivable.

Gibbs and Livermore don’t have that excuse, they’ve spent most of their careers in the Premier League. They’ve played for big clubs, played in Europe, played for England... they have experience and should be setting the example for the other players to follow. They’ve as bad, if not worse, than all the others. Piss poor performances, stupid red cards costing us matches, a general look as if they would rather be anywhere else...

They’ve stank the club out all season.

I disagree though I can understand why you might come to the conclusion. 

The fact is they're 3 yrs downstream on what were already declining careers. 

Gibbs's actions at Everton were incredibly stupid but also incredibly out of character ( a moment of madness - we've all had them)  but sadly it's almost totally disrupted his season and his persistent injuries and their consequences have caught up with him.  

We all get frustrated with the players,  but I do believe Jake does his very best when he pulls on the shirt.  I may be wrong, it has been known!
Jake May try but he wasn’t mobile enough for the Prem 3 years ago. Now he is just a passenger unfortunately.

Gibbs beggars belief. Their second goal was from a cross he made no effort to close down. Townsend from now on please.
Reply
#8
(01-30-2021, 08:25 PM)clem4england Wrote: The four seasons that Gibbs has been with us have been largely unsuccessful and it is no coincidence whatsoever IMO.

The same with Livermore Clem, it's been downhill for us from the minute he signed.
Reply
#9
At least Jake tries every game and will run through a wall for you despite his limitted ability. Gibbs- just please retire.
Reply
#10
As has been said; Livermore has lost any spark he used to have. I have no idea how, or what has happened, but he tries....unfortunately isn't good enough anymore.

Gibbs has screwed us up from the second game of the season v Everton. He doesn't need to play now Townsend is back, and hopefully won't.

If we're starting from the baseline of what they've done before then theyve been the most disappointing performers undoubtedly, although I wouldn't say either of them has been our worst player this season......though Gibbs would be in the bottom 2.

The problem is you need a decent team to help carry the players who are way below standard, unfortunately we have a couple of individuals trying to carry the vast majority of our players.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: