Posts: 2,414
Threads: 94
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
19
01-19-2021, 07:20 PM
(This post was last modified: 01-19-2021, 07:35 PM by ChamonixBaggie.)
(01-19-2021, 07:09 PM)Ossian Wrote: (01-19-2021, 06:55 PM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: (01-19-2021, 06:48 PM)Ossian Wrote: Somewhere between slightly and quite badly - in answer to the thread title. When the dust eventually settles there will be plenty of other countries in a much worse position than us, including some of the EU27; but that's when measurements (debt, deficit, GDP by sector) are expressed as national indicators. At the level of the individual there will be a vast disparity between - for want of a better expression - the winners and the losers. Anecdotally many of the most wealthy have, over the course of the last year or so, amassed even more.
That's going to need to change: and not by means of a Leninist insurrection either (at least hopefully not). However unpalatable it will be for some on the right, some of the solution lies in the manageable rebalancing of how wealth is accumulated; it will need to be redistributive without being punitive and that's a tough ask. It's just preferable to being completely... what was the word?
Awwwwww 
It wouldn't work in the UK anyway; halfway to the winter palace we'd get distracted by either Greggs or Caffe Nero.
In > explain to the staff that they're an oppressed proletariat and the wealth they create is being siphoned away by an undeserving elite - grab a free steak bake and an egg custard > out. Won't take 5 minutes
(01-19-2021, 07:28 PM)Ossian Wrote: (01-19-2021, 07:05 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (01-19-2021, 06:48 PM)Ossian Wrote: it will need to be redistributive without being punitive and that's a tough ask.
That's the nail on the head. Problem is - when the tax take is as high as it was in the mid-70s where do you go hunting for revenue? And if you increase marginal rates will you raise any additional revenue anyway?
My view is you avoid hitting any one thing too hard.
I'm not comfortable with a 50% income tax band - it just feels wrong for the taxman/woman to take half; so there's not much to be done there, possibly a 45% band. I think we could up our Corporation Tax rates by a couple of percent and still be well in line with similarly sized economies; that said I think the more pressing issue there is the lack of consistency applied when it comes to collection.
I'd probably remove the retirement age exemption from paying NI for those who continue to work; just on earned income that is, not pensions. I'd also be looking at landholdings - if not as a direct revenue earner for the treasury then certainly to assess whether there was justification for some of the subsidies received by certain types of estate.
The council tax banding system is in urgent need of an update; problem there is the cost of actually doing it.
Bite-sized chunks
When asked whether companies who use tax havens to avoid UK tax should therefore not receive UK government bailouts/support, Dominix Raab replied that this was "partisan baggage". Seems perfectly reasonable to me. Cracking down on the use of tax havens and tax loopholes seems an obvious starting point to me. We could also raise corporation tax by 5% and still have the lowest rate in mainland Europe.
Posts: 3,032
Threads: 78
Joined: Jun 2019
Reputation:
22
(01-19-2021, 07:05 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (01-19-2021, 06:48 PM)Ossian Wrote: it will need to be redistributive without being punitive and that's a tough ask.
That's the nail on the head. Problem is - when the tax take is as high as it was in the mid-70s where do you go hunting for revenue? And if you increase marginal rates will you raise any additional revenue anyway?
My view is you avoid hitting any one thing too hard.
I'm not comfortable with a 50% income tax band - it just feels wrong for the taxman/woman to take half; so there's not much to be done there, possibly a 45% band. I think we could up our Corporation Tax rates by a couple of percent and still be well in line with similarly sized economies; that said I think the more pressing issue there is the lack of consistency applied when it comes to collection.
I'd probably remove the retirement age exemption from paying NI for those who continue to work; just on earned income that is, not pensions. I'd also be looking at landholdings - if not as a direct revenue earner for the treasury then certainly to assess whether there was justification for some of the subsidies received by certain types of estate.
The council tax banding system is in urgent need of an update; problem there is the cost of actually doing it.
Bite-sized chunks
Posts: 13,569
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
(01-19-2021, 07:28 PM)Ossian Wrote: (01-19-2021, 07:05 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (01-19-2021, 06:48 PM)Ossian Wrote: it will need to be redistributive without being punitive and that's a tough ask.
That's the nail on the head. Problem is - when the tax take is as high as it was in the mid-70s where do you go hunting for revenue? And if you increase marginal rates will you raise any additional revenue anyway?
My view is you avoid hitting any one thing too hard.
I'm not comfortable with a 50% income tax band - it just feels wrong for the taxman/woman to take half; so there's not much to be done there, possibly a 45% band. I think we could up our Corporation Tax rates by a couple of percent and still be well in line with similarly sized economies; that said I think the more pressing issue there is the lack of consistency applied when it comes to collection.
I'd probably remove the retirement age exemption from paying NI for those who continue to work; just on earned income that is, not pensions. I'd also be looking at landholdings - if not as a direct revenue earner for the treasury then certainly to assess whether there was justification for some of the subsidies received by certain types of estate.
The council tax banding system is in urgent need of an update; problem there is the cost of actually doing it.
Bite-sized chunks
Three words. Land value tax
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
(01-19-2021, 07:28 PM)Ossian Wrote: (01-19-2021, 07:05 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (01-19-2021, 06:48 PM)Ossian Wrote: it will need to be redistributive without being punitive and that's a tough ask.
That's the nail on the head. Problem is - when the tax take is as high as it was in the mid-70s where do you go hunting for revenue? And if you increase marginal rates will you raise any additional revenue anyway?
My view is you avoid hitting any one thing too hard.
I'm not comfortable with a 50% income tax band - it just feels wrong for the taxman/woman to take half; so there's not much to be done there, possibly a 45% band. I think we could up our Corporation Tax rates by a couple of percent and still be well in line with similarly sized economies; that said I think the more pressing issue there is the lack of consistency applied when it comes to collection.
I'd probably remove the retirement age exemption from paying NI for those who continue to work; just on earned income that is, not pensions. I'd also be looking at landholdings - if not as a direct revenue earner for the treasury then certainly to assess whether there was justification for some of the subsidies received by certain types of estate.
The council tax banding system is in urgent need of an update; problem there is the cost of actually doing it.
Bite-sized chunks
That's entirely necessary. It's not common for me to agree with BB, but Land Value Tax is a fair and unavoidable tax - far preferable to further entirely avoidable capital or business taxes.
Posts: 613
Threads: 47
Joined: Apr 2019
Reputation:
2
(01-19-2021, 03:45 PM)Protheroe Wrote: In 2008, the UK spent 1.5% of GDP to alleviate the global financial crisis; this time we have spent 26% of GDP.
The answer to the question would appear to be, very.
Yet the S&P is at a record, Tesla & Bitcoin are at valuations disengaged from reality, the UK housing market is powering ahead and new IPOs & SPACs are announced every day - all on the foundation of cheap money and the printing press.
Sound money is dead. There are no monetary levers left for central banks to pull. The only way to get out of this hole is to inflate away our debt - and if you think "austerity" was bad, then wait for the return of inflation.
What will herald the inevitable correction this time? And which markets would you buy into to protect yourself from the carnage?
If the nominal growth rate is 4-5% of GDP, meaning higher inflation (raise the inflation target), then things will be fine. This will only happen if the government does some serious infrastructure spending and leaves taxes as they are. Brexit certainly doesn't help. We will have to live with a higher debt to gdp ratio for the foreseeable future but our debt to GDP ratio after WW2 was 250% of GDP. We need a more competitive economy, free trade, less tax avoidance, and investment in education. I think we will end up with the opposite though, which means low growth and rising inequality. This could lead to far right politics causing problems.
Posts: 8,954
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
(01-19-2021, 05:44 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (01-19-2021, 05:27 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Who'd have thought that voting for a failed journalist and London Mayor on a one promise campaign that everybody could see was set to fail could ever go wrong.
How's that relevant? Any government would be / is in a similar position.
Any? That’s not true is it, better handling of the pandemic and not giving our cash to their mates would have us in a better position to tackle the future problems.
Posts: 1,816
Threads: 69
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
5
(01-19-2021, 07:47 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (01-19-2021, 07:28 PM)Ossian Wrote: (01-19-2021, 07:05 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (01-19-2021, 06:48 PM)Ossian Wrote: it will need to be redistributive without being punitive and that's a tough ask.
That's the nail on the head. Problem is - when the tax take is as high as it was in the mid-70s where do you go hunting for revenue? And if you increase marginal rates will you raise any additional revenue anyway?
My view is you avoid hitting any one thing too hard.
I'm not comfortable with a 50% income tax band - it just feels wrong for the taxman/woman to take half; so there's not much to be done there, possibly a 45% band. I think we could up our Corporation Tax rates by a couple of percent and still be well in line with similarly sized economies; that said I think the more pressing issue there is the lack of consistency applied when it comes to collection.
I'd probably remove the retirement age exemption from paying NI for those who continue to work; just on earned income that is, not pensions. I'd also be looking at landholdings - if not as a direct revenue earner for the treasury then certainly to assess whether there was justification for some of the subsidies received by certain types of estate.
The council tax banding system is in urgent need of an update; problem there is the cost of actually doing it.
Bite-sized chunks
Three words. Land value tax
As unworkable and unfair as the poll tax
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
(01-19-2021, 08:48 PM)Jack Halford Wrote: As unworkable and unfair as the poll tax
Care to explain?
Posts: 13,569
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
(01-19-2021, 08:48 PM)Jack Halford Wrote: As unworkable and unfair as the poll tax
It is quite literally the most fair method of taxation you could get.
Posts: 1,816
Threads: 69
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
5
(01-19-2021, 08:58 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (01-19-2021, 08:48 PM)Jack Halford Wrote: As unworkable and unfair as the poll tax
Care to explain?
Ok, here goes.
The issue we have in this country is getting the thresholds , levels and valuation of such a tax right and to get the right balance in both the residential and commercial sectors.
I think we need to revisit SDLT. When Osbourne changed the Stamp Duty rates the levels received by HMRC dropped. SDLT is the only tax where you pay tax on a tax ( having to include Vat on rent , purchase price).
It will be interesting to see the levels of receipts during the stamp duty holiday.
It would be a massive exercise for VOA to value all Properties and they are Simply not enough district valuers.
A land valuation tax will also hit those on lower incomes in higher value houses who have stayed in them for many years and whose income is now disproportionate to the value of the property.
Then there is the thorny subject of land speculation and how to tax At a time when we are still building too few properties this would attack smaller developers.
Property is an easy target for taxation but one of the bedrocks of the economy, the first sector to drop in a recession.
|