Robinson...
#31
I feel for Grant for many of the reasons stated above and we don't play to his strengths but I do feel if we could get the ball forward quicker and get him turning the defence with balls into channels rather than to feet (his touch and hold up play are awful) he could still do a job for us
Reply
#32
(01-18-2021, 05:26 PM)Hopalong Wrote:
(01-18-2021, 03:29 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(01-18-2021, 03:23 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I prefer Robinson over Grant. As would most people I reckon.

I feel for Grant, he's been given an impossible job, not suited to his strengths and with a massive price tag hanging over him.

At Hudds he was a goal scorer, often from wide positions, similar in many ways to Wingie, but without the technique, so he hasn't adapted well to being a lone striker up top at all. He doesn't give much outside the box, he isn't lazy mind, just doesn't have anything to offer. He isn't quick, at least not like Robinson, he has a poor first touch, not great in the air and ultimately just not suited to the role he's been signed for.

What Bilic was thinking I don't know.

Sadly this was patently obvious to the Hudds fans who all said as much when we were linked in the summer.

Given how difficult it is to find any semblance of agreement on messageboards, the fact the vast majority of their fans could see it does raise concerns around what our scouting team and Slav saw in him.

I'm sure if/when we go down Grant will be a useful asset in that league, but £16m for a decent Championship striker feels like we've been done.

Really hope he proves me wrong mind!

At times like this it's useful to actually provide some facts. 

By way of comparison, over the past two seasons he has scored MORE league goals - 37 in 84  - than Watkins in FEWER games - 35 in 87 -  playing on the left of a front three, in a shit side struggling with relegation for two seasons!   He has also scored nearly as many goals as Robinson has (41) in his entire career and is two and a half years younger than Robinson and two years younger than Watkins.

He's been thrown into the deep-end in an unaccustomed role but I'm confident that over the course of his time with us he'll prove great value for money. 

As I've said countless times he's not an out and out no 9/lone striker who leads the line.  Get a proper no. 9 alongside him and he'll deliver (similar to Gayle). 

Whatever he has done or not done since he signed in a complete shit-fest of a season shouldn't be totally down to him.  Yes he's missed a couple of chances, but what support and service has he had?   Messi  and Ronaldo would struggle to score in our side.  How many have Aubamayang and Werner scored in far better sides and there are countless more examples.

Are you Grant’s agent Athers? You can’t wait to defend him at any given time...

You can make as many Watkins comparisons as you like to Grant, but I’d sooner have Watkins... Grant also took penalties, Watkins didn’t...

Again, Robinson has spent a lot more of his career wide, it’s not really fair to compare him with Grant... he also contributes a lot more.

I couldn’t care less if Grant didn’t score all season, if he played a part in a winning side. As it happens, you barely notice he’s on the pitch, whereas Robinson has been heavily involved in every game he’s played, and we have a much better goal and points per game return....
Reply
#33
I think many are in danger of going to early with their Grant assessment. Give the fella time.
Robinson is very handy in that role and has certainly boosted our attack. He isn't the answer though, we still need a no.9.
Reply
#34
I think the reason Watkins doesn't take penalties is because the ones he's taken before usually ended up going into orbit.
Reply
#35
(01-18-2021, 07:41 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: I think many are in danger of going to early with their Grant assessment. Give the fella time.
Robinson is very handy in that role and has certainly boosted our attack. He isn't the answer though, we still need a no.9.

Agreed. 

Nothing new though. You’d think the number of times players have been criticised heavily, only to go onto prove themselves over time would encourage people to have some patience. Still, here we are again.
Reply
#36
(01-18-2021, 05:26 PM)Hopalong Wrote:
(01-18-2021, 03:29 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(01-18-2021, 03:23 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I prefer Robinson over Grant. As would most people I reckon.

I feel for Grant, he's been given an impossible job, not suited to his strengths and with a massive price tag hanging over him.

At Hudds he was a goal scorer, often from wide positions, similar in many ways to Wingie, but without the technique, so he hasn't adapted well to being a lone striker up top at all. He doesn't give much outside the box, he isn't lazy mind, just doesn't have anything to offer. He isn't quick, at least not like Robinson, he has a poor first touch, not great in the air and ultimately just not suited to the role he's been signed for.

What Bilic was thinking I don't know.

Sadly this was patently obvious to the Hudds fans who all said as much when we were linked in the summer.

Given how difficult it is to find any semblance of agreement on messageboards, the fact the vast majority of their fans could see it does raise concerns around what our scouting team and Slav saw in him.

I'm sure if/when we go down Grant will be a useful asset in that league, but £16m for a decent Championship striker feels like we've been done.

Really hope he proves me wrong mind!

At times like this it's useful to actually provide some facts. 

By way of comparison, over the past two seasons he has scored MORE league goals - 37 in 84  - than Watkins in FEWER games - 35 in 87 -  playing on the left of a front three, in a shit side struggling with relegation for two seasons!   He has also scored nearly as many goals as Robinson has (41) in his entire career and is two and a half years younger than Robinson and two years younger than Watkins.

He's been thrown into the deep-end in an unaccustomed role but I'm confident that over the course of his time with us he'll prove great value for money. 

As I've said countless times he's not an out and out no 9/lone striker who leads the line.  Get a proper no. 9 alongside him and he'll deliver (similar to Gayle). 

Whatever he has done or not done since he signed in a complete shit-fest of a season shouldn't be totally down to him.  Yes he's missed a couple of chances, but what support and service has he had?   Messi  and Ronaldo would struggle to score in our side.  How many have Aubamayang and Werner scored in far better sides and there are countless more examples.

Spot on. The difference is Villa are playing to Watkins strengths. We're shoving Grant in the middle up front and hoping for the best, then moaning when he doesn't set the Prem alight.

He's also a few years younger. Sometimes we just like having players to shit on, particularly if they've cost a decent wedge through no fault of their own.
Reply
#37
(01-18-2021, 06:31 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(01-18-2021, 05:26 PM)Hopalong Wrote:
(01-18-2021, 03:29 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(01-18-2021, 03:23 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I prefer Robinson over Grant. As would most people I reckon.

I feel for Grant, he's been given an impossible job, not suited to his strengths and with a massive price tag hanging over him.

At Hudds he was a goal scorer, often from wide positions, similar in many ways to Wingie, but without the technique, so he hasn't adapted well to being a lone striker up top at all. He doesn't give much outside the box, he isn't lazy mind, just doesn't have anything to offer. He isn't quick, at least not like Robinson, he has a poor first touch, not great in the air and ultimately just not suited to the role he's been signed for.

What Bilic was thinking I don't know.

Sadly this was patently obvious to the Hudds fans who all said as much when we were linked in the summer.

Given how difficult it is to find any semblance of agreement on messageboards, the fact the vast majority of their fans could see it does raise concerns around what our scouting team and Slav saw in him.

I'm sure if/when we go down Grant will be a useful asset in that league, but £16m for a decent Championship striker feels like we've been done.

Really hope he proves me wrong mind!

At times like this it's useful to actually provide some facts. 

By way of comparison, over the past two seasons he has scored MORE league goals - 37 in 84  - than Watkins in FEWER games - 35 in 87 -  playing on the left of a front three, in a shit side struggling with relegation for two seasons!   He has also scored nearly as many goals as Robinson has (41) in his entire career and is two and a half years younger than Robinson and two years younger than Watkins.

He's been thrown into the deep-end in an unaccustomed role but I'm confident that over the course of his time with us he'll prove great value for money. 

As I've said countless times he's not an out and out no 9/lone striker who leads the line.  Get a proper no. 9 alongside him and he'll deliver (similar to Gayle). 

Whatever he has done or not done since he signed in a complete shit-fest of a season shouldn't be totally down to him.  Yes he's missed a couple of chances, but what support and service has he had?   Messi  and Ronaldo would struggle to score in our side.  How many have Aubamayang and Werner scored in far better sides and there are countless more examples.

Are you Grant’s agent Athers? You can’t wait to defend him at any given time...

You can make as many Watkins comparisons as you like to Grant, but I’d sooner have Watkins... Grant also took penalties, Watkins didn’t...

Again, Robinson has spent a lot more of his career wide, it’s not really fair to compare him with Grant... he also contributes a lot more.

I couldn’t care less if Grant didn’t score all season, if he played a part in a winning side. As it happens, you barely notice he’s on the pitch, whereas Robinson has been heavily involved in every game he’s played, and we have a much better goal and points per game return....

I defend what I consider to be unfair whatever it is - in this case criticism of a player who hasn't been here 5 minutes and who has had little or no support/service.  

You'd sooner have Watkins?  We couldn't afford Watkins so maybe you're missing the point with my comparison.  

You barely notice he's on the pitch because he's normally chasing hoofs and shadows 40 yards from the rest of the team.  I wasn't really comparing him with Robinson,  however it's not an unfair comparison as Grant has spent much of his career playing wide if you do your homework - like last season when he scored 19.  And penalties are goals - we may have still been in the FA Cup had he been playing. 

I really don't think a Robinson v Grant argument is particularly productive.  I'd like to see both of them in the team if we can find the right formula.  They linked up pretty well at Brighton for half an hour.
Reply
#38
(01-18-2021, 06:01 PM)fbaggy Wrote: I feel for Grant for many of the reasons stated above and we don't play to his strengths but I do feel if we could get the ball forward quicker and get him turning the defence with balls into channels rather than to feet (his touch and hold up play are awful) he could still do a job for us

That's a problem.

Drop it down his throat and he's okay. He'll finish.

Apart from that he'll offer absolutely nothing at all.

Abysmal player.
Reply
#39
Can't beat a nice refreshing glass of Robinsons Barley Water
Reply
#40
(01-18-2021, 09:16 PM)Baggie_Nick Wrote:
(01-18-2021, 06:01 PM)fbaggy Wrote: I feel for Grant for many of the reasons stated above and we don't play to his strengths but I do feel if we could get the ball forward quicker and get him turning the defence with balls into channels rather than to feet (his touch and hold up play are awful) he could still do a job for us

That's a problem.

Drop it down his throat and he's okay. He'll finish.

Apart from that he'll offer absolutely nothing at all.

Abysmal player.

The oracle has spoken.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: