Brexit deal sorted
#31
(12-27-2020, 09:42 AM)JOK Wrote:
(12-26-2020, 07:38 PM)Logic1 Wrote:
(12-26-2020, 06:52 PM)Wayne The Baggie Wrote: After 5 1/2 years the EU can still fish our waters with a 25% reduction in what they catch. Hardly ideal, and will they stick to it?

I don't remember discussions about fish (and Northern Ireland) featuring prominently during the referendum campaign. I am completely pissed off that mine and my children's freedom of movement has been restricted. This deal is better than no deal but it is not better for us than being members of the EU. As soon as we start to diverge from the EUs rules it will enhance the likelihood of a trade war with them, which we will not win because we are considerably smaller than our biggest trading partners (the EU). My hope though is that this will be a jolting to the EU to reform. Then, at a later date, once the Farage's of this world are having their nappies cleaned in their care homes (paid for by my generations taxes) we can rejoin.
Good luck with that! If you mean reforming for the better. The last 53 years have proved contrary to that.

The generation that paid for your education, health care and child allowance, you mean?

Your generation is set to take out over 20% more from the state than you put in as tax, and that's after being adjusted for inflation. You are literally the last person that should be talking about paying for stuff.
Reply
#32
(12-24-2020, 07:06 PM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: By all reports I've seen Britain has conceded more than the EU

Which one's are they? All the reports I've read suggest it's a very balanced deal. I was happy with the way Von Der Leyen presented it, let alone Johnson.

It seems once the grown ups got involved and sidelined the idiot Barnier things got moving very quickly.
Reply
#33
(12-27-2020, 10:13 AM)Logic1 Wrote: No doubt you are in the 60-80 year old generation. The biggest spongers in uk history. No tuition fees, massive property price rises, low retirement ages, massive debt put on my generation and now you get the vaccine first. Furthermore, you lot took us out of the EU that lowers our long run growth rate. If you don't think people like me, (30-40 age bracket) and the generations after me aren't pissed off then you are deluded. No doubt we will be paying for a national care service for you as well.

Oh dear. You need some cream for that butthurt.

The logic that you or I will actually be effected by a projected growth rate 4% lower than it might otherwise have been over a period of 15 years is bananas, particularly when you set that against a 8.6% reduction in GDP this year alone.

The biggest spongers in history? If only my mother and father were alive to hear you say that.....
Reply
#34
(12-27-2020, 11:53 AM)The liquidator Wrote: You do know you can move quite freely the problem is you want it all for free.... If they are good enough in the future they will be snapped up.... Paying your away through Europe is not a bad thing....... Thanks for keeping us all going on your wages we are eternally grateful. Xxx

Now listen here you odious little oik. In future if self proclaimed intellectual betters condescend to you, you are to doff your cap and thank your lucky stars that such highly skilled professionals honour you by still working in this grey racist little isle. Know your place ruffian.
Flag shagging,misogynistic,covidiot,anitvax gammon.
Or just a normal white bloke.
Reply
#35
(12-27-2020, 01:53 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(12-27-2020, 10:13 AM)Logic1 Wrote: No doubt you are in the 60-80 year old generation. The biggest spongers in uk history. No tuition fees, massive property price rises, low retirement ages, massive debt put on my generation and now you get the vaccine first. Furthermore, you lot took us out of the EU that lowers our long run growth rate. If you don't think people like me, (30-40 age bracket) and the generations after me aren't pissed off then you are deluded. No doubt we will be paying for a national care service for you as well.

Oh dear. You need some cream for that butthurt.

The logic that you or I will actually be effected by a projected growth rate 4% lower than it might otherwise have been over a period of 15 years is bananas, particularly when you set that against a 8.6% reduction in GDP this year alone.

The biggest spongers in history? If only my mother and father were alive to hear you say that.....
Because your mother and father are not alive, by definition they are obviously not spongers from the state. We have had to close the economy to protect the elderly who are more at risk from Covid. I am certainly all for that. The least they could do is partially pay for it. Why should my generation pay the bill? Furthermore, I don't buy the OBR's estimate. Leaving the EU on this deal will mean a lower level of growth for years and decades to come. Anyone who knows anything about economic growth and compound growth rates would understand that. I would imagine you are quite livid given the fact that this deal essentially locks us in to EU rules, without us having any control over them and making a trade war more likely. So much for sovereignty.

When people voted for Brexit, did they really vote for this...

I thought that it would be the easiest deal ever? And that red tape would be eliminated...

https://twitter.com/AntonSpisak/status/1...93728?s=19

Well done for helping to make us look a basket case. The rest of the world are laughing at us and our influence in world affairs is now gone forever.
Reply
#36
Poor lord snooty getting his knickers in a twist.
Reply
#37
(12-27-2020, 03:56 PM)The liquidator Wrote: Poor lord  snooty getting his knickers in a twist.

What's Jacob Rees-Mogg got to do with anything?
Reply
#38
(12-27-2020, 03:56 PM)The liquidator Wrote: Poor lord  snooty getting his knickers in a twist.

What's Jacob Rees-Mogg got to do with anything?
Reply
#39
Here is a great Martin Wolf piece in the FT that summarises things nicely. If you voted for Brexit, you were conned. 


By Martin Wolf 2 HOURS AGO290
After four and a half painful years, we have reached the end of the beginning of Brexit. We have a deal. It is, inevitably, a damaging deal for the British economy compared with remaining inside the EU. But it is far better than the stupidity of no deal. Above all, it maintains a working relationship with the UK’s close neighbours and principal economic partners.
No responsible government would leave mere days for businesses to adjust to the complexities of this new situation. Still less would it do so in the midst of a pandemic. This will remain a foolish and unnecessary divorce. But the reality of Brexit may even bring some benefits.
The EU should already seen some. It would almost certainly have been unable to agree its €750bn pandemic recovery fund if the UK had remained at the table. From now on, the EU will be able to move faster towards its shared objectives.

For the UK, too, Brexit will bring the big benefit of separating reality from delusion.
Recommended
Some delusions have already disappeared. Brexiters told the country that it would be easy to secure an excellent free trade agreement with the EU, because it held “all the cards”. In fact, it has proved quite hard to do so and the UK has had to make difficult concessions since 2016, notably over the money it owed the EU, the Irish border, and EU demands for a “level playing field”.
These delusions were buttressed by others. Among them was the idea that the UK and the EU would negotiate as “sovereign equals”. Yes, the EU and UK are equally sovereign. But they are not equally powerful. The UK economy is less than 20 per cent of the EU’s. Forty-six per cent of UK merchandise exports went to the EU in 2019, while only 15 per cent of EU merchandise exports (excluding its internal trade) went to the UK.
The economic relationship between the EU and UK is rather like Canada’s with the US. As Jonathan Portes of King’s College London points out, the trade deal imposed on Canada and Mexico by the US is quite intrusive.

Given this imbalance, and the UK’s sovereignty fetish, the UK has won a good deal. The 1,246 page text of the agreement contains scant and insignificant mention of the European Court of Justice. The detailed agreement on the vexed issue of the “level playing field” is symmetrical. But any action by the EU to “rebalance” its policies, in response to a UK action to which it has successfully objected, will have a far bigger impact on the UK than vice versa.
The reality is asymmetrical. That will remain the case in the many negotiations with the EU still to come. When one deals with foreign powers. and especially more powerful ones, “taking back control” is somewhat notional.
Yet that slogan is also a delusion in some other respects. In defence, education, housing, health, regional development, public investment and welfare, the UK already largely had control. But British people are about to lose valuable opportunities to do business or live, study and work in the EU. They will not “take back control” over their lives, but lose it.
Even where control will be regained, in theory, the reality may shock Leavers. Consider immigration. In the 12 months ending June 2016 (the month of the referendum), net immigration from EU plus non-EU sources was 355,000 (with net emigration by British people ignored). In the 12 months ending March 2020, net immigration was 374,000. Net immigration from the EU collapsed from 189,000 to 58,000. But that from the rest of the world — always notionally under UK control — exploded, from 166,000 to 316,000.
The UK has in fact preserved relatively favourable (albeit markedly worse) access for manufactures, in which it has a comparative disadvantage, while accepting substantially worse treatment of services, in which it has a comparative advantage. Indeed, it fought harder for the control over fishing, which generates 0.04 per cent of UK gross domestic product, than for services, which generates the great bulk of it.
Mr Johnson promised that the UK will “prosper mightily” even without a deal. But virtually all economists agree that the UK will be significantly poorer in the long run, even under this sort of deal, than if it had remained a member.
Even the survival of the UK is in doubt. Scotland and Northern Ireland may both leave the Union, the former to join the EU, arguing that it, too, wants “to take back control”, and the latter to join Ireland and so the EU, too. England may then have a border with the EU on the Irish Sea and the Tweed.
Brexit is, in many ways, the English equivalent of Donald Trump’s promise to “make America great again”. A big difference is that, unlike Mr Trump’s time as US president, Brexit is forever. It seems almost certain to damage the country’s prosperity and influence permanently. But only now can we find out. Let us look and learn.
martin.wolf@ft.com

Reply
#40
Poor Martin. Still fighting the (lost) battle of 2016.

In all seriousness, I'm watching Merkel sucking up to the Chinese who've ridden roughshod over human rights in Hong Kong and feeling even more pleased we're out of their rotten little club. At least she decided which side her bread was buttered on when she and Ursula sidelined the increasingly ludicrous Barnier.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)