Hey Fickle fans a great read on Sam Allardyce
#31
(12-18-2020, 09:56 AM)Olympic Wrote: One of my main gripes with the appointment is that we were on the right path with Slav. Getting in young players such as Grant, Diangana, Pereira, Gallagher, Krov and bedding in academy players such as O’Shea, Edwards even Ferguson before. Even if we got relegated we tried to play the right way and next season with a couple of additions we would have hell of an exciting side. With the appointment of big Sam we will now have the old timers coming in and taking place of the youngsters all so he can get his bonus payment.

I'm not overly concerned about that this season if I'm honest. Our finances are unlikely to permit Sam bringing in any old heads on big contracts / high fees... I imagine we'll make a couple of loans, possibly Tomkins, and probably a couple bodies from abroad. 

If we go down, Sam will depart and we're in no worse position than we'd have been had we stuck with Slav.... the young players you mention will still be here, and given some of our performances this season, the likes of O'Shea, Grady, Pereira and Grant will still be with us, and hopefully any of Sam's old guard will have seen their loans / short term deals come to an end. 

If we survive, then it's a more worrying picture as we will need surgery on the squad again and Sam's approach to recruitment wont necessarily match Downings - but we'll just have to hope that Lai is able to sell up and we may have a more flexible budget!
Reply
#32
(12-18-2020, 10:28 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(12-18-2020, 09:56 AM)Olympic Wrote: One of my main gripes with the appointment is that we were on the right path with Slav. Getting in young players such as Grant, Diangana, Pereira, Gallagher, Krov and bedding in academy players such as O’Shea, Edwards even Ferguson before. Even if we got relegated we tried to play the right way and next season with a couple of additions we would have hell of an exciting side. With the appointment of big Sam we will now have the old timers coming in and taking place of the youngsters all so he can get his bonus payment.

I'm not overly concerned about that this season if I'm honest. Our finances are unlikely to permit Sam bringing in any old heads on big contracts / high fees... I imagine we'll make a couple of loans, possibly Tomkins, and probably a couple bodies from abroad. 

If we go down, Sam will depart and we're in no worse position than we'd have been had we stuck with Slav.... the young players you mention will still be here, and given some of our performances this season, the likes of O'Shea, Grady, Pereira and Grant will still be with us, and hopefully any of Sam's old guard will have seen their loans / short term deals come to an end. 

If we survive, then it's a more worrying picture as we will need surgery on the squad again and Sam's approach to recruitment wont necessarily match Downings - but we'll just have to hope that Lai is able to sell up and we may have a more flexible budget!

*IF* we go down and the fat one goes, as expected, WHO the feck do we get in then? Will they be brave and take a riskier option? Will they play it safe and get in another old dinosaur?? For me this is the worst thing that could happen, as we have no plan for a promotion push. Without Slav who is to say that his players, who he pushed and pushed for, will even want to stay? (contracts don't matter when the player wants away).

We've shifted the problem and seem to be assuming that because BFS has saved teams before that it is a given that he'll keep us up. *IF* he keeps us up he then gets another year... The thought of that makes me really sad. Damned if we do and damned if we don't.

There were ifs and buts with Slav staying too, and yes relegation looked possible (even if we did seem to be starting to pull together of late), but I felt confident in his ability next year.

So the simple choices are:
Relegation, BFS goes, who then replaces him?? Likely that the decent managers will get snapped up by the teams who will be sacking in the Prem soon.

Survival, BFS stays and does a Pulis with the squad...

frying pan meet fire.
Reply
#33
(12-17-2020, 10:46 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: All of us fickle, me included.

I was upset at Bilic's departure, but now it's done it's acceptance. You live and die by the sword as a top professional manager, but the money is phenomenal- more than 99% of us mere mortals will ever see.

Truth is multi millions rest on us stopping up and Allardyce has the CV to show he can do the job. Also, the tales of purist play is the stuff of fantasy for most teams just up.

Some of our happiest times was under the gritty no frills era of Megson and I am, generally, happier watching us win 1-0 than lose 4-3.

Bilic was, based on the games so far, heading for too few points. That doesn't discredit his brilliant achievements last season though. We all wanted it to work.

If in 18 months we are financially better off Bilic's play would work again possibly, with 4 or 5 solid additions. 

This is a great read about Allardyce, which actually gives heart. https://www.theguardian.com/football/the...ier-league
Interesting thoughts, and thanks.

But can we please put this silly false dichotomy argument to bed.
There's no choice between "losing 4-3 and winning 1-0…"
Never has been. If there was we'd all choose winning, be top of the league and Tony Pulis would be managing Barcelona.
Just as there's no such thing as "winning football".
Just different styles, philosophes, methods, whatever.
You can prefer Pulis Ball over Mowbray or vice versa but no manager-even this week's version - can guarantee success. Pulis lost far more matches than he won. So does FS. 
Oh, and I'm not fickle either.
I preferred Bilic. Still do. That's consistent.
Reply
#34
(12-18-2020, 09:56 AM)Olympic Wrote: One of my main gripes with the appointment is that we were on the right path with Slav. Getting in young players such as Grant, Diangana, Pereira, Gallagher, Krov and bedding in academy players such as O’Shea, Edwards even Ferguson before. Even if we got relegated we tried to play the right way and next season with a couple of additions we would have hell of an exciting side. With the appointment of big Sam we will now have the old timers coming in and taking place of the youngsters all so he can get his bonus payment.

+1 

This is my greatest fear.  That he substitutes players with a huge amount of heart for those with experience and grit.  As a consequence of which we lose a generation of players who won't be playing, and won't want to play for the club again.  I think Allardyce does have room for flair players in his sides but to achieve safety they'll be at a premium and several of the guys we have at the moment are in for a rude awakening. 

One thing is for sure, Allardyce's teams are fit - and ours has been suspiciously lacking in this regard, although Man City did seem to belie this. Shit - even I'm confused/fickle.  I used to be undecided but now I'm not so sure.
Reply
#35
(12-18-2020, 10:28 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(12-18-2020, 09:56 AM)Olympic Wrote: One of my main gripes with the appointment is that we were on the right path with Slav. Getting in young players such as Grant, Diangana, Pereira, Gallagher, Krov and bedding in academy players such as O’Shea, Edwards even Ferguson before. Even if we got relegated we tried to play the right way and next season with a couple of additions we would have hell of an exciting side. With the appointment of big Sam we will now have the old timers coming in and taking place of the youngsters all so he can get his bonus payment.

I'm not overly concerned about that this season if I'm honest. Our finances are unlikely to permit Sam bringing in any old heads on big contracts / high fees... I imagine we'll make a couple of loans, possibly Tomkins, and probably a couple bodies from abroad. 

If we go down, Sam will depart and we're in no worse position than we'd have been had we stuck with Slav.... the young players you mention will still be here, and given some of our performances this season, the likes of O'Shea, Grady, Pereira and Grant will still be with us, and hopefully any of Sam's old guard will have seen their loans / short term deals come to an end. 

If we survive, then it's a more worrying picture as we will need surgery on the squad again and Sam's approach to recruitment wont necessarily match Downings - but we'll just have to hope that Lai is able to sell up and we may have a more flexible budget!

If we do go down you need a strong father figure to convince players to stay and that the club is on the right path. A bit like Farke at Norwich. There is no way Pereira, Krov, Gallagher etc will want to stay on with no future plan.
Reply
#36
(12-18-2020, 10:34 AM)MassDebater Wrote:
(12-18-2020, 10:28 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(12-18-2020, 09:56 AM)Olympic Wrote: One of my main gripes with the appointment is that we were on the right path with Slav. Getting in young players such as Grant, Diangana, Pereira, Gallagher, Krov and bedding in academy players such as O’Shea, Edwards even Ferguson before. Even if we got relegated we tried to play the right way and next season with a couple of additions we would have hell of an exciting side. With the appointment of big Sam we will now have the old timers coming in and taking place of the youngsters all so he can get his bonus payment.

I'm not overly concerned about that this season if I'm honest. Our finances are unlikely to permit Sam bringing in any old heads on big contracts / high fees... I imagine we'll make a couple of loans, possibly Tomkins, and probably a couple bodies from abroad. 

If we go down, Sam will depart and we're in no worse position than we'd have been had we stuck with Slav.... the young players you mention will still be here, and given some of our performances this season, the likes of O'Shea, Grady, Pereira and Grant will still be with us, and hopefully any of Sam's old guard will have seen their loans / short term deals come to an end. 

If we survive, then it's a more worrying picture as we will need surgery on the squad again and Sam's approach to recruitment wont necessarily match Downings - but we'll just have to hope that Lai is able to sell up and we may have a more flexible budget!

*IF* we go down and the fat one goes, as expected, WHO the feck do we get in then? Will they be brave and take a riskier option? Will they play it safe and get in another old dinosaur?? For me this is the worst thing that could happen, as we have no plan for a promotion push. Without Slav who is to say that his players, who he pushed and pushed for, will even want to stay? (contracts don't matter when the player wants away).

We've shifted the problem and seem to be assuming that because BFS has saved teams before that it is a given that he'll keep us up. *IF* he keeps us up he then gets another year... The thought of that makes me really sad. Damned if we do and damned if we don't.

There were ifs and buts with Slav staying too, and yes relegation looked possible (even if we did seem to be starting to pull together of late), but I felt confident in his ability next year.

So the simple choices are:
Relegation, BFS goes, who then replaces him?? Likely that the decent managers will get snapped up by the teams who will be sacking in the Prem soon.

Survival, BFS stays and does a Pulis with the squad...

frying pan meet fire.
when we would have gone down with slav he would have been sacked there was no offer of a new contract and i bet he didnt want one either way we would have a new manager
Reply
#37
(12-18-2020, 10:39 AM)Olympic Wrote:
(12-18-2020, 10:28 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(12-18-2020, 09:56 AM)Olympic Wrote: One of my main gripes with the appointment is that we were on the right path with Slav. Getting in young players such as Grant, Diangana, Pereira, Gallagher, Krov and bedding in academy players such as O’Shea, Edwards even Ferguson before. Even if we got relegated we tried to play the right way and next season with a couple of additions we would have hell of an exciting side. With the appointment of big Sam we will now have the old timers coming in and taking place of the youngsters all so he can get his bonus payment.

I'm not overly concerned about that this season if I'm honest. Our finances are unlikely to permit Sam bringing in any old heads on big contracts / high fees... I imagine we'll make a couple of loans, possibly Tomkins, and probably a couple bodies from abroad. 

If we go down, Sam will depart and we're in no worse position than we'd have been had we stuck with Slav.... the young players you mention will still be here, and given some of our performances this season, the likes of O'Shea, Grady, Pereira and Grant will still be with us, and hopefully any of Sam's old guard will have seen their loans / short term deals come to an end. 

If we survive, then it's a more worrying picture as we will need surgery on the squad again and Sam's approach to recruitment wont necessarily match Downings - but we'll just have to hope that Lai is able to sell up and we may have a more flexible budget!

If we do go down you need a strong father figure to convince players to stay and that the club is on the right path. A bit like Farke at Norwich. There is no way Pereira, Krov, Gallagher etc will want to stay on with no future plan.


There's not a snowball in hells chance, Gallagher will be here next year, no matter what division we're in.
Reply
#38
(12-18-2020, 10:40 AM)The liquidator Wrote:
(12-18-2020, 10:34 AM)MassDebater Wrote:
(12-18-2020, 10:28 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(12-18-2020, 09:56 AM)Olympic Wrote: One of my main gripes with the appointment is that we were on the right path with Slav. Getting in young players such as Grant, Diangana, Pereira, Gallagher, Krov and bedding in academy players such as O’Shea, Edwards even Ferguson before. Even if we got relegated we tried to play the right way and next season with a couple of additions we would have hell of an exciting side. With the appointment of big Sam we will now have the old timers coming in and taking place of the youngsters all so he can get his bonus payment.

I'm not overly concerned about that this season if I'm honest. Our finances are unlikely to permit Sam bringing in any old heads on big contracts / high fees... I imagine we'll make a couple of loans, possibly Tomkins, and probably a couple bodies from abroad. 

If we go down, Sam will depart and we're in no worse position than we'd have been had we stuck with Slav.... the young players you mention will still be here, and given some of our performances this season, the likes of O'Shea, Grady, Pereira and Grant will still be with us, and hopefully any of Sam's old guard will have seen their loans / short term deals come to an end. 

If we survive, then it's a more worrying picture as we will need surgery on the squad again and Sam's approach to recruitment wont necessarily match Downings - but we'll just have to hope that Lai is able to sell up and we may have a more flexible budget!

*IF* we go down and the fat one goes, as expected, WHO the feck do we get in then? Will they be brave and take a riskier option? Will they play it safe and get in another old dinosaur?? For me this is the worst thing that could happen, as we have no plan for a promotion push. Without Slav who is to say that his players, who he pushed and pushed for, will even want to stay? (contracts don't matter when the player wants away).

We've shifted the problem and seem to be assuming that because BFS has saved teams before that it is a given that he'll keep us up. *IF* he keeps us up he then gets another year... The thought of that makes me really sad. Damned if we do and damned if we don't.

There were ifs and buts with Slav staying too, and yes relegation looked possible (even if we did seem to be starting to pull together of late), but I felt confident in his ability next year.

So the simple choices are:
Relegation, BFS goes, who then replaces him?? Likely that the decent managers will get snapped up by the teams who will be sacking in the Prem soon.

Survival, BFS stays and does a Pulis with the squad...

frying pan meet fire.
when we would have gone down with slav he would have been sacked there was no offer of a new contract and i bet he didnt want one either way we would have a new manager

Maybe, maybe not. Sadly, we'll never get to find out.
Reply
#39
(12-18-2020, 10:39 AM)Olympic Wrote:
(12-18-2020, 10:28 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(12-18-2020, 09:56 AM)Olympic Wrote: One of my main gripes with the appointment is that we were on the right path with Slav. Getting in young players such as Grant, Diangana, Pereira, Gallagher, Krov and bedding in academy players such as O’Shea, Edwards even Ferguson before. Even if we got relegated we tried to play the right way and next season with a couple of additions we would have hell of an exciting side. With the appointment of big Sam we will now have the old timers coming in and taking place of the youngsters all so he can get his bonus payment.

I'm not overly concerned about that this season if I'm honest. Our finances are unlikely to permit Sam bringing in any old heads on big contracts / high fees... I imagine we'll make a couple of loans, possibly Tomkins, and probably a couple bodies from abroad. 

If we go down, Sam will depart and we're in no worse position than we'd have been had we stuck with Slav.... the young players you mention will still be here, and given some of our performances this season, the likes of O'Shea, Grady, Pereira and Grant will still be with us, and hopefully any of Sam's old guard will have seen their loans / short term deals come to an end. 

If we survive, then it's a more worrying picture as we will need surgery on the squad again and Sam's approach to recruitment wont necessarily match Downings - but we'll just have to hope that Lai is able to sell up and we may have a more flexible budget!

If we do go down you need a strong father figure to convince players to stay and that the club is on the right path. A bit like Farke at Norwich. There is no way Pereira, Krov, Gallagher etc will want to stay on with no future plan.
Or like... Bilic?
Reply
#40
(12-18-2020, 10:43 AM)Psalm23 Wrote:
(12-18-2020, 10:39 AM)Olympic Wrote:
(12-18-2020, 10:28 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(12-18-2020, 09:56 AM)Olympic Wrote: One of my main gripes with the appointment is that we were on the right path with Slav. Getting in young players such as Grant, Diangana, Pereira, Gallagher, Krov and bedding in academy players such as O’Shea, Edwards even Ferguson before. Even if we got relegated we tried to play the right way and next season with a couple of additions we would have hell of an exciting side. With the appointment of big Sam we will now have the old timers coming in and taking place of the youngsters all so he can get his bonus payment.

I'm not overly concerned about that this season if I'm honest. Our finances are unlikely to permit Sam bringing in any old heads on big contracts / high fees... I imagine we'll make a couple of loans, possibly Tomkins, and probably a couple bodies from abroad. 

If we go down, Sam will depart and we're in no worse position than we'd have been had we stuck with Slav.... the young players you mention will still be here, and given some of our performances this season, the likes of O'Shea, Grady, Pereira and Grant will still be with us, and hopefully any of Sam's old guard will have seen their loans / short term deals come to an end. 

If we survive, then it's a more worrying picture as we will need surgery on the squad again and Sam's approach to recruitment wont necessarily match Downings - but we'll just have to hope that Lai is able to sell up and we may have a more flexible budget!

If we do go down you need a strong father figure to convince players to stay and that the club is on the right path. A bit like Farke at Norwich. There is no way Pereira, Krov, Gallagher etc will want to stay on with no future plan.


There's not a snowball in hells chance, Gallagher will be here next year, no matter what division we're in.

Well 100% not a chance under Big Sam as Chelsea carefully select where their young players go to suit Chelsea style of play. Under Slav I'd say there was definitely a possibility if we had stayed up. As good as he is he is still not getting in the Chelsea team ahead of Kante, Mount, Kovacic or Jorginho. In fact a huge worry for me is that Lampard might recall him in January and send him off to Brighton or someone.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)