The Return of Brexit
I like Tobias Ellwood, and I sympathise with him. He's the 'go to' Tory who gets pushed in front of a camera to repair the damage when something crass has been said out loud.
Reply
(12-13-2020, 11:54 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(12-13-2020, 10:07 AM)Protheroe Wrote: You've swallowed the conventional Protectionist's Charter hook, line and sinker. None of the arguments you make are in favour of free trade, all of them point to protectionism.

The bottom line is this. You cannot give me an example of a country that ever, in human history - made itself poorer by making itself more open to trade.

What I just listed are the problems with unilateral free trade and correcting the nonsense belief, alternatively the blatant lie, that it is better for the consumer. These do not apply to reciprocal free trade deals, which I wholeheartedly support. Even your arguments for unilateral free trade rely on conflating it with reciprocal free trade and hoping nobody notices. To call me protectionist by pointing out the stupidity and illogical nature of what you want is ridiculous, especially when I'm someone who's against tariffs and non-tariff barriers.

And aside from Somalia no country has been stupid enough to pursue unilateral free trade, stop conflating your stupid unilateral free trade idea with actual successful examples of free trade. They're nothing alike.

(12-13-2020, 10:17 AM)Jack Halford Wrote: As always one rule for us one rule for the EU.

In addition we are the 9th largest manufacturing nation in the world and our output will only increase.

We also have some great niche industries. In the gaming world we have Leamington Spa talked about in the same breath as Silicon Valley.

Will we survive a no deal, he’ll yes we will.

Mate, a single Polish video gaming company is bigger than Codemasters and Playground Games. The biggest video gaming company outside of the US and Japan is French, not British. Leamington Spa is not talked about in the same breath as Silicon Valley.

Mate, the tech sector in Leamington is growing rapidly. We have an office in California. Do the tech companies there know about the growth in Leamington, yes.

The point I’m making is that it’s very easy to knock GB but we are seeing some real growth areas, Life Sciences being another.

(12-13-2020, 11:54 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(12-13-2020, 10:07 AM)Protheroe Wrote: You've swallowed the conventional Protectionist's Charter hook, line and sinker. None of the arguments you make are in favour of free trade, all of them point to protectionism.

The bottom line is this. You cannot give me an example of a country that ever, in human history - made itself poorer by making itself more open to trade.

What I just listed are the problems with unilateral free trade and correcting the nonsense belief, alternatively the blatant lie, that it is better for the consumer. These do not apply to reciprocal free trade deals, which I wholeheartedly support. Even your arguments for unilateral free trade rely on conflating it with reciprocal free trade and hoping nobody notices. To call me protectionist by pointing out the stupidity and illogical nature of what you want is ridiculous, especially when I'm someone who's against tariffs and non-tariff barriers.

And aside from Somalia no country has been stupid enough to pursue unilateral free trade, stop conflating your stupid unilateral free trade idea with actual successful examples of free trade. They're nothing alike.

(12-13-2020, 10:17 AM)Jack Halford Wrote: As always one rule for us one rule for the EU.

In addition we are the 9th largest manufacturing nation in the world and our output will only increase.

We also have some great niche industries. In the gaming world we have Leamington Spa talked about in the same breath as Silicon Valley.

Will we survive a no deal, he’ll yes we will.

Mate, a single Polish video gaming company is bigger than Codemasters and Playground Games. The biggest video gaming company outside of the US and Japan is French, not British. Leamington Spa is not talked about in the same breath as Silicon Valley.

Mate, the tech sector in Leamington is growing rapidly. We have an office in California. Do the tech companies there know about the growth in Leamington, yes.

The point I’m making is that it’s very easy to knock GB but we are seeing some real growth areas, Life Sciences being another.
Reply
(12-13-2020, 12:48 PM)Jack Halford Wrote:
(12-13-2020, 11:54 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(12-13-2020, 10:07 AM)Protheroe Wrote: You've swallowed the conventional Protectionist's Charter hook, line and sinker. None of the arguments you make are in favour of free trade, all of them point to protectionism.

The bottom line is this. You cannot give me an example of a country that ever, in human history - made itself poorer by making itself more open to trade.

What I just listed are the problems with unilateral free trade and correcting the nonsense belief, alternatively the blatant lie, that it is better for the consumer. These do not apply to reciprocal free trade deals, which I wholeheartedly support. Even your arguments for unilateral free trade rely on conflating it with reciprocal free trade and hoping nobody notices. To call me protectionist by pointing out the stupidity and illogical nature of what you want is ridiculous, especially when I'm someone who's against tariffs and non-tariff barriers.

And aside from Somalia no country has been stupid enough to pursue unilateral free trade, stop conflating your stupid unilateral free trade idea with actual successful examples of free trade. They're nothing alike.

(12-13-2020, 10:17 AM)Jack Halford Wrote: As always one rule for us one rule for the EU.

In addition we are the 9th largest manufacturing nation in the world and our output will only increase.

We also have some great niche industries. In the gaming world we have Leamington Spa talked about in the same breath as Silicon Valley.

Will we survive a no deal, he’ll yes we will.

Mate, a single Polish video gaming company is bigger than Codemasters and Playground Games. The biggest video gaming company outside of the US and Japan is French, not British. Leamington Spa is not talked about in the same breath as Silicon Valley.

Mate, the tech sector in Leamington is growing rapidly. We have an office in California. Do the tech companies there know about the growth in Leamington, yes.

The point I’m making is that it’s very easy to knock GB but we are seeing some real growth areas, Life Sciences being another.

(12-13-2020, 11:54 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(12-13-2020, 10:07 AM)Protheroe Wrote: You've swallowed the conventional Protectionist's Charter hook, line and sinker. None of the arguments you make are in favour of free trade, all of them point to protectionism.

The bottom line is this. You cannot give me an example of a country that ever, in human history - made itself poorer by making itself more open to trade.

What I just listed are the problems with unilateral free trade and correcting the nonsense belief, alternatively the blatant lie, that it is better for the consumer. These do not apply to reciprocal free trade deals, which I wholeheartedly support. Even your arguments for unilateral free trade rely on conflating it with reciprocal free trade and hoping nobody notices. To call me protectionist by pointing out the stupidity and illogical nature of what you want is ridiculous, especially when I'm someone who's against tariffs and non-tariff barriers.

And aside from Somalia no country has been stupid enough to pursue unilateral free trade, stop conflating your stupid unilateral free trade idea with actual successful examples of free trade. They're nothing alike.

(12-13-2020, 10:17 AM)Jack Halford Wrote: As always one rule for us one rule for the EU.

In addition we are the 9th largest manufacturing nation in the world and our output will only increase.

We also have some great niche industries. In the gaming world we have Leamington Spa talked about in the same breath as Silicon Valley.

Will we survive a no deal, he’ll yes we will.

Mate, a single Polish video gaming company is bigger than Codemasters and Playground Games. The biggest video gaming company outside of the US and Japan is French, not British. Leamington Spa is not talked about in the same breath as Silicon Valley.

Mate, the tech sector in Leamington is growing rapidly. We have an office in California. Do the tech companies there know about the growth in Leamington, yes.

The point I’m making is that it’s very easy to knock GB but we are seeing some real growth areas, Life Sciences being another.

GDP of silicon valley $275 billion
GDP of Leamington Spa tech ins. £100 million
Reply
(12-13-2020, 12:48 PM)Jack Halford Wrote: Mate, the tech sector in Leamington is growing rapidly. We have an office in California. Do the tech companies there know about the growth in Leamington, yes.

The point I’m making is that it’s very easy to knock GB but we are seeing some real growth areas, Life Sciences being another.

It may well be growing rapidly, but just because a few local business leaders in Warwickshire have branded it as "Silicon Spa" for marketing purposes doesn't mean that it is mentioned in the same breath as Silicon Valley, there's a brilliant up and coming distillery in the south of the county but it's not the Islay of England.

Warwickshire's economy is still centred around high tech manufacturing and tourism, two things that will take a hit from Brexit. The new Forza and Fable games won't change that as they pale in comparison. Hell, logistics and distribution is a huge industry in the county and that's going to take a massive hit with customs backlogs.

As for life sciences, that industry has been heavily reliant on cooperation within the single market, the second biggest pharmaceutical company in the UK is Anglo-Swedish.
Reply
(12-13-2020, 01:02 PM)Bilich Wrote:
(12-13-2020, 12:48 PM)Jack Halford Wrote:
(12-13-2020, 11:54 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(12-13-2020, 10:07 AM)Protheroe Wrote: You've swallowed the conventional Protectionist's Charter hook, line and sinker. None of the arguments you make are in favour of free trade, all of them point to protectionism.

The bottom line is this. You cannot give me an example of a country that ever, in human history - made itself poorer by making itself more open to trade.

What I just listed are the problems with unilateral free trade and correcting the nonsense belief, alternatively the blatant lie, that it is better for the consumer. These do not apply to reciprocal free trade deals, which I wholeheartedly support. Even your arguments for unilateral free trade rely on conflating it with reciprocal free trade and hoping nobody notices. To call me protectionist by pointing out the stupidity and illogical nature of what you want is ridiculous, especially when I'm someone who's against tariffs and non-tariff barriers.

And aside from Somalia no country has been stupid enough to pursue unilateral free trade, stop conflating your stupid unilateral free trade idea with actual successful examples of free trade. They're nothing alike.

(12-13-2020, 10:17 AM)Jack Halford Wrote: As always one rule for us one rule for the EU.

In addition we are the 9th largest manufacturing nation in the world and our output will only increase.

We also have some great niche industries. In the gaming world we have Leamington Spa talked about in the same breath as Silicon Valley.

Will we survive a no deal, he’ll yes we will.

Mate, a single Polish video gaming company is bigger than Codemasters and Playground Games. The biggest video gaming company outside of the US and Japan is French, not British. Leamington Spa is not talked about in the same breath as Silicon Valley.

Mate, the tech sector in Leamington is growing rapidly. We have an office in California. Do the tech companies there know about the growth in Leamington, yes.

The point I’m making is that it’s very easy to knock GB but we are seeing some real growth areas, Life Sciences being another.

(12-13-2020, 11:54 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(12-13-2020, 10:07 AM)Protheroe Wrote: You've swallowed the conventional Protectionist's Charter hook, line and sinker. None of the arguments you make are in favour of free trade, all of them point to protectionism.

The bottom line is this. You cannot give me an example of a country that ever, in human history - made itself poorer by making itself more open to trade.

What I just listed are the problems with unilateral free trade and correcting the nonsense belief, alternatively the blatant lie, that it is better for the consumer. These do not apply to reciprocal free trade deals, which I wholeheartedly support. Even your arguments for unilateral free trade rely on conflating it with reciprocal free trade and hoping nobody notices. To call me protectionist by pointing out the stupidity and illogical nature of what you want is ridiculous, especially when I'm someone who's against tariffs and non-tariff barriers.

And aside from Somalia no country has been stupid enough to pursue unilateral free trade, stop conflating your stupid unilateral free trade idea with actual successful examples of free trade. They're nothing alike.

(12-13-2020, 10:17 AM)Jack Halford Wrote: As always one rule for us one rule for the EU.

In addition we are the 9th largest manufacturing nation in the world and our output will only increase.

We also have some great niche industries. In the gaming world we have Leamington Spa talked about in the same breath as Silicon Valley.

Will we survive a no deal, he’ll yes we will.

Mate, a single Polish video gaming company is bigger than Codemasters and Playground Games. The biggest video gaming company outside of the US and Japan is French, not British. Leamington Spa is not talked about in the same breath as Silicon Valley.

Mate, the tech sector in Leamington is growing rapidly. We have an office in California. Do the tech companies there know about the growth in Leamington, yes.

The point I’m making is that it’s very easy to knock GB but we are seeing some real growth areas, Life Sciences being another.

GDP of silicon valley $275 billion
GDP of Leamington Spa tech ins. £100 million

Well done you can google.
Let’s compare again in 5 years time shall we. What bit of growing rapidly don’t you understand?
Reply
(12-13-2020, 01:25 PM)Jack Halford Wrote:
(12-13-2020, 01:02 PM)Bilich Wrote:
(12-13-2020, 12:48 PM)Jack Halford Wrote:
(12-13-2020, 11:54 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(12-13-2020, 10:07 AM)Protheroe Wrote: You've swallowed the conventional Protectionist's Charter hook, line and sinker. None of the arguments you make are in favour of free trade, all of them point to protectionism.

The bottom line is this. You cannot give me an example of a country that ever, in human history - made itself poorer by making itself more open to trade.

What I just listed are the problems with unilateral free trade and correcting the nonsense belief, alternatively the blatant lie, that it is better for the consumer. These do not apply to reciprocal free trade deals, which I wholeheartedly support. Even your arguments for unilateral free trade rely on conflating it with reciprocal free trade and hoping nobody notices. To call me protectionist by pointing out the stupidity and illogical nature of what you want is ridiculous, especially when I'm someone who's against tariffs and non-tariff barriers.

And aside from Somalia no country has been stupid enough to pursue unilateral free trade, stop conflating your stupid unilateral free trade idea with actual successful examples of free trade. They're nothing alike.

(12-13-2020, 10:17 AM)Jack Halford Wrote: As always one rule for us one rule for the EU.

In addition we are the 9th largest manufacturing nation in the world and our output will only increase.

We also have some great niche industries. In the gaming world we have Leamington Spa talked about in the same breath as Silicon Valley.

Will we survive a no deal, he’ll yes we will.

Mate, a single Polish video gaming company is bigger than Codemasters and Playground Games. The biggest video gaming company outside of the US and Japan is French, not British. Leamington Spa is not talked about in the same breath as Silicon Valley.

Mate, the tech sector in Leamington is growing rapidly. We have an office in California. Do the tech companies there know about the growth in Leamington, yes.

The point I’m making is that it’s very easy to knock GB but we are seeing some real growth areas, Life Sciences being another.

(12-13-2020, 11:54 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(12-13-2020, 10:07 AM)Protheroe Wrote: You've swallowed the conventional Protectionist's Charter hook, line and sinker. None of the arguments you make are in favour of free trade, all of them point to protectionism.

The bottom line is this. You cannot give me an example of a country that ever, in human history - made itself poorer by making itself more open to trade.

What I just listed are the problems with unilateral free trade and correcting the nonsense belief, alternatively the blatant lie, that it is better for the consumer. These do not apply to reciprocal free trade deals, which I wholeheartedly support. Even your arguments for unilateral free trade rely on conflating it with reciprocal free trade and hoping nobody notices. To call me protectionist by pointing out the stupidity and illogical nature of what you want is ridiculous, especially when I'm someone who's against tariffs and non-tariff barriers.

And aside from Somalia no country has been stupid enough to pursue unilateral free trade, stop conflating your stupid unilateral free trade idea with actual successful examples of free trade. They're nothing alike.

(12-13-2020, 10:17 AM)Jack Halford Wrote: As always one rule for us one rule for the EU.

In addition we are the 9th largest manufacturing nation in the world and our output will only increase.

We also have some great niche industries. In the gaming world we have Leamington Spa talked about in the same breath as Silicon Valley.

Will we survive a no deal, he’ll yes we will.

Mate, a single Polish video gaming company is bigger than Codemasters and Playground Games. The biggest video gaming company outside of the US and Japan is French, not British. Leamington Spa is not talked about in the same breath as Silicon Valley.

Mate, the tech sector in Leamington is growing rapidly. We have an office in California. Do the tech companies there know about the growth in Leamington, yes.

The point I’m making is that it’s very easy to knock GB but we are seeing some real growth areas, Life Sciences being another.

GDP of silicon valley $275 billion
GDP of Leamington Spa tech ins. £100 million

Well done you can google.
Let’s compare again in 5 years time shall we. What bit of growing rapidly don’t you understand?

what's yr prediction?
Reply
So basically the Leamington Spa games industry has grown whilst in the EU, potentially because of EU funding and freedom of movement for gaming specialists to move here, and has benefitted from UK state aid through Tax relief (hold on I thought we couldn't make our own rules!) and will be free to expand further out of the EU (or possibly it would make no difference and we could have had this anyway as part of the EU)

It appears that Jack's argument is that an industry that would have grown as part of the EU will grow outside of the EU - therefore no reason to have left for this industry.
Reply
Anyone work for a company who deals with businesses in the EU & clear on how they will be trading with these partners in 19 days time?
Reply
(12-13-2020, 03:02 PM)Loanee Wrote: Anyone work for a company who deals with businesses in the EU & clear on how they will be trading with these partners in 19 days time?

No, and not through lack of preparation but because there are no rules to apply yet. We are lucky in that we are only talking about transfer of funds and data but even those have required us to have two approaches to everything and even then we don't know if either are acceptable in the case of no deal. God knows what it will be like if you are transferring goods and services.
Reply
(12-13-2020, 01:22 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(12-13-2020, 12:48 PM)Jack Halford Wrote: Mate, the tech sector in Leamington is growing rapidly. We have an office in California. Do the tech companies there know about the growth in Leamington, yes.

The point I’m making is that it’s very easy to knock GB but we are seeing some real growth areas, Life Sciences being another.

It may well be growing rapidly, but just because a few local business leaders in Warwickshire have branded it as "Silicon Spa" for marketing purposes doesn't mean that it is mentioned in the same breath as Silicon Valley, there's a brilliant up and coming distillery in the south of the county but it's not the Islay of England.

Warwickshire's economy is still centred around high tech manufacturing and tourism, two things that will take a hit from Brexit. The new Forza and Fable games won't change that as they pale in comparison. Hell, logistics and distribution is a huge industry in the county and that's going to take a massive hit with customs backlogs.

As for life sciences, that industry has been heavily reliant on cooperation within the single market, the second biggest pharmaceutical company in the UK is Anglo-Swedish.

Granted, tech in Leam is nowhere near on the same scale as Silicon Valley but there are plenty of new start ups who are growing rapidly. It’s the start ups that will create the new jobs we need and opportunities for the grads of today.

Tourism will be an interesting one as the majority of high spending tourists in Stratford are from the US and China.

Distribution is huge. Amazon are building some massive distribution units at the moment. The logistics sector will continue to grow notwithstanding the customs backlog. There is significant investment in the development of these units going on at the moment and that’s not likely to change either.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)