Posts: 1,058
Threads: 51
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
3
One of the subjects often debated is why are so few females in certain careers? IT, engineering etc.
I have been invigilating GCSE mocks this week (yes, risking life and limb in a school) and in one session we had three exams. The make up of the sexes in each subject was quite marked.
Of the 10 DT candidates there was one boy.
Of the 19 P.E. candidates there were only five girls.
Out of twenty five in the computer Science exam, there were NO females.
Now, I can honestly say that both sexes are equally encouraged to be engaged with all subjects at my school. (At least up to three years ago, they were. Assume it is the same now.)
One reason given for females not pursuing IT roles is the ‘Geek Effect’ well, I can safely say, looking at most of the candidates the other day, there were very few’ geeks’ amongst them.
DT includes Woodwork, metalwork and CAD, as well as sowing (for want of a better word) and foody /entertainment industry stuff. So why no boys? Are we going to be short of even male engineers eventually?
As for PE I know, from experience, that it is almost impossible to get most girls to participate enthusiastically in physical exercise. No amount of telling them it can be fun or beneficial to their wellbeing makes any difference. They just amble about trying to avoid the ball or walk round the track.
We are often told ‘We need to remove the barriers to girls in such and such a trade’ but what are these barriers in 2020? (I know some dinosaur employers still exist) Certainly non in schools. After 50 years of telling our daughters (and sons for that matter) that they can pursue any trade or profession they have an inclination for, it makes no difference. Is there some sort of nature ingrained difference or DNA driven code between boys and girls that causes them to gravitate to certain aspects of life and no number of stimuli will change that? No matter what phycologists , equal rights and equal opportunity groups, and women’s rights tell us.
Marvellous what the brain cogitates when your stood for two hours unable to use any artificial stimulus.
Posts: 13,569
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
Speaking as an engineer who did mechanical engineering as my first degree, I don't think DT is in any way a relevant GCSE qualification. If a kid wants to be an engineer, I would tell them to do physics, maths and then whatever they find fun and engaging. In fact, I'd say computer science would be a better GCSE to take than DT as you get a grounding in logical thinking and I would assume programming experience.
And there's nothing genetic about it, it's purely to do with cultural stimuli and environments growing up, otherwise you would never see women being engineers or men being nurses. Kids will gravitate towards subjects that help them pursue what they want to do, girls tend to want to be doctors or nurses and boys tend to want to be engineers so more boys do physics and more girls do biology. It's the same with people with certain races or class being attracted to certain jobs, it relates to how they were brought up.
Posts: 3,034
Threads: 20
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
8
Borin' Baggie Wrote:Speaking as an engineer who did mechanical engineering as my first degree, I don't think DT is in any way a relevant GCSE qualification. If a kid wants to be an engineer, I would tell them to do physics, maths and then whatever they find fun and engaging. In fact, I'd say computer science would be a better GCSE to take than DT as you get a grounding in logical thinking and I would assume programming experience.
And there's nothing genetic about it, it's purely to do with cultural stimuli and environments growing up, otherwise you would never see women being engineers or men being nurses. Kids will gravitate towards subjects that help them pursue what they want to do, girls tend to want to be doctors or nurses and boys tend to want to be engineers so more boys do physics and more girls do biology. It's the same with people with certain races or class being attracted to certain jobs, it relates to how they were brought up.
Not proven to be true.
Totally agree that environment plays a big role, a huge one in fact. But genetics may well play a role too.
Posts: 13,569
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
11-25-2020, 05:25 PM
(This post was last modified: 11-25-2020, 05:25 PM by Borin' Baggie.)
(11-25-2020, 05:13 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: Borin' Baggie Wrote:Speaking as an engineer who did mechanical engineering as my first degree, I don't think DT is in any way a relevant GCSE qualification. If a kid wants to be an engineer, I would tell them to do physics, maths and then whatever they find fun and engaging. In fact, I'd say computer science would be a better GCSE to take than DT as you get a grounding in logical thinking and I would assume programming experience.
And there's nothing genetic about it, it's purely to do with cultural stimuli and environments growing up, otherwise you would never see women being engineers or men being nurses. Kids will gravitate towards subjects that help them pursue what they want to do, girls tend to want to be doctors or nurses and boys tend to want to be engineers so more boys do physics and more girls do biology. It's the same with people with certain races or class being attracted to certain jobs, it relates to how they were brought up.
Not proven to be true.
Totally agree that environment plays a big role, a huge one in fact. But genetics may well play a role too.
I meant in relation to sex. There's been evidence that genetics can factor into subject choices and there's also physical factors that come into play that are caused by genetics but there's none that link sex into it with the variances being replicable across girls and boys.
Posts: 8,125
Threads: 201
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
55
11-25-2020, 05:42 PM
(This post was last modified: 11-25-2020, 05:45 PM by HawkingsHalfpint.)
(11-25-2020, 05:08 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Speaking as an engineer who did mechanical engineering as my first degree, I don't think DT is in any way a relevant GCSE qualification. If a kid wants to be an engineer, I would tell them to do physics, maths and then whatever they find fun and engaging. In fact, I'd say computer science would be a better GCSE to take than DT as you get a grounding in logical thinking and I would assume programming experience.
And there's nothing genetic about it, it's purely to do with cultural stimuli and environments growing up, otherwise you would never see women being engineers or men being nurses. Kids will gravitate towards subjects that help them pursue what they want to do, girls tend to want to be doctors or nurses and boys tend to want to be engineers so more boys do physics and more girls do biology. It's the same with people with certain races or class being attracted to certain jobs, it relates to how they were brought up.
I also have a Mech Eng degree. I’d echo that physics and maths is imperative really, especially the former which gives a much better grounding (and kind of elicits the necessary maths aptitude by default). But that’s not to take away anything from maths, which really comes in useful for my initial field of expertise (FEA/stress engineering, before I sold out and joined the dark side  ).
Of the few birds on our first (common programme) year, only a couple were fit. But even the munters were beating off nerds with a slide rule! But jokes aside, the irony is that of the women in engineering I know, most have gone on to do brilliantly. I’d actively encourage diversity in the field for no other reason than that.
Honestly no other reason, I mean it’s not like I want to fill my office with young, slim, bright, athletic, sexy eye-candy. Not at all.
Always should be some subject you really love.
Posts: 10,700
Threads: 674
Joined: Feb 2020
With 18 years experience of working in IT, I have to disagree as there are an equal amount of women as there are men and as a contractor, I’ve worked at many organisations over than duration.
Posts: 1,058
Threads: 51
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
3
(11-25-2020, 06:30 PM)Fulham Fallout Wrote: With 18 years experience of working in IT, I have to disagree as there are an equal amount of women as there are men and as a contractor, I’ve worked at many organisations over than duration.
That is what I’d assumed and couldn’t comprehend the lack of girls. I believe there is an equality of choice now. So, I googled it this morning and the first three or four posts were lamenting the fact there was a paucity of females tacking degrees in Computer science and STEM in general.
Here is what one said. “The percentage of women in CS flattened and then plunged” , even as the numbers of professional women kept rising. (at the advent of PCs it suggested). It also does say (not sure where they get the evidence though) “Women think differently and have a tendency to want to avoid mistakes and may be frustrated when their code does not work. “Men, on the other hand, are often more aware of the fact that learning programming is a trial-and-error process”.
Why aren’t more women in computer science? | CIO
“The history of computing is filled with the accomplishments of women. But in the West, the number of women taking computer science degrees has fallen sharply from its peak in the 1980s…” Maybe you’re experiencing the remnants of that cohort.
BBC World Service - The Why Factor, Why aren’t more women in computer science?
This was the worst. “Recent UCAS data from HSEA 2017/2018 has revealed that women make up just 13% of students studying computer science, gaming and related courses in the UK2.”
It is just perplexing to me. Girls obviously have the brains for it the same as boys and I think reports have shown they have more of a propensity to study than boys. They get the encouragement and have the opportunity. That’s what prompted my thoughts, why don’t they want to do it?
My own daughter really enjoyed maths. She attained A*s in Maths, Physics and Biology but chose an Arts faculty degree.
Women in Computer Science | ComputerScience.org
Posts: 12,682
Threads: 1,158
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
15
I'm in the process of hiring experienced SQL & Python scriptors for a 50/50 Data Science/Business Analyst role in the Midlands region with above average going rate salary, I've probably had 40% more female applicants than male, and pretty much all of those females are of equal if not better education and experience than the males with a relevant degree.
Posts: 3,775
Threads: 73
Joined: May 2020
(11-26-2020, 12:00 AM)SausEggBaton Wrote: I'm in the process of hiring experienced SQL & Python scriptors for a 50/50 Data Science/Business Analyst role in the Midlands region with above average going rate salary, I've probably had 40% more female applicants than male, and pretty much all of those females are of equal if not better education and experience than the males with a relevant degree.
That would suit me perfectly.
If I wanted to work.
Which I don't.
Posts: 12,682
Threads: 1,158
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
15
(11-26-2020, 12:02 AM)Baggie_Nick Wrote: (11-26-2020, 12:00 AM)SausEggBaton Wrote: I'm in the process of hiring experienced SQL & Python scriptors for a 50/50 Data Science/Business Analyst role in the Midlands region with above average going rate salary, I've probably had 40% more female applicants than male, and pretty much all of those females are of equal if not better education and experience than the males with a relevant degree.
That would suit me perfectly.
If I wanted to work.
Which I don't.
You wouldn't get to interview stage for the position that you wouldn't want to work for anyway Nick, the girls want to be given the opportunity, are nicer and cleverer.
|