For so many reasons VAR is not working
#1
I'll start by saying it has a led to an unnecessary and just plain wrong change in the handball rule, just to facilitate its smooth introduction.
Reply
#2
Because as with all technology, it is only as good as the humans operating and overseeing it, and the FA and PGMOL are inherently biased and corrupt.
Reply
#3
(11-23-2020, 10:37 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Because as with all technology, it is only as good as the humans operating and overseeing it, and the FA and PGMOL are inherently biased and corrupt.

Quite right SW4. A rubbish ref is rubbish whether he is on the pitch or watching a T.V monitor in Crookley Park or whatever it is.That clown we had on Satarday, Coote, was, IIRC, the VAR official in 2 or 3 controversial incidents already this season. Didn`t he tell Michael Oliver to disallow a perfectly good goal or something, as well as saying Pickford had done nothing wrong when he crippled Van Dijk?
As for bias / corruption, I feel it is so obvious now, that it is almost laughable. Remember when Man Utd won 5 - 0 at our place, Rob Styles sent one of ours off, for a tackle when even their players didn`t appeal for a foul, booked about 5 others. Apparently, at every incident, Styles barked `Oi, number 6, come here` etc, to our players, for Man Utd it was ` Ryan, can I have a word`.
Reply
#4
(11-23-2020, 10:55 AM)Ministry Of Silly Signings Wrote:
(11-23-2020, 10:37 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Because as with all technology, it is only as good as the humans operating and overseeing it, and the FA and PGMOL are inherently biased and corrupt.

Quite right SW4. A rubbish ref is rubbish whether he is on the pitch or watching a T.V monitor in Crookley Park or whatever it is.That clown we had on Satarday, Coote, was, IIRC, the VAR official in 2 or 3 controversial incidents already this season. Didn`t he tell Michael Oliver to disallow a perfectly good goal or something, as well as saying Pickford had done nothing wrong when he crippled Van Dijk?
As for bias / corruption, I feel it is so obvious now, that it is almost laughable. Remember when Man Utd won 5 - 0 at our place, Rob Styles sent one of ours off, for a tackle when even their players didn`t appeal for a foul, booked about 5 others. Apparently, at every incident, Styles barked `Oi, number 6, come here` etc, to our players, for Man Utd it was ` Ryan, can I have a word`.

Yup, completely ... the whole system is corrupt.
Reply
#5
It kills the excitement and flow of the game. In order to justify this we would have to see a substantial benefit from good decisions vs the decisions that were being made pre-VAR.

We aren't seeing this. Get rid.
Reply
#6
(11-23-2020, 11:00 AM)Sliced Wrote: It kills the excitement and flow of the game. In order to justify this we would have to see a substantial benefit from good decisions vs the decisions that were being made pre-VAR.

We aren't seeing this. Get rid.

Perhaps. But! Must be a unanimous decision and on the understanding that any criticism of officials will lead to harsh punishment..
Reply
#7
I have been loud and vocal about my hatred of VAR from the moment it was introduced - unlike others on here, I may add, who have staunchly defended it when it's been discussed previously.

My view has always been that the excitement of football is about the instant celebration of a goal, penalty award or save etc. The ball goes in, you have a quick look at the ref to see if he's pointing to the centre circle, glance at the lino to see his flag isn't up and then go mental. VAR has taken all of that away. If it's aim is to remove subjectivity, it's had the opposite effect so it's lose, lose all round.

Our penalty on Saturday is a good example of why the system is an utter failure. Like others, I'm not 100% convinced it was one but giving it was fair enough in the circumstances and certainly not a clear and obvious error. I'd be disappointed if we gave one away like that, but wouldn't complain too much. To overturn it is 100% a subjective decision forced on the referee by someone else being subjective after looking at some inconclusive replays. How does this help?

VAR is a blight on football and will ruin the game. Referees make mistakes but make decisions they believe to be right at the time. This is how it's always been. It doesn't even itself over the season, but that's OK. That's football. That's the game we love. It's clinical, cynical and removes every ounce of joy I get out of the game.

I was desperate for us to get promoted and, as soon as we did, I cancelled Sky Sports and BT Sport as I knew that entering the world of VAR would wind me up to the extent I'd become someone I don't want to be. I therefore I didn't watch the footage of our game until Sunday, calmly and rationally. I was following the game on Saturday, but watching it would have sent me apoplectic.
Reply
#8
Without getting into conspiracy theories,  Coote was originally selected as VAR ref for Liverpool v Leicester.  There was then a social media meltdown because of the Van Dyck incident and he was replaced by Peter Barnes who works for the Liverpool County FA working with both Everton and Liverpool academies. I bet Klopp was very happy with that as it was probably his appointment. 

Coote (formerly employed by Manchester CFA - should he be officiating Manchester fixtures?) was then given the straightforward home fixture Man U v little West Brom, what could possibly go wrong.  He sees Gallagher clobbered and instantly awards a penalty.  If you look at the replay Gallagher is just north of the penalty spot and Coote is perfectly positioned with no obstructions on the edge of the box - so 6 yards from the incident. As clear and obvious a penalty as you will see.  He then gets the call from Stockley Park .....now the critical thing is - what was said to him?  In Rugby we would know as the conversations are public.  Clearly enough doubt was put in his mind to reverse the decision and you do wonder whether either the Van Dyck incident was mentioned ("we don't want another meltdown") or subconsciously that ran through his mind as he ran over to the screen - am I going to get slaughtered again if I give this and could this be the end of my fledgling premier league career?  

Then if you look at the United pen, Gallagher appears is clearly fouled by Fred.  Again Coote is perfectly positioned but doesn't deem it a foul when it clearly was (Bilic was apparently told by Atkinson that this was checked in the VAR review - I bet it was!).

If you look at the actual handball, Furlong is within 2 yds of Mata when Mata hits the ball - I know the rule has changed but it's an utter farce, how could he get out of the way and his arm doesn't move towards the ball as has been the case with a couple of others. 

Just makes you sick. 

However as we've seen from the last couple of games, we are becoming more resilient and could (had we got the pen) scored at least a couple on Saturday - if only Townsend had slightly lifted the ball off the ground as keepers always go to ground for those and try to save them with their feet.  

So close to getting something. However, beat Sheff U and we'll be on our way.  Keep the faith lol
Reply
#9
I hate VAR with a passion , the only technology we need is the goal line technology. Human error is better than waiting for minutes while someone sitting on there arses say yes he’s offside because he has a size 11 boot which is slightly bigger than the defenders size 9. They get as many wrong as they do right and then it’s only for the big clubs.
Reply
#10
Sad but my interest in the former beautiful game is being severely tested, and mainly due to the reasons stated by others.

The Prem is bent.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: