Our penalty on Saturday
#1
Has it been explained officially anywhere as to why it was overturned? Player got the ball first? Gallagher dived?
Reply
#2
Wrong end of the pitch.
Reply
#3
(11-23-2020, 08:02 AM)BilstonBaggie Wrote: Wrong end of the pitch.

Nice one  Big Grin
Reply
#4
(11-23-2020, 08:02 AM)BilstonBaggie Wrote: Wrong end of the pitch.

Bravo!
Reply
#5
(11-23-2020, 07:59 AM)baggie_ray Wrote: Has it been explained officially anywhere as to why it was overturned? Player got the ball first? Gallagher dived?

Hi Ray.

Similar to incident at Brighton. Ref believed Fernandez touched the ball before impacting on Gallagher shins. I hadn’t noticed another rule change, I thought if follow through contact made with player. It’s a penalty. I was wrong.
Reply
#6
(11-23-2020, 08:40 AM)Super_Slav Wrote:
(11-23-2020, 07:59 AM)baggie_ray Wrote: Has it been explained officially anywhere as to why it was overturned? Player got the ball first? Gallagher dived?

Hi Ray.

Similar to incident at Brighton. Ref believed Fernandez touched the ball before impacting on Gallagher shins. I hadn’t noticed another rule change, I thought if follow through contact made with player. It’s a penalty. I was wrong.

So the ref has spoken publicly about his reasons for overturning it then? I tend to the theory you’re putting words in his mouth and offering those words as the facts of the matter. 
Reply
#7
Super_Slav Wrote:
baggie_ray Wrote:Has it been explained officially anywhere as to why it was overturned? Player got the ball first? Gallagher dived?

Hi Ray.

Similar to incident at Brighton. Ref believed Fernandez touched the ball before impacting on Gallagher shins. I hadn’t noticed another rule change, I thought if follow through contact made with player. It’s a penalty. I was wrong.

If Fernandez did touch the ball first it must have been the faintest of touches. I certainly couldn't come to that conclusion watching the replays.

Also saw a Leicester player booked yesterday for a tackle on Milner where he got the ball first. All bollocks.

And loffin at BilstonBaggie's reply  Big Grin
Reply
#8
For me it was a 50/50 decision, if we hadn't got the decision in the first place i wouldn't have been that annoyed.

But once given i don't see that the ref's decision was so 'wrong' that it should be overturned.

The problem is that many, if not the majority of decisions a referee has to make will be subjective , Adding the clear and obvious clause into the var process just adds another level of subjectivity - what is clear and obvious to one person may not to another.
Reply
#9
Anywhere else on the pitch it would've been a foul and free kick. I was sure he wouldn't overturn it when watching the replays and still a bit baffled why he did.
Reply
#10
(11-23-2020, 09:45 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: For me it was a 50/50 decision, if we hadn't got the decision in the first place i wouldn't have been that annoyed.

But once given i don't see that the ref's decision was so 'wrong' that it should be overturned.

The problem is that many, if not the majority of decisions a referee has to make will be subjective , Adding the clear and obvious clause into the var process just adds another level of subjectivity - what is clear and obvious to one person may not to another.

Not a 50/50 for me. I've watched it over and over. He barely touches the ball but clearly takes out Gallagher

Their pen a 50/50. Neither Leicester or Arsenal got ones for similar incidents yesterday
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)