Boris
#71
I agree Hawks which is why I use the word indicative, but when you see results from Germany that have had less than 10k excess deaths from the 1st wave then that difference is too big to base on demographics.

The other figure that they use is the r-rate, and again i was dubious about it as it is an estimate, but it does correlate very closely with the weekly increase in hospital admissions which is running at about 1.2x week on week. The problem is that there are a lot of people that this doesn't suit, some for good reason like baggiebuckster whose income has been drastically effected or those who are suffering isolation and mental issues (these are who I have sympathy with) and those who just can't be bothered because they want to go to the pub or just party.
Reply
#72
(11-17-2020, 10:54 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(11-17-2020, 10:35 PM)baggiebuckster Wrote: Why is Boris still having to isolate after having a negative test today? How is it any different from the Albion players carrying on when they have been in contact with Pereira and Ivanovic for example?

I think (and I'm not an expert) elite sportsmen have different rules, and also they are tested multiple times each week,at the clubs cost.

Boris is following NHS guidelines, and whilst I'm sure he could have antibody tests and multiple virus tests, if he declared himself to be ok to continue there would be a bigger outcry than the Barnard Castle situation.

He either had the virus 6 mths ago and is immune or he didn't have it (or he's really special 1 in 700m people who have genetic variation such they can be reinfected).

If he didn't have it then he has to lock himself away because to declare he didn't would be a death warrant to his career.

If he did have it and therefore is immune there is absolutely no reason why he should be isolating. He also had a negative test (although we will never know if the PCR test came back as a false +ve - other than the fact if it did they could sell us the re-infection bullshit so we can have many vaccine jabs a year and make more cash).

So basically what we are saying then is: when (hopefully) only those people who need a vaccine get one if they bump into someone who didn't have the vaccine subsequently tests positive (and let's assume it's a proper test not the PCR one and lets assume per the news that the vaccine is actually 95% successful - that's another load...) then the person with the vaccine has to isolate.

If people really can't see the absurdity in this and how contrary to immunology and how we've managed to last on this planet all these years then there's no helping them.
Reply
#73
Have they proved that people who have had it can't carry it then?
Reply
#74
(11-18-2020, 10:42 AM)billybassett Wrote:
(11-17-2020, 10:54 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(11-17-2020, 10:35 PM)baggiebuckster Wrote: Why is Boris still having to isolate after having a negative test today? How is it any different from the Albion players carrying on when they have been in contact with Pereira and Ivanovic for example?

I think (and I'm not an expert) elite sportsmen have different rules, and also they are tested multiple times each week,at the clubs cost.

Boris is following NHS guidelines, and whilst I'm sure he could have antibody tests and multiple virus tests, if he declared himself to be ok to continue there would be a bigger outcry than the Barnard Castle situation.

He either had the virus 6 mths ago and is immune or he didn't have it (or he's really special 1 in 700m people who have genetic variation such they can be reinfected).

If he didn't have it then he has to lock himself away because to declare he didn't would be a death warrant to his career.

If he did have it and therefore is immune there is absolutely no reason why he should be isolating. He also had a negative test (although we will never know if the PCR test came back as a false +ve - other than the fact if it did they could sell us the re-infection bullshit so we can have many vaccine jabs a year and make more cash).

So basically what we are saying then is: when (hopefully) only those people who need a vaccine get one if they bump into someone who didn't have the vaccine subsequently tests positive (and let's assume it's a proper test not the PCR one and lets assume per the news that the vaccine is actually 95% successful - that's another load...) then the person with the vaccine has to isolate.

If people really can't see the absurdity in this and how contrary to immunology and how we've managed to last on this planet all these years then there's no helping them.

Under current rules maybe, maybe the rules will be eased when there is a vaccine
Reply
#75
(11-18-2020, 10:56 AM)strawman Wrote:
(11-18-2020, 10:42 AM)billybassett Wrote:
(11-17-2020, 10:54 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(11-17-2020, 10:35 PM)baggiebuckster Wrote: Why is Boris still having to isolate after having a negative test today? How is it any different from the Albion players carrying on when they have been in contact with Pereira and Ivanovic for example?

I think (and I'm not an expert) elite sportsmen have different rules, and also they are tested multiple times each week,at the clubs cost.

Boris is following NHS guidelines, and whilst I'm sure he could have antibody tests and multiple virus tests, if he declared himself to be ok to continue there would be a bigger outcry than the Barnard Castle situation.

He either had the virus 6 mths ago and is immune or he didn't have it (or he's really special 1 in 700m people who have genetic variation such they can be reinfected).

If he didn't have it then he has to lock himself away because to declare he didn't would be a death warrant to his career.

If he did have it and therefore is immune there is absolutely no reason why he should be isolating. He also had a negative test (although we will never know if the PCR test came back as a false +ve - other than the fact if it did they could sell us the re-infection bullshit so we can have many vaccine jabs a year and make more cash).

So basically what we are saying then is: when (hopefully) only those people who need a vaccine get one if they bump into someone who didn't have the vaccine subsequently tests positive (and let's assume it's a proper test not the PCR one and lets assume per the news that the vaccine is actually 95% successful - that's another load...) then the person with the vaccine has to isolate.

If people really can't see the absurdity in this and how contrary to immunology and how we've managed to last on this planet all these years then there's no helping them.

Under current rules maybe, maybe the rules will be eased when there is a vaccine

I think the wider pt being that if we take the testing data as true from the govt website (and I don't) and that 1.4m cases have been found then the likely immunity in the community with the R numbers that have been touted (but lets not start on how that's calculated because we will end up down another govt hole) plus the existing tcell immunity estimate of between 18-28% (hence asymptomatics) then millions of people are already immune and thus why are we all locked down.
Reply
#76
(11-18-2020, 11:02 AM)billybassett Wrote:
(11-18-2020, 10:56 AM)strawman Wrote:
(11-18-2020, 10:42 AM)billybassett Wrote:
(11-17-2020, 10:54 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(11-17-2020, 10:35 PM)baggiebuckster Wrote: Why is Boris still having to isolate after having a negative test today? How is it any different from the Albion players carrying on when they have been in contact with Pereira and Ivanovic for example?

I think (and I'm not an expert) elite sportsmen have different rules, and also they are tested multiple times each week,at the clubs cost.

Boris is following NHS guidelines, and whilst I'm sure he could have antibody tests and multiple virus tests, if he declared himself to be ok to continue there would be a bigger outcry than the Barnard Castle situation.

He either had the virus 6 mths ago and is immune or he didn't have it (or he's really special 1 in 700m people who have genetic variation such they can be reinfected).

If he didn't have it then he has to lock himself away because to declare he didn't would be a death warrant to his career.

If he did have it and therefore is immune there is absolutely no reason why he should be isolating. He also had a negative test (although we will never know if the PCR test came back as a false +ve - other than the fact if it did they could sell us the re-infection bullshit so we can have many vaccine jabs a year and make more cash).

So basically what we are saying then is: when (hopefully) only those people who need a vaccine get one if they bump into someone who didn't have the vaccine subsequently tests positive (and let's assume it's a proper test not the PCR one and lets assume per the news that the vaccine is actually 95% successful - that's another load...) then the person with the vaccine has to isolate.

If people really can't see the absurdity in this and how contrary to immunology and how we've managed to last on this planet all these years then there's no helping them.

Under current rules maybe, maybe the rules will be eased when there is a vaccine

I think the wider pt being that if we take the testing data as true from the govt website (and I don't) and that 1.4m cases have been found then the likely immunity in the community with the R numbers that have been touted (but lets not start on how that's calculated because we will end up down another govt hole) plus the existing tcell immunity estimate of between 18-28% (hence asymptomatics) then millions of people are already immune and thus why are we all locked down.

That's been done to death on the politics page - to protect the vulnerable of all ages - you don't agree with it  - in fact it seems you have become somewhat of a religious zealot about it - so we'll leave you to continue with your total misrepresentations of stats
Reply
#77
(11-18-2020, 11:12 AM)strawman Wrote:
(11-18-2020, 11:02 AM)billybassett Wrote:
(11-18-2020, 10:56 AM)strawman Wrote:
(11-18-2020, 10:42 AM)billybassett Wrote:
(11-17-2020, 10:54 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: I think (and I'm not an expert) elite sportsmen have different rules, and also they are tested multiple times each week,at the clubs cost.

Boris is following NHS guidelines, and whilst I'm sure he could have antibody tests and multiple virus tests, if he declared himself to be ok to continue there would be a bigger outcry than the Barnard Castle situation.

He either had the virus 6 mths ago and is immune or he didn't have it (or he's really special 1 in 700m people who have genetic variation such they can be reinfected).

If he didn't have it then he has to lock himself away because to declare he didn't would be a death warrant to his career.

If he did have it and therefore is immune there is absolutely no reason why he should be isolating. He also had a negative test (although we will never know if the PCR test came back as a false +ve - other than the fact if it did they could sell us the re-infection bullshit so we can have many vaccine jabs a year and make more cash).

So basically what we are saying then is: when (hopefully) only those people who need a vaccine get one if they bump into someone who didn't have the vaccine subsequently tests positive (and let's assume it's a proper test not the PCR one and lets assume per the news that the vaccine is actually 95% successful - that's another load...) then the person with the vaccine has to isolate.

If people really can't see the absurdity in this and how contrary to immunology and how we've managed to last on this planet all these years then there's no helping them.

Under current rules maybe, maybe the rules will be eased when there is a vaccine

I think the wider pt being that if we take the testing data as true from the govt website (and I don't) and that 1.4m cases have been found then the likely immunity in the community with the R numbers that have been touted (but lets not start on how that's calculated because we will end up down another govt hole) plus the existing tcell immunity estimate of between 18-28% (hence asymptomatics) then millions of people are already immune and thus why are we all locked down.

That's been done to death on the politics page - to protect the vulnerable of all ages - you don't agree with it  - in fact it seems you have become somewhat of a religious zealot about it - so we'll leave you to continue with your total misrepresentations of stats

Wow. Straight in for me. Thanks. Not religious not a zealot. Passionate and informed - yes. I guess I could trade insults no point though when dealing with closed minds.
Reply
#78
(11-18-2020, 11:14 AM)billybassett Wrote:
(11-18-2020, 11:12 AM)strawman Wrote:
(11-18-2020, 11:02 AM)billybassett Wrote:
(11-18-2020, 10:56 AM)strawman Wrote:
(11-18-2020, 10:42 AM)billybassett Wrote: He either had the virus 6 mths ago and is immune or he didn't have it (or he's really special 1 in 700m people who have genetic variation such they can be reinfected).

If he didn't have it then he has to lock himself away because to declare he didn't would be a death warrant to his career.

If he did have it and therefore is immune there is absolutely no reason why he should be isolating. He also had a negative test (although we will never know if the PCR test came back as a false +ve - other than the fact if it did they could sell us the re-infection bullshit so we can have many vaccine jabs a year and make more cash).

So basically what we are saying then is: when (hopefully) only those people who need a vaccine get one if they bump into someone who didn't have the vaccine subsequently tests positive (and let's assume it's a proper test not the PCR one and lets assume per the news that the vaccine is actually 95% successful - that's another load...) then the person with the vaccine has to isolate.

If people really can't see the absurdity in this and how contrary to immunology and how we've managed to last on this planet all these years then there's no helping them.

Under current rules maybe, maybe the rules will be eased when there is a vaccine

I think the wider pt being that if we take the testing data as true from the govt website (and I don't) and that 1.4m cases have been found then the likely immunity in the community with the R numbers that have been touted (but lets not start on how that's calculated because we will end up down another govt hole) plus the existing tcell immunity estimate of between 18-28% (hence asymptomatics) then millions of people are already immune and thus why are we all locked down.

That's been done to death on the politics page - to protect the vulnerable of all ages - you don't agree with it  - in fact it seems you have become somewhat of a religious zealot about it - so we'll leave you to continue with your total misrepresentations of stats

Wow. Straight in for me. Thanks. Not religious not a zealot. Passionate and informed - yes. I guess I could trade insults no point though when dealing with closed minds.

Precisely my point - we are in agreement - now fuck off
Reply
#79
[Image: EnF5sOEW8AAC3zJ?format=jpg&name=900x900]
Reply
#80
(11-18-2020, 11:15 AM)strawman Wrote:
(11-18-2020, 11:14 AM)billybassett Wrote:
(11-18-2020, 11:12 AM)strawman Wrote:
(11-18-2020, 11:02 AM)billybassett Wrote:
(11-18-2020, 10:56 AM)strawman Wrote: Under current rules maybe, maybe the rules will be eased when there is a vaccine

I think the wider pt being that if we take the testing data as true from the govt website (and I don't) and that 1.4m cases have been found then the likely immunity in the community with the R numbers that have been touted (but lets not start on how that's calculated because we will end up down another govt hole) plus the existing tcell immunity estimate of between 18-28% (hence asymptomatics) then millions of people are already immune and thus why are we all locked down.

That's been done to death on the politics page - to protect the vulnerable of all ages - you don't agree with it  - in fact it seems you have become somewhat of a religious zealot about it - so we'll leave you to continue with your total misrepresentations of stats

Wow. Straight in for me. Thanks. Not religious not a zealot. Passionate and informed - yes. I guess I could trade insults no point though when dealing with closed minds.

Precisely my point - we are in agreement - now fuck off

What a lovely chap you are. Explains everything.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: