Shareholders 4 Albion - big hand!!!!!
#11
We normally get a 'state of the nation' address after the close of the transfer window from the Club/Chairman/Chief Executive, which I think was promised during the window? 

Have I missed it?
Reply
#12
(11-10-2020, 11:38 AM)Hopalong Wrote: We normally get a 'state of the nation' address after the close of the transfer window from the Club/Chairman/Chief Executive, which I think was promised during the window? 

Have I missed it?

After that window they're probably too embarrassed!
Reply
#13
Got one from Dowling - who it seems is currently defacto Prince of The Hawthorns at the moment.
Reply
#14
I'll bet Lepko's loving the thought of this potential shit storm.
Reply
#15
Our owners are despicable gutless wankers...... Front up you tossers if they have nothing to hide.
Reply
#16
(11-10-2020, 12:20 PM)The liquidator Wrote: Our owners are despicable gutless wankers...... Front up you tossers if they have nothing to hide.

Are these the very same people you want to sack Bilic,  due to the lack of investment??  Huh   Big Grin
Reply
#17
How anyone can defend these shit houses is beyond me.
Reply
#18
(11-10-2020, 10:34 AM)Stourbridge Baggie Wrote: It has always been my view, from documents seen (the irony), that a number of the protagonists behind S4A have personal issues with certain officials of the Club and this festered and grew when JP sold and they didn't get a substantial pay out. My share was purchased when the Club was on the brink and I never considered it to be more than a donation, an equivalent of the modern GoFundMe schemes.  it didn't give me any control over the Club nor did I expect it too. I am well aware that interests of Minority Shareholders should be taken into account under governance protocols but in the real Corporate world Majority shareholders call the shots and like it or not the Club exists in this world. When JP took control of the Club and restructured the shareholding it was made clear that anyone that retained their shares would be left with a financially worthless un-tradeable investment with little or no input on Club affairs. I fully understand why some Shareholders were upset by this at the time, I have a good friend who was a home and away season ticket holder who has never been to a game since, but this argument was lost a long time ago and the Club, like so many others, is no longer the same organization. An inter-Company loan is common within Corporate structures but the inference from S4A is that the funds were some how "miss-directed" and I have seen comments all over social media along the lines of "definitely dodgy" (mostly from people who wouldn't recognize a set of accounts if it smacked them in the face). I have no idea what the purpose of the loan was or what happened to the funds, but 1) It was years ago and pre-dates the current ownership and 2) The Club has turned over hundreds of millions of pounds since the transaction and the amount in question is miniscule by comparison. If the owner wanted to divert funds he could easily have reduced salary and transfer budgets this season and paid himself a dividend, from which the loan could be repaid but I doubt S4A would have been happy with that. S4A has every right to question the future strategy of the Club, lack of Investment etc as do we all but it is naïve in the extreme to demand that the owners respond, we are a privately owned club not a Publicly listed one.  As I said in my opening comments, I still feel private grievances have driven the S4A agenda which is the reason why I have never joined the organization. Just my opinion and others may feel differently but worth putting a different view forward for discussion. And no I don't have any connection to the Club and I am not JP/MJ or Chinese !

I really can't add a lot more, an excellent summary. Like you I am a former shareholder, my shares were purchased when I declined to increase my shareholding.

I share S4A's comments in the past about how JRP ran the ship. Whilst I used to shout loudly about it, this was just to bring it to the attention of everyone, who didn't quite understand the complexities of finance/accounts. 

S4A have shouted about this loan, and it has been ignored. They have been ignored. They have about as much clout as Donald Trump has in America right now. They can go legal, they can kick up a fuss, but I doubt it will get them anywhere. Many of them thought there was a gravy train for them when JRP sold, but their shares are powerless and worthless.
Reply
#19
Still not right to be ignored though KK just shows you that this lot in charge don't give a toss..... Its called being respectful they have none to any of us I reckon.
Reply
#20
(11-10-2020, 01:11 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(11-10-2020, 10:34 AM)Stourbridge Baggie Wrote: It has always been my view, from documents seen (the irony), that a number of the protagonists behind S4A have personal issues with certain officials of the Club and this festered and grew when JP sold and they didn't get a substantial pay out. My share was purchased when the Club was on the brink and I never considered it to be more than a donation, an equivalent of the modern GoFundMe schemes.  it didn't give me any control over the Club nor did I expect it too. I am well aware that interests of Minority Shareholders should be taken into account under governance protocols but in the real Corporate world Majority shareholders call the shots and like it or not the Club exists in this world. When JP took control of the Club and restructured the shareholding it was made clear that anyone that retained their shares would be left with a financially worthless un-tradeable investment with little or no input on Club affairs. I fully understand why some Shareholders were upset by this at the time, I have a good friend who was a home and away season ticket holder who has never been to a game since, but this argument was lost a long time ago and the Club, like so many others, is no longer the same organization. An inter-Company loan is common within Corporate structures but the inference from S4A is that the funds were some how "miss-directed" and I have seen comments all over social media along the lines of "definitely dodgy" (mostly from people who wouldn't recognize a set of accounts if it smacked them in the face). I have no idea what the purpose of the loan was or what happened to the funds, but 1) It was years ago and pre-dates the current ownership and 2) The Club has turned over hundreds of millions of pounds since the transaction and the amount in question is miniscule by comparison. If the owner wanted to divert funds he could easily have reduced salary and transfer budgets this season and paid himself a dividend, from which the loan could be repaid but I doubt S4A would have been happy with that. S4A has every right to question the future strategy of the Club, lack of Investment etc as do we all but it is naïve in the extreme to demand that the owners respond, we are a privately owned club not a Publicly listed one.  As I said in my opening comments, I still feel private grievances have driven the S4A agenda which is the reason why I have never joined the organization. Just my opinion and others may feel differently but worth putting a different view forward for discussion. And no I don't have any connection to the Club and I am not JP/MJ or Chinese !

I really can't add a lot more, an excellent summary. Like you I am a former shareholder, my shares were purchased when I declined to increase my shareholding.

I share S4A's comments in the past about how JRP ran the ship. Whilst I used to shout loudly about it, this was just to bring it to the attention of everyone, who didn't quite understand the complexities of finance/accounts. 

S4A have shouted about this loan, and it has been ignored. They have been ignored. They have about as much clout as Donald Trump has in America right now. They can go legal, they can kick up a fuss, but I doubt it will get them anywhere. Many of them thought there was a gravy train for them when JRP sold, but their shares are powerless and worthless.

I too was a shareholder back when the club were desperate for the money, JRP soon rode roughshod over all of us, I bailed out at that point,  I believe he also did a company buy-back which whilst used in the corporate world, stinks in football.  Using the clubs money to buy the shares back to make himself richer.

Anyway he's gone and he did very well off the back of us which is always going to leave a sour taste.  Football clubs need a special set of governance rules, they almost be treated as Community Interest Companies given the audience they attract and where they derive their income from.  Roland left us knowing that he'd found the right buyer and we were in capable hands...  I'm sure I've seen fairies at the bottom of my garden too.  

The new owners clearly have no interest in the club or its wellbeing and ignoring shareholders etc is just another example of this.  Compare this behaviour to how good owners have conducted themselves such as Fosun.  They don't have to be chucking money at the club to behave considerately.

The 2 bombs in all of this: 

The "loan". If this wasn't properly disclosed in the accounts then there are going to be a few twitchy bums at the auditor's office.  I don't recall the accounts but is it really an immaterial figure to the balance sheet?  Has the materiality been adjusted to reflect the nature of the transaction i.e. connected party?

Increase in Management Charges - this is the one to watch.  Has Holdings upped it's fees to the club trading company and thereby reduced our funds and ability to trade in the transfer market.  It's an easier transaction to slip through and will raise less eyebrows than declaring dividends, possibly more justifiable if Holding management teams have been stepping in to cover the cone-chucker's absence. 

Simple fact is that we need to be sold ASAP as this lot don't give 2 fucks about us and have no intention supporting us in anyway.  

What a mess, thanks Roland.  First you shafted (legally if not morally) the shareholders and then you sold out for your own interests and not those of the clubs.  How many millions does one man need exactly?  I guess the ideal that we got along so long as the clubs needs matched Roland's ring true and as soon as they didn't he shafted us again.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)