11-10-2020, 09:46 AM
A pal of mine has asked me to post this out for consumption.
Please take the time to read and I’m sure you’ll agree that we should be grateful that this group of people have always got the best interests of our great club at the heart of all they do...
Press statement by the Committee of Shareholders for Albion—WBA give Red Card to Supporters
West Bromwich Albion Football Club Limited ('Club') is a wholly owned subsidiary of West Bromwich Albion Group Limited ('Group'). Minority shareholders account for 12.2% of the shareholding of Group, the overwhelming majority of minority shareholders being lifelong and loyal supporters of the football club. The majority of minority shareholders are represented by Shareholders for Albion ('S4A'). S4A seeks at all times to act in the interests of the Football Club and its loyal supporters, as well as minority shareholders.
West Bromwich Albion Holdings Limited ('Holdings') owns the remaining 87.8% of the shareholding of Group. The ultimate ownership of Holdings is determined through complex Chinese corporate structures.
Following the departure of Mark Jenkins as Chief Executive on 3 August 2020 and succession in post by Ke Xu, the Chairman of S4A attempted to make contact with Ke Xu to congratulate him on his appointment and seek an informal meeting to build on prior relationships with senior management, for the benefit of all going forward. Having not even received the courtesy of a reply, the Chairman hand-delivered a follow-up letter to the Administrative HQ at The Palm Training Ground, to ensure that the correspondence had been received. Several weeks later in legal correspondence, the Chairman was castigated for hand-delivering a letter! This was dealt with in an immediate and appropriate
response from S4A which also pointed out that the Chairman and most members of S4A are lifelong and loyal supporters of the football club and actually own part of it.
We can also report that a shareholder whose family own a significant number of shares and annually pay for an executive box at the Hawthorns has not received any response whatsoever to written requests for a meeting or other form of contact with Ke Xu to discuss important matters.
A General Meeting of the shareholders of Group which had been requisitioned by over 200 shareholders and scheduled for March 2020 has yet to take place, due to Covid-19 restrictions. This meeting was called by the minority shareholders to discuss proposed company resolutions seeking: a) the investigation of all the circumstances surrounding the grant of a loan of £3.7million made between Club and Holdings in September 2014 when Holdings was wholly owned by the Chairman Jeremy Peace; and b) the non-repayment of the loan (together with all interest due under that loan) to Club.
The loan was granted at the time when Jeremy Peace controlled his shares in Group through
his company Holdings. The repayment of the loan (and all interest payable) by Holdings was already in default before Jeremy Peace sold Holdings and is now significantly overdue. It is a legal debt due to Club. Reports have suggested that Chinese restrictions on foreign investment prevent repayment. We contend that this is not correct. It does not constitute investment. It is a contractual legal obligation under English law. It can and should be repaid without further delay. The Football Club clearly needs those funds at present for team strengthening.
Jeremy Peace's solicitors were originally involved in advising Group when the General Meeting was called by minority shareholders, upon the instructions of Mark Jenkins. In early August 2020, S4A were successful in ensuring that Jeremy Peace's solicitors no longer acted for Group, as there were clear potential conflicts of interest. Group appointed alternative and independent solicitors, shortly after the departure of Mark Jenkins.
The majority shareholders of Group have been invited by S4A to conduct the investigation proposed by the minority shareholders without the need to wait for the General Meeting to take place. They have declined to do so. Whilst we have always suggested that there could be legitimate explanations regarding the circumstances around the grant and non- repayment of the loan, we are yet to be provided with those. An investigation is required as part of basic, sound corporate governance. Further, if there are issues of concern uncovered, there may be courses of action available to Club (who granted the loan) which
could potentially see very significant sums brought back into the Football Club through legal channels. This would benefit both the Football Club by providing much needed extra
funds and increase the value of both Group and Holdings. We do not understand why this is not of interest to the majority shareholders on either front.
Over a significant period of time we have not been able to obtain answers to legitimate and important accounts and audit questions. The usual forum for this (the annual general meeting-AGM) was firstly relocated to London by Jeremy Peace and Mark Jenkins in 2013, making it difficult or impossible for most of the minority shareholders to attend. Subsequently, they were not held at all. AGMs are yet to be reinstated by the new majority shareholders. Responsible post-holders have also declined to respond to questions relating to the accounts of Club and Group, in the absence of AGMs . Many queries relate to the non-disclosure of the 2014 loan agreement, as it should have been listed under 'Contracts with Directors and Related Third Parties.' We contend that this is clearly not good, or even adequate corporate governance.
We assume that the content of our communications is reaching our ultimate Chinese majority shareholders, but there remains a degree of doubt that this may not be the case. It appears that a number of individuals working at the club in recent and current times may have been involved in matters which we believe require investigation and upon which clarity is overdue.
We are concerned that there does not appear to be a clear strategy for the Football Club on the part of the majority shareholders. To date, there has been negligible substantive investment into the Football Club since the acquisition of the majority shareholding. Last season, reports suggested that there had been attempts to raise significant funds by either
Group or Club. More recently, reports suggest that significant levels of management costs may being taken out of the Club by the majority shareholders. These reports naturally add to our concern.
We have also seen evidence which suggests that there may have been a change in the ultimate ownership and control of Holdings and, in turn, the majority shareholding in Group (and therefore the Football Club). Group maintain that there has been no change in
ownership but have not provided any evidence to rebut the evidence we have seen, in spite of us providing Group with several opportunities to do so, over the last three weeks, via its solicitors. Consequently, we have been left with no choice. We have formally referred the matter to the Premier League to investigate (as regulator on this issue) in accordance with its rules relating to ownership and control of member clubs. We trust that this will provide clarity on the matter.
Our majority shareholders are invisible, as is our new Chief Executive. The football club appears to lack the leadership needed at this critical time.
The apparent lack of appetite to invest and compete to stay in the Premier League is perplexing, given that reports suggest that the majority shareholders are seeking to sell their interests or attract outside investment. With even moderate investment, there would be a good chance of survival in the Premier League of 2020-21. It is sadly clear and not a
surprise that the squad is not fit for purpose for Premier League football, carrying clear deficiencies in several positions.
We feel that our Head Coach, Slaven Bilic, has been undermined in his efforts to strengthen and develop the team. Slaven immediately galvanised the football team and club. He is the main reason we achieved promotion, in spite of a clear shortfall in the striker resource afforded to him.
We will continue to monitor all matters mentioned in this statement and take all necessary action to protect the interests of our wonderful football club, its loyal supporters and minority shareholders at all times.
We are asking any minority shareholders who have yet to join S4A to consider membership. This will enable S4A to clearly demonstrate to the majority shareholders that we act for all minority shareholders in our great club.
Please take the time to read and I’m sure you’ll agree that we should be grateful that this group of people have always got the best interests of our great club at the heart of all they do...
Press statement by the Committee of Shareholders for Albion—WBA give Red Card to Supporters
West Bromwich Albion Football Club Limited ('Club') is a wholly owned subsidiary of West Bromwich Albion Group Limited ('Group'). Minority shareholders account for 12.2% of the shareholding of Group, the overwhelming majority of minority shareholders being lifelong and loyal supporters of the football club. The majority of minority shareholders are represented by Shareholders for Albion ('S4A'). S4A seeks at all times to act in the interests of the Football Club and its loyal supporters, as well as minority shareholders.
West Bromwich Albion Holdings Limited ('Holdings') owns the remaining 87.8% of the shareholding of Group. The ultimate ownership of Holdings is determined through complex Chinese corporate structures.
Following the departure of Mark Jenkins as Chief Executive on 3 August 2020 and succession in post by Ke Xu, the Chairman of S4A attempted to make contact with Ke Xu to congratulate him on his appointment and seek an informal meeting to build on prior relationships with senior management, for the benefit of all going forward. Having not even received the courtesy of a reply, the Chairman hand-delivered a follow-up letter to the Administrative HQ at The Palm Training Ground, to ensure that the correspondence had been received. Several weeks later in legal correspondence, the Chairman was castigated for hand-delivering a letter! This was dealt with in an immediate and appropriate
response from S4A which also pointed out that the Chairman and most members of S4A are lifelong and loyal supporters of the football club and actually own part of it.
We can also report that a shareholder whose family own a significant number of shares and annually pay for an executive box at the Hawthorns has not received any response whatsoever to written requests for a meeting or other form of contact with Ke Xu to discuss important matters.
A General Meeting of the shareholders of Group which had been requisitioned by over 200 shareholders and scheduled for March 2020 has yet to take place, due to Covid-19 restrictions. This meeting was called by the minority shareholders to discuss proposed company resolutions seeking: a) the investigation of all the circumstances surrounding the grant of a loan of £3.7million made between Club and Holdings in September 2014 when Holdings was wholly owned by the Chairman Jeremy Peace; and b) the non-repayment of the loan (together with all interest due under that loan) to Club.
The loan was granted at the time when Jeremy Peace controlled his shares in Group through
his company Holdings. The repayment of the loan (and all interest payable) by Holdings was already in default before Jeremy Peace sold Holdings and is now significantly overdue. It is a legal debt due to Club. Reports have suggested that Chinese restrictions on foreign investment prevent repayment. We contend that this is not correct. It does not constitute investment. It is a contractual legal obligation under English law. It can and should be repaid without further delay. The Football Club clearly needs those funds at present for team strengthening.
Jeremy Peace's solicitors were originally involved in advising Group when the General Meeting was called by minority shareholders, upon the instructions of Mark Jenkins. In early August 2020, S4A were successful in ensuring that Jeremy Peace's solicitors no longer acted for Group, as there were clear potential conflicts of interest. Group appointed alternative and independent solicitors, shortly after the departure of Mark Jenkins.
The majority shareholders of Group have been invited by S4A to conduct the investigation proposed by the minority shareholders without the need to wait for the General Meeting to take place. They have declined to do so. Whilst we have always suggested that there could be legitimate explanations regarding the circumstances around the grant and non- repayment of the loan, we are yet to be provided with those. An investigation is required as part of basic, sound corporate governance. Further, if there are issues of concern uncovered, there may be courses of action available to Club (who granted the loan) which
could potentially see very significant sums brought back into the Football Club through legal channels. This would benefit both the Football Club by providing much needed extra
funds and increase the value of both Group and Holdings. We do not understand why this is not of interest to the majority shareholders on either front.
Over a significant period of time we have not been able to obtain answers to legitimate and important accounts and audit questions. The usual forum for this (the annual general meeting-AGM) was firstly relocated to London by Jeremy Peace and Mark Jenkins in 2013, making it difficult or impossible for most of the minority shareholders to attend. Subsequently, they were not held at all. AGMs are yet to be reinstated by the new majority shareholders. Responsible post-holders have also declined to respond to questions relating to the accounts of Club and Group, in the absence of AGMs . Many queries relate to the non-disclosure of the 2014 loan agreement, as it should have been listed under 'Contracts with Directors and Related Third Parties.' We contend that this is clearly not good, or even adequate corporate governance.
We assume that the content of our communications is reaching our ultimate Chinese majority shareholders, but there remains a degree of doubt that this may not be the case. It appears that a number of individuals working at the club in recent and current times may have been involved in matters which we believe require investigation and upon which clarity is overdue.
We are concerned that there does not appear to be a clear strategy for the Football Club on the part of the majority shareholders. To date, there has been negligible substantive investment into the Football Club since the acquisition of the majority shareholding. Last season, reports suggested that there had been attempts to raise significant funds by either
Group or Club. More recently, reports suggest that significant levels of management costs may being taken out of the Club by the majority shareholders. These reports naturally add to our concern.
We have also seen evidence which suggests that there may have been a change in the ultimate ownership and control of Holdings and, in turn, the majority shareholding in Group (and therefore the Football Club). Group maintain that there has been no change in
ownership but have not provided any evidence to rebut the evidence we have seen, in spite of us providing Group with several opportunities to do so, over the last three weeks, via its solicitors. Consequently, we have been left with no choice. We have formally referred the matter to the Premier League to investigate (as regulator on this issue) in accordance with its rules relating to ownership and control of member clubs. We trust that this will provide clarity on the matter.
Our majority shareholders are invisible, as is our new Chief Executive. The football club appears to lack the leadership needed at this critical time.
The apparent lack of appetite to invest and compete to stay in the Premier League is perplexing, given that reports suggest that the majority shareholders are seeking to sell their interests or attract outside investment. With even moderate investment, there would be a good chance of survival in the Premier League of 2020-21. It is sadly clear and not a
surprise that the squad is not fit for purpose for Premier League football, carrying clear deficiencies in several positions.
We feel that our Head Coach, Slaven Bilic, has been undermined in his efforts to strengthen and develop the team. Slaven immediately galvanised the football team and club. He is the main reason we achieved promotion, in spite of a clear shortfall in the striker resource afforded to him.
We will continue to monitor all matters mentioned in this statement and take all necessary action to protect the interests of our wonderful football club, its loyal supporters and minority shareholders at all times.
We are asking any minority shareholders who have yet to join S4A to consider membership. This will enable S4A to clearly demonstrate to the majority shareholders that we act for all minority shareholders in our great club.


