Karlan Grant
#21
(11-08-2020, 10:46 PM)Super_Slav Wrote:
(11-08-2020, 10:45 PM)Hopalong Wrote: We've not quite got the right support for him as yet, Brighton late on we saw what he can do and today was better with Robinson and he could have done better with the half chance. 

At Fulham he just slightly scuffed the shot and yes unfortunate with the header against Burnley and actually today, it was just in front of him.  

Difficult to say but I would think he'll get 10 this season.  When we actually get him in positions and create chances for him he will take them.  

He's 23 and there is still a lot of development there.

What is your decision going forward Hoppy? 

How do we fit Diang, Pereria, Robinson & Grant in first XI

This is a real conundrum for Bilic to solve as its the key to the season and our hope of staying up. 

It depends on the opposition SS and therefore formation and also form is a factor. 

In a back three you could then have a 4  or 5 and then a 3 or 2. 

Robinson and Grant fit into both with say Diangana in the 3 but the latter in a 2.  This raises two issues. You would like to think so but I'm not sure whether the signing of Diangana was really thought through in terms of where he would fit into certain formations which would be necessary against quite a large percentage of teams and also whether he is physically able to cope with the Prem. He is very lightweight and easily eased off the ball - or that is certainly evident so far. He is just not the player we thought we we were getting and doesn't appear at the moment to be able to make the step up. 

Pereira on the other other hand can. And I don't buy this notion that he can't play in a three. Of course he can but with a licence to roam. He did so against Chelsea and Everton. 

For now I would have Diangana on the bench and bring him on as and when. Today has demonstrated he's not as vital as most of us probably thought. 

Covid has thrown a temporary spanner in the works in respect of Ivan/Pereira and our United preparations plus of course internationals. Not sure if Ivan and Pereira will be available - can they train alone in isolation at the training ground or do they have to isolate indoors. 

Subject to availability my 11 at the moment to fit into whatever formation would be Sam, O'Shea,Ivan,Ajayi Gibbs Gallagher Livermore Kroc Pereira Robinson Grant.
Reply
#22
5 3 2
Johnstone Furlong Semi Ivan O'Shea Townsend
Livermore Gallagher Pereira
Robinson Grant
Austin Grosicki on the bench , stop cutting your nose off Slav.
Johnstone in as I don't think Button is much better.
Reply
#23
He's not going to keep us up with 20+ goals but I've been reasonably impressed so far. Robinson isn't getting much publicity but I think he can have a big part to play up front. I do think Grant is snatching at his chances a little bit at the moment and a little bit more composure wouldn't hurt.
Reply
#24
So far he has shown he can finish and he grafts. Thats good enough for me.

He also shows good movement and does try to stretch teams. Weirdly he could be well served playing up top with HRK.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#25
Seems to have a bit of Earnshaw about him. May not get too involved but knows where the back of the net is.

As said above Robinson has probably been our most productive forward player so far this season (even discounting his goals)
Reply
#26
Made teh choice to ignore yesterday's game, but did see some highlights, looked like he should have done better with at least one of them, ditto vs Fulham, should have at least hit the target.

However, he's still probably a little way of full match sharpness, and at least he got into the positions, so here's hoping.
Reply
#27
I think that based on the number of games he's played for us, it maybe a little bit premature to either, start pant pissing cuz he's shit, or wanking over how great he is. OMVHO
Reply
#28
(11-08-2020, 10:49 PM)albion_pigeon Wrote:
(11-08-2020, 10:46 PM)Super_Slav Wrote:
(11-08-2020, 10:45 PM)Hopalong Wrote: We've not quite got the right support for him as yet, Brighton late on we saw what he can do and today was better with Robinson and he could have done better with the half chance. 

At Fulham he just slightly scuffed the shot and yes unfortunate with the header against Burnley and actually today, it was just in front of him.  

Difficult to say but I would think he'll get 10 this season.  When we actually get him in positions and create chances for him he will take them.  

He's 23 and there is still a lot of development there.

What is your decision going forward Hoppy? 

How do we fit Diang, Pereria, Robinson & Grant in first XI

Unless Pereira is in the middle then we don't. Absolutely wasted outside.
Spot on, has to be this as our attacking 4

Grady.        Grant.         Robinson

                  Peiarra
Reply
#29
(11-09-2020, 08:49 AM)Loanee Wrote: Seems to have a bit of Earnshaw about him.  May not get too involved but knows where the back of the net is.

Tend to agree on the early evidence -  defo something of an Earny/ Defoe type.

Unfortunately that means his finishing has to be spot on - as he wont offer too much in the way of general/ link play
Reply
#30
(11-09-2020, 12:34 PM)MancBaggie Wrote:
(11-09-2020, 08:49 AM)Loanee Wrote: Seems to have a bit of Earnshaw about him.  May not get too involved but knows where the back of the net is.

Tend to agree on the early evidence -  defo something of an Earny/ Defoe type.

Unfortunately that means his finishing has to be spot on - as he wont offer too much in the way of general/ link play

This is just silly, Earnshaw was an Alien, Roger from Family Guy style, Grant has nothing of that about him Wink
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: