Button or Bond
#1
I think it’s time to drop Johnstone and give another keeper a chance. Good shot stopper, but Johnstone simply does not command his box. Early in the game he started to come out for the ball, stopped and retreated leaving the defender in a precarious position. This is the biggest weakness in his game. This same indecisiveness cost us the game today. We have two other keepers, time to give one a chance in my opinion.
Reply
#2
He’s been our best player this season. That goal wasn’t just his error
Reply
#3
I think if we drop SJ for one error - and did the same for everyone else - then we wouldn't be able to field an XI.
Reply
#4
Shilton.
Reply
#5
He's still very much in credit for this season. Unfortunately he's the best we have (as it stands)
Reply
#6
(11-08-2020, 02:50 PM)Sliced Wrote: He's still very much in credit for this season. Unfortunately he's the best we have (as it stands)

He's been superb this season.

I must have been watching different games.

Most of the first eleven deserve dropping. Pereira has had some shockers and so had Grady.
Reply
#7
Trouble is if the other keepers may be more commanding in the area then i dont think either have SJ ability to shot stop like he does , catch 22 situation but then again if he put those two aspects of his game together he probably wouldnt be playing for us .
Reply
#8
Jesus, yes he made a mistake but he’s well in credit this season.

I think the international break will help us. We need to build on today.
Reply
#9
(11-08-2020, 02:48 PM)baggiebloke Wrote: Shilton.

I've been a critic for 2 seasons now, but I wouldn't drop him, as I'm sure he's probably the best we've got. I blame the club for not getting a  better one.
He showed today why this board is so divided on his ability particularly to make important decisions in his 6 yard box.
I was told I was a pessimist at half time because I dared to suggest we would lose 1 - 0, no, just being a long time Baggie
Reply
#10
Johnstone well in credit this season.

Yes it was his mistake, but if Bartley gets goal.side of Kane as he should have done, it wouldn't have mattered.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: