“Lack of Investment” - The Myth
#31
(11-04-2020, 02:14 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(11-03-2020, 09:28 PM)Duffers Wrote: Been reading a few times on here about the lack of investment in the transfer market by the owners, it’s something that gets repeated so often it becomes an accepted fact. I thought I would do a little digging to see how true it actually is...

Lai took over September 2016, so let’s look at the spend in the years building up:

(Figures courtesy of  Transfermarkt)

11/12 -  Players in: £8.2m Players out: £10m. Net Spend -£1.8m - Plus Gera and McAuley on frees.

12/13 - In: £4.5m Out: £3.3m. Net spend £1.2m - Plus Rosenberg and Yacob on frees and Lukaku loan fee & wages.

13/14 - In: £14.1m Out: £10.2m. Net spend £3.9m - Plus Anelka and Lugano on frees and Sinclair loan.

14/15 - In: £22.4m Out: £2.1m. Net spend £20.3m - Plus Lescott, Gardner, Fletcher on frees.

15/16 - In: £38.6m Out: £11.6m. Net spend £27m

16/17 - In: £34.1m Out: £24.2m. Net spend £9.9m

17/18 (Lai’s first summer window) In: £48.1m Out: £1.9m. Net spend £46.2m - Plus loans and wages for Sturridge and Gap-year Greg

18/19 (Champ) - In: £13.7m. Out: £23.9m. Net spend -£9.8m - Plus Gayle, Barnes, Tosin loan and wages.

19/20 (Champ) - In: £19.4m Out: £29.5m. Net spend -£10.2m

20/21 - In: £36.4 Out: £6.8m. Net spend £29.6m - Plus Ivanovic free and loans for Gallagher and Krov.

Conclusions:

Investment in the transfer market has not slowed down under Lai at all. Barring the two Championship seasons where we turned over an entire squad to cut costs investment has remained at the same rough level it always has. The line from the club has always been we will spend within our means and these figure demonstrate we are doing just that. This season’s slight dip in net spend could easily attributed to projected loss of revenue as a result of COVID. The money has been spent, the more pertinent question is whether it was spent well.

A further interesting quirk is that spend really jumped from 14/15 onwards, which was around the time JP first expressed keenness to sell the club.

And how much additional equity has been injected by the shareholders to purchase anything?

Cashflows are different to profits.  Hudds show a profit on Grant, but they will wait 6 years for the cash.

Too many people scream "where's the money gone, Tom" who couldn't understand cashflow vs Profit vs Net Worth if it was spoon fed to them.

What I do understand about finance Kit Kat, is that you’re a liability to this bored Big Grin   Only joking mucka.

I wrote a post recently about cash flow and profit being mutually exclusive and used Grant and Grady as examples in that the accounting policy for the amortisation of player’s transfer fees will be the same irrespective of how the payment for the player has been agreed between Albion and the selling club.
Reply
#32
(11-04-2020, 09:16 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(11-04-2020, 08:54 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(11-04-2020, 07:30 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(11-03-2020, 11:04 PM)Baggie_Nick Wrote:
(11-03-2020, 09:45 PM)Duffers Wrote: Which ones? The ones backed by wealthy Arabs or the ones bankrolled by a Chinese acquisition firm in bed with the Portuguese super agent?

What our neighbours do is irrelevant.

No it's,not, they are our rivals.

Our investment has been pathetic.

Last time we played Fulham at home we couldn't beat them.with more or less the same team.

And then we sell a first team player.

Nick, I know you love using emotive phrases like “pathetic” and “penny pinching” but I’m going to ask a simple question and I’m keen to get your response...

How could we have spent more? We have a 25k stadium that we struggle to fill, no wealthy backers and little sponsorship revenue. Where is this extra money you feel we should be spending coming from?

He won't answer, he never does.

Of course he won’t. Or he’ll and deflect by accusing  meof being “rattled” or “taking it too seriously”.


And he'll then amend his signature to reflect said comments.     Rolleyes

Something like,  Mr 2011 but by no means delicate, rattled, or taking things too seriously.
Reply
#33
(11-03-2020, 10:47 PM)Jack Halford Wrote:
(11-03-2020, 10:39 PM)MrFizz Wrote: Some perspective. Leicester's net spend over the same period?

£72.4m

I'll leave that with you......

Leicester have sold players at the right time.

Drinkwater and Kante went to Chelsea for £67m combined.

Thats the thing though, how many of our players do we sell for a big profit? Berahino? Then what did we spend it on? Burke?
Pulis mentioned this a few years ago no one ever shows interest in our players when was the last time we had a player we were actually worried about losing to a bigger club? Hegazi possibly?
These days we are simply trying to offload.
Its our scouting that needs investment.
Reply
#34
(11-04-2020, 09:33 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote:
(11-04-2020, 02:14 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(11-03-2020, 09:28 PM)Duffers Wrote: Been reading a few times on here about the lack of investment in the transfer market by the owners, it’s something that gets repeated so often it becomes an accepted fact. I thought I would do a little digging to see how true it actually is...

Lai took over September 2016, so let’s look at the spend in the years building up:

(Figures courtesy of  Transfermarkt)

11/12 -  Players in: £8.2m Players out: £10m. Net Spend -£1.8m - Plus Gera and McAuley on frees.

12/13 - In: £4.5m Out: £3.3m. Net spend £1.2m - Plus Rosenberg and Yacob on frees and Lukaku loan fee & wages.

13/14 - In: £14.1m Out: £10.2m. Net spend £3.9m - Plus Anelka and Lugano on frees and Sinclair loan.

14/15 - In: £22.4m Out: £2.1m. Net spend £20.3m - Plus Lescott, Gardner, Fletcher on frees.

15/16 - In: £38.6m Out: £11.6m. Net spend £27m

16/17 - In: £34.1m Out: £24.2m. Net spend £9.9m

17/18 (Lai’s first summer window) In: £48.1m Out: £1.9m. Net spend £46.2m - Plus loans and wages for Sturridge and Gap-year Greg

18/19 (Champ) - In: £13.7m. Out: £23.9m. Net spend -£9.8m - Plus Gayle, Barnes, Tosin loan and wages.

19/20 (Champ) - In: £19.4m Out: £29.5m. Net spend -£10.2m

20/21 - In: £36.4 Out: £6.8m. Net spend £29.6m - Plus Ivanovic free and loans for Gallagher and Krov.

Conclusions:

Investment in the transfer market has not slowed down under Lai at all. Barring the two Championship seasons where we turned over an entire squad to cut costs investment has remained at the same rough level it always has. The line from the club has always been we will spend within our means and these figure demonstrate we are doing just that. This season’s slight dip in net spend could easily attributed to projected loss of revenue as a result of COVID. The money has been spent, the more pertinent question is whether it was spent well.

A further interesting quirk is that spend really jumped from 14/15 onwards, which was around the time JP first expressed keenness to sell the club.

And how much additional equity has been injected by the shareholders to purchase anything?

Cashflows are different to profits.  Hudds show a profit on Grant, but they will wait 6 years for the cash.

Too many people scream "where's the money gone, Tom" who couldn't understand cashflow vs Profit vs Net Worth if it was spoon fed to them.

What I do understand about finance Kit Kat, is that you’re a liability to this bored Big Grin   Only joking mucka.

I wrote a post recently about cash flow and profit being mutually exclusive and used Grant and Grady as examples in that the accounting policy for the amortisation of player’s transfer fees will be the same irrespective of how the payment for the player has been agreed between Albion and the selling club.

But cash is king, FF. 

Hudds can't spend their headline £16M because they don't have it. Similarly we are owed money on sales and have liabilities such as Grant on purchases.

Love you too   Big Grin
Reply
#35
(11-04-2020, 09:44 AM)coxy134 Wrote:
(11-03-2020, 10:47 PM)Jack Halford Wrote:
(11-03-2020, 10:39 PM)MrFizz Wrote: Some perspective. Leicester's net spend over the same period?

£72.4m

I'll leave that with you......

Leicester have sold players at the right time.

Drinkwater and Kante went to Chelsea for £67m combined.

Thats the thing though, how many of our players do we sell for a big profit? Berahino? Then what did we spend it on? Burke?
Pulis mentioned this a few years ago no one ever shows interest in our players when was the last time we had a player we were actually worried about losing to a bigger club? Hegazi possibly?
These days we are simply trying to offload.
Its our scouting that needs investment.

As I mentioned earlier, clubs don’t show interest in players that are playing pragmatic football in pragmatic teams... How many of Burnley or Sheff United’s players are linked to bigger clubs? Compare that with Bournemouth who were regularly seeing players linked with £50m moves.

Players need to be seen to be attacking, scoring goals and creating mayhem... even defenders in teams that score a lot of goals get inflated.

Add to that most of the players we had under TP were the wrong side of 27 or had already failed at bigger clubs, and you see why we didn’t sell for profits.

Evans should have been sold when we had £25m bids, there had been big bids for Foster over the years, and we could have gotten more money (in the long term) for Berahino. There were also links for Yacob, Mulumbu etc etc..

We have to be better at knowing when to sell, and have confidence we can replace them. Grant, Diangana, Pereira... will all attract attention in the next 12-18 months.
Reply
#36
It's called Reminomic's my friend
Reply
#37
(11-04-2020, 10:04 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(11-04-2020, 09:44 AM)coxy134 Wrote:
(11-03-2020, 10:47 PM)Jack Halford Wrote:
(11-03-2020, 10:39 PM)MrFizz Wrote: Some perspective. Leicester's net spend over the same period?

£72.4m

I'll leave that with you......

Leicester have sold players at the right time.

Drinkwater and Kante went to Chelsea for £67m combined.

Thats the thing though, how many of our players do we sell for a big profit? Berahino? Then what did we spend it on? Burke?
Pulis mentioned this a few years ago no one ever shows interest in our players when was the last time we had a player we were actually worried about losing to a bigger club? Hegazi possibly?
These days we are simply trying to offload.
Its our scouting that needs investment.

As I mentioned earlier, clubs don’t show interest in players that are playing pragmatic football in pragmatic teams... How many of Burnley or Sheff United’s players are linked to bigger clubs? Compare that with Bournemouth who were regularly seeing players linked with £50m moves.

Players need to be seen to be attacking, scoring goals and creating mayhem... even defenders in teams that score a lot of goals get inflated.

Add to that most of the players we had under TP were the wrong side of 27 or had already failed at bigger clubs, and you see why we didn’t sell for profits.

Evans should have been sold when we had £25m bids, there had been big bids for Foster over the years, and we could have gotten more money (in the long term) for Berahino. There were also links for Yacob, Mulumbu etc etc..

We have to be better at knowing when to sell, and have confidence we can replace them. Grant, Diangana, Pereira... will all attract attention in the next 12-18 months.

From league 1 if they don’t bloody improve.
Reply
#38
(11-04-2020, 02:14 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(11-03-2020, 09:28 PM)Duffers Wrote: Been reading a few times on here about the lack of investment in the transfer market by the owners, it’s something that gets repeated so often it becomes an accepted fact. I thought I would do a little digging to see how true it actually is...

Lai took over September 2016, so let’s look at the spend in the years building up:

(Figures courtesy of  Transfermarkt)

11/12 -  Players in: £8.2m Players out: £10m. Net Spend -£1.8m - Plus Gera and McAuley on frees.

12/13 - In: £4.5m Out: £3.3m. Net spend £1.2m - Plus Rosenberg and Yacob on frees and Lukaku loan fee & wages.

13/14 - In: £14.1m Out: £10.2m. Net spend £3.9m - Plus Anelka and Lugano on frees and Sinclair loan.

14/15 - In: £22.4m Out: £2.1m. Net spend £20.3m - Plus Lescott, Gardner, Fletcher on frees.

15/16 - In: £38.6m Out: £11.6m. Net spend £27m

16/17 - In: £34.1m Out: £24.2m. Net spend £9.9m

17/18 (Lai’s first summer window) In: £48.1m Out: £1.9m. Net spend £46.2m - Plus loans and wages for Sturridge and Gap-year Greg

18/19 (Champ) - In: £13.7m. Out: £23.9m. Net spend -£9.8m - Plus Gayle, Barnes, Tosin loan and wages.

19/20 (Champ) - In: £19.4m Out: £29.5m. Net spend -£10.2m

20/21 - In: £36.4 Out: £6.8m. Net spend £29.6m - Plus Ivanovic free and loans for Gallagher and Krov.

Conclusions:

Investment in the transfer market has not slowed down under Lai at all. Barring the two Championship seasons where we turned over an entire squad to cut costs investment has remained at the same rough level it always has. The line from the club has always been we will spend within our means and these figure demonstrate we are doing just that. This season’s slight dip in net spend could easily attributed to projected loss of revenue as a result of COVID. The money has been spent, the more pertinent question is whether it was spent well.

A further interesting quirk is that spend really jumped from 14/15 onwards, which was around the time JP first expressed keenness to sell the club.

And how much additional equity has been injected by the shareholders to purchase anything?

Cashflows are different to profits.  Hudds show a profit on Grant, but they will wait 6 years for the cash.

Too many people scream "where's the money gone, Tom" who couldn't understand cashflow vs Profit vs Net Worth if it was spoon fed to them.

This is what I was getting at Minstrel, we haven’t had any external investment, nobody is putting money into the club. Our spend is about right for a club of our size living within its means.

What we don’t have is data on wages, which for most PL clubs are usually at least 60% of turnover these days.
Reply
#39
(11-04-2020, 11:07 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(11-04-2020, 02:14 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(11-03-2020, 09:28 PM)Duffers Wrote: Been reading a few times on here about the lack of investment in the transfer market by the owners, it’s something that gets repeated so often it becomes an accepted fact. I thought I would do a little digging to see how true it actually is...

Lai took over September 2016, so let’s look at the spend in the years building up:

(Figures courtesy of  Transfermarkt)

11/12 -  Players in: £8.2m Players out: £10m. Net Spend -£1.8m - Plus Gera and McAuley on frees.

12/13 - In: £4.5m Out: £3.3m. Net spend £1.2m - Plus Rosenberg and Yacob on frees and Lukaku loan fee & wages.

13/14 - In: £14.1m Out: £10.2m. Net spend £3.9m - Plus Anelka and Lugano on frees and Sinclair loan.

14/15 - In: £22.4m Out: £2.1m. Net spend £20.3m - Plus Lescott, Gardner, Fletcher on frees.

15/16 - In: £38.6m Out: £11.6m. Net spend £27m

16/17 - In: £34.1m Out: £24.2m. Net spend £9.9m

17/18 (Lai’s first summer window) In: £48.1m Out: £1.9m. Net spend £46.2m - Plus loans and wages for Sturridge and Gap-year Greg

18/19 (Champ) - In: £13.7m. Out: £23.9m. Net spend -£9.8m - Plus Gayle, Barnes, Tosin loan and wages.

19/20 (Champ) - In: £19.4m Out: £29.5m. Net spend -£10.2m

20/21 - In: £36.4 Out: £6.8m. Net spend £29.6m - Plus Ivanovic free and loans for Gallagher and Krov.

Conclusions:

Investment in the transfer market has not slowed down under Lai at all. Barring the two Championship seasons where we turned over an entire squad to cut costs investment has remained at the same rough level it always has. The line from the club has always been we will spend within our means and these figure demonstrate we are doing just that. This season’s slight dip in net spend could easily attributed to projected loss of revenue as a result of COVID. The money has been spent, the more pertinent question is whether it was spent well.

A further interesting quirk is that spend really jumped from 14/15 onwards, which was around the time JP first expressed keenness to sell the club.

And how much additional equity has been injected by the shareholders to purchase anything?

Cashflows are different to profits.  Hudds show a profit on Grant, but they will wait 6 years for the cash.

Too many people scream "where's the money gone, Tom" who couldn't understand cashflow vs Profit vs Net Worth if it was spoon fed to them.

This is what I was getting at Minstrel, we haven’t had any external investment, nobody is putting money into the club. Our spend is about right for a club of our size living within its means.

What we don’t have is data on wages, which for most PL clubs are usually at least 60% of turnover these days.

Someone’s posted the wages as a percentage of turnover on here before and ours is very high (around 80% IIRC).
Reply
#40
Would be surprised if it’s that high right now FF, but could easily imagine it being 80%+ last time we went down.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)