Who would you replace Bilic with?
#11
(11-03-2020, 12:09 PM)Lightnin Wrote:
(11-03-2020, 12:04 PM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(11-03-2020, 12:01 PM)Lightnin Wrote: I know the vote is close but should Bilic go, who do you replace him with would be my question?

Poch - not a chance, we aren't Real Madrid!
Pearson - Couldn't even recognise that Vardy was a striker
Alex Neil - High on our list before
Jokanovic - High on list before but managing in Qatar
Eddie Howe?
McInnes?
Appleton?
Ralf Rangnick?
Ossie Ardiles and a full barcode return?

Add Paul Cook to the list.

I assume everyone's Marco Silva fascination has gone, but there are probably a few other ex-Watford managers we could line up.  Flores?

I was going to mention Marco Silva funnily enough but like you say, his stock dropped considerably after leaving Everton in 18th. Cook is a good shout despite being ex-dingle and worked extremely well at Wigan, Portsmouth and Chesterfield. It's just a big jump from those 3 clubs and the players to the Premier League.
Unfortunately Lightnin, what you say about Cook is right. He seems a good manager / coach , could do a good job. Would our `Premier League Stars`, most of whom aren`t as good as they probably think they are, accept a `lower league coach`telling them a few home truths?
Like I said on another post, if Slav is sacked, walks or `mutual consent`, there will be loads of managers who want the job, - Alex McLeish, Mark Hughes, Chris Coleman, Marco Silva, all out of work. Would Alex Neill be interested, is he any better than Cook ? Will McInnes say he wants the job?
Reply
#12
Pearson IMO, but if there was any chance of Howe then we should be all over it
Reply
#13
I'm still of the opinion that Bilic should be given a little more time, but Cook isn't a bad choice if we do decide to replace Slaven. I was impressed with how he managed Wigan last season, and the dignity he showed in difficult circumstances. That would put him in good stead if he ends up with us!

Ultimately, we have to accept that it's a really tough gig for whoever is at the helm this season. Generally money talks, and we're barely audible this season. If Slav is replaced we need to give his successor time to build their own squad, and to develop a team that represents their ethos & footballing approach. It probably ain't going to be a smooth journey getting there.
Reply
#14
Let’s get Shakey from the Vile!
Reply
#15
(11-03-2020, 12:36 PM)ElbowGrease1973 Wrote: I'm still of the opinion that Bilic should be given a little more time, but Cook isn't a bad choice if we do decide to replace Slaven. I was impressed with how he managed Wigan last season, and the dignity he showed in difficult circumstances. That would put him in good stead if he ends up with us!

Ultimately, we have to accept that it's a really tough gig for whoever is at the helm this season. Generally money talks, and we're barely audible this season. If Slav is replaced we need to give his successor time to build their own squad, and to develop a team that represents their ethos & footballing approach. It probably ain't going to be a smooth journey getting there.

In fairness to Cook he also improves players. You only have to look at the number of players that are now playing at a higher level than Wigan, and how many young players he gave game time to.

Our next manager has to ultimately tick 3 longer term boxes;

- give youth a chance
- show demonstrable experience of improving players
- play attacking football

The latter is purely because we have to be a self funding club meaning development of players and selling at profit is utterly crucial for our ongoing finances and teams that play attacking football sell players for higher prices. It’s a crucial part of Brentford’s philosophy for example.
Reply
#16
1. We need someone to get the best out of what we have got.
2. He cannot be worried about being PC with players or senior mgt.
3. Will need to install discipline and organisation throughout the club.
4. Will not accept slacking, drastically improve fitness and have no favourites.
5. Quickly stabilise the current rocking boat.
For me it can only be Pearson with Shakey as his assistant.
IMO Howe I feel would be just use us a stepping stone.
Cook would be worth considering if we were in the chump, but at PL level he could be lacking.
We have made mistake after mistake when timing the change of managers, often keeping managers long after
the sell by date has passed. If you look at Europe managers are in the results business and if you don't get results
your out. You just don't get another 10 games to see if results improve.
Reply
#17
We are fucked either way.
Reply
#18
Id like to keep faith with bilic.but the defending we do is shocking.so much space.him being a defender too
Reply
#19
(11-03-2020, 01:15 PM)LIMABAGGIE Wrote: We are fucked either way.

That's the spirit!  Big Grin
Reply
#20
Christ! I'm sure we have more or less the same list as before we employed Pardew here!
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)