The way forward???
Corbyn, mcdonnell, Abbott, thornberry........ That's is all you need to know why people didn't put their x next to Labour.
Reply
(11-02-2020, 01:29 PM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: How then, do you rationalise the savage cuts to life-saving services in mental health, homelessness provision, policing et al? The 600k more children living in poverty in 2019 than 2012? The tripling in the usage of food banks in the same period? The number of rough sleepers doubling between 2010 and 2016 (due in no small part to the aforementioned cuts to necessary service, alongside cuts to social housing) etcetra etcetera etcetera

All of this was, apparently, in order to reduce the UKs budget deficit. How did that go? *spoiler alert - it went really really badly* Not that a homeless drug addict gives a shit about the deficit when their halfway house and therapist isn't there any more, or someone who's seen their real-term wages cut repeatedly and can't afford rent, or someone who never did find out whether the police caught the person who mugged them because there's 20,000 less of them to go around.

My point is that all of the above was an entirely unnecessary exercise in idealogical warfare perpetrated upon the British people that achieved the square root of fuck all. There is no policy in any Labour manifesto since 2010 that would have had further-reaching and/or longer-lasting negative effects on the British people that the Tory polices of the last decade. As such, anyone who still voted for them (or indeed campaigned for them) in 2017 and 2019 - knowing all of the above - deserves all of the scorn and contempt they get.  If they didn't go into the polling booth knowing the suffering that they wrought then they're a fucking moron.

If there is any rational argument that one can provide whereby a small raise in corporation tax (whilst still keeping it the lowest in Europe) and a small raise in tax for the top 5% of earners would have led to worse outcomes for the British people I'm all ears. I don't exactly see how it would lead to a repeat of Stalin's 1932 famine somehow...

The rational argument against your angst-ridden polemic is that the tax burden is the greatest it's been since the mid 70s. History teaches us that any increases will be avoided by equally rational taxpayers and corporations.

The case for raising Corporation Tax in a recession is off the scale bonkers tbh.
Reply
(11-02-2020, 05:28 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(11-02-2020, 01:29 PM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: How then, do you rationalise the savage cuts to life-saving services in mental health, homelessness provision, policing et al? The 600k more children living in poverty in 2019 than 2012? The tripling in the usage of food banks in the same period? The number of rough sleepers doubling between 2010 and 2016 (due in no small part to the aforementioned cuts to necessary service, alongside cuts to social housing) etcetra etcetera etcetera

All of this was, apparently, in order to reduce the UKs budget deficit. How did that go? *spoiler alert - it went really really badly* Not that a homeless drug addict gives a shit about the deficit when their halfway house and therapist isn't there any more, or someone who's seen their real-term wages cut repeatedly and can't afford rent, or someone who never did find out whether the police caught the person who mugged them because there's 20,000 less of them to go around.

My point is that all of the above was an entirely unnecessary exercise in idealogical warfare perpetrated upon the British people that achieved the square root of fuck all. There is no policy in any Labour manifesto since 2010 that would have had further-reaching and/or longer-lasting negative effects on the British people that the Tory polices of the last decade. As such, anyone who still voted for them (or indeed campaigned for them) in 2017 and 2019 - knowing all of the above - deserves all of the scorn and contempt they get.  If they didn't go into the polling booth knowing the suffering that they wrought then they're a fucking moron.

If there is any rational argument that one can provide whereby a small raise in corporation tax (whilst still keeping it the lowest in Europe) and a small raise in tax for the top 5% of earners would have led to worse outcomes for the British people I'm all ears. I don't exactly see how it would lead to a repeat of Stalin's 1932 famine somehow...

The rational argument against your angst-ridden polemic is that the tax burden is the greatest it's been since the mid 70s. History teaches us that any increases will be avoided by equally rational taxpayers and corporations.

The case for raising Corporation Tax in a recession is off the scale bonkers tbh.

To paraphrase Mandy Rice-Davies “Well you would say that wouldn’t you?”
Reply
2017 was 9 years after a recession but who's counting. I didn't realise that any tax increase would be 100% avoided by everyone..something that no other country that has higher tax bands has ever reported. The UK really are a canny lot eh.

To say that tax avoidance is 'rational' is rather telling...as is the fact that you refer to my post as an "angst-ridden polemic" rather than "exactly what has actually been happening to real people"

There is also of course, the fact that the government could invest in public services if they stopped shovelling so much of our cash into their mates pockets and the pockets of those who need it least. Corporate socialism is all perfectly alright though eh
Reply
(11-02-2020, 06:16 PM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: the government could invest in public services

It does, a lot. Far more than it should IMO.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)