Posts: 499
Threads: 40
Joined: Jan 2019
BillyBassett,
you may not want to appear a conspiracy loon, but you sure sound like 1.
Posts: 17,074
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(10-29-2020, 06:15 PM)billybassett Wrote: (10-29-2020, 09:30 AM)baggy1 Wrote: (10-28-2020, 10:42 PM)billybassett Wrote: Look I've had my say. It's a respiratory virus that will be with us for years. It will become endemic once we reach a community immunity saturation level like we do with all other respiratory illnesses.
If people think that protecting the NHS at all costs is a price worth paying then that's up to them but I'm not going to accept my son's future being trashed because of the inability of people to do simple risk cost benefit analysis. If you can't work out that lockdowns and masks don't work after using them as tools for 8 months to "control" the virus then you're having your trousers pulled down.
The prison my son lives in called a £18k a year university, his mental health, his life chances and job chances next year trashed. Racking up debt.
Im not doing it anymore, no.mask, holiday , meeting the people I love and are friends with. Stuff your rules.
I'm.sure you're all get your way and we'll be screwed in lockdown for another 2 months..and then in the spring when it all comes back again I'm sure you'll all be begging for another lockdown 12 mths on convincing yourselves it still works still with your heads in the clouds with not s clue of what damage you've really requested to be applied to yourselves and more importantly our younger generation (under 40s).
I'm glad me and others I know have tried but it seems that the masses are happy to swallow this bullshit and be controlled , fed misleading information ( nobody on here has still answered the question why Hancock won't publish the false positive rate), and softened up for whatever else the govt wants to shovel through whilst all this is going on.
Goodbye you've got what you wanted and I know my conscience is clear.
Billy, you have taken a militant line over the past few weeks in so much that you are right and everybody else is wrong and now you're throwing your toys out. Take a step back and consider the bigger picture. Taking your comments line by line:
It will be with us for years I would imagine and you are right we can't keep locking down and ruining the economy in the meantime. It's good that you recognise that it isn't endemic yet but to add to my point above, yesterday you were adamant that is was - that's not a criticism of you, it's just reiterating the point above about taking a step back and recognising we will be wrong on some points because we don't know enough about this virus.
Nobody is saying protect the NHS at any cost, but we do need to make sure that we have enough NHS resource and staffing to deal with this virus over the winter period. We have to prepare for the worst case scenario this winter because taking a gamble on it not being an issue leaves with a huge problem if we lose that gamble. I personally don't think it will be as bad in numbers of deaths but numbers in hospitals will keep increasing if we do nothing - that has been shown by the growth over the past couple of months.
Your son will be fine, trust me. My lad came out of Uni in the last financial crash, the market he was going into wasn't recruiting so he took a lower starting salary in an unrelated field and he has progressed, people do come out of bad situations and survive. It sounds like he has a decent support mechanism around him to provide him with the security he needs.
The 'i'm not doing it...' line is throwing the toys out bit - by all means mix with people that are like minded and do what you want, it is your choice, but when around those that maybe don't agree with you then wear a mask, keep you distance etc. It's one thing to gamble with your lives, don't bring others into that.
Lockdown isn't about those on here getting our way, it is about a consensus of people that have far more information than we do trying to stop the rise in infections. The reason for that is not to get rid of it, because that would take a lockdown of massive damaging proportions, but to reduce the numbers so that the NHS doesn't get overrun. This virus is more deadly than the flu - In 29 weeks from the start of April we have had 60k more deaths than normal, that's 20% increase on a normal year. Think about that one fifth of all deaths have been accounted down to covid, and that hasn't replaced other deaths, it has added to them. And, although we don't know the future, we are heading into normal flu season without a plan or an answer. Going back to my earlier point we have learned a lot in that time (don't send old folk with the virus into large groups of old folks being one) but we could easily be looking at 100k excess deaths by the time we have done a full year of this. And just for context a normal year of all deaths is around 500k. It is not flu.
You seem obsessed with this PCR test rate - ignore it, the government will cover up as much as they can because of how badly they have managed this and how blind they are. Look at the empirical data, numbers in hospital, numbers of excess deaths. Cases and tests is simply bullshit, ignore it.
And pack in with the dramatic flounce, you're better than that. Now take some time away from the keyboard and chill, I do enjoy debating with you and the main point is neither of us know the answers, we just have opinions.
I've not flounced off at all and stop with the condescension. I've just come to the conclusion - as I seem to be the only one here who is providing a different narrative - that it's a forlorn hope to think I could persuade people to look more widely and not just posting the latest Herd Immunity bullshit headline from Boris' DG BBC friend like Dekka.
I mean when the deaths were rising everyone was all over the issue the BBC every night with a new epic graph regurgitated by others on here ... and then deaths stopped and haven't been rising so what gets reported to create a shitstorm... cases yay... 100s of thousands tested for no reason and look at all the cases going through the roof. It's like a first year GCSE student asked to draw a graph to make a point - any point.
But I'll answer your points.
1. My view is not militant - it's not a militant view. That paints me as some form of crackpot or conspiracist. It isn't. My view coincides with many others including Ionannidis at WHO and may other eminent immunologists, biologists, medics etc from round the world. I'm not putting myself into their expertise bracket but like many on here I'm a relatively intelligent chap who can think for themselves. It's an easy picture for people to paint though isn't it. Don't read what he says without telling them first I'm some form of lunatic. Well done.
2. You know the point I was making about an endemic virus so don't go there. It will be endemic, almost certainly is close to being that now. The point you dodge is that every year we have "pandemics" of flu - that become endemic in their strain over time - 100s of thousands die around the world. Yet this time the world thinks we should kill the rest of society at the cost of "removing" the virus. If it wasn't so ridiculous I'd cry.
3. You talk about the "consensus of people" . You mean SAGE. Last I heard SAGE weren't taking a consensus. They were modelling based on a set of false assumptions the main one being 100% of people were susceptible from the beginning. That has been clearly ridiculed by many worldwide scientists - and I'm not going to go round the tcell bcell, covid genome work again.
4. I'm confident I'm not gambling with anyone's life. I wasn't gambling last year or the year before that when some of my family had flu. My wife had swine flu in 2009 - more virulent they say than covid - I went to work, kept clean sensible and got on with my life. Just like I'd expect anyone else to do. The whole argument about infecting others and putting them at risk is so limp given what we know about IFR and what we know about other life risks it's completely non-sensical.
5. I'll say it a final time. 8 months in, some places locked down for months, wearing masks - see Leicester basically since June - others many weeks and days after the first national lockdown suffering. Has the virus disappeared? No. Will it, no matter how many lockdowns we have? No. I thought the definition of madness was doing something that fails over and over again. If we do lockdown will the virus return? Of course. Sweden now has virtually no deaths a day for covid. No doubt I'll be net-shamed for mentioning Sweden god forbid but you'd have to be really one-eyed not to wonder what's happening there. I suggest you look.
6. There have been no excess deaths since June. You don't want to hear it but that's what happens. There is currently no correlation between excess deaths and covid deaths. Unlike Mar/Apr when there was. Happy to provide the data.
7. Deaths and admissions of people with influenza or other respiratory illnesses have disappeared. Yes we've cured the wrong virus -well done. Oh but that's because we're all wearing masks and cleaning our hands. Jesus christ - astonishing.
8. Protecting the NHS at all costs. If that's your view then that's your view but if that is what is happening then I'm a monkey's uncle. Admissions are similar to last year, ICUs always run at 90% - regional differences occur and the beds are balanced around areas. I don't want to live in a world where the only thing left is the NHS thanks.
9. If you're not obsessed with the PCR test then there's really something wrong with your analysis you provide. You detail the cases every week like they are written on Moses' tablets. Do your reading baggy1. The PCR test is flawed. The labs are under enormous strain. In Scotland you're twice as likely to get a positive test on a Friday than a Sunday. Guess what - the labs are cleaned Saturday night. They are not retesting, they are not using multiple primers and we have the first PCR test in history where the false positive rate is by all accounts unknowable. I mean you say look at the numbers in hospital as if they are all covid cases. I think the blinkers need to come off. Estimates are between 24-35% are nosocomial/other. Stop testing healthy people and lets see what happens. Ask your MP for the false positive rate that every other PCR test in history has provided.
10. Don't tell me that my son will be fine please. You can't possibly know. You literally have no clue as to the future damage all this is going to do to people and the country. Healthy people. People who would never ever die from covid if they caught it. Nobody knows. I'm sure in the years to come you'll have magically forgotten the impact of your views and requests. Your flippantry on this point tells me everything about the perspective you are bringing to this issue.
I won't chill. But thanks. The biggest issue of our time and this social media casedemic has caused a majority of the human race to lose all perspective on our life, how we live it, how we protect people, how we grow and develop, how we think objectively and calmly and how we turn all that into the right actions for the whole of humanity. I'm entering the final stage of my life and I'll be relatively protected but my younger family and friends won't be. I don't chill because I honestly weep for their future what with this shambolic mess and the damage we are doing to the planet.
Would it be easier if we all said we agreed with you?
Posts: 8,954
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
I can’t be arsed to try and provide much further points to what I’ve said billy but one thing really confuses me with what you say - where have I once referred to cases? I refer to hospital beds and excess deaths and that is it.
There have been over 1,000 excess deaths since June including one mad week where there were nearly 1,500 under the average btw.
And I try to give comfort over your son because I have seen two kids out of school / uni and into jobs in difficult circumstances so I was speaking from experience and trying to provide some hope for you.
England and Wales total mortality from ONS online: https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationa...ndandwales
7 weeks from Start Sep to w/c 18 Oct.
Total mortality 2020 7739, 9811, 9523, 9634, 9945, 9954, 10534: 67140
Total mortality 2019 9795, 9513, 9440, 9517, 9799, 9973, 10156: 68093
Show me the excess deaths
No excess deaths total mortality the same.
(10-29-2020, 08:44 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (10-29-2020, 06:15 PM)billybassett Wrote: [quote="baggy1" pid="235339" dateline="1603963822"]
[quote="billybassett" pid="235290" dateline="1603924943"]
Would it be easier if we all said we agreed with you?
Typical vacuous snidey remark Dekka. Well done bet you got off on that. Although this is a more sensible post than the usual.
Posts: 8,954
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
10-30-2020, 11:15 AM
(This post was last modified: 10-30-2020, 11:22 AM by baggy1.)
(10-30-2020, 10:55 AM)billybassett Wrote: England and Wales total mortality from ONS online: https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationa...ndandwales
7 weeks from Start Sep to w/c 18 Oct.
Total mortality 2020 7739, 9811, 9523, 9634, 9945, 9954, 10534: 67140
Total mortality 2019 9795, 9513, 9440, 9517, 9799, 9973, 10156: 68093
Show me the excess deaths
No excess deaths total mortality the same.
You can't pick and chose your data to fit your point - Use the 5YA and come back to me or I'll pick the lowest death numbers in a year to refute your argument.
If you want to compare 2019 as a whole we are at 61,837 excess deaths this year whilst that figure is only 55,122 against the 5YA. Against 2019 we have a 10% higher excess death rate - I chose the 5YA because that is the better measure.
And for good measure you've got your figures wrong - week 36 is 9,695 plus in your original statement you talked about since June, I gave you the figures since June and you seem to have randomly chosen those since September.
How many other holes do you want me to pick in your 'facts'?
(10-30-2020, 11:15 AM)baggy1 Wrote: (10-30-2020, 10:55 AM)billybassett Wrote: England and Wales total mortality from ONS online: https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationa...ndandwales
7 weeks from Start Sep to w/c 18 Oct.
Total mortality 2020 7739, 9811, 9523, 9634, 9945, 9954, 10534: 67140
Total mortality 2019 9795, 9513, 9440, 9517, 9799, 9973, 10156: 68093
Show me the excess deaths
No excess deaths total mortality the same.
You can't pick and chose your data to fit your point - Use the 5YA and come back to me or I'll pick the lowest death numbers in a year to refute your argument.
If you want to compare 2019 as a whole we are at 61,837 excess deaths this year whilst that figure is only 55,122 against the 5YA. Against 2019 we have a 10% higher excess death rate - I chose the 5YA because that is the better measure.
And for good measure you've got your figures wrong - week 36 is 9,695 plus in your original statement you talked about since June, I gave you the figures since June and you seem to have randomly chosen those since September.
How many other holes do you want me to pick in your 'facts'?
Well if I go back to June, weeks 23-42: it's exactly the same 188K deaths in both 2019 and 2020. 2018: 182K 2017: 192K, 2016:185K, 2015: 183K. And if you want to get really picky it should be weighted by population so England's population in 2020 is circa 2.7% bigger than it was in 2015 (ONS). Thus 183K in 2015 = 188K adjusted - the same.
So I wasn't picking the lowest year and absolute deaths is a good but not accurate comparator. Hung up on a 5YA are you? What about 1968? What about 2009? I know you're getting desperate when you finish with "How many other holes do you want me to pick in your 'facts'?".
I'm not trying to refute that there have been excess deaths - there have. Old, infirm people susceptible to a respiratory virus tragically died by being in close contact to other ill people with the virus in hospital and care home type settings. 1000s died and it's tragic because we didn't know a lot about the virus and some poor decisions were made (in hindsight).
In the last 4 months we are seeing none or little change in mortality and yet we are still subject to these draconian privations. You do know you can be classed as a covid death 28 days after being tested? You've not made any comment on how other respiratory illness deaths have dropped off a cliff or made any attempt to engage me on the PCR test which I think is a head in sand approach. I'd take any bet with you to any charity. If the govt stopped mass testing immediately this would be a normal time of year for the health service (notwithstanding all those people now coming in with ischemias and heart conditions and cancers because they weren't treated over the summer - and yes you guessed it had a test some were positive and some died of Covid).
I could wind you up with a parting shot like you and Dekka are fond of. But that's not me and if you can't see the pattern or understand what is happening then I'm not going to be able to help you.
Posts: 1,403
Threads: 12
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
4
(10-30-2020, 11:58 AM)billybassett Wrote: (10-30-2020, 11:15 AM)baggy1 Wrote: (10-30-2020, 10:55 AM)billybassett Wrote: England and Wales total mortality from ONS online: https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationa...ndandwales
7 weeks from Start Sep to w/c 18 Oct.
Total mortality 2020 7739, 9811, 9523, 9634, 9945, 9954, 10534: 67140
Total mortality 2019 9795, 9513, 9440, 9517, 9799, 9973, 10156: 68093
Show me the excess deaths
No excess deaths total mortality the same.
You can't pick and chose your data to fit your point - Use the 5YA and come back to me or I'll pick the lowest death numbers in a year to refute your argument.
If you want to compare 2019 as a whole we are at 61,837 excess deaths this year whilst that figure is only 55,122 against the 5YA. Against 2019 we have a 10% higher excess death rate - I chose the 5YA because that is the better measure.
And for good measure you've got your figures wrong - week 36 is 9,695 plus in your original statement you talked about since June, I gave you the figures since June and you seem to have randomly chosen those since September.
How many other holes do you want me to pick in your 'facts'?
Well if I go back to June, weeks 23-42: it's exactly the same 188K deaths in both 2019 and 2020. 2018: 182K 2017: 192K, 2016:185K, 2015: 183K. And if you want to get really picky it should be weighted by population so England's population in 2020 is circa 2.7% bigger than it was in 2015 (ONS). Thus 183K in 2015 = 188K adjusted - the same.
So I wasn't picking the lowest year and absolute deaths is a good but not accurate comparator. Hung up on a 5YA are you? What about 1968? What about 2009? I know you're getting desperate when you finish with "How many other holes do you want me to pick in your 'facts'?".
I'm not trying to refute that there have been excess deaths - there have. Old, infirm people susceptible to a respiratory virus tragically died by being in close contact to other ill people with the virus in hospital and care home type settings. 1000s died and it's tragic because we didn't know a lot about the virus and some poor decisions were made (in hindsight).
In the last 4 months we are seeing none or little change in mortality and yet we are still subject to these draconian privations. You do know you can be classed as a covid death 28 days after being tested? You've not made any comment on how other respiratory illness deaths have dropped off a cliff or made any attempt to engage me on the PCR test which I think is a head in sand approach. I'd take any bet with you to any charity. If the govt stopped mass testing immediately this would be a normal time of year for the health service (notwithstanding all those people now coming in with ischemias and heart conditions and cancers because they weren't treated over the summer - and yes you guessed it had a test some were positive and some died of Covid).
I could wind you up with a parting shot like you and Dekka are fond of. But that's not me and if you can't see the pattern or understand what is happening then I'm not going to be able to help you.
Right, so deaths have been similar despite the fact that many people are not going to work, we are wearing masks and avoiding people, a lot of the country is locked down and not meeting relations, going to gigs or doing many normal things.
So a genuine comparison of circumstance then or do you not think that the entirely different behaviours between years may have something to do with it and also for other respiratory illnesses.
Deaths are also a trailing statistic, hospital admissions and ICU have increased, deaths will follow, hopefully not as many as treatments have improved.
Posts: 8,954
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
Again stop with the population figures they are an estimate based on the 2011 census increased each year, they are not exact so using them to make exact statements is just daft. It's simple, we've had a period of time where excess deaths have been negligible (as strawman says in very different conditions), hospitalisations are increasing week on week in a uniform manner, excess deaths have started to creep up again (even with a two week lag on figures), and we are heading into winter.
Covid exists whether you like it or not, whether it impacts on your life or not, it exists. It also has a higher mortality rate than any other virus that we have encountered in a century, and it is on the rise again - I'm not measuring cases, I'm measuring people in hospital (something that even you can't dispute with any actual figures)
You mention 2009 and 1968 - what were the actual deaths in those years (I'd ignore 1968 if I were you because the population, healthcare, demographics aren't comparable but seeing as you mentioned them it's up to you)
I'm not denying it's had some impact. But if the lockdown Mar-Jun was actually a method of combatting transmission why are we seeing it now. Point is it's respiratory and transmission will not go away because people hide. It will go away when the virus has no more hosts to infect and it will die of and become endemic. So hiding again will just kick the can down the road.
In terms of an impact by a respiratory illness it's actually more likely to impact more severely people locked up in warm houses over autumn and winter - has an especially difficult impact on the old because they become less mobile and sit more. This is common of all respiratory illnesses. The last thing we should be doing is staying in confined warm spaces with diminished airflow. Go outside enjoy yourself, catch covid, keep moving, eat well take precautions like every winter.
I'm not trying to say the virus isn't something we shouldn't be careful of or protect the vulnerable etc.
Hospital admissions increase this time of year full stop and ICUs are built to run at 90% capacity because there's few facilities and ill people get to use them. I'm also not saying that there may not be more this winter. But if you're drawing correlation directly between covid and admissions and ICU beds then I'm not comfortable with that. With the way the PCR tests are the 28d lag, other illnesses now being caught late because nobody went in summer etc...
To conflate all of those issues into lets lock everybody down to protect the nhs is in my opinion a poor decision and will undoubtedly leave us over Christmas and Spring in similar situations because if you make decision now on the basis of these types of correlations now all you are doing is delaying the inevitable further lockdowns later because unfortunately people have completely lost perspective on what this is.
(10-30-2020, 12:34 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Again stop with the population figures they are an estimate based on the 2011 census increased each year, they are not exact so using them to make exact statements is just daft. It's simple, we've had a period of time where excess deaths have been negligible (as strawman says in very different conditions), hospitalisations are increasing week on week in a uniform manner, excess deaths have started to creep up again (even with a two week lag on figures), and we are heading into winter.
Covid exists whether you like it or not, whether it impacts on your life or not, it exists. It also has a higher mortality rate than any other virus that we have encountered in a century, and it is on the rise again - I'm not measuring cases, I'm measuring people in hospital (something that even you can't dispute with any actual figures)
You mention 2009 and 1968 - what were the actual deaths in those years (I'd ignore 1968 if I were you because the population, healthcare, demographics aren't comparable but seeing as you mentioned them it's up to you)
I see no reason to use population figures as estimate. They are no doubt an under estimate for many reasons. In the same period you say is different influenza and other non-covid respiratory deaths have disappeared. Also it's a clear indicator that wearing masks and over sanitising has no affect. It's also clear that lockdowns now have zero affect. You only have to look at boroughs who've effectively been locked down for weeks on end to see "covid cases" not diminishing.
The 1968 flu pandemic saw an estimated 1m deaths around the world : https://www.cdc.gov/flu/pandemic-resourc...demic.html. I haven't got a second source yet for the uk. A much higher impact in population terms and the H3N2 seasonal virus has many covid similarities.
Posts: 17,074
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(10-30-2020, 10:55 AM)billybassett Wrote: England and Wales total mortality from ONS online: https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationa...ndandwales
7 weeks from Start Sep to w/c 18 Oct.
Total mortality 2020 7739, 9811, 9523, 9634, 9945, 9954, 10534: 67140
Total mortality 2019 9795, 9513, 9440, 9517, 9799, 9973, 10156: 68093
Show me the excess deaths
No excess deaths total mortality the same.
(10-29-2020, 08:44 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (10-29-2020, 06:15 PM)billybassett Wrote: (10-29-2020, 09:30 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Would it be easier if we all said we agreed with you?
Typical vacuous snidey remark Dekka. Well done bet you got off on that. Although this is a more sensible post than the usual.
Let’s rewind this discussion to where it began with you wanting to ‘go back to normal’. A more vacuous proposition given the circumstances you won’t find. I discussed your opinion with you politely but you have become more like a missionary expounding your ‘truth’ to everyone and setting yourself up as more enlightened. Now your suggesting that others are having a dig at you when you’ve questioned people’s intelligence, ability to make informed decisions, complicity with the governments handling of the situation etc. You have your opinions but don’t state them as the truth that others who are less enlightened cannot see.
|