Man Marks
#21
(10-19-2020, 08:07 PM)MancBaggie Wrote: Good summary Cuzer. Not far off with those marks/summaries

Lot of reports that Grosicki was a real troublemaker/ bad influence. Must be a reason his game time has been so limited since in his spell

I’ve also read somewhere on the twatter he’s a pisshead, utter bollocks and I’ve heard nothing either along the lines of him being a troublemaker, he loves being here and just wants to play more 

Seems Furlong is the new scapegoat for some, whether they thought he was good, bad or indifferent tonight harsh to be over critical in aback four which kept its first clean sheet but seem to be having a pop at him?

As for Gallagher as I said Ima huge fan, loved him last season too but tonight was all a bit safe and sideways for me, he’s capable of so much better and I’m sure we’ll see that very soon

Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Reply
#22
Furlong is getting a huge amount of stick, bearing in mind that we kept a clean sheet. He gets forward well and that's obviously the plan.

Livermore stuck to his task, although another unnecessary booking underlined his achilles heel in that deep role. There were times when no-one showed for the ball in midfield, which is probably why Cuzer marked Gallagher down. He seemed to fade badly after a bright start. I was beginning to think we were missing Sawyers. Then he came on and showed why he shouldn't be a first choice. I fear that we haven't entirely addressed the shortage in midfield. Bilic maybe needs to get Field involved and let Livermore play higher up the pitch.

Most of all we were let down by poor quality and poor decision-making in the attacking half. All of our best attacking talent was on the pitch and we hardly created a chance against Burnley. That's about temperament. Clean sheet is a big positive, but we need a win.
Reply
#23
Matthius and diaganna were bang average today in games like these you need them to make the difference that's 2cgames on the trot they have gone missing.
Reply
#24
(10-20-2020, 08:42 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Furlong is getting a huge amount of stick, bearing in mind that we kept a clean sheet. He gets forward well and that's obviously the plan.

Livermore stuck to his task, although another unnecessary booking underlined his achilles heel in that deep role. There were times when no-one showed for the ball in midfield, which is probably why Cuzer marked Gallagher down. He seemed to fade badly after a bright start. I was beginning to think we were missing Sawyers. Then he came on and showed why he shouldn't be a first choice. I fear that we haven't entirely addressed the shortage in midfield. Bilic maybe needs to get Field involved and let Livermore play higher up the pitch.

Most of all we were let down by poor quality and poor decision-making in the attacking half. All of our best attacking talent was on the pitch and we hardly created a chance against Burnley. That's about temperament. Clean sheet is a big positive, but we need a win.

Correct, and that's a big worry.

We have goals in this team but it feels very one dimensional. We score our goals on the break, or by forcing a turnover high up the field. When teams sit deep we lack a plan B.

Field, Livermore and Gallagher in the middle next week, with Krov a viable option as part of the front 3.
Reply
#25
(10-20-2020, 08:42 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Furlong is getting a huge amount of stick, bearing in mind that we kept a clean sheet. He gets forward well and that's obviously the plan.

Livermore stuck to his task, although another unnecessary booking underlined his achilles heel in that deep role. There were times when no-one showed for the ball in midfield, which is probably why Cuzer marked Gallagher down. He seemed to fade badly after a bright start. I was beginning to think we were missing Sawyers. Then he came on and showed why he shouldn't be a first choice. I fear that we haven't entirely addressed the shortage in midfield. Bilic maybe needs to get Field involved and let Livermore play higher up the pitch.

Most of all we were let down by poor quality and poor decision-making in the attacking half. All of our best attacking talent was on the pitch and we hardly created a chance against Burnley. That's about temperament. Clean sheet is a big positive, but we need a win.

I think we saw how well Livermore and Gallagher did when Sawyers and Phillips came on.
Reply
#26
(10-19-2020, 08:29 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Felt this was a workmanlike team performance , but it wasn't anything other than decent, good would be a stretch.

Think my marks would be in the 6-7 range with the exception of Ivanovic and Johnstone whom i would give 7.5.

Totally agree
Reply
#27
(10-20-2020, 08:46 AM)The liquidator Wrote: Matthius and diaganna were bang average today in games like these you need them to make the difference that's 2cgames on the trot they have gone missing.
True - They're not going to play well every game, but they are crucial for us from a creative perspective.

I remember saying last season to a West Ham supporting mate that Diagana showed flashes of brilliance, but was nowhere near the finished article. That's obviously still true this season, and he's up against better players. There were a few times yesterday where he wasn't able to get the simple 5 - 10 yard pass right. This is a side of his game that he needs to work on if he's going to realise his potential.

Pereira's free kick delivery was really poor yesterday, but I thought he always made himself available in open play, and it feels like he can make something happen out of nothing. 

If we're going to stay up, they both need to perform near the best of their ability more often than not.
Reply
#28
(10-19-2020, 08:03 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Ok so better give mine.

Johnstone: 7
Furlong: 7
Hegazi: 8
Ivanovic: 9*
Townsend: 6
Livermore: 6
Gallagher: 7
Krov: 7
Pereira: 5
Diangana: 4
Grant: 6 (could be 7 considering how little he's even trained recently!)

Robinson: 6
Sawyers: 2
Phillips: 6

Ivan 9? Bloody hell! Johnstone 11 in that case.
Reply
#29
(10-19-2020, 07:58 PM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote: Think you're being generous to Furlong who defensively was poor for me. Otherwise I'd agree with most of that.

Slav will have had to work with the players available to him especially on defensive shape so that's why O'shea and Ajayi probably didn't feature.
Reply
#30
Having a bit more time to reflect on the game last night, i feel i and others on here are being a bit harsh on Perreria and Diangana. They were involved in moves that led to chances to score and on another night we could have bagged a couple of goals (mind you we could have conceded a couple too, but that's another issue). If we had won the game 2-0 i doubt anyone would have complained about their contribution.

At this level they are not going to be consistently dangerous as they were at the Championship.

That's not to say they played at their best and there isn't improvement to be had - think Perreria needs to work on the quality of his crosses at this level. But i do think we may be guilty of having unrealistic expectations of them,
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: