02-17-2019, 12:29 PM
I think those of us who wanted Smith did so because we expected a higher number of departures in the summer than transpired. Smith was my first choice because I felt we needed to combine changing our way of playing with cutting the wage bill and adding some youth and potential to the squad.
My reservations with him joining Villa were that he’s never had to “deliver” and managing the egos and expectations would be very difficult. For me Smith would have been a better bet for us had we needed a rebuild, but I doubt with the squad we currently have he’d be doing as well as Moore.
He’s not a manager who will play to the strengths of what he has, instead will try and force what he believes to be the right way. Should Villa’s FFP issues actually hit home, he’s probably the best appointment they could make, but I imagine he’ll be long gone by then!
My reservations with him joining Villa were that he’s never had to “deliver” and managing the egos and expectations would be very difficult. For me Smith would have been a better bet for us had we needed a rebuild, but I doubt with the squad we currently have he’d be doing as well as Moore.
He’s not a manager who will play to the strengths of what he has, instead will try and force what he believes to be the right way. Should Villa’s FFP issues actually hit home, he’s probably the best appointment they could make, but I imagine he’ll be long gone by then!

