10-19-2020, 02:51 PM
|
The way forward???
|
|
10-19-2020, 03:02 PM
(10-19-2020, 02:27 PM)baggy1 Wrote: It gets confusing when you conflate a lockdown with a circuit break. Unfortunately rates are rising and hospital admission are rising. Experience shows us that the only way of stopping the rise is by stopping transmission and there is only one way to do that. Yes I did baggy1. Like I said happy to be righted. Perhaps await what happens with this flu season as we've seen reports already that the 4 corona virus strains in operation seasonally seem to be disappeared. See the GISR (https://www.who.int/influenza/surveillan...8.pdf?ua=1) reporting much lower flu levels. But as you say a way to go this season although Southern Hemisphere flu disappeared almost completely. Also interesting is this data baggy1 - I've quickly scanned: https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationa...homes-data 106K deaths not involving Covid in private homes. 83K is the 5yr average. Almost half of that "excess" was during period 27/03 to 29/05 - the first lockdown. Also dwarfs the Covid at home deaths to put lethality into perspective. (10-19-2020, 02:51 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: LBC circuit breaker We know how good polls are don't we they've been done to death on here. But in that poll 60% of 3390 people basically said no, don't know or maybe. Hardly a ringing endorsement. I can imagine what the 27% somewhat support people may have said...
Quote function playing up again I see - Looking at that ONS report the main way I read it is that more people died in their home that would have normally died in hospital. there appear to be about 22k non-covid excess deaths in private homes and the comment that i read as it evens out was: Deaths in private homes and care homes for the leading causes of death in England and Wales were above the five-year average while deaths in hospitals and hospices were below the five-year average, suggesting a re-distribution of deaths between locations.
On a separate, positive, note - a byproduct of this year is increased washing of hands and wearing of masks which I would guess has led to that much lower flu levels in the southern hemisphere.
10-19-2020, 03:10 PM
Lockdown, Circuit Breaker and now Wales are having a Firebreak. Somebody probably get paid a shed load of money to come up with catchy names and slogans.
I have a more straightforward slogan that may have helped if adopted when lockdown came in March - Comply or Die! That may have sent a stronger message
10-19-2020, 03:16 PM
Potentially a redistribution if you assume those people who died at home would all die in hospital care. Impossible to know but has to be a factor and the general lack of admissions during the summer should be concerning for us all.
Also baggy1 on hospital beds. 5608 in hospital "with" covid out of circa 110,000 beds. 592 on ventilators. We have been made aware that the govt spent was it nearly 600m on 30000 ventilators. Whilst there is a rise it is flattening and absolutely nowhere near March April if you look at a logged graph that tells you the rates of increase. I'm just not buying the story. Hospitals are always busy this time of year. The concern is that a proportion of the people who should have had treatment (non-covid) March-now become ill over the winter. As for masks the jury is out baggy1 but I dare not go down that hole, or reply to baggiebuckster's statement, as I'm likely to be denounced as satan.
10-19-2020, 03:24 PM
I agree entirely on the people that should have had non-covid treatment will bite us on the arse over the winter, it is symptomatic of how shit this bunch have managed the track and trace and original lockdown that leaves us in another even shittier position.
I'm watching the figures and if we are at less than 5.5k by the end of the week it will show slowing down (I'm just measuring England btw) as the past 5 weeks have shown a worrying growth of 1.5x each week - that would take us up to 6k by Thursday / Friday. The problem comes with the delay in the cases reaching the older generation, the yuff can handle it but you can see that over a period with more infection then it also goes up the age groups as well. It won't be as bad as March, that bit is clear, and that's mainly because the government won't chuck the virus into care homes this time you would hope which will keep the numbers down, plus there are a lot of people carrying out the right steps. Which is why a quick break is what is needed to bring it below a point where it keeps multiplying up exponentially.
10-19-2020, 03:38 PM
I know we don't see eye to eye on this and no surprise from me but I really hope there's no break at all. Worst thing we can do for the 99.5% of the population. Really enraged by Labour's stance on this pure political manoeuvring as opposed to a considered position.
10-19-2020, 03:46 PM
The problem is we can sit and wait to see what happens because we don't have to make a decision, Labour have looked at the week on week growth and hospital beds take up and made a decision, whether you like it or not it will reduce the spread of the virus. Johnson is paralysed and keeps tinkering with the rules each week and looking for someone to blame.
The number of people in hospital on Friday was the same as it was on 25th / 26th March, if it continues a the 1.5x increase it will be at 6k by the end of the week which compares with the 27th March, another week on and it will be at the 30th March figure. The problem comes with making that call or watching it grow and get to the levels of earlier in the year. It is definitely much slower than it was but 'if' it continues then it will get to the peaks of earlier in the year, that will lead to shortage of hospital beds and stress on the hospital staff. Labour have made a call that saves a bigger call in a month. Johnson is dithering with his fingers crossed.
10-19-2020, 03:52 PM
(This post was last modified: 10-19-2020, 03:58 PM by baggiebuckster.)
(10-19-2020, 03:16 PM)billybassett Wrote: Potentially a redistribution if you assume those people who died at home would all die in hospital care. Impossible to know but has to be a factor and the general lack of admissions during the summer should be concerning for us all. Why can't you reply to my statement? It was only a light hearted take on ridiculous elements of the political landscape over Covid in the last 6 months. If it makes you feel any better I agree with an awful lot of what you have said over the last few days. (10-19-2020, 03:46 PM)baggy1 Wrote: The problem is we can sit and wait to see what happens because we don't have to make a decision, Labour have looked at the week on week growth and hospital beds take up and made a decision, whether you like it or not it will reduce the spread of the virus. Johnson is paralysed and keeps tinkering with the rules each week and looking for someone to blame. Is this wholly correct though? Or is it the number of people who have tested positive for Covid is roughly the same as in March. This is not the same if the number of people in hospital in March were being treated for Covid but now there are people in hospital for something entirely different who were tested in hospital and got a positive result. They are not actually being treated for Covid so this would be misleading would you not agree? When stats were presented last week that 25% of people in hospital with Covid caught it whilst in hospital then this indicates to me that not everybody went to hospital to be treated for Covid.
10-19-2020, 03:58 PM
(10-19-2020, 03:52 PM)baggiebuckster Wrote:(10-19-2020, 03:16 PM)billybassett Wrote: Potentially a redistribution if you assume those people who died at home would all die in hospital care. Impossible to know but has to be a factor and the general lack of admissions during the summer should be concerning for us all. Ah I see the nuance now. Apologies. Another for the cause I'll take that. |
|
« Next Oldest | Next Newest »
|
Users browsing this thread:

