Up to Slaven now
#81
(10-07-2020, 12:57 PM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote: Brighton are the ones to emulate. They have a top class coach in Potter and they're signing exciting young talent from here and abroad under Ashworth. Signing Lamptey from Chelsea was a fantastic bit of business.

When it's that type of club we're supposed to be competing with, it shows we still have a lot of work to do.

We could have gone for Potter when we got relegated, there were a few of us on here saying this. Great coach.

Shame Dowling's spreadsheet doesn't have enough rows for U23 sides.
Reply
#82
(10-07-2020, 01:08 PM)Hopalong Wrote:
(10-06-2020, 11:57 AM)Duffers Wrote: I think we are miles off having the conversation about Slav’s future, but if or when it comes I hope those in charge are thinking “who can do a better job?” before any decision is made. We’ve seen with Pardew and Mel how bad things get when a manager is canned without any actual plan to replace them. I have a horrible feeling if Bilic went we’d just end up with another Pardew-esque has been like Mark Hughes.

Like I say though, we are miles off those sort of discussions.

We are Duffers, but I am concerned about his ability or inability to motivate the players.  The performance at Saints from the first minute was appalling and there was absolutely no intensity or fight.  

Heads went down against Leicester in the first game.   There was a vast improvement against Everton and Chelsea but awful against Saints. 

If he can't motivate the team to put in a shift them we are doomed.  

In  contrast, look at the intensity and way Leeds are performing, it's like they're on drugs!

Bielsa one of the worlds best coaches though. 

Southampton game wasn't due to lack of motivation, it was Slav getting his tactics completely wrong.
Reply
#83
(10-07-2020, 01:52 PM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote:
(10-07-2020, 01:08 PM)Hopalong Wrote:
(10-06-2020, 11:57 AM)Duffers Wrote: I think we are miles off having the conversation about Slav’s future, but if or when it comes I hope those in charge are thinking “who can do a better job?” before any decision is made. We’ve seen with Pardew and Mel how bad things get when a manager is canned without any actual plan to replace them. I have a horrible feeling if Bilic went we’d just end up with another Pardew-esque has been like Mark Hughes.

Like I say though, we are miles off those sort of discussions.

We are Duffers, but I am concerned about his ability or inability to motivate the players.  The performance at Saints from the first minute was appalling and there was absolutely no intensity or fight.  

Heads went down against Leicester in the first game.   There was a vast improvement against Everton and Chelsea but awful against Saints. 

If he can't motivate the team to put in a shift them we are doomed.  

In  contrast, look at the intensity and way Leeds are performing, it's like they're on drugs!

Bielsa one of the worlds best coaches though. 

Southampton game wasn't due to lack of motivation, it was Slav getting his tactics completely wrong.

Not according to some on here. Overrated apparently...
Reply
#84
(10-07-2020, 12:48 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Posted this on the wrong thread - joys of using your MCW phone.

Odemwingie
Brunt Morrison Thomas
Mulumbu Yacob
Ridgwell Olsson GMac Jones
Foster

That XI cost less than Villa have paid to loan Barkley for a season... we’ve also had players like the MAF, Scharner, Reid etc come in and do jobs. I know inflation is on our side, but the point is that with good coaching and then a joined up approach between clever scouting and managerial style, plus a little bit of luck, you can be competitive without breaking the bank.

PL clubs get carried away looking for the finished article, and these cost money. Interesting that none of those signings were made under Pulis, where we moved to that recruitment strategy.

The best value is in finding players in the Champ and League One and giving them an opportunity, and looking at leagues like Germany, Holland, Turkey, Austria and Scandinavia where traditionally teams in Spain, France and Italy shop before selling to the PL at massive profit.

As per other comments, great post SW4, and just reinforces how good the scouting network was under Ashworth.

When Dowling was recruited, he made comments that implied a move back to the Ashworth days, which was encouraging. Does anyone with insider information know where we are in relation to that journey? Given the fact that we're relying upon the Championship for our strike force, it would suggest that there's some way to go yet, but hopefully there is progress being made...
Reply
#85
(10-07-2020, 01:13 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(10-07-2020, 01:08 PM)Hopalong Wrote:
(10-06-2020, 11:57 AM)Duffers Wrote: I think we are miles off having the conversation about Slav’s future, but if or when it comes I hope those in charge are thinking “who can do a better job?” before any decision is made. We’ve seen with Pardew and Mel how bad things get when a manager is canned without any actual plan to replace them. I have a horrible feeling if Bilic went we’d just end up with another Pardew-esque has been like Mark Hughes.

Like I say though, we are miles off those sort of discussions.

We are Duffers, but I am concerned about his ability or inability to motivate the players.  The performance at Saints from the first minute was appalling and there was absolutely no intensity or fight.  

Heads went down against Leicester in the first game.   There was a vast improvement against Everton and Chelsea but awful against Saints. 

If he can't motivate the team to put in a shift them we are doomed.  

In  contrast, look at the intensity and way Leeds are performing, it's like they're on drugs!

With a squad on a similar level. 8 games without a victory says to me we're closer to discussing if Slav is up to it than many realise. 

Let's see what happens if we sign the players we want and still lose to Burnley

I don't think we'll do anything drastic unless we lose the next 4/5. 

Burnley may be too soon Sliced,  I would say mini-review after Fulham.
Reply
#86
(10-06-2020, 06:28 PM)Robbo2604 Wrote:
(10-06-2020, 06:23 PM)Super_Slav Wrote:
(10-06-2020, 06:13 PM)Robbo2604 Wrote: Dean Smith was given near enough £150m, 38 games, and survived because VAR was turned off. By the sounds of it, we are giving Slaven a 5th of the budget and a handful of games.

Slaven also a far far better manager IMO

Smith got out of jail last season, but the owners backed him, even though the fans did not.  If they had their way, he would have been gone much sooner. Now look at them!!

It's early days, that Liverpool result was a freak.  Any other team would have shut up shop after 4 at the most, something Poo are not used to but their naivity was incredible.  The keeper and Gomez had a complete mare and gifted them 3 goals and there were 3 ridiculous deflections but credit where credit is due,  you don't strike oil without drilling.  

I still think Villa's defence is very suspect,  though they have improved the keeper.  A lot will depend on whether their key players can steer clear of injuries.  I do think their ego/ambition will now lead to possibly another two signings (they probably think they have a chance of making Champions League at this point) - Behrama/Sarr and maybe King?   If so,  with Traore yet to get in the side they could push for Europe this season, which wouldn't necessarily be a bad thing as the Europa would probably completed fck them up!
Reply
#87
(10-07-2020, 01:53 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(10-07-2020, 01:52 PM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote:
(10-07-2020, 01:08 PM)Hopalong Wrote:
(10-06-2020, 11:57 AM)Duffers Wrote: I think we are miles off having the conversation about Slav’s future, but if or when it comes I hope those in charge are thinking “who can do a better job?” before any decision is made. We’ve seen with Pardew and Mel how bad things get when a manager is canned without any actual plan to replace them. I have a horrible feeling if Bilic went we’d just end up with another Pardew-esque has been like Mark Hughes.

Like I say though, we are miles off those sort of discussions.

We are Duffers, but I am concerned about his ability or inability to motivate the players.  The performance at Saints from the first minute was appalling and there was absolutely no intensity or fight.  

Heads went down against Leicester in the first game.   There was a vast improvement against Everton and Chelsea but awful against Saints. 

If he can't motivate the team to put in a shift them we are doomed.  

In  contrast, look at the intensity and way Leeds are performing, it's like they're on drugs!

Bielsa one of the worlds best coaches though. 

Southampton game wasn't due to lack of motivation, it was Slav getting his tactics completely wrong.

Not according to some on here. Overrated apparently...

Amazing coach.

Not convinced as a manager, and not due to ability, more the fact he can start a fight in an empty room at times and sometimes does very silly stuff for some bizarre reason.

Leeds seems an excellent fit for him though, at least for now.
Reply
#88
Anyone that can get Stuart Dallas playing like a world beater is a decent coach! I doubt there isn't a Leeds player that hasn't improved under his coaching.

The team spirit and intensity that Leeds play with gives them an advantage over most teams they play against. They approach each game on the front foot, and aim to win, even when they're up against the likes of Liverpool & Man City. I think it shows how our levels have dropped when you consider we matched them in every sense at their place last season, and to a lesser extent at home. Hopefully Slaven can get our players back to that level again - He needs to if we're to stand a chance of staying up.
Reply
#89
(10-07-2020, 01:52 PM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote:
(10-07-2020, 01:08 PM)Hopalong Wrote:
(10-06-2020, 11:57 AM)Duffers Wrote: I think we are miles off having the conversation about Slav’s future, but if or when it comes I hope those in charge are thinking “who can do a better job?” before any decision is made. We’ve seen with Pardew and Mel how bad things get when a manager is canned without any actual plan to replace them. I have a horrible feeling if Bilic went we’d just end up with another Pardew-esque has been like Mark Hughes.

Like I say though, we are miles off those sort of discussions.

We are Duffers, but I am concerned about his ability or inability to motivate the players.  The performance at Saints from the first minute was appalling and there was absolutely no intensity or fight.  

Heads went down against Leicester in the first game.   There was a vast improvement against Everton and Chelsea but awful against Saints. 

If he can't motivate the team to put in a shift them we are doomed.  

In  contrast, look at the intensity and way Leeds are performing, it's like they're on drugs!

Bielsa one of the worlds best coaches though. 

Southampton game wasn't due to lack of motivation, it was Slav getting his tactics completely wrong.

I quite like Bielsa, fascinating guy but he's never had a really big job, won any of the major trophies or stayed anywhere long,  so his status with others in the game is a bit of a mystery.   As soon as things start to go wrong at Leeds he'll be off.  

Re, Saints,  yes, easy to say the tactics were wrong after the event,  I assume you feel we should have stuck with 3-4-3?  I disagree that the tactics alone were the cause, you must have been watching a different game to me if you don't think it was due to a lack of motivation which is the basis for everything.  To quote Slaven '"we lacked aggression....application, pace, strength and quality'.  Pretty damning. 

He said the only positive for him was Sam who was faultless, long may it continue.  I would say the other positive was Sam Field who looked composed and not out of his depth but I'm not really sure that he offers enough? Could he be converted to a left-back?   I also thought Slav's subs caused us to lose momentum.  

It has to be said that Ajayi had two very good almost identical chances which he simply needed to get his head on but for some bizarre reason he  tried to get his foot to the ball.  
Reply
#90
(10-07-2020, 03:55 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(10-07-2020, 01:53 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(10-07-2020, 01:52 PM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote:
(10-07-2020, 01:08 PM)Hopalong Wrote:
(10-06-2020, 11:57 AM)Duffers Wrote: I think we are miles off having the conversation about Slav’s future, but if or when it comes I hope those in charge are thinking “who can do a better job?” before any decision is made. We’ve seen with Pardew and Mel how bad things get when a manager is canned without any actual plan to replace them. I have a horrible feeling if Bilic went we’d just end up with another Pardew-esque has been like Mark Hughes.

Like I say though, we are miles off those sort of discussions.

We are Duffers, but I am concerned about his ability or inability to motivate the players.  The performance at Saints from the first minute was appalling and there was absolutely no intensity or fight.  

Heads went down against Leicester in the first game.   There was a vast improvement against Everton and Chelsea but awful against Saints. 

If he can't motivate the team to put in a shift them we are doomed.  

In  contrast, look at the intensity and way Leeds are performing, it's like they're on drugs!

Bielsa one of the worlds best coaches though. 

Southampton game wasn't due to lack of motivation, it was Slav getting his tactics completely wrong.

Not according to some on here. Overrated apparently...

Amazing coach.

Not convinced as a manager, and not due to ability, more the fact he can start a fight in an empty room at times and sometimes does very silly stuff for some bizarre reason.

Leeds seems an excellent fit for him though, at least for now.

Bielsa needs complete control over every facet of the club... he will want to be left alone on the training ground, and leave other people to do the scouting and make the signings, but he will select 100% every player that arrives and will want every single one of his asks to be delivered.

Leeds know they have the level of manager in charge that they will never replicate, and his draw and persona has raised their profile massively - hence the signings they've made this summer - so it's a perfect fit all round. They will indulge Bielsa in every way and in return he's delivering.

He's as mad as a box of frogs, but an absolutely brilliant coach who is thriving. It'll be very interesting however to see how they do post-Xmas, as the 3 week break between seasons will definitely deliver some tired legs. They started to blow out of their arse prior to lockdown saving their bacon, and I can't see how flogging them into the ground again will produce any different results.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: