Up to Slaven now
#41
(10-06-2020, 01:24 PM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(10-06-2020, 01:10 PM)Jacobthebaggie Wrote: What we need to do is fill the team up with big players, field teams full of defensively minded players and practice pinching goals from set pieces after defending like crazy to stay in games as long as possible. Don't think we've ever tried that before.

Big Grin   We seem to have another poster who is lost.


Par last season was probably a top 6 finish, he over-achieved but not by much, it was hardly a miracle.

He's probably feeling as frustrated as the rest of us and wondering whether he really wants to own a relegation when realistically that's where the odds lie.  If he keeps this squad up then this is easily on a par with SGM's first promotion.

Despite the above I'd say he's not getting the most out of what we've got either.  So a squad realistically not good enough to stay up is being managed to below its maximum ability will only lead to a parting of the ways.

He has deserved better backing and a better scouting system than he's been given and he certainly deserves a lot longer than 4 games.  However, I suspect the boardroom will get very twitchy in another 3 to 4 games if we haven't picked up a reasonable haul of points from those games.  The irony being the ones doing the sacking will be at more fault that the man they're sacking.
Sounds like every football team ever.
I agree btw.
Reply
#42
(10-06-2020, 09:01 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: We don't have the money of virtually all our peers. However, that doesn't mean we have to accept being bottom or second bottom. Truth is the difference between a £5m player and a £15m one sometimes can be negligible. 
It's why clubs like Huddersfield managed to get up and stay up for a couple of seasons and why Burnley are still there. 
Regardless of now, Bilic was well backed last season and got us there. Now though it is time for him to use what we have in the club.
Many managers have done it before, look at how Roy turned us around. A good manager makes all the difference.
We have to be balanced knowing what we have and what we are up against.
I think playing three of the top 6 or 7 come the end of the season is giving us a false sense of what is possible, and whilst there's no excuse for how poor we were v Southampton, many a time we've had days like that and come back.
Bilic has to show what he can do with this squad like many others have in the past all over football.

Spot on. Look at Sheff Utd squad last season and what they achieved. Organisation is key. And fitness. Back to basics re defensive shape and build from there as we have pace and creativity going forwards.
Reply
#43
(10-06-2020, 01:54 PM)Peachy Wrote:
(10-06-2020, 09:01 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: We don't have the money of virtually all our peers. However, that doesn't mean we have to accept being bottom or second bottom. Truth is the difference between a £5m player and a £15m one sometimes can be negligible. 
It's why clubs like Huddersfield managed to get up and stay up for a couple of seasons and why Burnley are still there. 
Regardless of now, Bilic was well backed last season and got us there. Now though it is time for him to use what we have in the club.
Many managers have done it before, look at how Roy turned us around. A good manager makes all the difference.
We have to be balanced knowing what we have and what we are up against.
I think playing three of the top 6 or 7 come the end of the season is giving us a false sense of what is possible, and whilst there's no excuse for how poor we were v Southampton, many a time we've had days like that and come back.
Bilic has to show what he can do with this squad like many others have in the past all over football.

Spot on. Look at Sheff Utd squad last season and what they achieved. Organisation is key. And fitness. Back to basics re defensive shape and build from there as we have pace and creativity going forwards.

Arf back to basics, organisation and fitness you say? They are very old fashioned attributes for a team with limited resources. Dinosaur football that is! I wanna a team oo av a roight gud goo!
Reply
#44
Dean Smith was given near enough £150m, 38 games, and survived because VAR was turned off. By the sounds of it, we are giving Slaven a 5th of the budget and a handful of games.
Reply
#45
(10-06-2020, 06:13 PM)Robbo2604 Wrote: Dean Smith was given near enough £150m, 38 games, and survived because VAR was turned off. By the sounds of it, we are giving Slaven a 5th of the budget and a handful of games.

Slaven also a far far better manager IMO
Reply
#46
(10-06-2020, 06:23 PM)Super_Slav Wrote:
(10-06-2020, 06:13 PM)Robbo2604 Wrote: Dean Smith was given near enough £150m, 38 games, and survived because VAR was turned off. By the sounds of it, we are giving Slaven a 5th of the budget and a handful of games.

Slaven also a far far better manager IMO

Smith got out of jail last season, but the owners backed him, even though the fans did not.  If they had their way, he would have been gone much sooner. Now look at them!!
Reply
#47
Big Slav can have this season for me. Although considering where he played, I'd like to see him straighten the defence out. Being first to the ball would help, maybe playing our best defender would help. Either way, he's still in credit with me.
Pereira and Diangana are down to him and we'd have signed them both yesterday we'd all be over the moon. Hope he gets a few more this week.
Reply
#48
"Straightening the defence out" isn't necessarily that easy. Klopp could only sort his out by buying better defenders (such as Van Dyke) and a better goalkeeper.

Megson could only sort out our defence originally by buying better defenders and a decent keeper. It was only when Big Dave arrived that we stopped conceding goals because he was the player who met every cross into our box.

If your defenders don't have the ability (use whatever word you want here) to actually defend for the entire length of the match then it's hard to get them to do so. How many on here think Bartley, for example, isn't good enough? That is where we are at. Are our defenders from last season good enough? Have we bought better defenders in the window?
Reply
#49
(10-07-2020, 10:38 AM)baggie_ray Wrote: "Straightening the defence out" isn't necessarily that easy. Klopp could only sort his out by buying better defenders (such as Van Dyke) and a better goalkeeper.

Megson could only sort out our defence originally by buying better defenders and a decent keeper. It was only when Big Dave arrived that we stopped conceding goals because he was the player who met every cross into our box.

If your defenders don't have the ability (use whatever word you want here) to actually defend for the entire length of the match then it's hard to get them to do so. How many on here think Bartley, for example, isn't good enough? That is where we are at. Are our defenders from last season good enough? Have we bought better defenders in the window?

In all fairness Ray you’ve made good points. But so far we’ve not seen Cedric Kipré, Ivanovic and Hegazi at this level this season
Reply
#50
(10-07-2020, 10:39 AM)Super_Slav Wrote:
(10-07-2020, 10:38 AM)baggie_ray Wrote: "Straightening the defence out" isn't necessarily that easy. Klopp could only sort his out by buying better defenders (such as Van Dyke) and a better goalkeeper.

Megson could only sort out our defence originally by buying better defenders and a decent keeper. It was only when Big Dave arrived that we stopped conceding goals because he was the player who met every cross into our box.

If your defenders don't have the ability (use whatever word you want here) to actually defend for the entire length of the match then it's hard to get them to do so. How many on here think Bartley, for example, isn't good enough? That is where we are at. Are our defenders from last season good enough? Have we bought better defenders in the window?

In all fairness Ray you’ve made good points. But so far we’ve not seen Cedric Kipré, Ivanovic and Hegazi at this level this season

We've sat through an entire season of Hegazi in the PL running around like he's wearing wellies.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: