Posts: 1,777
Threads: 5
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
4
I was thinking about Sawyers this morning, and the reaction of the Brentford fans when we signed him. I read their forum at the time, and to a man / woman, they were all disappointed that he was leaving, with some suggesting he was the best player they'd even seen play for them. The key was the position he played for them, his role for Brentford was more the one Pereira plays for us. He didn't have defensive responsibilities.
In the Championship, teams obviously don't have the quality of players to punish the lack of defensive midfield protection. In the Prem this weakness is being exploited. I think Romaine needs to play further forwards, and not worry as much about defensive aspects of play, but that position is currently taken by our best player.
As others have suggested, we need a Mulumbu type player in that position protecting the back 4 or 5, and Sawyers isn't that player, and those aren't his strengths.
Posts: 3,011
Threads: 287
Joined: Jun 2019
(10-05-2020, 10:07 AM)ElbowGrease1973 Wrote: I was thinking about Sawyers this morning, and the reaction of the Brentford fans when we signed him. I read their forum at the time, and to a man / woman, they were all disappointed that he was leaving, with some suggesting he was the best player they'd even seen play for them. The key was the position he played for them, his role for Brentford was more the one Pereira plays for us. He didn't have defensive responsibilities.
In the Championship, teams obviously don't have the quality of players to punish the lack of defensive midfield protection. In the Prem this weakness is being exploited. I think Romaine needs to play further forwards, and not worry as much about defensive aspects of play, but that position is currently taken by our best player.
As others have suggested, we need a Mulumbu type player in that position protecting the back 4 or 5, and Sawyers isn't that player, and those aren't his strengths.
The issue is whichever way we go there is glaring weaknesses to this team. Are any of our centre backs good enough to play in a 2? I’m not so sure.
I think the issue with O’Shea is he lacks acceleration at this level to play full back. Look how Marty Cash has stepped up for Villa for example. Nathan Ferguson was a huge reason for our early season success last season. He would have made the step up seamlessly (obviously I know he’s got an injury atm).
Look at the back 5 on Sunday.
Johnstone - O’Shea - Ajayi - Bartley - Townsend.
Arguably the “best” which is subjective could be...
Johnstone - O’Shea - Ivanović - Hegazi - Gibbs...(we already play a deep line so having Ivanović and Hegazi wouldn’t really make a massive difference IMO)
The issue is midfield.
It has to be 3.
With Livermore and Field competing for the “screening role”.
With Sawyers and Krovinovic competing to play as one of the “number 8’s”
With Gallagher and Harper competing to play as another of the “number 8’s”.
Even then I just don’t think we are good enough, sadly.
Johnstone; O’Shea, Ivanovic, Hegazi, Gibbs; Livermore, Sawyers, Gallagher; Pereria, Robinson, Diangana.
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(10-05-2020, 10:07 AM)ElbowGrease1973 Wrote: I was thinking about Sawyers this morning, and the reaction of the Brentford fans when we signed him. I read their forum at the time, and to a man / woman, they were all disappointed that he was leaving, with some suggesting he was the best player they'd even seen play for them. The key was the position he played for them, his role for Brentford was more the one Pereira plays for us. He didn't have defensive responsibilities.
In the Championship, teams obviously don't have the quality of players to punish the lack of defensive midfield protection. In the Prem this weakness is being exploited. I think Romaine needs to play further forwards, and not worry as much about defensive aspects of play, but that position is currently taken by our best player.
As others have suggested, we need a Mulumbu type player in that position protecting the back 4 or 5, and Sawyers isn't that player, and those aren't his strengths.
Agree with this 100% which is why I’m shocked we haven’t prioritised a central midfielder this summer.
For me, after our well known striker dilemma, the lack of a combative midfielder and commanding centre half were the 2 positions we needed to strengthen most. As lovey as bringing Krov back is, Sawyers should have been moved into his role and we should have brought a much tougher midfielder in alongside Gallagher.
The concerning thing for me is that Slav didn’t seem to realise this, and was happy to let Field go until the last minute!
Posts: 1,777
Threads: 5
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
4
(10-05-2020, 10:16 AM)Super_Slav Wrote: (10-05-2020, 10:07 AM)ElbowGrease1973 Wrote: I was thinking about Sawyers this morning, and the reaction of the Brentford fans when we signed him. I read their forum at the time, and to a man / woman, they were all disappointed that he was leaving, with some suggesting he was the best player they'd even seen play for them. The key was the position he played for them, his role for Brentford was more the one Pereira plays for us. He didn't have defensive responsibilities.
In the Championship, teams obviously don't have the quality of players to punish the lack of defensive midfield protection. In the Prem this weakness is being exploited. I think Romaine needs to play further forwards, and not worry as much about defensive aspects of play, but that position is currently taken by our best player.
As others have suggested, we need a Mulumbu type player in that position protecting the back 4 or 5, and Sawyers isn't that player, and those aren't his strengths.
The issue is whichever way we go there is glaring weaknesses to this team. Are any of our centre backs good enough to play in a 2? I’m not so sure.
I think the issue with O’Shea is he lacks acceleration at this level to play full back. Look how Marty Cash has stepped up for Villa for example. Nathan Ferguson was a huge reason for our early season success last season. He would have made the step up seamlessly (obviously I know he’s got an injury atm).
Look at the back 5 on Sunday.
Johnstone - O’Shea - Ajayi - Bartley - Townsend.
Arguably the “best” which is subjective could be...
Johnstone - O’Shea - Ivanović - Hegazi - Gibbs...(we already play a deep line so having Ivanović and Hegazi wouldn’t really make a massive difference IMO)
The issue is midfield.
It has to be 3.
With Livermore and Field competing for the “screening role”.
With Sawyers and Krovinovic competing to play as one of the “number 8’s”
With Gallagher and Harper competing to play as another of the “number 8’s”.
Even then I just don’t think we are good enough, sadly.
Johnstone; O’Shea, Ivanovic, Hegazi, Gibbs; Livermore, Sawyers, Gallagher; Pereria, Robinson, Diangana. Fair points fella, although I think Semi has acquitted himself pretty well so far this season, and deserves to keep his position.
Watching yesterday, I couldn't help thinking that to accommodate our players, in a system that works, we really need 12 players on the pitch, then we'd be competitive! Wonder if VAR would pick up on that...
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(10-05-2020, 10:16 AM)Super_Slav Wrote: (10-05-2020, 10:07 AM)ElbowGrease1973 Wrote: I was thinking about Sawyers this morning, and the reaction of the Brentford fans when we signed him. I read their forum at the time, and to a man / woman, they were all disappointed that he was leaving, with some suggesting he was the best player they'd even seen play for them. The key was the position he played for them, his role for Brentford was more the one Pereira plays for us. He didn't have defensive responsibilities.
In the Championship, teams obviously don't have the quality of players to punish the lack of defensive midfield protection. In the Prem this weakness is being exploited. I think Romaine needs to play further forwards, and not worry as much about defensive aspects of play, but that position is currently taken by our best player.
As others have suggested, we need a Mulumbu type player in that position protecting the back 4 or 5, and Sawyers isn't that player, and those aren't his strengths.
The issue is whichever way we go there is glaring weaknesses to this team. Are any of our centre backs good enough to play in a 2? I’m not so sure.
I think the issue with O’Shea is he lacks acceleration at this level to play full back. Look how Marty Cash has stepped up for Villa for example. Nathan Ferguson was a huge reason for our early season success last season. He would have made the step up seamlessly (obviously I know he’s got an injury atm).
Look at the back 5 on Sunday.
Johnstone - O’Shea - Ajayi - Bartley - Townsend.
Arguably the “best” which is subjective could be...
Johnstone - O’Shea - Ivanović - Hegazi - Gibbs...(we already play a deep line so having Ivanović and Hegazi wouldn’t really make a massive difference IMO)
The issue is midfield.
It has to be 3.
With Livermore and Field competing for the “screening role”.
With Sawyers and Krovinovic competing to play as one of the “number 8’s”
With Gallagher and Harper competing to play as another of the “number 8’s”.
Even then I just don’t think we are good enough, sadly.
Johnstone; O’Shea, Ivanovic, Hegazi, Gibbs; Livermore, Sawyers, Gallagher; Pereria, Robinson, Diangana.
I really think Ivanovic will play RB for us, as this won’t impact his leadership or his organisation skills, and his aerial ability at set pieces won’t be compromised.
Ivanovic Hegazy Ajayi Gibbs Is a solid back 4, and give we’ll see Gibbs going forward and Ivanovic tucking in he’ll be able to organise Hegazy and Ajayi. Whilst I’d like to see him at CB, neither Furlong nor O’Shea are good enough.
Johnstone
Ivanovic Hegazi Ajayi Gibbs
Gallagher Field Krovinovic
Periera Diallo Grady
Button, Furlong, Bartley, Sawyers, Livermore, Edwards, Robinson
Posts: 1,904
Threads: 49
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
Ivanovic at right back? Oh dear.
Posts: 903
Threads: 43
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
1
(10-05-2020, 10:16 AM)Super_Slav Wrote: (10-05-2020, 10:07 AM)ElbowGrease1973 Wrote: I was thinking about Sawyers this morning, and the reaction of the Brentford fans when we signed him. I read their forum at the time, and to a man / woman, they were all disappointed that he was leaving, with some suggesting he was the best player they'd even seen play for them. The key was the position he played for them, his role for Brentford was more the one Pereira plays for us. He didn't have defensive responsibilities.
In the Championship, teams obviously don't have the quality of players to punish the lack of defensive midfield protection. In the Prem this weakness is being exploited. I think Romaine needs to play further forwards, and not worry as much about defensive aspects of play, but that position is currently taken by our best player.
As others have suggested, we need a Mulumbu type player in that position protecting the back 4 or 5, and Sawyers isn't that player, and those aren't his strengths.
The issue is whichever way we go there is glaring weaknesses to this team. Are any of our centre backs good enough to play in a 2? I’m not so sure.
I think the issue with O’Shea is he lacks acceleration at this level to play full back. Look how Marty Cash has stepped up for Villa for example. Nathan Ferguson was a huge reason for our early season success last season. He would have made the step up seamlessly (obviously I know he’s got an injury atm).
Look at the back 5 on Sunday.
Johnstone - O’Shea - Ajayi - Bartley - Townsend.
Arguably the “best” which is subjective could be...
Johnstone - O’Shea - Ivanović - Hegazi - Gibbs...(we already play a deep line so having Ivanović and Hegazi wouldn’t really make a massive difference IMO)
The issue is midfield.
It has to be 3.
With Livermore and Field competing for the “screening role”.
With Sawyers and Krovinovic competing to play as one of the “number 8’s”
With Gallagher and Harper competing to play as another of the “number 8’s”.
Even then I just don’t think we are good enough, sadly.
Johnstone; O’Shea, Ivanovic, Hegazi, Gibbs; Livermore, Sawyers, Gallagher; Pereria, Robinson, Diangana.
Hate saying this but spot on SS, the issue has been the midfield for a while going back to last season, the game just seems to pass us by in the middle of the park
Posts: 10,524
Threads: 487
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
28
(10-05-2020, 10:34 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (10-05-2020, 10:16 AM)Super_Slav Wrote: (10-05-2020, 10:07 AM)ElbowGrease1973 Wrote: I was thinking about Sawyers this morning, and the reaction of the Brentford fans when we signed him. I read their forum at the time, and to a man / woman, they were all disappointed that he was leaving, with some suggesting he was the best player they'd even seen play for them. The key was the position he played for them, his role for Brentford was more the one Pereira plays for us. He didn't have defensive responsibilities.
In the Championship, teams obviously don't have the quality of players to punish the lack of defensive midfield protection. In the Prem this weakness is being exploited. I think Romaine needs to play further forwards, and not worry as much about defensive aspects of play, but that position is currently taken by our best player.
As others have suggested, we need a Mulumbu type player in that position protecting the back 4 or 5, and Sawyers isn't that player, and those aren't his strengths.
The issue is whichever way we go there is glaring weaknesses to this team. Are any of our centre backs good enough to play in a 2? I’m not so sure.
I think the issue with O’Shea is he lacks acceleration at this level to play full back. Look how Marty Cash has stepped up for Villa for example. Nathan Ferguson was a huge reason for our early season success last season. He would have made the step up seamlessly (obviously I know he’s got an injury atm).
Look at the back 5 on Sunday.
Johnstone - O’Shea - Ajayi - Bartley - Townsend.
Arguably the “best” which is subjective could be...
Johnstone - O’Shea - Ivanović - Hegazi - Gibbs...(we already play a deep line so having Ivanović and Hegazi wouldn’t really make a massive difference IMO)
The issue is midfield.
It has to be 3.
With Livermore and Field competing for the “screening role”.
With Sawyers and Krovinovic competing to play as one of the “number 8’s”
With Gallagher and Harper competing to play as another of the “number 8’s”.
Even then I just don’t think we are good enough, sadly.
Johnstone; O’Shea, Ivanovic, Hegazi, Gibbs; Livermore, Sawyers, Gallagher; Pereria, Robinson, Diangana.
I really think Ivanovic will play RB for us, as this won’t impact his leadership or his organisation skills, and his aerial ability at set pieces won’t be compromised.
Ivanovic Hegazy Ajayi Gibbs Is a solid back 4, and give we’ll see Gibbs going forward and Ivanovic tucking in he’ll be able to organise Hegazy and Ajayi. Whilst I’d like to see him at CB, neither Furlong nor O’Shea are good enough.
Johnstone
Ivanovic Hegazi Ajayi Gibbs
Gallagher Field Krovinovic
Periera Diallo Grady
Button, Furlong, Bartley, Sawyers, Livermore, Edwards, Robinson
Ivanovic at right back?
A midfield of Gallagher, Field and Krov. Some PL experience there.
Diallo that’s about to sign for Straosburg?
Doomed.
Posts: 34
Threads: 0
Joined: Sep 2020
Reputation:
1
(10-05-2020, 10:16 AM)Super_Slav Wrote: The issue is midfield.
It has to be 3.
All day long.
2 in midfield in the Prem is never, ever going to cut it. If you stick two in the midfield, they'll just flood you. If we play two midfielders as DCM, we can't then link up the attacking play. We've seen this since last season. 4-3-3 is the answer.
And defense wise... well no one in the Prem seems to be covering themselves in glory this year.
Posts: 4,258
Threads: 263
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
Our problems are as much about the way Bilic deploys the players as they are about the players' capability. He seems to think that Livermore and Sawyers make a suitable foundation to build the team around. It was clear last season that this didn't work, and we are playing in a harder league now. Bilic needs to change his mindset and the shape of his team - then we will be better able to judge the players, especially Sawyers. Our midfield options have very much of a Mowbray 2008 look about them just now.
Elsewhere in this thread, Hegazi is being lined up in our best defence. I thought he was back in training, but not on the bench yesterday. Any news on what's what with him?
|