Bilic
#1
Needs to take a good, long look in the mirror.

Completely wrong today, start to finish.


Why 4-2-3-1? This only works if you have a solid defensive base to work from, Livermore and Sawyers will never, ever offer this. Our defense isn't that strong by itself to make up for that. By doing that today you expose everyone's weakness, Sawyers looks lightweight and his passing not worth it. Livermore doesn't have the energy or intensity to run for 90 minutes doing it all. Centre backs need to do too much, which when they are Bartley and Ajayi, means the full backs have to help out, giving wide players space. This means the 4 attacking players may as well go and watch from the stands because they either come back, which means they don't alleviate pressure, or they never see the ball. We cannot afford to have 4 attackers on the pitch with the players we have. Diangana, Pereira and Robinson should have been the only 3 attacking players from the start today. Pereira will do nothing at this level in the middle, the days of a centre attacking midfielder are now all but over as teams play more defensive minded central midfielders. Putting Field in is an almost instant fix to this, preferably to that Gallagher, I don't know the reasoning for that today, but if he wasn't available, play Field. He adds a defensive side no one else does. 

Why are we so unfit? Honestly, this bugs me so much. We aren't a very good side, so strive to be the fittest. We look shattered so much earlier than other teams, this is on the coaching staff and the medical teams, it needs fixing, ASAP, no technique training for a few weeks and get them in the gym and running. It'll pay off over the season.

Why move from the formation against Chelsea at all? We had pretty much the same players available, we looked good against a much better team using that, it covered weaknesses and gave Pereira, Diagnana and Robinson the chances to show what they can do, which is what we need to do to stand any chance this season? I'm at a loss at the decisions leading up to the game today. More attackers =/= more attacking, that's the thinking of a 12 year old playing Fifa ffs. Yes we should have been looking for points today, so contain Southampton, then use our pretty decent attackers to hurt them by giving them licence too, not just fielding another attacker, and therefore allowing Southampton the freedom of the pitch. 

Sawyers is a liability in a midfield 2, not his fault, he isn't that sort of player, so stop making him act like it. It's doing him no favours, and it's leading to poor results. Livermore and Field, that makes more sense, however pick any two from Mulumbu, Scharner, Yacob or Fletcher, fuck, even Craig Gardner, and it's a better base already. We've neglected this part of the field badly, and now relying on a young loanee and Field to step up. So play a midfield 3, with Krov or Field. I don't get why we played with 2 there today, I don't.

Southampton won't get an easier game than today this season, and you can whine and complain about the squad all you want, but today, was poor decisions from the manager, and a result of what is looking like very poor coaching. We can't afford either of those things right now. We can't play a possession based style, we are better, with the pace and directness of our attackers, a counter attacking team still.

I'm not giving up hope, because I don't think we're as bad as it seems, but Bilic isn't doing us any favours so far, and his job is to maximise what he has available. If anyone really thinks he is doing that, pick another sport, football isn't for you. I want him to sort it because I like him as a man and he has at times seemed like a great manager for us. But at this level you don't get a lot of time to learn.

We have some decent young players, I think getting them game time is good, I know our impatient fans have already written off Harper and Edwards already, and many Field, with O'Shea somehow suddenly crap too. But they aren't, however being thrown into a team and expected to deal with being hammered because of poor tactical ideas, will do none of them any good. Accept what we should be, a team that works on hitting quick on the break and defensively organised first and foremost, they can then come in and start to develop well.

Rant over.
Reply
#2
Great post. Nail on head summary.
Reply
#3
(10-04-2020, 02:35 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Needs to take a good, long look in the mirror.

Completely wrong today, start to finish.


Why 4-2-3-1? This only works if you have a solid defensive base to work from, Livermore and Sawyers will never, ever offer this. Our defense isn't that strong by itself to make up for that. By doing that today you expose everyone's weakness, Sawyers looks lightweight and his passing not worth it. Livermore doesn't have the energy or intensity to run for 90 minutes doing it all. Centre backs need to do too much, which when they are Bartley and Ajayi, means the full backs have to help out, giving wide players space. This means the 4 attacking players may as well go and watch from the stands because they either come back, which means they don't alleviate pressure, or they never see the ball. We cannot afford to have 4 attackers on the pitch with the players we have. Diangana, Pereira and Robinson should have been the only 3 attacking players from the start today. Pereira will do nothing at this level in the middle, the days of a centre attacking midfielder are now all but over as teams play more defensive minded central midfielders. Putting Field in is an almost instant fix to this, preferably to that Gallagher, I don't know the reasoning for that today, but if he wasn't available, play Field. He adds a defensive side no one else does. 

Why are we so unfit? Honestly, this bugs me so much. We aren't a very good side, so strive to be the fittest. We look shattered so much earlier than other teams, this is on the coaching staff and the medical teams, it needs fixing, ASAP, no technique training for a few weeks and get them in the gym and running. It'll pay off over the season.

Why move from the formation against Chelsea at all? We had pretty much the same players available, we looked good against a much better team using that, it covered weaknesses and gave Pereira, Diagnana and Robinson the chances to show what they can do, which is what we need to do to stand any chance this season? I'm at a loss at the decisions leading up to the game today. More attackers =/= more attacking, that's the thinking of a 12 year old playing Fifa ffs. Yes we should have been looking for points today, so contain Southampton, then use our pretty decent attackers to hurt them by giving them licence too, not just fielding another attacker, and therefore allowing Southampton the freedom of the pitch. 

Sawyers is a liability in a midfield 2, not his fault, he isn't that sort of player, so stop making him act like it. It's doing him no favours, and it's leading to poor results. Livermore and Field, that makes more sense, however pick any two from Mulumbu, Scharner, Yacob or Fletcher, fuck, even Craig Gardner, and it's a better base already. We've neglected this part of the field badly, and now relying on a young loanee and Field to step up. So play a midfield 3, with Krov or Field. I don't get why we played with 2 there today, I don't.

Southampton won't get an easier game than today this season, and you can whine and complain about the squad all you want, but today, was poor decisions from the manager, and a result of what is looking like very poor coaching. We can't afford either of those things right now. We can't play a possession based style, we are better, with the pace and directness of our attackers, a counter attacking team still.

I'm not giving up hope, because I don't think we're as bad as it seems, but Bilic isn't doing us any favours so far, and his job is to maximise what he has available. If anyone really thinks he is doing that, pick another sport, football isn't for you. I want him to sort it because I like him as a man and he has at times seemed like a great manager for us. But at this level you don't get a lot of time to learn.

We have some decent young players, I think getting them game time is good, I know our impatient fans have already written off Harper and Edwards already, and many Field, with O'Shea somehow suddenly crap too. But they aren't, however being thrown into a team and expected to deal with being hammered because of poor tactical ideas, will do none of them any good. Accept what we should be, a team that works on hitting quick on the break and defensively organised first and foremost, they can then come in and start to develop well.

Rant over.

Agree with all that, also Edward's and O'Shea together was a strange selection  with a total lack of experience . However we are 17th at the moment!
Reply
#4
Fair comment. Especially about the defence not being shielded enough from midfield (although it's worth adding, plus the midfield not helped by the ball not sticking up front). Our defenders really aren't good enough and that needs addressing.
Reply
#5
Yep, summed it up very well, Birdman.
Reply
#6
Good post Birdie
Reply
#7
Spot on Birdy. Especially on the coaching / fitness.
Reply
#8
Decent reflection that, problem is Birdy we don't have a Yacob/Mulumbu partnership or nothing like it available

Field is no Yacob but sits deeper than the rest

I think Slav's mentality is we will try and play on the front foot and get the likes of Grady, Pereira, Krov, Robinson, John Doe striker on the ball as much as possible, all for this as you have to play to your strenghts and they are ours but respectfully Townsend, O-Shea, possibly Barltey/Semi are not a premiership defence

The biggest fustration is the window, buying Grady was an absolute no brainer and is a total investment for the club long term but no doubt it's fucked up what was a tiny, Covid hampered budget in the first place

Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Reply
#9
(10-04-2020, 02:35 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Needs to take a good, long look in the mirror.

Completely wrong today, start to finish.


Why 4-2-3-1? This only works if you have a solid defensive base to work from, Livermore and Sawyers will never, ever offer this. Our defense isn't that strong by itself to make up for that. By doing that today you expose everyone's weakness, Sawyers looks lightweight and his passing not worth it. Livermore doesn't have the energy or intensity to run for 90 minutes doing it all. Centre backs need to do too much, which when they are Bartley and Ajayi, means the full backs have to help out, giving wide players space. This means the 4 attacking players may as well go and watch from the stands because they either come back, which means they don't alleviate pressure, or they never see the ball. We cannot afford to have 4 attackers on the pitch with the players we have. Diangana, Pereira and Robinson should have been the only 3 attacking players from the start today. Pereira will do nothing at this level in the middle, the days of a centre attacking midfielder are now all but over as teams play more defensive minded central midfielders. Putting Field in is an almost instant fix to this, preferably to that Gallagher, I don't know the reasoning for that today, but if he wasn't available, play Field. He adds a defensive side no one else does. 

Why are we so unfit? Honestly, this bugs me so much. We aren't a very good side, so strive to be the fittest. We look shattered so much earlier than other teams, this is on the coaching staff and the medical teams, it needs fixing, ASAP, no technique training for a few weeks and get them in the gym and running. It'll pay off over the season.

Why move from the formation against Chelsea at all? We had pretty much the same players available, we looked good against a much better team using that, it covered weaknesses and gave Pereira, Diagnana and Robinson the chances to show what they can do, which is what we need to do to stand any chance this season? I'm at a loss at the decisions leading up to the game today. More attackers =/= more attacking, that's the thinking of a 12 year old playing Fifa ffs. Yes we should have been looking for points today, so contain Southampton, then use our pretty decent attackers to hurt them by giving them licence too, not just fielding another attacker, and therefore allowing Southampton the freedom of the pitch. 

Sawyers is a liability in a midfield 2, not his fault, he isn't that sort of player, so stop making him act like it. It's doing him no favours, and it's leading to poor results. Livermore and Field, that makes more sense, however pick any two from Mulumbu, Scharner, Yacob or Fletcher, fuck, even Craig Gardner, and it's a better base already. We've neglected this part of the field badly, and now relying on a young loanee and Field to step up. So play a midfield 3, with Krov or Field. I don't get why we played with 2 there today, I don't.

Southampton won't get an easier game than today this season, and you can whine and complain about the squad all you want, but today, was poor decisions from the manager, and a result of what is looking like very poor coaching. We can't afford either of those things right now. We can't play a possession based style, we are better, with the pace and directness of our attackers, a counter attacking team still.

I'm not giving up hope, because I don't think we're as bad as it seems, but Bilic isn't doing us any favours so far, and his job is to maximise what he has available. If anyone really thinks he is doing that, pick another sport, football isn't for you. I want him to sort it because I like him as a man and he has at times seemed like a great manager for us. But at this level you don't get a lot of time to learn.

We have some decent young players, I think getting them game time is good, I know our impatient fans have already written off Harper and Edwards already, and many Field, with O'Shea somehow suddenly crap too. But they aren't, however being thrown into a team and expected to deal with being hammered because of poor tactical ideas, will do none of them any good. Accept what we should be, a team that works on hitting quick on the break and defensively organised first and foremost, they can then come in and start to develop well.

Rant over.

Agree with most of this.

Except i think we can play a possession game at this level, but absolutely need to pick the right team. Feel if we don't play possession we won't see the best of Perreria at this level.

At the moment we are neither fish nor fowl. 

Bilic needs to start to come to a definitive opinion of how we want to play, pick the players who best fit that style of play and stick to it.
Reply
#10
Pereira can do well in a counter attacking team, especially with the other 2 attackers being Robinson and Diangana, that's a very fluid front 3, directness, pace, trickery, ability to win set pieces, ability to take set pieces. And of course finishing.

I don't think any team outside the top 6 can play Possession based football and do well, it's always been a belief of mine. Maybe that's my 'football philosophy' ha.

We also need to be a lot fitter, whatever we decide to play.

Either way, right now, blame lies almost squarely at the door of Bilic, these are decisions he makes. If I felt we were using every player to their best role and they weren't good enough, he is absolved, no one can say he is.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: