Alan Effing Irvine
#11
(10-03-2020, 09:59 AM)Psalm23 Wrote: The real question for me, is not why he was sacked, but why the fuck he was ever appointed in the first place.

Because he was cheap and available.

Anything else I can help you with?
Reply
#12
(10-03-2020, 10:00 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: It was the most bizarre managerial appointment in the Peace years. As you said the period is hard to recall. All I know is they appointed him on the same day England were playing a huge game, which seemed to indicate they didn’t want it highlighted. A day for burying bad news.

Interesting Spandau. At that time, having been made redundant, I did some security work at a firm in West Brom. There was some speculation Albion had approched Tim Sherwood. On the Thursday, a contractor came on site, said to me, `I just drove past the Hawthorns, saw Sherwood getting into a car with Terry Burton etc`. I don`t know how true that was, but expected Sherwood to get the job, Irvine would not have been my choice, but would not have wanted Sherwood either.
Reply
#13
(10-03-2020, 09:59 AM)Psalm23 Wrote: The real question for me, is not why he was sacked, but why the fuck he was ever appointed in the first place.

  ^   ^   ^
Reply
#14
It wasn’t an odd appointment at all. It was a logical one based on the club believing it’s own hype in terms of thinking the ‘Head Coaching system’ was bullet proof. The parameters set were for a respected experienced coach not a manager, who would work within our rigid structure of DoF, coaches and scouts. If you take that into account his appointment hit all the criteria asked. He was appointed to coach the team, have limited input into signings and limited coaching support of his choice.

Not bizarre, odd or strange appointment at all, in fact it was very a logical appointment sadly the system was only as good as those employed within it. A point lost on some at the time and even now it seems.
Reply
#15
I seem to remember, after Irvine had "turned us down" to stay at Preston, the Preston chairman saying they had one of the best managers in the league. They sacked him shortly after when results went downhill.

On the same subject, Karren Brady said the same thing about Slaven at West Ham. Within a year or two Slaven was shown the door.

It's strange how all these fantastic managers become useless when they go on a losing streak.
Reply
#16
(10-03-2020, 11:26 AM)baggie_ray Wrote: I seem to remember, after Irvine had "turned us down" to stay at Preston, the Preston chairman saying they had one of the best managers in the league. They sacked him shortly after when results went downhill.

On the same subject, Karren Brady said the same thing about Slaven at West Ham. Within a year or two Slaven was shown the door.

It's strange how all these fantastic managers become useless when they go on a losing streak.

True Ray. Managers don`t get time anymore. I remember Don Howe taking us down, still there nearly 2 years later. Now it seems you are only as good as the last 3 results.
Reply
#17
We employed him a head coach not a manager
Reply
#18
Always felt a bit for Irvine as he got our job at probably the worst time in 10 years. Huge turnover of players, no real direction with recruitment after the departure of Ashworth and no authority to really stipulate who he wanted. We spread a smallish budget very thin to sign a load of players who really weren’t good enough, and not sure he really wanted any of them.

Not sure he had it in him to make a success of it as a manager, and no doubt that it was a strange appointment, but he’d have had a better chance if we’d given him some half decent players. That said he was also fortunate to come in when Berahino was hitting his best form.

We actually had a few decent performances (I remember is hammering Burnley and playing pretty well on the opening day too, albeit also several poor ones, but it was never going to work out because so many fans unhappy with the appointment decided from the off that it was going to be a disaster regardless, and that scenario rarely works out. It’s always just a matter of time until the tide turns.
Reply
#19
(10-03-2020, 11:34 AM)ABBaggie Wrote: Always felt a bit for Irvine as he got our job at probably the worst time in 10 years. Huge turnover of players, no real direction with recruitment after the departure of Ashworth and no authority to really stipulate who he wanted. We spread a smallish budget very thin to sign a load of players who really weren’t good enough, and not sure he really wanted any of them.

Not sure he had it in him to make a success of it as a manager, and no doubt that it was a strange appointment, but he’d have had a better chance if we’d given him some half decent players. That said he was also fortunate to come in when Berahino was hitting his best form.

We actually had a few decent performances (I remember is hammering Burnley and playing pretty well on the opening day too, albeit also several poor ones, but it was never going to work out because so many fans unhappy with the appointment decided from the off that it was going to be a disaster regardless, and that scenario rarely works out. It’s always just a matter of time until the tide turns.

Some of those signings were abject. Davidson, Samaras, Blanco etc. Irvine is probably a decent coach, better suited as someone elses assistant.
Reply
#20
(10-03-2020, 10:06 AM)MancBaggie Wrote:
(10-03-2020, 10:01 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: We had a reputation under Peace for sacking managers “unfairly” because we effectively got rid of the before the rot set in. He held onto Megson and especially Robson for too long and learned from it. RDM, Irvine and Clarke all left as soon as the cracks began to show. Contrast that with the impact sticking with Pulis and Pardew as long as we did had...

When AFI was sacked it was clear the gamble hadn’t paid off. We’d had a few decent performances, and had a few points on the board, but it was clear we were treading water at best. As with all things, Pulis likes the narrative that he kept us up against all odds, but I don’t believe we’d actually been in the bottom 3 at any point under AFI.

Spot on that. We briefly went into the bottom 3 after a dire 0-2 at home to Everton - but surprisingly  that was the only time. 

We incredibly won away at Spurs and a week later beat Burnley at home 4-0. But we steadily declined and that 2-3 at bottom place QPR (after being 2 up) was the beginning of the end.

Was that when Chas Austin got a hat trick
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)