How can anyone
#11
(10-02-2020, 01:16 PM)strawman Wrote:
(10-02-2020, 01:09 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(10-02-2020, 01:05 PM)Protheroe Wrote: There are 3 million dividend remunerated directors of small companies, or the newly self employed who are possibly more deserving...

Did all of them stop working Proth or is that the total number of directors in the UK? Also divided remuneration - isn't that a way of avoiding tax from which they have benefitted over however many years they have been receiving the dividends (otherwise what is the point)?

Unless things have changed dividends avoid Employers and Employees NI not Income Tax. However as dividends have to be paid out of profit then Corporation Tax will have been paid on that profit as well. I'm a few years out of date though

Dividends at Basic Rate pay 26.5% tax - 19% Corp Tax and 7.5% on the dividend.

Through payroll it would be 20% PAYE, 12% E'ees and 13.8% E'ers, but the Corp Tx is reduced by the Gross Wage and E'ers NIC.

There's not a lot in it now up to Basic Rate.

Divi Route
Salary £8500
Dividends £41,500

Tax payable £2813
Lost CT Saving £7885
Total Tax £10698
Take Home Pay £47187


Salary Route
Salary £50K
PAYE £7500
E'ee NIC 4859
Take home £37,641
E'ee NIC £5688

Tax\NIC on salary£18047
CT Relief (£10581)
Actual Tax liability £7466

So, more take home but more tax.  If you tried a salary route to give you the same take home pay then it would get more expensive obviously.  It's not the saving it once was and to be honest what's wrong with a bit of a tax incentive for people that have the bollocks to go out and start their own company?

Self-employed people pay less NIC than employed people but they got a bail out.
Reply
#12
Exactly look at FF track and trace thread ...imagine that plus 1000,s doing the same.
Reply
#13
(10-02-2020, 01:09 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(10-02-2020, 01:05 PM)Protheroe Wrote: There are 3 million dividend remunerated directors of small companies, or the newly self employed who are possibly more deserving...

Did all of them stop working Proth or is that the total number of directors in the UK? Also divided remuneration - isn't that a way of avoiding tax from which they have benefitted over however many years they have been receiving the dividends (otherwise what is the point)?

I don't how many stopped working, but plenty of my friends have - particularly in travel, hospitality & other personal services.

The tax advantages are marginal these days, more's the pity. Though why anyone in permanent employment or on a fixed income without company debt secured by PGs should resent that I find hard to fathom anyway.

You can bet we will all be absolutely hammered when this is all over despite having received nothing like the largesse doled out through furlough or SEISS.
Reply
#14
(10-02-2020, 12:54 PM)yeoman lai Wrote: Spot on cornish.. There are far, far more important things for the Gov to spend money on.

Edit*.. This may come across as me being sarcastic.. It's not.

Different, I know, but almost every day on the news, a leading figure comes on from one industry / sector or another, saying ` unless the Government ( taxpayer), helps us out, we are doomed etc `. 
The other day, the bloke that owns The Cavern club in Liverpool said they are losing £20,000 a week, they and other music clubs need government help and so on, we are an iconic venue etc. What is wrong with some of the famous musicians who started out there giving them a hand ? To the likes of Paul McCartney, £200,000 would be like me giving somebody a tenner.
Reply
#15
I don’t think the government or the premier league should bail out lower league clubs but going forward there should be a fairer distribution of the media millions. 
Maybe the players in the Prem on mega money could donate a weeks wages each to help out the lower league clubs but I don’t think that’s gonna happen
Reply
#16
Why should prem players donate their wages for clubs who have been run piss poorly it's not their responsibility......unfortunately as rishi said they cant save every job and that includes football clubs .
Reply
#17
(10-02-2020, 01:43 PM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(10-02-2020, 01:16 PM)strawman Wrote:
(10-02-2020, 01:09 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(10-02-2020, 01:05 PM)Protheroe Wrote: There are 3 million dividend remunerated directors of small companies, or the newly self employed who are possibly more deserving...

Did all of them stop working Proth or is that the total number of directors in the UK? Also divided remuneration - isn't that a way of avoiding tax from which they have benefitted over however many years they have been receiving the dividends (otherwise what is the point)?

Unless things have changed dividends avoid Employers and Employees NI not Income Tax. However as dividends have to be paid out of profit then Corporation Tax will have been paid on that profit as well. I'm a few years out of date though

Dividends at Basic Rate pay 26.5% tax - 19% Corp Tax and 7.5% on the dividend.

Through payroll it would be 20% PAYE, 12% E'ees and 13.8% E'ers, but the Corp Tx is reduced by the Gross Wage and E'ers NIC.

There's not a lot in it now up to Basic Rate.

Divi Route
Salary £8500
Dividends £41,500

Tax payable £2813
Lost CT Saving £7885
Total Tax £10698
Take Home Pay £47187


Salary Route
Salary £50K
PAYE £7500
E'ee NIC 4859
Take home £37,641
E'ee NIC £5688

Tax\NIC on salary£18047
CT Relief (£10581)
Actual Tax liability £7466

So, more take home but more tax.  If you tried a salary route to give you the same take home pay then it would get more expensive obviously.  It's not the saving it once was and to be honest what's wrong with a bit of a tax incentive for people that have the bollocks to go out and start their own company?

Self-employed people pay less NIC than employed people but they got a bail out.

Some did. Some of us got absolutely jack all and can't claim any sort of benefits or grants either.
Reply
#18
Surely it is not beyond the capabilities of people to submit proof of matchday income to the relevant people (Premier League, FA, EFL) and for this sum to be given to Championship (non-parachute clubs) L1, L2 and National League clubs as 0% loans. Repay them over say 10yrs. Job done.
Reply
#19
You really trust some of these slimeball chairman to not rig the accounts.
Reply
#20
(10-02-2020, 05:15 PM)The liquidator Wrote: You really trust some of these slimeball chairman to not rig the accounts.

Shirley figures can be checked against most recent submitted accounts though. Matchday income is usually declared. If they suspect someone is taking the piss
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)