Handball
#21
Handball decisions becoming a joke. Ball hits Diers hand. Pen given. Ball hits Chelsea players hand yesterday. Yet they are still given the goal.
Reply
#22
Ouch ouch ouch. But couldn’t happen to a nicer club or manager.

I swear they do this for talking points.
Reply
#23
(09-27-2020, 02:56 PM)Duffers Wrote: Sounds like there’s been a dodgy penalty in the Spurs - Newcastle game.

Not watching but on the BBC updates they are incredulous it’s been given.

I just saw it. Much less blatant than Chelsea's, yet a penalty shot was given allowing Newcastle to draw. Hit the defender in the back of the arm, high up near the shoulder. How can they justify calling that and not calling Chelsea. Absolutely horrible.
Reply
#24
Whoever thought VAR is a good idea is a f in W****r it’s ruining football. This hand ball rule is total crap.
When is a ref going to have the bottle to not give it.
Reply
#25
(09-27-2020, 02:58 PM)scotbaggie Wrote:
(09-27-2020, 02:56 PM)Duffers Wrote: Sounds like there’s been a dodgy penalty in the Spurs - Newcastle game.

Not watching but on the BBC updates they are incredulous it’s been given.

I just saw it. Much less blatant than Chelsea's, yet a penalty shot was given allowing Newcastle to draw. Hit the defender in the back high up near the shoulder. How can they justify calling that and not calling Chelsea. Absolutely horrible.

Absolutely
Reply
#26
(09-27-2020, 03:00 PM)wba13 Wrote: Whoever thought VAR is a good idea is a f in W****r it’s ruining football. This hand ball rule is total crap.
When is a ref going to have the bottle to not give it.

It’s not the technology that’s at fault. It’s the use of it
Reply
#27
Where's the common sense in football. It's handball if a player uses his arm intentionally to stop the ball, anything else no. Simple.
Reply
#28
I've never wanted VAR.
In the name of consistency we've taken decisions out of refs' hands. 
Given also that a ref is marked- presumably- against a scorecard which refers to his following the rules, then he has crucial decisions taken out of his hands.
So I guess, following the rules, the Spurs handball has to be given, daft though I think it is. A ref has no leeway.
I'd get rid of var and give decisions back to the ref.
The argument that crucial decisions will be got right is clearly... wrong!
Reply
#29
The ref has given that.

Not VAR.

It’s shocking. He isn’t even looking at the ball. There’s not a thing he can do.

Mourinho’s interview could be ‘special’ Big Grin
Reply
#30
Johnnykayeengland Wrote:I've never wanted VAR.
In the name of consistency we've taken decisions out of refs' hands. 
Given also that a ref is marked- presumably- against a scorecard which refers to his following the rules, then he has crucial decisions taken out of his hands.
So I guess, following the rules, the Spurs handball has to be given, daft though I think it is. A ref has no leeway.
I'd get rid of var and give decisions back to the ref.
The argument that crucial decisions will be got right is clearly... wrong!

Having watched MOTD and then we have today's controversy, I'm convinced a case can be made for any outcome. It really could work and yet has simply muddied the water. In my experience, fans of every club would like it binned.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: