Johnstone
(09-27-2020, 10:50 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(09-27-2020, 10:17 AM)MancBaggie Wrote:
(09-27-2020, 10:09 AM)billybassett Wrote:
(09-27-2020, 09:59 AM)wba13 Wrote:
(09-27-2020, 08:48 AM)The liquidator Wrote: A bit harsh on Sj mount hit that early and with power he was unsighted by the defender .

You are right liquidator, but even when SJ Pulls of great saves he gets no praise, he played well yesterday has also played well so far this season, he’s had no chance with any of the goals. I think it’s about time our defenders started to help him out. All the SJ haters see is  bad in him and will never except him. Personally it might be a good thing to sell him because he will never get the praise he deserves at the Albion.   Straight swap for Butland .

Gave him praise last week at Everton and he has made some blinding saves over the 2 years.. A goalkeeper can make a 10pt swing on a season. Ask Lampard about Kepa, ask Klopp about Mignolet. He's a 6'2 keeper that plays 5'9 , no comms, little foot movement. Give Button a go and let's see if Johnson really is our best keeper

Bang on

Surprised to see you calling for Button here Manc.

I don’t think Johnstone did anything wrong yesterday. We lack a leader at the back, but that’s not just down to him, a more organised back line would help immeasurably. We just don’t seem to have that desire across the back line to get a head on the ball or the no nonsense approach to getting rid... take HRK’s feeble clearance at the death yesterday.

The lack of an aerial leader at the back is putting a lot more pressure on SJ to come for balls when he’s just not good at that.

From what I’ve seen of Button is he comes off his line more, but doesn’t have the reactions or the agility of SJ.... I mean Grealish goes down faster than Button.

A man you've seen play just twice is now not good enough to be given a chance to show how good/bad he is but a keeper I've watched for 2 yrs and nigh on 90 matches I'm not supposed to have an opinion on and say is a liability. He's the only thing that's not been changed in a defence that's conceded 10s of goals in 2years.

Mignolet played behind Van Dyke and was still garbage.

You ask for an aerial leader - Bartley was talking all the way through that game yesterday. The only time Johnson did really come out he punched Bartley mostly and the ball dropped in our box. Useless.
Reply
He isnt foster he will never be foster .
Reply
(09-27-2020, 11:01 AM)The liquidator Wrote: He isnt foster he will never be foster .

I know. But I don't know why he's an immoveable object between the sticks. Give Button 5 games and let's see. (i hope you liked the little dig too...)
Reply
What if we lose the 5 games with him in goal because he isnt used to the defence?

I'm not arsed either way but if he is to be dropped let it for be for howlers billy
Reply
(09-27-2020, 11:03 AM)The liquidator Wrote: What if we lose the 5 games with him in goal because he isnt used to the defence?

Come on Mr Liq you've a better argument in you than that...

What if Button makes a big difference and we keep 5 clean sheets...

(09-27-2020, 11:03 AM)The liquidator Wrote: What if we lose the 5 games with him in goal because he isnt used to the defence?

I'm not arsed either way but if he is to be dropped let it for be for howlers billy

He's made plenty of howlers and never been dropped.
Reply
(09-27-2020, 11:02 AM)billybassett Wrote:
(09-27-2020, 11:01 AM)The liquidator Wrote: He isnt foster he will never be foster .

I know. But I don't know why he's an immoveable object between the sticks. Give Button 5 games and let's see. (i hope you liked the little dig too...)

He’s clearly got a problem with shots from distance, due to his poor footwork, however dropping him isn’t the answer. 

You’d think something like that could be coached easy enough. On the rare occasions I got some proper goalkeeping coaching as a kid it was something we’d work on a lot, as it’s vitally important. Have a look at Villa’s goal on Monday for a great example of why.
Reply
(09-27-2020, 11:01 AM)The liquidator Wrote: He isnt foster he will never be foster .

And neither will 99% of 'keepers. Who's acceptable?
Reply
We wouldn't pay the money to get a decent replacement in ......there is your problem.
Reply
Andy Townsend blamed Johnstone 100% for the first goal. Not moving on his line so he wasn't in a good position to see the shot coming in.
Reply
(09-27-2020, 11:00 AM)billybassett Wrote:
(09-27-2020, 10:50 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(09-27-2020, 10:17 AM)MancBaggie Wrote:
(09-27-2020, 10:09 AM)billybassett Wrote:
(09-27-2020, 09:59 AM)wba13 Wrote: You are right liquidator, but even when SJ Pulls of great saves he gets no praise, he played well yesterday has also played well so far this season, he’s had no chance with any of the goals. I think it’s about time our defenders started to help him out. All the SJ haters see is  bad in him and will never except him. Personally it might be a good thing to sell him because he will never get the praise he deserves at the Albion.   Straight swap for Butland .

Gave him praise last week at Everton and he has made some blinding saves over the 2 years.. A goalkeeper can make a 10pt swing on a season. Ask Lampard about Kepa, ask Klopp about Mignolet. He's a 6'2 keeper that plays 5'9 , no comms, little foot movement. Give Button a go and let's see if Johnson really is our best keeper

Bang on

Surprised to see you calling for Button here Manc.

I don’t think Johnstone did anything wrong yesterday. We lack a leader at the back, but that’s not just down to him, a more organised back line would help immeasurably. We just don’t seem to have that desire across the back line to get a head on the ball or the no nonsense approach to getting rid... take HRK’s feeble clearance at the death yesterday.

The lack of an aerial leader at the back is putting a lot more pressure on SJ to come for balls when he’s just not good at that.

From what I’ve seen of Button is he comes off his line more, but doesn’t have the reactions or the agility of SJ.... I mean Grealish goes down faster than Button.

A man you've seen play just twice is now not good enough to be given a chance to show how good/bad he is but a keeper I've watched for 2 yrs and nigh on 90 matches I'm not supposed to have an opinion on and say is a liability. He's the only thing that's not been changed in a defence that's conceded 10s of goals in 2years.

Mignolet played behind Van Dyke and was still garbage.

You ask for an aerial leader - Bartley was talking all the way through that game yesterday. The only time Johnson did really come out he punched Bartley mostly and the ball dropped in our box. Useless.

That’s not what I’m saying at all, I’m saying I’ve not seen Johnstone do anything to deserve being dropped yet. Which of the goals we’ve conceded this season should he have done better for? He is yet to cost us a goal... meanwhile, in his 2 appearances so far I’ve seen nothing from Button that makes me think we’ve got a budding Buffon waiting to usurp Johnstone from the bench.

I get that older football fans want to see goalie come and catch a ball when it comes into the box, but how many still do? Teams defend deeper at set pieces now, keepers are told to stay on their line, and players no longer mark the post. It’s all about cutting a delivery out before it makes it into the danger zone, instead of letting it into the danger zone hoping the keeper claims it.  Ever find yourself bemoaning corners not beating the first man anymore?! It’s how teams defend them (unless Phillips is taking them, because he is garbage).

I really do not know why people let Johnstone’s presence in our team annoy them so much. He’s probably 5th or 6th down the list of players that need replacing.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: