Five at the back
#1
When did this start to happen? Did we play that way all pre-season, or did it start when Ivanovic came onto the radar? Is this the system Zenit St P have been using during their recent spell of success?

What I'm trying to understand is whether Bilic is setting up for his new signing or just trying to shore up a poor defence. Or maybe accepting that his undroppable midfield duo can't provide the cover. I don't like the system and it hasn't worked so far - although we conceded far too many softish goals from set-pieces and crosses last season with a flat back four. So maybe Bilic can't coach a defence.

As with the Moore/Jones Championship season, defence will be our weakness this season, unless Bilic changes his ways and starts to coach common sense and caution.
Reply
#2
Bilic has already alluded to it being used due to lack of midfield options and wanting to make us a bit harder to break down.

Probably the stupidest thing I’ve ever said, considering we’ve conceded 8 goals in 2 games but I can kind of see where he’s coming from.
Reply
#3
Chesh, Zenit played a 4-3-3 with Ivanovic at CB

I just wonder what that is his preferred formation going forward? Maybe converting Kipré into a RB to offer more pace too.

Johnstone - Button

Kipré - Furlong
Ivanović - Bartley
Ajayi - O’Shea
Gibbs - Townsend

Livermore - Field
Gallagher - Krovinovic
Sawyers - Harper

Pereria - Phillips
Grant - Robinson
Diangana - Edwards
Reply
#4
I think it’s a combination of things. For starters, with Gallagher missing for Leicester, unavailable yesterday, and no Krov, he only really has two senior central midfielders. Without an extra body in there if the quality he wants he clearly doesn’t see that we can protect a weak defence though, especially with both Grady and Pereira in the side, so he’s tried to shore things up with an extra defender.

What’s happened in reality as we now have a weak defence with an extra body, and none of those players to take responsibility to organise or mark. We also can’t get hold of a game in midfield, which adds more pressure.

Not sure it’s based on anything Ivanovic did with Zenit as they played a 4, but given his age and lack of pace for this level I wouldn’t be surprised if protecting him is part of his thinking.

Will be interesting to see what happens when Gallagher is available, because we desperately need a 3rd body in midfield and I think we’d be much more comfortable with a back 4.
Reply
#5
If old Bran can form a partnership with any one of the others (and I'm guessing it won't be Bartley, but you never know) then we'll still need Field to shield them. Sawyers can't play that role and Livermore doesn't have the discipline to sit tight and cover. For me, O'Shea would be first choice at right back in a back four, so Kipre and Ajayi are fighting for a place.

A properly functional back four. What are the chances of that happening, eh?
Reply
#6
(09-20-2020, 08:34 AM)ABBaggie Wrote: I think it’s a combination of things. For starters, with Gallagher missing for Leicester, unavailable yesterday, and no Krov, he only really has two senior central midfielders. Without an extra body in there if the quality he wants he clearly doesn’t see that we can protect a weak defence though, especially with both Grady and Pereira in the side, so he’s tried to shore things up with an extra defender.

What’s happened in reality as we now have a weak defence with an extra body, and none of those players to take responsibility to organise or mark. We also can’t get hold of a game in midfield, which adds more pressure.

Not sure it’s based on anything Ivanovic did with Zenit as they played a 4, but given his age and lack of pace for this level I wouldn’t be surprised if protecting him is part of his thinking.

Will be interesting to see what happens when Gallagher is available, because we desperately need a 3rd body in midfield and I think we’d be much more comfortable with a back 4.

I dunno about that. When we brought in Mccauley, he was older than Ivanovic, and hardly blessed with pace himself. But he had defensive smarts, was a great organiser,  something I'm hoping Ivanovic will add. Him alongside Ajai, with Oshea and Gibbs at full back , hopefully will be adequate,  especially with Galagher replacing Sawyers .
Reply
#7
This talk of Sawyers being replaced. Not a chance. Bilic loves him.

Also G Mac was 32 when we signed him.
Reply
#8
(09-20-2020, 09:15 AM)Super_Slav Wrote: This talk of Sawyers being replaced. Not a chance. Bilic loves him.

Also G Mac was 32 when we signed him.

He wont love him if he keeps giving chances away like the 1st half Yesterday
Reply
#9
(09-20-2020, 08:34 AM)ABBaggie Wrote: I think it’s a combination of things. For starters, with Gallagher missing for Leicester, unavailable yesterday, and no Krov, he only really has two senior central midfielders. Without an extra body in there if the quality he wants he clearly doesn’t see that we can protect a weak defence though, especially with both Grady and Pereira in the side, so he’s tried to shore things up with an extra defender.

What’s happened in reality as we now have a weak defence with an extra body, and none of those players to take responsibility to organise or mark. We also can’t get hold of a game in midfield, which adds more pressure.

Not sure it’s based on anything Ivanovic did with Zenit as they played a 4, but given his age and lack of pace for this level I wouldn’t be surprised if protecting him is part of his thinking.

Will be interesting to see what happens when Gallagher is available, because we desperately need a 3rd body in midfield and I think we’d be much more comfortable with a back 4.

Good post.

I worry that Bilic has introduced 5 at the back with a view to playing Ivanovic. At least once he gets going the defence should be a bit more organised.

The problem with 5 at the back is that it inevitably makes us weaker in midfield. Thought yesterday in the first half we competed reasonably well in midfield, especially considering how much money have thrown this window at their midfield. But it's going to be hard work, if we continue to play this system, especially with the lack of quality we have at wing back.

Hoping Ivanaovic has enough to be able to operate in a back 4, and this is a temporary measure whilst we wait for him to get up to speed.
Reply
#10
(09-20-2020, 01:27 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(09-20-2020, 08:34 AM)ABBaggie Wrote: I think it’s a combination of things. For starters, with Gallagher missing for Leicester, unavailable yesterday, and no Krov, he only really has two senior central midfielders. Without an extra body in there if the quality he wants he clearly doesn’t see that we can protect a weak defence though, especially with both Grady and Pereira in the side, so he’s tried to shore things up with an extra defender.

What’s happened in reality as we now have a weak defence with an extra body, and none of those players to take responsibility to organise or mark. We also can’t get hold of a game in midfield, which adds more pressure.

Not sure it’s based on anything Ivanovic did with Zenit as they played a 4, but given his age and lack of pace for this level I wouldn’t be surprised if protecting him is part of his thinking.

Will be interesting to see what happens when Gallagher is available, because we desperately need a 3rd body in midfield and I think we’d be much more comfortable with a back 4.

Good post.

I worry that Bilic has introduced 5 at the back with a view to playing Ivanovic. At least once he gets going the defence should be a bit more organised.

The problem with 5 at the back is that it inevitably makes us weaker in midfield. Thought yesterday in the first half we competed reasonably well in midfield, especially considering how much money have thrown this window at their midfield. But it's going to be hard work, if we continue to play this system, especially with the lack of quality we have at wing back.

Hoping Ivanaovic has enough to be able to operate in a back 4, and this is a temporary measure whilst we wait for him to get up to speed.

I think playing with a back 3/5 can be great, but more often than not that’s when it’s used to get more players forward, so finding a way to get 6 of the 10 outfielders ahead of the ball with wing backs playing high, 2/3 forwards and a midfielder or 2 in support.

In our case though we’ve clearly switched to add more protection around a weak defence, and have sacrificed a midfielder to do so. What we end up with too often is a back 5, 2 sat in front and an isolated front 3. I just don’t think the current options available make it a viable system for us. It will always end up with us having to play a more defensive style.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: