VAR
#1
Bilic complaining about it post-match, to be fair he has a very valid point. Didn't check for the push on Furlong by Richarlison that was a pretty big cause for Furlong failing to clear and playing the ball backwards, reason why he was sent off at half time. Same thing happened against Liverpool in the FA Cup where Dawson (?) had his goal disallowed for offside because Barry was obstructing the view of the keeper but one of our players was being fouled in the box before the ball went in.
Reply
#2
(09-19-2020, 04:21 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Bilic complaining about it post-match, to be fair he has a very valid point. Didn't check for the push on Furlong by Richarlison that was a pretty big cause for Furlong failing to clear and playing the ball backwards, reason why he was sent off at half time. Same thing happened against Liverpool in the FA Cup where Dawson (?) had his goal disallowed for offside because Barry was obstructing the view of the keeper but one of our players was being fouled in the box before the ball went in.

Do not get var definite foul on furlong. So goal should not have stood. 
Now watching UTD v Palace and palace full back Ward just lead with his arm not even a foul given deserved at least a boring. Fuck it off it’s useless.
Reply
#3
Anyone else get the feeling that if the roles had been reversed, VAR wouldn't even have been consulted.

Still looked offside to me after watching the replay - no reason given as to why it was over ruled and probably what Slavan was trying to find out from the ref. - Fumin
Reply
#4
Once again it’s the absolute inconsistencies that leave a bad taste.
Just watching the manure game. Atkinson is told to go and look at the penalty himself. Dean wasn’t told to do that for the Everton goal.
They spent over a minute looking at that first goal today to determine who played the ball yet nobody thought to look for a foul in the build up.
Everton’s third goal came from a free kick (before the one they actually scored from) where 2 players were still on the floor, at the spot of the foul, and Dean allowed it to be taken 6/7 yards further forward. Whilst this happens every game how on earth can you take offside to within a mm using VAR yet your are happy to let a free kick be taken that much further forward. Livermore complained to Dean immediately about where it was taken. Nothing happened.

Nothing takes away our sloppy defending btw.

The technology isn’t the issue. The use of it absolutely is
Reply
#5
(09-19-2020, 05:49 PM)igorbalis Wrote: Anyone else get the feeling that if the roles had been reversed, VAR wouldn't even have been consulted.

Still looked offside to me after watching the replay - no reason given as to why it was over ruled and probably what Slavan was trying to find out from the ref. - Fumin

They believe he was played onside because the ball was not last played by a team mate but by Furlong however, the rule states
  • A player in an offside position receiving the ball from an opponent who deliberately plays the ball, including by deliberate handball, is not considered to have gained an advantage, unless it was a deliberate save by any opponent. 
As the ball bounced off the back of Furlong's head it was plainly not deliberately played and the offside should have stood.

Shit ref as ever
Reply
#6
VAR is there to prevent the big clubs being caught out by the little clubs. That might not be the intent, but it's how it works out.

It's interesting to compare it with DRS in cricket. The "rules of engagement" for DRS are agreed at the start of a series. How many reviews, what technology etc. Once a review is called, they check everything. There is acceptance of "umpire's call" - so if a marginal decision is made by an umpire and proven to be reasonable by DRS, the on-field decision stands.

There's none of that reasonableness in VAR. So you get the Villa goal where the technology failed. Even though the VAR man could see it, he couldn't declare it a goal. Today VAR was used to detect a deflection off our player and over-rule a linesman's off-side flag - but the push on our player wasn't even considered. Refs can decide whether or not to review the video themselves. It all just dilutes accountability to the point where no-one is responsible.

(09-19-2020, 08:54 PM)strawman Wrote:
(09-19-2020, 05:49 PM)igorbalis Wrote: Anyone else get the feeling that if the roles had been reversed, VAR wouldn't even have been consulted.

Still looked offside to me after watching the replay - no reason given as to why it was over ruled and probably what Slavan was trying to find out from the ref. - Fumin

They believe he was played onside because the ball was not last played by a team mate but by Furlong however, the rule states
  • A player in an offside position receiving the ball from an opponent who deliberately plays the ball, including by deliberate handball, is not considered to have gained an advantage, unless it was a deliberate save by any opponent. 
As the ball bounced off the back of Furlong's head it was plainly not deliberately played and the offside should have stood.

Shit ref as ever

Mike Dean is truly shit.
Reply
#7
(09-19-2020, 10:19 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: VAR is there to prevent the big clubs being caught out by the little clubs. That might not be the intent, but it's how it works out.

It's interesting to compare it with DRS in cricket. The "rules of engagement" for DRS are agreed at the start of a series. How many reviews, what technology etc. Once a review is called, they check everything. There is acceptance of "umpire's call" - so if a marginal decision is made by an umpire and proven to be reasonable by DRS, the on-field decision stands.

There's none of that reasonableness in VAR. So you get the Villa goal where the technology failed. Even though the VAR man could see it, he couldn't declare it a goal. Today VAR was used to detect a deflection off our player and over-rule a linesman's off-side flag - but the push on our player wasn't even considered. Refs can decide whether or not to review the video themselves. It all just dilutes accountability to the point where no-one is responsible.

(09-19-2020, 08:54 PM)strawman Wrote:
(09-19-2020, 05:49 PM)igorbalis Wrote: Anyone else get the feeling that if the roles had been reversed, VAR wouldn't even have been consulted.

Still looked offside to me after watching the replay - no reason given as to why it was over ruled and probably what Slavan was trying to find out from the ref. - Fumin

They believe he was played onside because the ball was not last played by a team mate but by Furlong however, the rule states
  • A player in an offside position receiving the ball from an opponent who deliberately plays the ball, including by deliberate handball, is not considered to have gained an advantage, unless it was a deliberate save by any opponent. 
As the ball bounced off the back of Furlong's head it was plainly not deliberately played and the offside should have stood.

Shit ref as ever

Mike Dean is truly shit.

He's an arrogant wanker and always has been
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: