He’s on his way, he’s on his way. How did we entice him? I don’t know.
#51
(09-18-2020, 12:07 PM)MrFizz Wrote: Dear Beg

Perhaps you should start your posts with 'VFIP' just so we know!

Interesting take on Samatta. Have to admit i wasn't impressed with us being linked. However having read your take on him i've mellowed somewhat. But it does beg the question if he's good enough why would you consider sending him to us?

VFIP  Wink

I think the only reason he is available is that the Villa owners are looking to spend big money and want to try and get more of a guaranteed return. We also have Wesley returning from injury in Oct / Nov. When Samatta first joined I think every Villa fan wrote about how they liked his attitude on the pitch. We works hard and just looks like he needs a goal or two to kick off as a decent striker. The lockdown came at a good time for Villa but at a bad time for Samatta. Also, he just moved country etc so it was a huge change for him and it is understandable that he will take a little settling in time. There are many Villa fans that want him gone but they just moan about everything and believe we should be competing with Liverpool & City this season. More sensible fans want him to stay and Villa. I think he could be a great signing for you guys but I would prefer him to be a Villa player this season.
Reply
#52
Begley Wrote:
Beachboysbaggie Wrote:For me loan players to a PL club should be players like Batshuayi who is more or less guaranteed to deliver what Palace what him for.

Yeah but there’s not too many of them on offer. Out of interest how would you have classed Lukaku when we first got him in; a finished article type like Batshuayi or a callow youth like Gallagher?

Yep, I would have classified Lukaku as a high risk and not a good loan. Obviously that was not the case and he proved his worth. But a Lukaku is a one in a blue moon I think and I wouldn't be putting my house on a 20 year old in such a key position needed to retain PL status

Old Stroller Wrote:
Beachboysbaggie Wrote:For me loan players to a PL club should be players like Batshuayi who is more or less guaranteed to deliver what Palace what him for.

Yeah but there’s not too many of them on offer. Out of interest how would you have classed Lukaku when we first got him in; a finished article type like Batshuayi or a callow youth like Gallagher?

I've no objection to Begley being on here, as he is one of the more articulate Villa posters to have found his way to the bored, and his contributions are for the most part well informed, but I wish he would at least acknowledge the fact that he's not Albion when he joins in. 

It'd be more relevant asking him about Tammy Abraham than Romelu Lulaku in this discussion, for instance.

I have never denied I was a Villa supporter and have been very open about it. I just like football and like discussing it, I find it very interesting to get the opinion of other fans. I have posted on here a bit but I have stopped opening with I am a Villa supporter as I very often got dogs abuse. I am not interested in giving or receiving abuse. We are all just people who support our football teams and we are local rivals. The abuse Baggies fans, Blues fans and Villa fans give each other is at times fairly disgusting and that is just not my thing. If you have read my posts, I actually wished Baggies luck last season and said I hoped u get promoted. Nearly all mentions of Villa on here are hoping our players get serious injury and everything about the club fails. I think it is great having a couple of derby games with you guys this season and I would like us both to stay up and I would like Blues to join us in the PL
Just to chuck my tuppence worth in.  I don't have any problems with fans of other clubs coming on here. I, too, like to hear other perspectives. A couple of things, though.
First, there are four weeks of the transfer window left and every single club will make changes before it's out. I think our fans on here are overreacting to something that has barely begun yet.
Second, it grates when I hear "West Brom have no money". Actually Albion are pretty much the only club that does have money. They just don't spend what they don't have.  A level playing field on that would make football a lot more interesting.
Anyway, my ambition for this season is just to be in the ground at some point.
Reply
#53
(09-18-2020, 06:21 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
Begley Wrote:
Beachboysbaggie Wrote:For me loan players to a PL club should be players like Batshuayi who is more or less guaranteed to deliver what Palace what him for.

Yeah but there’s not too many of them on offer. Out of interest how would you have classed Lukaku when we first got him in; a finished article type like Batshuayi or a callow youth like Gallagher?

Yep, I would have classified Lukaku as a high risk and not a good loan. Obviously that was not the case and he proved his worth. But a Lukaku is a one in a blue moon I think and I wouldn't be putting my house on a 20 year old in such a key position needed to retain PL status

Old Stroller Wrote:
Beachboysbaggie Wrote:For me loan players to a PL club should be players like Batshuayi who is more or less guaranteed to deliver what Palace what him for.

Yeah but there’s not too many of them on offer. Out of interest how would you have classed Lukaku when we first got him in; a finished article type like Batshuayi or a callow youth like Gallagher?

I've no objection to Begley being on here, as he is one of the more articulate Villa posters to have found his way to the bored, and his contributions are for the most part well informed, but I wish he would at least acknowledge the fact that he's not Albion when he joins in. 

It'd be more relevant asking him about Tammy Abraham than Romelu Lulaku in this discussion, for instance.

I have never denied I was a Villa supporter and have been very open about it. I just like football and like discussing it, I find it very interesting to get the opinion of other fans. I have posted on here a bit but I have stopped opening with I am a Villa supporter as I very often got dogs abuse. I am not interested in giving or receiving abuse. We are all just people who support our football teams and we are local rivals. The abuse Baggies fans, Blues fans and Villa fans give each other is at times fairly disgusting and that is just not my thing. If you have read my posts, I actually wished Baggies luck last season and said I hoped u get promoted. Nearly all mentions of Villa on here are hoping our players get serious injury and everything about the club fails. I think it is great having a couple of derby games with you guys this season and I would like us both to stay up and I would like Blues to join us in the PL
Just to chuck my tuppence worth in.  I don't have any problems with fans of other clubs coming on here. I, too, like to hear other perspectives. A couple of things, though.
First, there are four weeks of the transfer window left and every single club will make changes before it's out. I think our fans on here are overreacting to something that has barely begun yet.
Second, it grates when I hear "West Brom have no money". Actually Albion are pretty much the only club that does have money. They just don't spend what they don't have.  A level playing field on that would make football a lot more interesting.
Anyway, my ambition for this season is just to be in the ground at some point.

I like your ambition for this season Smile 

I don't think I have seen anyone say that West Brom have no money. Haven't u spent about 30m this window already? As for a level playing field unfortunately that will never happen. The teams at the top of the PL are so far ahead of the rest that it is impossible to level the field. Unfortunately to stay in the PL costs crazy money and forces newly promoted clubs to take extra risk.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)