Ratings
#1
Benjamin. 7. Solid performance but never tried. Good competition in that area now.

Peltier. 6. Never noticed him which isn't bad in his role as back up utility defender. 
Kipre. 7. Big, powerful, quick, abit clumsy. Him and Ajayi either side of Bane could work. 
O'Shea. 7. Will be a serious defender in years to come. Has the ability to come out into midfield too. 
Townsend. 6. Not a bad sbowing, but was sloppy at time's on the ball. 

Grosiki. 5. Just not a fan. 
Harper. 7. As always with Rak each touch is an 8 or a 4. He just needs to work out his consistency and all round impact. Extra point for the goal. 
Field. 6. See Harper  but the exact opposite. Don't think he'll make the grade without regular football. More loans or move him on for his sake. 
Edwards. 8. MOTM. Good energy and ambition in possession. Good sub option. 

Austin. 5. Poor, slow, looked way off it. 
HRK. 7. Good  mature performance and a good goal. 

Subs:

Sawyers. 6. Allowed us to keep the ball ticking over. There's a degree of the Jimmy Morrisons about him in as much as you notice him more when he isn't there.
Phillips. 6. Looked like he hadn't played for weeks funnily enough. Needs games as we all know what he can do. 
Robinson. 7. Good energy movement for the goal.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#2
Field deserves a 7. He's the sort of defensive midfielder we will need in the Prem. Proved under Meggo he can do it at this level.
Reply
#3
Honestly I thought prior to the goal HRK was absolutely shocking, and not much better after. Austin will be remembered for the misses but his overall contribution was fine. A couple of cracking final balls. The problem is I don't see how he can fit in the team if he's now struggling to score and has lost his pace.

What was clear is that Robinson is head and shoulders above both.

Also thought the defence were a bit shaky initially but got better as the game progressed. Would go with:

Button 7

Peltier. 7.
Kipre. 7.
O'Shea. 7.
Townsend. 6.

Grosicki 4
Harper. 7
Field. 6
Edwards. 9

Austin. 6
HRK. 6

Subs:

Sawyers. 5.
Phillips. 6.
Robinson. 7.
Reply
#4
Austin is turning in to Ricky Lambert time to move on
Let’s
Try and get some money for him

Blues would be a good move for him
Reply
#5
Sorry don’t get the Edwards hype except for the brilliant skill for the goal he was very average. Field was way better . Button did everything asked of him. Back 4 solid midfield ok Austin and Kanu not good enough . Robinson did more in 5 mins than them 2 in 75.
Reply
#6
(09-16-2020, 07:23 PM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote: Field deserves a 7. He's the sort of defensive midfielder we will need in the Prem. Proved under Meggo he can do it at this level.

You mean he did well in two games?

Jury is still out for me.
Reply
#7
Button 7 solid
Peltier 6 steady
Kipre 6.5 promising
O'Shea 6.5 again promising,
Townsend 6 steady

Harper 7 - good goal, slightly the curate's egg, plays his best football in the opposition's half,
Field 6.5 steady needs an injection of confidence

Grosicki 6 - tonight's scapegoat? nowhere near as bad as some are suggesting
Edwards 7 .5 - Entertaining

HRK 6 - Good goal, sloppy in possession and passing poor
Austin 5 - Missed opportunity for hi to impress

Subs
Phillips 6.5 thought he did well when he came on
Sawyers 6 good management to give him some time tonight, confidence builder
Robinson not on long enough to rate

Overall decent performance, first half disjointed, but that's inevitable given few of these players given the limited game time so many have had in recent times.
Reply
#8
(09-16-2020, 07:30 PM)Sliced Wrote: Honestly I thought prior to the goal HRK was absolutely shocking, and not much better after. Austin will be remembered for the misses but his overall contribution was fine. A couple of cracking final balls. The problem is I don't see how he can fit in the team if he's now struggling to score and has lost his pace.

What was clear is that Robinson is head and shoulders above both.

Also thought the defence were a bit shaky initially but got better as the game progressed. Would go with:

Button 7

Peltier.  7.
Kipre. 7.
O'Shea. 7.
Townsend. 6.

Grosicki 4
Harper. 7
Field. 6
Edwards. 9

Austin. 6
HRK. 6

Subs:

Sawyers. 5.
Phillips. 6. 
Robinson. 7.

Thought Austin was awful

Button 7

Peltier.  7
Kipre. 7
O'Shea. 7
Townsend. 6 

Grosicki 4
Harper. 7
Field. 7
Edwards. 8

Austin. 3
HRK. 6 

Subs:

Sawyers. 6
Phillips. 5 
Robinson. 7
Reply
#9
(09-16-2020, 07:37 PM)HUGHIE REED31 Wrote: Austin is turning in to Ricky Lambert time to move on
Let’s
Try and get some money for him

Blues would be a good move for him

How weird I was thinking exactly this a minute ago. I don’t think Austin has much left in him at all. Might do a couple of seasons in the Championship but he’s past his best and unfortunately none of it was at the Hawthorns.
Reply
#10
Quote:Grosicki 6 - tonight's scapegoat? nowhere near as bad as some are suggesting


He was fine, a bit wasteful.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: