Biggest disappointing signings of all time
#11
(09-09-2020, 01:23 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: So as an Albion career that failed to get going, despite a huge fee, I wonder where Burke sits in the list of biggest big fee disappointments?
To me, a fan since 1975, I'd place him alongside Luke Moore, but still behind David Mills. No one else really jumps out, but sure there are a good few.
One thing I'm glad about though, as someone who recalls both well, with the constant social media chatter and Talkshite being invented since David Mills days, is that we didn't have social media then.
Reading jibes and general negative stuff based on underwhelming footballers who for some reason don't gel at the club is draining.
We've had very few failures past decade or more, which says much about our general progression as a club.

Geoff Hurst.  Big Grin
Reply
#12
Still got to be Paul Groves for me.
Reply
#13
Wasn’t Borja Valero our record signing at the time? Never really happened for him here but he’s been a success everywhere else he’s played.
Reply
#14
As a kid, remember us signing Geoff Hurst. Other kids saying `Great, world cup winner` , etc, etc. He was way past it.

Mike Phelan otherwise.
Reply
#15
I'm just baffled how Luke Moore got on Spandau's list. I think he just about met the expectation of everyone else.
Reply
#16
Ministry Of Silly Signings Wrote:As a kid, remember us signing Geoff Hurst. Other kids saying `Great, world cup winner` , etc, etc. He was way past it.

Mike Phelan otherwise.

I remember losing away to Stoke ( which we always did ) 4 1 and Phelan committed a bad foul, the whole away end immediately started chanting off off off.
Reply
#17
(09-09-2020, 01:56 PM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: I'm just baffled how Luke Moore got on Spandau's list. I think he just about met the expectation of everyone else.

He was supposed to be around £5m worth of striker in the Curtis Davies move, which was a lot for us then. Seemed a step up at the time and many had great hopes for him as being a step above what we had.
Maybe what disappointed me more is how we persisted with him for so long.
Reply
#18
(09-09-2020, 01:56 PM)cornishbaggie Wrote:
Ministry Of Silly Signings Wrote:As a kid, remember us signing Geoff Hurst. Other kids saying `Great, world cup winner` , etc, etc. He was way past it.

Mike Phelan otherwise.

I remember losing away to Stoke ( which we always did ) 4 1 and Phelan committed a bad foul, the whole away end immediately started chanting off off off.

God, we were rubbish then, but, for me , Phelan was one of our worst.
Andy Townsend also worth a mention, although, we were once on holiday in Brixham, our lad and and his mate were overjoyed to hear on the radio that we had signed Brown Ideye! Spent the rest of an idyllic week in Devon thinking we had Nigeria`s version of Messi.
Reply
#19
(09-09-2020, 02:08 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(09-09-2020, 01:56 PM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: I'm just baffled how Luke Moore got on Spandau's list. I think he just about met the expectation of everyone else.

He was supposed to be around £5m worth of striker in the Curtis Davies move, which was a lot for us then. Seemed a step up at the time and many had great hopes for him as being a step above what we had.
Maybe what disappointed me more is how we persisted with him for so long.

Are you sure about that? I seem to recall pretty much everyone thought Villa had got one over us and so it proved.
Reply
#20
For those of us of a certain age David Mills by a country mile but I'd also add Colin Suggett, who when he signed was supposed to be the man that would turn a good cup side into league champions. It started so well two goals in his first game at Southampton but was downhill afterwards, he also missed a sitter at Wembley in the league cup final and cost us the cup.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: