Following the science
#11
(09-01-2020, 10:00 PM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote: Covid deaths have been below flu and pneumonia deaths for two and a half months now. What science are they following?

I've heard this but not seen anything to back it up, how many flu deaths have there been in the last couple of months? I didn't think it was flu season. And pneumonia is quite common especially with the elderly that die of natural causes, it was on both my Mom and Dad's death certificate.
Reply
#12
Pneumonia is the end result of a lot of diseases such as Aids etc. That is a very misleading route to take with regards to the stats,
Reply
#13
(09-02-2020, 07:41 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(09-01-2020, 10:00 PM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote: Covid deaths have been below flu and pneumonia deaths for two and a half months now. What science are they following?

I've heard this but not seen anything to back it up, how many flu deaths have there been in the last couple of months? I didn't think it was flu season. And pneumonia is quite common especially with the elderly that die of natural causes, it was on both my Mom and Dad's death certificate.

Scroll down to the graph

https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationa...august2020

I’m certainly not saying just open everything tomorrow, by the way. I just don’t see how they can justify another lockdown, even at local levels.
Reply
#14
Summer flu deaths are declining year on year; partly a consequence of the background protection of the annual vaccine programme. They might well have been higher than Covid-related mortality during the latter period of lockdown and distancing, but they are also less likely to spike further as measures are relaxed.

There are still too many unknowns with Covid for a direct comparison: is the virus becoming less virulent? is an element of so-called herd immunity developing? For the time being - short of a vaccine or a miracle treatment - the defining factor will be our own common sense. We can keep locking down, but there'll still be the problem of how/when to emerge.

Keep your distance, wear your masks, (cross your fingers).
Reply
#15
I agree Malc, I'm not keen on the 'it's a hoax' brigade because (like Brexit) it just divides the nation again into 'it's real and we should be shit scared of it' and 'it's not real and a government plot to control us'.

There is good evidence to show that there is minuscule risk to those under 45, and a good deal of evidence to show that if you are healthy then you will be ok.

Unfortunately, and to Proth's point above, this has been so badly handled by the government with misinformation and covering of there own arses, that the public clearly feel it is better just to stay at home. The other main point on the working from home aspect of it all is people actually like working from home so why would they want to go back to an office with an hours commute on either end of the day. We have the infrastructure to support working from home for office workers and this situation has accelerated that way of working by at least 5 years.
Reply
#16
(09-02-2020, 07:58 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Pneumonia is the end result of a lot of diseases such as Aids etc. That is a very misleading route to take with regards to the stats,

Very true Dek, but Covid deaths are also in the vast majority of cases co morbidity deaths. It’s no coincidence that deaths from heart disease, kidney disease and a few others are well down this year, as they’ve gone down as Covid deaths. Covid in many cases finishes people off in a similar way to other respiratory infections. Apologies for the crude expression but you get what I mean.
Reply
#17
Pack in this 'well they should have been coded as something else' please. There are 60k excess deaths this year, let's forget for a second that they have put down on a death certificate as different reasons, there are 60 thousand more people that have died this year than last in England and Wales alone.

And also let's not go down the route of 'well lockdown has caused a lot of those because they haven't been able to see doctors so it's cancer, or other diseases' - those won't kick in to that extent until later on this year (I believe they will be a big issue later on as well), they won't have occurred en masse yet.

If it isn't covid that has caused these extra deaths and the lack of medical care won't show the effects until later on then what else can have caused these extra deaths (whether they code them as covid, pneumonia, dementia or anything else)?

And it would be interesting to see the numbers on heart disease, kidney disease etc to support a statement like that. Do you have any I could look at?

(09-02-2020, 11:41 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(09-02-2020, 07:58 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Pneumonia is the end result of a lot of diseases such as Aids etc. That is a very misleading route to take with regards to the stats,

Very true Dek, but Covid deaths are also in the vast majority of cases co morbidity deaths. It’s no coincidence that deaths from heart disease, kidney disease and a few others are well down this year, as they’ve gone down as Covid deaths. Covid in many cases finishes people off in a similar way to other respiratory infections. Apologies for the crude expression but you get what I mean.

You see this is what winds me up about taking your info from Facebook or Twitter or Guido or whatever bullshit media you are spouting from. This is from the BHF website on this years figures "Throughout the whole of the pandemic, there were over 3,600 excess deaths from heart and circulatory diseases, some of whom will also have had Covid-19"

I won't bother wasting my time looking at kidney or the vague 'a few others' if you don't mind as they are probably bullshit as well
Reply
#18
(09-02-2020, 12:10 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Pack in this 'well they should have been coded as something else' please. There are 60k excess deaths this year, let's forget for a second that they have put down on a death certificate as different reasons, there are 60 thousand more people that have died this year than last in England and Wales alone.

And also let's not go down the route of 'well lockdown has caused a lot of those because they haven't been able to see doctors so it's cancer, or other diseases' - those won't kick in to that extent until later on this year (I believe they will be a big issue later on as well), they won't have occurred en masse yet.

If it isn't covid that has caused these extra deaths and the lack of medical care won't show the effects until later on then what else can have caused these extra deaths (whether they code them as covid, pneumonia, dementia or anything else)?

And it would be interesting to see the numbers on heart disease, kidney disease etc to support a statement like that. Do you have any I could look at?

(09-02-2020, 11:41 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(09-02-2020, 07:58 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Pneumonia is the end result of a lot of diseases such as Aids etc. That is a very misleading route to take with regards to the stats,

Very true Dek, but Covid deaths are also in the vast majority of cases co morbidity deaths. It’s no coincidence that deaths from heart disease, kidney disease and a few others are well down this year, as they’ve gone down as Covid deaths. Covid in many cases finishes people off in a similar way to other respiratory infections. Apologies for the crude expression but you get what I mean.

You see this is what winds me up about taking your info from Facebook or Twitter or Guido or whatever bullshit media you are spouting from. This is from the BHF website on this years figures "Throughout the whole of the pandemic, there were over 3,600 excess deaths from heart and circulatory diseases, some of whom will also have had Covid-19"

I won't bother wasting my time looking at kidney or the vague 'a few others' if you don't mind as they are probably bullshit as well

I didnt get the info from Facebook and Twitter, I got it from the ONS. As far as I can see, dementia, heart disease, lower respiratory disease, cerebrovasuclar disease, malignant neoplasm of trachea are the leading causes and are overall down this year. If I’m wrong I’m wrong, but that’s how it looks to me. The Facebook assumption wasn’t correct, but that’s why it’s just not worth discussing on here, too many people get arsey and make wild assumptions about where I got the info from. It was the ONS.
Reply
#19
The problem I have is the vague statements, and I can't see where on the ONS site it says that deaths, of any sort, are well down - maybe you can link me to it.

There is so much bullshit floating around about how it isn't as bad as they are making out when people are simply ignoring basic statistics - excess deaths, and the reason for that is they have the answer 'It's safe to go back to work' so they are redefining the question to suit that.

Now as it happens I've looked at the BHF figures in a bit more detail and as said they are up by about 3,600, however there is also an estimated figure that 5,000 heart disease related deaths have occurred because of lack of access to the medical treatment needed. So using this e figures and accepting an estimate is close to the truth, then the actual figure for heart disease related deaths in comparison could be down by as much as 1,400. again taking into account all of those 5,000 would have been saved. However as there are 170,000 deaths each year of this type that figure is hardly 'well down' whichever way we look at it.

The big problem is you say something like this one day, someone reads it and it spreads when it has no basis in reality. It would be great if you could link me to it BB.
Reply
#20
(09-02-2020, 01:24 PM)baggy1 Wrote: The problem I have is the vague statements, and I can't see where on the ONS site it says that deaths, of any sort, are well down - maybe you can link me to it.

There is so much bullshit floating around about how it isn't as bad as they are making out when people are simply ignoring basic statistics - excess deaths, and the reason for that is they have the answer 'It's safe to go back to work' so they are redefining the question to suit that.

Now as it happens I've looked at the BHF figures in a bit more detail and as said they are up by about 3,600, however there is also an estimated figure that 5,000 heart disease related deaths have occurred because of lack of access to the medical treatment needed. So using this e figures and accepting an estimate is close to the truth, then the actual figure for heart disease related deaths in comparison could be down by as much as 1,400. again taking into account all of those 5,000 would have been saved. However as there are 170,000 deaths each year of this type that figure is hardly 'well down' whichever way we look at it.

The big problem is you say something like this one day, someone reads it and it spreads when it has no basis in reality. It would be great if you could link me to it BB.

There are charts for the leading ten causes of deaths Each month against the five year average, and I had to add the figures together for the 7 months so far (up to July). Here’s the July one... it’s in section 5. It would be helpful if there was a chart did the year to date but annoyingly I can’t find one. I’m sure I’ve seen one a few months ago when we were only a few months into the year, but can’t seem to find one now.

https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationa...-july-2020
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)