Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(07-23-2020, 09:02 PM)Peachy Wrote: (07-23-2020, 08:23 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Scharner’s influence was massive on that squad. We recruited really well that summer, balancing a side that had already had a year in the PL, and had plenty of of talented younger players, with some experienced pros (Reid and Thomas were particularly important) ... add to that Scharner’s ludicrous self belief and Odemwingie’s class and we had enough to establish ourselves.
I fully expect us to keep faith with a lot of the players who got us promoted, however we have to remember many of our key players are on loan, and once they’re taken out we’re left with a lot more work than going into that season.
I think Slav will be true to his word and keep faith with a fair few. I think you will see the following start the season.
SJ (not convinced personally)
O'Shea
Ayayi
Livermore
Sawyers
Pereira
Grosicki
I also think we may see Krov and Robinson signed too. Would love Grady but I really do think West Ham will want to keep him.
I don't think Slav rates either of our three strikers so we have a busy summer coming up in the forward department.
Not sure I see Grosicki starting every week, think Slav more likely to go with Phillips due to his defensive work... but otherwise I agree.
I really hope he addresses the Sawyers-Livermore midfield combo... we are just far too open and PL players will relish running through the middle 4/5x a half!
Posts: 1,040
Threads: 48
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
9
07-24-2020, 04:07 AM
(This post was last modified: 07-24-2020, 04:15 AM by HLS.)
Robinson's physical attributes remind me of Odemwingie and I think he's got a similar mindset of wanting to get on the ball and make runs into space, but Odemwingie was the best finisher we've ever had at the club in our Prem era. Berahino in his prime was up there but Odemwingie scored goals from pretty much every position. I don't see Robinson being able to replicate that as of right now, but tbf he's not really had much of a chance. I'd be very happy to sign him up given the fee is no more than 7m but I wouldn't want to go into the season with him as first choice striker. An Odemwingie type would be perfect, though some on here say that Slav likes a big no.9. Not too bothered about their size, but for me, they need to have 3 attributes. Can finish, make space-making movements, and willing to defend from the front. Gayle is the obvious one for me but there may be better unknowns.~
Fortune would thrive in this team.
Something missing from the OP is that many of the players who played in the Champ season already had Prem experience and plenty were on the upward curve of their development:
Brunt, Mozza, Olsson, Mulumbu, Tamas, Reid, Carson (Thomas?), Zuiverloon.
Aside from the striker position, our spine was as good a champo team as it could have been.
This season, very few of our spine have Prem experience and the ones that do, are arguably on downward curve of development (HRK, Livermore, Austin, Phillips). I think we'll need to at least match our success in that transfer window and then some to make sure we've got enough in the tank. We're already a Diangana down, so it won't be an easy window, you'd imagine.
Posts: 2,420
Threads: 158
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
2
HLS
You are the new Dan Ashworth and need adding to our scouting team
Agree about Austin and HRK being on the way down, hopefully with Phillips it is fitness
Posts: 13,017
Threads: 1,260
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
2 differences. We were lucky with getting a Premier League quality goalscorer (Odemwingie) at a decent price. Second, Roy joined us half way through the season. He is the master of mid table stability.
Posts: 2,420
Threads: 158
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
2
Odemwinge had never played in the Premier League when we bought him
Mark Hughes is available
Posts: 4,108
Threads: 50
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
13
(07-24-2020, 04:07 AM)HLS Wrote: Robinson's physical attributes remind me of Odemwingie and I think he's got a similar mindset of wanting to get on the ball and make runs into space, but Odemwingie was the best finisher we've ever had at the club in our Prem era. Berahino in his prime was up there but Odemwingie scored goals from pretty much every position. I don't see Robinson being able to replicate that as of right now, but tbf he's not really had much of a chance. I'd be very happy to sign him up given the fee is no more than 7m but I wouldn't want to go into the season with him as first choice striker. An Odemwingie type would be perfect, though some on here say that Slav likes a big no.9. Not too bothered about their size, but for me, they need to have 3 attributes. Can finish, make space-making movements, and willing to defend from the front. Gayle is the obvious one for me but there may be better unknowns.~
Fortune would thrive in this team.
Something missing from the OP is that many of the players who played in the Champ season already had Prem experience and plenty were on the upward curve of their development:
Brunt, Mozza, Olsson, Mulumbu, Tamas, Reid, Carson (Thomas?), Zuiverloon.
Aside from the striker position, our spine was as good a champo team as it could have been.
This season, very few of our spine have Prem experience and the ones that do, are arguably on downward curve of development (HRK, Livermore, Austin, Phillips). I think we'll need to at least match our success in that transfer window and then some to make sure we've got enough in the tank. We're already a Diangana down, so it won't be an easy window, you'd imagine.
MAF was so so underrated. He was an excellent "back to goal" striker, and he could score a few as well. Imagine him being up front this season with our attacking midfielders playing off him.
Posts: 1,040
Threads: 48
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
9
07-24-2020, 09:50 AM
(This post was last modified: 07-24-2020, 09:52 AM by HLS.)
(07-24-2020, 08:29 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: HLS
You are the new Dan Ashworth and need adding to our scouting team
Agree about Austin and HRK being on the way down, hopefully with Phillips it is fitness
Arf. I'd be terrible. I'm one of those who can't see what Livermore does until he goes off the pitch.
If available at a decent price, I would absolutely go for Gayle. That goal he scored against those bastards in claret and blue in the play offs epitomises why he is better than all of our current strikers. When he was through on goal, you would bet your left nut that he would go on to score it. Robinson, I wouldn't be so sure, HRK would have stopped running through on goal to see what options he had, and Austin would have been caught up by a snail in the turf. I don't know Gayle's contractual situation but unless there's a good reason we shouldn't, I'd be happy with him holding up a barcode this Summer.
(07-24-2020, 08:42 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote: MAF was so so underrated. He was an excellent "back to goal" striker, and he could score a few as well. Imagine him being up front this season with our attacking midfielders playing off him.
Yep. It took me a while to warm to his performances when he first came back but he proved how valuable he was as a team player. Sign a Fortune and an Odemwingie this summer (easier said than done) and we are well on our way to a competitive squad.
Posts: 13,407
Threads: 402
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
14
(07-24-2020, 04:07 AM)HLS Wrote: Robinson's physical attributes remind me of Odemwingie and I think he's got a similar mindset of wanting to get on the ball and make runs into space, but Odemwingie was the best finisher we've ever had at the club in our Prem era. Berahino in his prime was up there but Odemwingie scored goals from pretty much every position. I don't see Robinson being able to replicate that as of right now, but tbf he's not really had much of a chance. I'd be very happy to sign him up given the fee is no more than 7m but I wouldn't want to go into the season with him as first choice striker. An Odemwingie type would be perfect, though some on here say that Slav likes a big no.9. Not too bothered about their size, but for me, they need to have 3 attributes. Can finish, make space-making movements, and willing to defend from the front. Gayle is the obvious one for me but there may be better unknowns.~
Fortune would thrive in this team.
Something missing from the OP is that many of the players who played in the Champ season already had Prem experience and plenty were on the upward curve of their development:
Brunt, Mozza, Olsson, Mulumbu, Tamas, Reid, Carson (Thomas?), Zuiverloon.
Aside from the striker position, our spine was as good a champo team as it could have been.
This season, very few of our spine have Prem experience and the ones that do, are arguably on downward curve of development (HRK, Livermore, Austin, Phillips). I think we'll need to at least match our success in that transfer window and then some to make sure we've got enough in the tank. We're already a Diangana down, so it won't be an easy window, you'd imagine.
I'd put Lukaku way ahead of Berahino or Odemwingie... Of course he wasn't really ours, but I suspect we've more chance of loaning and unearthing the next Rom than we have of finding and buying the next Berahino / Odemwingie.
Posts: 1,040
Threads: 48
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
9
(07-24-2020, 09:56 AM)MassDebater Wrote: I'd put Lukaku way ahead of Berahino or Odemwingie... Of course he wasn't really ours, but I suspect we've more chance of loaning and unearthing the next Rom than we have of finding and buying the next Berahino / Odemwingie.
Fair enough, a game of onions and all. If you gave me a choice of 2010-2012 Odem vs 12-13 Lukaku I'd pick ODW every day. He was the difference in so many games and had greater versatility. Lukaku, you could argue had a better more established team around him so it was easier. The pair of them are the best forwards we've had this century.
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(07-24-2020, 10:14 AM)HLS Wrote: (07-24-2020, 09:56 AM)MassDebater Wrote: I'd put Lukaku way ahead of Berahino or Odemwingie... Of course he wasn't really ours, but I suspect we've more chance of loaning and unearthing the next Rom than we have of finding and buying the next Berahino / Odemwingie.
Fair enough, a game of onions and all. If you gave me a choice of 2010-2012 Odem vs 12-13 Lukaku I'd pick ODW every day. He was the difference in so many games and had greater versatility. Lukaku, you could argue had a better more established team around him so it was easier. The pair of them are the best forwards we've had this century.
Agree.
For all the praise RL gets during his time here, we actually played our best football, and got our best results without him in the starting line up. Rom was a sub in the first half of the season when we stormed into top 4 contention.
Odemwingie was far more important a player, and a far bigger loss the following season IMO.
|