De Gea or Sam?
#11
(07-19-2020, 07:51 PM)74bus Wrote:
(07-19-2020, 07:21 PM)Duffers Wrote: I’d choose De Gea every single time.

Why wouldn’t you?
No disrespect, but Roy Keane, who's played at a higher level than both of us, has been telling everyone for some time now that this keeper is a total liablity. DeGea had a chance of stopping all of Chelsea's goals and the second one could have been saved by a schoolboy. It's not as if this is a one off. Look back through the season and he's been responsible for any number of gaffes. He's living on past reputation, but you can only do that for so long.

Mark Lawrenson has won the European Cup but knows fuck all about football. Keane just rants these days, he’s a bad parody of himself.

De Gea has been below par for a couple of seasons now, I said in another thread that he had a bad World Cup in 2018 and had not recovered from it. However for 4-5 years prior he was undoubtedly one of the best keepers in the world. His problems are in his head, not his hands or feet, he has proven he has the ability. If I was managing an elite club I’d be thinking I could still get him back up to that level with a change of scenery and coaching.
Reply
#12
(07-19-2020, 07:49 PM)Sliced Wrote: I would choose one of the best keepers in the world who's having a bit of a dodgy season

Do you actually watch football? He might have been a good goalkeeper a couple of years ago, but he's been  totally shot for a long time now.
The second goal today would have been stopped by a pub team goalkeeper.  If Johnstone had let that one in, we'd never hear the last of it.

DeGea will be gone soon. They can't keep up making excuses for him.
Reply
#13
De Gea is unreliable, but played at a level most players can even dream about.

Man U will want better, no doubt.

De Gea's biggest problem will be finding someone else to pay his wages.reported at £375k a week for the next 5 years.

To answer the question, I would take neither. Man U will be looking to offload for someone better, and I think we will be trying to achieve the same with SJ.
Reply
#14
(07-19-2020, 08:22 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: De Gea is unreliable, but played at a level most players can even dream about.

Man U will want better, no doubt.

De Gea's biggest problem will be finding someone else to pay his wages.reported at £375k a week for the next 5 years.

To answer the question, I would take neither. Man U will be looking to offload for someone better, and I think we will be trying to achieve the same with SJ.
TBH, I agree. I rate Sam more highly than most on here, but if we go up, I'd want better. Any club that is fooled by DeGea's past reputation deserves what they get.
Reply
#15
I'd say neither. De Gea seems to have gone past his best. Johnstone flaps at crosses instead of catching them. There are many better goalkeepers than both.
Reply
#16
No one is doubting Johnstone's potential and I'm his biggest critic. But as a young keeper if you can't work on your weaknesses and look like you're improving as a £5m+ keeper then you deserve the criticism. Friday's BLM drop save for the first was a disgrace.

As for De He's a world.class keeper 3 years ago but the Man U defence in that period has completely shot his confidence and he's a shell of what he was.

Call me old fashioned but I like a sprawling giraffe of a keeper 6'4 min who will come for the big balls in the box. Johnstone and De Gea are 6' shot stoppers, and if you're that size with no box confidence then it's a shambles. Give me a 6'1 Edison who comes for the lot anyday
Reply
#17
(07-19-2020, 08:48 PM)billybassett Wrote: No one is doubting Johnstone's potential and I'm his biggest critic. But as a young keeper if you can't work on your weaknesses and look like you're improving as a £5m+ keeper then you deserve the criticism. Friday's BLM drop save for the first was a disgrace.

As for De He's a world.class keeper 3 years ago but the Man U defence in that period has completely shot his confidence and he's a shell of what he was.

Call me old fashioned but I like a sprawling giraffe of a keeper 6'4 min who will come for the big balls in the box. Johnstone and De Gea are 6' shot stoppers, and if you're that size with no box confidence then it's a shambles. Give me a 6'1 Edison who comes for the lot anyday

Well here is your man then.

[Image: 170px-Fraser_Forster_2016-02-27_1.jpg]
Reply
#18
(07-19-2020, 08:53 PM)scotbaggie Wrote:
(07-19-2020, 08:48 PM)billybassett Wrote: No one is doubting Johnstone's potential and I'm his biggest critic. But as a young keeper if you can't work on your weaknesses and look like you're improving as a £5m+ keeper then you deserve the criticism. Friday's BLM drop save for the first was a disgrace.

As for De He's a world.class keeper 3 years ago but the Man U defence in that period has completely shot his confidence and he's a shell of what he was.

Call me old fashioned but I like a sprawling giraffe of a keeper 6'4 min who will come for the big balls in the box. Johnstone and De Gea are 6' shot stoppers, and if you're that size with no box confidence then it's a shambles. Give me a 6'1 Edison who comes for the lot anyday

Well here is your man then.

[Image: 170px-Fraser_Forster_2016-02-27_1.jpg]

Id take him over SJ any day
Reply
#19
Are we really having a De Gea Vs Johnstone debate!? Seriously?
Reply
#20
When the OP makes Nick talk sense you know posting was probably a mistake.
In the form of his life.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: