Gone With The Wind
#41
(06-10-2020, 09:34 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Here you go Colliers. Here’s the professor. He is black. Walking on friggin eggshells here! https://www.pressandjournal.co.uk/fp/new...learances/

In that same article he also expressed disappointment that despite years of pressure nothing has got done by going through the legal channels. In no way was he advocating the status quo!
Reply
#42
Geoff Palmer?

Fucking Dingle.
Reply
#43
Looks to have backfired...
@Variety
· 3h


‘Gone With the Wind’ Hits No. 1 on Amazon Best-Sellers Chart After HBO Max Drops Movie https://wp.me/p2WgDE-1lynOp
Reply
#44
(06-10-2020, 07:58 PM)ColliersWoodBaggie Wrote:


One or two crow about 'censorship'. Well, let's talk about the censorship of the GCSE Medicine Through Time Curriculum. Mary Seacole has all but been expunged from the Curriculum. Gove , when Ed Sec in 2013, tried to do it for the KS3 History curriculum. There wa a backlash and the decision was reversed, but Edexcel's textbook is devoid of any mention of her.

Well, let’s be a little more careful where we give praise and condemnation. A couple of years ago I went into the classroom of a colleague, a history teacher, who had decorated one wall with ‘Black Heroes and Role Models’. He had put pictures up of the usual suspects: Mandela, Martin Luther King, Malcolm X and Walter Tull (a chap who gets my admiration). I innocently asked why he hadn’t put up a picture of Mary Seacole. His first words were, “your joking, that racists”! He promptly, and in no uncertain terms, explained why and furnished me with some sources to read. Which I did. The ex colleague, as it happens, is black.
Seacole never considered herself as black: “I am a Creole, and have good Scotch blood coursing in my veins,” she wrote in her memoir, describing her father as being “of an old Scotch family,” Her mother was Creole /mixed heritage but she was adamant that her “energy and activity” came from her “Scotch blood,” characteristics “not always found in the Creole race”. The “lazy Creole” description “applied to my country people,”. Roughly one quarter African in decent, Seacole described herself as being “only a little brown--a few shades duskier than the brunettes whom you all admire so much”.
Seacole frequently referred to “blacks” in her memoir, often her own servants--her maid and cooks There are references also to “good-for-nothing black cooks” and “excited ni**er cooks”.
She described the Turkish as “the degenerate descendants of the fierce Arabs and “deliberate, slow and indolent” and Greeks as “villainous-looking” .
 
She was also elitist, she did not set up a hospital for troops but with a business partner, opened an officers club for resting or convalescing officers and “visiting sightseers” only. This club was profit making. She visited the battle fields twice and then primarily to serve food, again as a business venture, to the ‘spectators’ overlooking the field. She did, however, go onto the battlefield to tend to the wounded on each occasion. Most of her contact with the ordinary ranks, however, was as that of a sutler; visiting the British army camps. Writing to her brother, Nightingale said, “Anyone who employs Mrs Seacole will introduce much kindness - also much drunkenness and improper conduct".
So perhaps Mary Seacole isn’t the personification of all things sweetness and light and shouldn’t be held up as a shining example of humanity. (That is if we insist on putting the sensibilities of today on to the people of the past, which we shouldn’t.)
As regards the ‘Medicine Through Time’ GCSE module, it covers 1000 years of advancement in a half term, about 12 lessons. Seacole added nothing to the advancement of medical knowledge so why should she be shoehorned into an already rushed syllabus when Galen, the so called ‘father of medicine’, isn’t taught either?
Reply
#45
(06-10-2020, 10:59 PM)JOK Wrote:
(06-10-2020, 07:58 PM)ColliersWoodBaggie Wrote:


One or two crow about 'censorship'. Well, let's talk about the censorship of the GCSE Medicine Through Time Curriculum. Mary Seacole has all but been expunged from the Curriculum. Gove , when Ed Sec in 2013, tried to do it for the KS3 History curriculum. There wa a backlash and the decision was reversed, but Edexcel's textbook is devoid of any mention of her.

Well, let’s be a little more careful where we give praise and condemnation. A couple of years ago I went into the classroom of a colleague, a history teacher, who had decorated one wall with ‘Black Heroes and Role Models’. He had put pictures up of the usual suspects: Mandela, Martin Luther King, Malcolm X and Walter Tull (a chap who gets my admiration). I innocently asked why he hadn’t put up a picture of Mary Seacole. His first words were, “your joking, that racists”! He promptly, and in no uncertain terms, explained why and furnished me with some sources to read. Which I did. The ex colleague, as it happens, is black.
Seacole never considered herself as black: “I am a Creole, and have good Scotch blood coursing in my veins,” she wrote in her memoir, describing her father as being “of an old Scotch family,” Her mother was Creole /mixed heritage but she was adamant that her “energy and activity” came from her “Scotch blood,” characteristics “not always found in the Creole race”. The “lazy Creole” description “applied to my country people,”. Roughly one quarter African in decent, Seacole described herself as being “only a little brown--a few shades duskier than the brunettes whom you all admire so much”.
Seacole frequently referred to “blacks” in her memoir, often her own servants--her maid and cooks There are references also to “good-for-nothing black cooks” and “excited ni**er cooks”.
She described the Turkish as “the degenerate descendants of the fierce Arabs and “deliberate, slow and indolent” and Greeks as “villainous-looking” .
 
She was also elitist, she did not set up a hospital for troops but with a business partner, opened an officers club for resting or convalescing officers and “visiting sightseers” only. This club was profit making. She visited the battle fields twice and then primarily to serve food, again as a business venture, to the ‘spectators’ overlooking the field. She did, however, go onto the battlefield to tend to the wounded on each occasion. Most of her contact with the ordinary ranks, however, was as that of a sutler; visiting the British army camps. Writing to her brother, Nightingale said, “Anyone who employs Mrs Seacole will introduce much kindness - also much drunkenness and improper conduct".
So perhaps Mary Seacole isn’t the personification of all things sweetness and light and shouldn’t be held up as a shining example of humanity. (That is if we insist on putting the sensibilities of today on to the people of the past, which we shouldn’t.)
As regards the ‘Medicine Through Time’ GCSE module, it covers 1000 years of advancement in a half term, about 12 lessons. Seacole added nothing to the advancement of medical knowledge so why should she be shoehorned into an already rushed syllabus when Galen, the so called ‘father of medicine’, isn’t taught either?

Galen was taught in my day, as was Ibn Sina aka Avicenna.
Reply
#46
(06-10-2020, 09:02 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(06-10-2020, 08:32 AM)The liquidator Wrote: The re writing of history  is concerning  it's going one way ....if they want to get all slavery statues that's fine by me but they they want anyone who was a abuser to their workforce and tyrants but I hope some dont go crying to mommy  when nelson Mandela is torn down by some as he neclaced his own people by putting tyres around their neck and set them alight burning them alive .its a dangerous path we are going down.
They binned little Britain yesterday too!
Some black professor was saying yesterday that getting rid of the slave trader statues, eradicating any references to anything unPC from history actually is counterproductive as it stops people realising these things happened.
As someone middle of the road, cosmopolitan and liberal, I think extreme liberalism is fuelling the right wing. What happened with that George Floyd is a million miles away from  a bit of a piss take like they did on Little Britain.
If we can't gently find the humour in life's differences then we are well and truly fecked. 
The rise of the right will continue to gather momentum unless we stop such extreme actions by the far left. It really isn't helping our society that we can't have mature debates.

Have to agree 100%
Speaking to a black lad yesterday he said it was embarrassing how people are jumping on another bandwagon
His said the climate change one left town with coronavirus & another rolled up
Reply
#47
(06-10-2020, 09:54 PM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(06-10-2020, 09:34 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Here you go Colliers. Here’s the professor. He is black. Walking on friggin eggshells here! https://www.pressandjournal.co.uk/fp/new...learances/

In that same article he also expressed disappointment that despite years of pressure nothing has got done by going through the legal channels. In no way was he advocating the status quo!

They have been shite for 20 years.
Reply
#48
Where does it stop though
Every country in the world has a history of slavery of some sort
But thats the past. We dont do it anymore

Will the Egyptians pull the pyramids down?
The Usa return the statue of liberty to france?

Re Kinver being ultra right wing etc
Have any of you ever tried to drink in The Red Fort in Smethwick High Street
Thats probably on the same level as Kinver
Reply
#49
(06-11-2020, 09:00 AM)Pipkins Wrote: Where does it stop though
Every country in the world has a history of slavery of some sort
But thats the past. We dont do it anymore

Will the Egyptians pull the pyramids down?
The Usa return the statue of liberty to france?

Re Kinver being ultra right wing etc
Have any of you ever tried to drink in The Red Fort in Smethwick High Street
Thats probably on the same level as Kinver

Wasn't that a gift though?
Reply
#50
fuck this I'm off to watch White Chicks
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)