Posts: 13,573
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
05-31-2020, 02:02 PM
(This post was last modified: 05-31-2020, 02:20 PM by Borin' Baggie.)
(05-31-2020, 05:55 AM)JOK Wrote: (05-30-2020, 01:40 PM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote: (05-30-2020, 07:04 AM)The liquidator Wrote: Turkey's voted for xmas
Blah blah blah
Keep ignoring the facts. Two big UK car plants are closing over the next 13 months, two more are moving production from their UK bases to Germany and another is sounding a complete closure for 2023.
And, to get it back to my point on Sunderland, no new investment is being made as all that is happening is that they're moving production of CMF-CD (Kadjar) and CMF-B (Captur) Renault models to a factory already producing cars on those frameworks for Nissan (Qashqai, Juke) meaning no new workers need to be hired or trained and no new tooling needs to be fitted, and as production of two models were moved to Japan last year there is space in the two lines there meaning no money needs to be put into a new production line.
This is a complete nothing story, the only interesting thing is that Renault and Nissan are being forced to work closely together despite trying their best not to since the alliance was signed in order to stave off the threat of going under. Until new models are actually being built in Sunderland there will be no new investment there.
I think the motivation for some of the posts on this thread is the fact that, for over four years, we have had it insisted to us that leaving the EU would be the death nell to the British automotive industry.
Admittedly only a quick bit of research but I’m struggling to find any catastrophic disaster that your first paragraph might infer.
Nissan are actually suggesting they could pull out of manufacturing in Europe and “ramp up” production in the U.K. following Brexit.
Honda are closing Swindon (it’s only plant in Europe) due to “Global changes” and “Nothing to do with Brexit”.
Ford are closing an engine plant in Wales and denied “Brexit was a factor”. Adding “We are committed to the U.K.”.
They also closed a car plant in France and cut jobs in Germany. and 3 other plants Europe wide. Also 7000 office jobs worldwide.
Toyota have stated there are no plans for changes to their U.K. operations at present but could consider closing it’s U.K. plant, scaling back or even more investment. So, the expression “sounding complete closure” is a bit of hyperbole.
Vauxhall’s Ellesmere Port plant is slowly turning around from crippling inefficiency but Luton, according to the FT. is fairly safe. Especially following a £100 mil investment in 2018.
Again we have the threatening ‘could’ move Mini production and “may need to consider” moving. Those comments made by Peter Schwarzenbauer who has since been replaced as director responsible for the Mini. Some production of engines bound for South African built cars has moved abroad.
Thanks to a trade deal between the EU and Japan, cars can be imported direct from Japan into Europe without tariffs. So again closures of Japanese plants would have been on the cards with or without Brexit.
Here is an article from one of Dekka’s fave papers, The FT, so I’m sure he’ll like it (well, perhaps he won’t!). He must have missed it otherwise he’d have shared it, surely. Here is a snippet;
‘Every year, more than 1m brand new cars leave Britain, bound for Europe and the rest of the world. ...for each one that departs, two arrive, a testament to the UK’s deep reliance on overseas car plants to keep its forecourts stocked.
The prospect of new tariffs after Brexit is prompting some carmakers to consider tearing up this decades-old arrangement by making more of their locally-sold vehicles in Britain.
“It’s always a good thing to manufacture the cars close to the market where you sell them, generally speaking,” said Carlos Tavares, chief executive of Vauxhall owner PSA. “So I would love to manufacture many Vauxhall cars in the UK for the UK market . . . that’s what’s at stake with the Brexit outcome.”
https://www.ft.com/content/97fef2b8-4915...5839e06441
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-47287386
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-wales-48533790
https://www.theguardian.com/business/202...ard-brexit
Honda are closing their Swindon plant because a no-deal Brexit makes it uneconomical to ship cars from that plant into Europe instead of importing them from Japan, especially with the new FTA with Japan. Parts being easier to source from continental Europe and ship to Japan is a significant reason, as is the fact that us leaving the EU means we couldn't continue vetoing the FTA with Japan. Their fall in European market share happened after the GFC in 2008 yet only now after Brexit has running the Swindon plant become a factor due to Brexit related issues. They're being polite, anyone with any knowledge of the automotive industry knows that was a smokescreen statement and that a no-deal Brexit is the catalyst for that plant closure and it corresponds with the initial statements out of Japan.
Nissan are in deep financial shit, Sunderland is now reliant on production of models from a company that is part owned by the French state who are also in financial shit. Nissan/Renault/Mitsubishi have announced that Sunderland is in their European production sphere and if their downturn continues then Renault will not close their French factories for political reasons and it might not be worth the investment to retool the Sunderland plant in the future if Renault refuse to continue building cars there. Nissan have already moved Infiniti models out of Sunderland and opted not to build the X-Trail there.
Ford are closing Bridgend due to additional costs associated with leaving the EU's customs union. Roelant de Waard has explicitly said as much. Halewood manufactures transmissions and that will also be significantly affected by Bridgend closing. Their remaining plant is a diesel engine plant in Dagenham, I don't need to explain why that's not secure.
BMW have set up contingency plans to move production of Minis out of Cowley if no FTA is signed, this common knowledge. Both Nicolas Peter and Harald Krüger have explained this.
PSA have moved some Astra production out of Ellesmere Port to other factories and have said they will move all if no satisfactory deal is signed. Carlos Tavares has said that he would like to keep production here but he also said he won't risk the finances to do so.
Posts: 1,058
Threads: 51
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
3
(05-31-2020, 02:02 PM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote: (05-31-2020, 05:55 AM)JOK Wrote: I think the motivation for some of the posts on this thread is the fact that, for over four years, we have had it insisted to us that leaving the EU would be the death nell to the British automotive industry.
Admittedly only a quick bit of research but I’m struggling to find any catastrophic disaster that your first paragraph might infer.
Nissan are actually suggesting they could pull out of manufacturing in Europe and “ramp up” production in the U.K. following Brexit.
Honda are closing Swindon (it’s only plant in Europe) due to “Global changes” and “Nothing to do with Brexit”.
Ford are closing an engine plant in Wales and denied “Brexit was a factor”. Adding “We are committed to the U.K.”.
They also closed a car plant in France and cut jobs in Germany. and 3 other plants Europe wide. Also 7000 office jobs worldwide.
Toyota have stated there are no plans for changes to their U.K. operations at present but could consider closing it’s U.K. plant, scaling back or even more investment. So, the expression “sounding complete closure” is a bit of hyperbole.
Vauxhall’s Ellesmere Port plant is slowly turning around from crippling inefficiency but Luton, according to the FT. is fairly safe. Especially following a £100 mil investment in 2018.
Again we have the threatening ‘could’ move Mini production and “may need to consider” moving. Those comments made by Peter Schwarzenbauer who has since been replaced as director responsible for the Mini. Some production of engines bound for South African built cars has moved abroad.
Thanks to a trade deal between the EU and Japan, cars can be imported direct from Japan into Europe without tariffs. So again closures of Japanese plants would have been on the cards with or without Brexit.
Here is an article from one of Dekka’s fave papers, The FT, so I’m sure he’ll like it (well, perhaps he won’t!). He must have missed it otherwise he’d have shared it, surely. Here is a snippet;
‘Every year, more than 1m brand new cars leave Britain, bound for Europe and the rest of the world. ...for each one that departs, two arrive, a testament to the UK’s deep reliance on overseas car plants to keep its forecourts stocked.
The prospect of new tariffs after Brexit is prompting some carmakers to consider tearing up this decades-old arrangement by making more of their locally-sold vehicles in Britain.
“It’s always a good thing to manufacture the cars close to the market where you sell them, generally speaking,” said Carlos Tavares, chief executive of Vauxhall owner PSA. “So I would love to manufacture many Vauxhall cars in the UK for the UK market . . . that’s what’s at stake with the Brexit outcome.”
Honda are closing their Swindon plant because a no-deal Brexit makes it uneconomical to ship cars from that plant into Europe instead of importing them from Japan, especially with the new FTA with Japan. Parts being easier to source from continental Europe and ship to Japan is a significant reason, as is the fact that us leaving the EU means we couldn't continue vetoing the FTA with Japan. Their fall in European market share happened after the GFC in 2008 yet only now after Brexit has running the Swindon plant become a factor due to Brexit related issues. They're being polite, anyone with any knowledge of the automotive industry knows that was a smokescreen statement and that a no-deal Brexit is the catalyst for that plant closure and it corresponds with the initial statements out of Japan.
Nissan are in deep financial shit, Sunderland is now reliant on production of models from a company that is part owned by the French state who are also in financial shit. Nissan/Renault/Mitsubishi have announced that Sunderland is in their European production sphere and if their downturn continues then Renault will not close their French factories for political reasons and it might not be worth the investment to retool the Sunderland plant in the future if Renault refuse to continue building cars there. Nissan have already moved Infiniti models out of Sunderland and opted not to build the X-Trail there.
Ford are closing Bridgend due to additional costs associated with leaving the EU's customs union. Roelant de Waard has explicitly said as much. Halewood manufactures transmissions and that will also be significantly affected by Bridgend closing. Their remaining plant is a diesel engine plant in Dagenham, I don't need to explain why that's not secure.
BMW have set up contingency plans to move production of Minis out of Cowley if no FTA is signed, this common knowledge. Both Nicolas Peter and Harald Krüger have explained this.
PSA have moved some Astra production out of Ellesmere Port to other factories and have said they will move all if no satisfactory deal is signed. Carlos Tavares has said that he would like to keep production here but he also said he won't risk the finances to do so.
Ford of Europe president Stuart Rowley said creating a sustainable business required the company to make "difficult decisions", including the need to make its engine manufacturing base suitable for the vehicles it produces in the future.
“We are committed to the UK. However, changing customer demand and cost disadvantages, plus an absence of additional engine models for Bridgend going forward make the plant economically unsustainable in the years ahead. The decision was nothing to do with Brexit.”
Where does it mention “additional costs associated with Brexit”, in there? Indeed, it clearly states ‘... nothing to do with Brexit”.
A Nissan statement early in May stated, “Work has already begun to ready our plant in Sunderland, UK, to begin production of the next generation Qashqai crossover. And we’re pushing to further electrify our lineup, with new product entries on the way.”
In a press conference in Japan on 29th May 2020 they announced “Nissan’s Sunderland factory is safe as the firm announces it will become a European manufacturing hub.”
The management said it will be closing its factory in Barcelona as it admitted its brand had been ‘severely damaged’ with losses last year of £306m (40.5bn Yen).
It is now likely that some Renault models, built in other countries, could be built in Sunderland as the alliance looks to increase efficiencies.”
Of coarse, you may know more than the Nissan board but they seem quite clear. How do you square your gloom laden view of Sunderland with Nissan’s own statement of two days ago?
The last statement from Mr Peter I can find, in October, on the subject he said “there were no plans to close any UK factories on the table.” And if there was a ‘no deal’ Brexit, “The increase of price means an impact on the volume you sell, and would eventually lead to a reduction of produced cars in Oxford. Nothing about “contingency plans” to end production at Cowley. So it doesn’t appear to be “common knowledge with him.
August is the last pronouncement I can see from Harald Krüger when he said “ we can move more production of its Mini to a plant in the Netherlands if Britain fails to strike a trade deal with the European Union” again not a “we will end U.K. production” so it’s not, as you state, shutting down U.K. production but possibly reduce output, if and or when .
Perhaps you should have a word with: Mr. Rowley, Mr. Peter, Mr. Kruger, Mr. Tavares and the Nissan board and tell them they’re not saying what you won’t them to mean.
Posts: 13,573
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
Firstly, can you not reply in size 4 pt Times New Roman? It's a massive pain in the arse to read without Sherlock Holmes' magnifying glass.
Secondly, wrt Ford, you can bury your head in the sand and cite whomever you want but de Waard explicitly outlined the additional costs associated with leaving the Customs Union would lead to the Bridgend factory being unsustainable, then a few months later Bridgend is announced for closure. Do you think this is a massive coincidence or something? The other two remaining factories are a transmissions facility that is going to take a massive hit to output with Bridgend closing and a diesel engine production facility that is extremely vulnerable to the changing automotive environment given diesels are extremely unpopular at the moment.
Secondly, your citing of what the Nissan board is a paraphrase of what I have already said in this thread. They're consolidating frameworks across the Alliance to mitigate the very serious risks of financial catastrophe. Renault are moving the Kadjar and Captur out of Valladolid and into Sunderland as they don't want to pay to upgrade Barcelona's production line when Sunderland is already tooled for that design framework, and Nissan are moving works out of Barcelona and into Valladolid to allow them to implement the cuts they need. The 2021 Qashqai uses the same module framework as the Kadjar, the old Qashqai and the Captur with the Juke. None of this involves new investment, there is no need to retool and the capacity at Sunderland is there due to decisions made with producing the X-Trail and Infiniti Q30 in Japan instead of in Sunderland. No idea why you decided to bring them up again, it's redundant.
The contingency plans are set, I know as I know people working at BMW Oxford who helped to draft them. They're already shifting out of Hams Hall due to meeting EU trade rules with place of origin and they will follow through on Mini production out of Cowley. Nicolas Peter and Harald Krüger have explained this strategy. They're not dealing in absolutes because they don't know if the issues over certification will affect the production coming out of Cowley but those plans are in place and if there is a risk it will happen very quickly as a result, I believe their new CE Zipse has said as much.
Stop reading press statements pushed out by automotive PR divisions and look at what is being said and done behind the scenes. Anyone with any knowledge knew this Sunderland thing was coming when they dropped the Q30 and Nissan and Renault announced their financial results, Ford were citing no-deal Brexit as a huge pain in the arse with additional costs at Bridgend before they announced their closure and BMW have set up their contingency plans at Cowley. And don't fucking dare call me doom and gloom laden in an industry I'm involved with and have friends involved in, I do not want these jobs gone and my position is based one what is being actually being done there.
Posts: 3,733
Threads: 116
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
14
No comment on Nissan COO saying that a tariff free future is key to Sunderland's future?
Posts: 4,261
Threads: 263
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
06-05-2020, 01:17 PM
(This post was last modified: 06-05-2020, 01:17 PM by Cheshire East Baggie.)
(06-04-2020, 08:54 AM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: No comment on Nissan COO saying that a tariff free future is key to Sunderland's future?
Extremely clear message from Nissan this week that Sunderland depends of tariff-free trading between UK and EU. They're fucked if (when) we go for the WTO free-for-all. Not expecting the gung-ho Brexit monkeys on here to comment on that.
Posts: 11,314
Threads: 420
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
(06-05-2020, 01:17 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: (06-04-2020, 08:54 AM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: No comment on Nissan COO saying that a tariff free future is key to Sunderland's future?
Extremely clear message from Nissan this week that Sunderland depends of tariff-free trading between UK and EU. They're fucked if (when) we go for the WTO free-for-all. Not expecting the gung-ho Brexit monkeys on here to comment on that.
Or they're after a bung, again.
Posts: 1,712
Threads: 20
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
18
(06-05-2020, 01:20 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (06-05-2020, 01:17 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: (06-04-2020, 08:54 AM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: No comment on Nissan COO saying that a tariff free future is key to Sunderland's future?
Extremely clear message from Nissan this week that Sunderland depends of tariff-free trading between UK and EU. They're fucked if (when) we go for the WTO free-for-all. Not expecting the gung-ho Brexit monkeys on here to comment on that.
Or they're after a bung, again.
Probably. Except unlike Ford and GM in the 60s,70s,80s and 90s, it doesn't look like an empty threat.
Posts: 4,217
Threads: 169
Joined: Jan 2019
(06-05-2020, 01:17 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: (06-04-2020, 08:54 AM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: No comment on Nissan COO saying that a tariff free future is key to Sunderland's future?
Extremely clear message from Nissan this week that Sunderland depends of tariff-free trading between UK and EU. They're fucked if (when) we go for the WTO free-for-all. Not expecting the gung-ho Brexit monkeys on here to comment on that. Monkeys???
Posts: 3,733
Threads: 116
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
14
(06-05-2020, 01:20 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (06-05-2020, 01:17 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: (06-04-2020, 08:54 AM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: No comment on Nissan COO saying that a tariff free future is key to Sunderland's future?
Extremely clear message from Nissan this week that Sunderland depends of tariff-free trading between UK and EU. They're fucked if (when) we go for the WTO free-for-all. Not expecting the gung-ho Brexit monkeys on here to comment on that.
Or they're after a bung, again.
Well yes, very likely - but I don't think those voting for sunlit uplands are expecting to have to subsidise every industry that comes cap in hand if we leave with no-deal.
Posts: 11,314
Threads: 420
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
06-28-2021, 01:00 PM
(This post was last modified: 06-28-2021, 01:00 PM by Protheroe.)
(05-29-2020, 01:53 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: What "huge investment" are you on about? No new frameworks have been announced, no new models have been announced, no new investment has been announced. All they've done is consolidate the Nissan and Renault frameworks into one factory to cut costs in one factory and not invest in another.
This new investment: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-57640001
|