Is Lockdown Counter Productive?
#61
(05-01-2020, 07:27 PM)HomersBelly Wrote: A gradual release while measuring the R0 rate and keeping it below 1 is the way forward I feel.

I don’t see how this R number is anything other than a total guess, without widespread testing.
Reply
#62
(05-02-2020, 12:12 AM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote:
(05-01-2020, 07:27 PM)HomersBelly Wrote: A gradual release while measuring the R0 rate and keeping it below 1 is the way forward I feel.

I don’t see how this R number is anything other than a total guess, without widespread testing.

You could determine the accuracy by comparing against the rate of tests being conducted.

If the tests numbers are increasing but the R number is decreasing then it's pretty safe to assume that the R number is actually decreasing. There's also sampling and whatnot that needs to be done.
Reply
#63
(05-01-2020, 09:38 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(05-01-2020, 07:36 PM)Neil Parsley Wrote:
(04-30-2020, 09:03 AM)Protheroe Wrote: There's no settled science on the matter, what we do know is that the opportunity cost for peoples' livelihoods is horrendous.

What if we're doing entirely the wrong thing?
https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/coul...OoMt7Bql5s

Here's another argument in that sort of viewpoint. Thing is, we won't know until we look back, I don't think, as to the efficacy of all the different strategies.https://www.dailywire.com/news/israeli-s...ency-chair

I do wonder whether, by the time the virus threat has gone away, whether there will be massive differences in death rates. I am minded to think not.

You genuinely believe that the 30 odd thousand extra deaths in the 1st 4 months of the year will just net out?

They would have died eventually anyway, you know.
Reply
#64
There’s some fucked up logic on here tonight. Yes, all people will die at some stage but the 30k extra in 1st 3 months of this year weren’t necessarily going to die this year, next year or in the next decade. By the end of June we will probably have about an extra 60k people die this year than last year. It’s quite naive to think that they would have died anyway so we shouldn’t worry.

There were 50 million people that died from the Spanish flu and it affected all ages because of malnutrition and general ill health after a brutal war, not because it was particularly worse than coronavirus.

I’m guessing too many Friday night ales have clouded the collective brains.
Reply
#65
(05-02-2020, 01:46 AM)baggy1 Wrote: There’s some fucked up logic on here tonight. Yes, all people will die at some stage but the 30k extra in 1st 3 months of this year weren’t necessarily going to die this year, next year or in the next decade. By the end of June we will probably have about an extra 60k people die this year than last year. It’s quite naive to think that they would have died anyway so we shouldn’t worry.

There were 50 million people that died from the Spanish flu and it affected all ages because of malnutrition and general ill health after a brutal war, not because it was particularly worse than coronavirus.

I’m guessing too many Friday night ales have clouded the collective brains.

Don't recall saying that at all. All I put was that there was logic in the belief that the people who have sadly passed were likely to have passed soon anyway owing to the high number of deaths being in people with serious underlying health conditions. The extent of that will only be known until we have a longer term picture and understand how the rates normalise and when they do so, and obviously I don't think I need to say that I don't want unnecessary and premature deaths as that's time lost and with huge pain and suffering.

As for the Spanish flu, it disproportionately affected younger people. 99% of victims in the US were under the age of 65 during the second wave (dropping to 92% in 1920, two years after the war) and the worst hit group was the 20-40 age range which consisted of half of all total deaths. Even attributing for the war, which definitely had an effect on the overall total of deaths, that is far too disproportionate to dismiss and wasn't consistent with the fatality distribution of seasonal flu and other epidemics in the 1910s. It's also consistent with the stronger immune systems of young adults causing cytokine shock.
Reply
#66
Good thread this with reasoned argument. Certainly gets one thinking around all areas of the issue.

In respect of the sad passing of people the numbers are irrelevant obviously. But in respect of learning for a future event there are so many issues to consider I hope someone does a better job than with Sars

The sensationalism through social and traditional media outlets means it's impossible to have a reasoned argument but at some point the review into Covid needs to account for all these factors.

The UK's response given a 4 mth lag from China was woeful in the beginning. Nobody took it seriously enough. Borders werent locked and provisions not stockpiled. But in the last month may due to the lockdown it's settled things down. I hope this is something they have learned.

So root causes need to be understood. Force China to close all those ridiculous markets or monitor them in someway and close borders fast with quarantine provisions.
Reply
#67
(05-02-2020, 03:50 AM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote:
(05-02-2020, 01:46 AM)baggy1 Wrote: There’s some fucked up logic on here tonight. Yes, all people will die at some stage but the 30k extra in 1st 3 months of this year weren’t necessarily going to die this year, next year or in the next decade. By the end of June we will probably have about an extra 60k people die this year than last year. It’s quite naive to think that they would have died anyway so we shouldn’t worry.

There were 50 million people that died from the Spanish flu and it affected all ages because of malnutrition and general ill health after a brutal war, not because it was particularly worse than coronavirus.

I’m guessing too many Friday night ales have clouded the collective brains.

Don't recall saying that at all. All I put was that there was logic in the belief that the people who have sadly passed were likely to have passed soon anyway owing to the high number of deaths being in people with serious underlying health conditions. The extent of that will only be known until we have a longer term picture and understand how the rates normalise and when they do so, and obviously I don't think I need to say that I don't want unnecessary and premature deaths as that's time lost and with huge pain and suffering.

As for the Spanish flu, it disproportionately affected younger people. 99% of victims in the US were under the age of 65 during the second wave (dropping to 92% in 1920, two years after the war) and the worst hit group was the 20-40 age range which consisted of half of all total deaths. Even attributing for the war, which definitely had an effect on the overall total of deaths, that is far too disproportionate to dismiss and wasn't consistent with the fatality distribution of seasonal flu and other epidemics in the 1910s. It's also consistent with the stronger immune systems of young adults causing cytokine shock.

There is a very good reason that the vast majority of the deaths were below 65 and that’s because the global population expected age of death in 1920 was 52! You can make statistics say anything you want but you have to understand the wider picture. At that time very few people made it to 65!!!!

And before you state that it disproportionately affected women you are correct, but that’s because there were more women as the vast majority of deaths in WW1 were men!
Reply
#68
That doesn't account for the higher than usual rate of death for people in the 20-40 age group from Spanish flu relative to other epidemics or illnesses at around the same time. You're also completely ignoring the effect of cytokine shock as a cause of death as a result of being infected with Spanish flu.
Reply
#69
They've released the data up to week 17 today and it has to be remembered that these are just for England and Wales and not the UK as a whole.

Up to week 17 (w/e 24th April) the excess deaths compared to the same period last year is now at 43,789. There are 'better' figures if you take the average from the last 5 years for the same period showing excess deaths in 2020 at 33,660.

Grim reading and a wake up call for those that were saying it's no worse than the flu. The majority (about 40k) of the excess deaths have occurred in the weeks 14 to 17.

(05-02-2020, 12:51 PM)Borin\ Baggie Wrote: That doesn't account for the higher than usual rate of death for people in the 20-40 age group from Spanish flu relative to other epidemics or illnesses at around the same time. You're also completely ignoring the effect of cytokine shock as a cause of death as a result of being infected with Spanish flu.

Sorry BB, didn't see this, not ignoring you. Don't disagree with that but one underreported issue that may or not be related to the current problems is an increase in Kawasaki disease amongst young kids which, as far as I know, is similar to what you are saying (just in a younger group). There will be a lot of issues that we find out about as time goes on.

I do think the spanish flu comparisons can be a bit misleading (of which I am guilty btw) because of the extra harsh conditions at the end of and after WW1 that helped with transmission.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: