Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
There's no settled science on the matter, what we do know is that the opportunity cost for peoples' livelihoods is horrendous.
What if we're doing entirely the wrong thing?
https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/coul...OoMt7Bql5s
Posts: 8,954
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
One massive flaw in that argument is the assumption that we are locked down with no contact and the virus isn't spreading therefore not mutating into a milder version (a complete hypothesis btw). You only have to look at the Spanish Flu death toll of 50,000,000 to see what a virus can do unchecked.
Stop revolving your life around opportunity costs for people's livelihoods FFS, there's no point running a business if all of the customers have died.
Posts: 5,322
Threads: 356
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
It is always important to question what we are doing, so have no problem with anyone making a case against the lockdown policy.
Not sure I can agree with them though. Without the lockdown I think we would be looking at deaths in the hundreds of thousands (albeit low hundreds of thousands), rather than the tens of thousands.. Not sure as a nation we could sustain death at that rate, without their being a massive negative impact on the nation's morale.
There will be at the end of this a thorough global enquiry into how the pandemic was handled, so it would be unwise to pre judge it, but there does seem to be a case to make that those countries that have handled it best are those who went for an early and hard lockdown - such as NZ, Denmark, Czech Republic.
Posts: 1,236
Threads: 71
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
3
I floated this conversation right at the beginning with a colleague - basically would we be better off letting it run its course, all things factored in. The wider issue for me is our absolute obsession as a race with trying to control what will ultimately prove the uncontrollable. The thread about this being a 1 in a 100 year event got deleted but the reality is this will be far from unique or the biggest challenge in the coming decades. Its an opening shot, not a freak occurence. How we learn to evaluate and process our responses will be a huge factor in how humanity proceeds.
Posts: 5,322
Threads: 356
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
(04-30-2020, 09:32 AM)HeathAyIt Wrote: I floated this conversation right at the beginning with a colleague - basically would we be better off letting it run its course, all things factored in. The wider issue for me is our absolute obsession as a race with trying to control what will ultimately prove the uncontrollable. The thread about this being a 1 in a 100 year event got deleted but the reality is this will be far from unique or the biggest challenge in the coming decades. Its an opening shot, not a freak occurence. How we learn to evaluate and process our responses will be a huge factor in how humanity proceeds.
Again it's a valid argument to make, but we can only deal with what we know - we will learn more about the virus as time elapses.
But what we did know at the point of the lockdown, was that the virus is more contagious that many others of its kind, and that unchecked it would probably infect 60% of the population - over 40m people. Given a death rate close to 1% (with that level of infection), that would mean 400k deaths, in a relatively short period of time.
Not remotely possible for a Govt to sanction that kind of policy.
How we move out of lockdown, and manage it before a vaccination is available, will be extraordinarily difficult, but not to have done something would have been negligent.
Posts: 1,236
Threads: 71
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
3
(04-30-2020, 09:41 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: (04-30-2020, 09:32 AM)HeathAyIt Wrote: I floated this conversation right at the beginning with a colleague - basically would we be better off letting it run its course, all things factored in. The wider issue for me is our absolute obsession as a race with trying to control what will ultimately prove the uncontrollable. The thread about this being a 1 in a 100 year event got deleted but the reality is this will be far from unique or the biggest challenge in the coming decades. Its an opening shot, not a freak occurence. How we learn to evaluate and process our responses will be a huge factor in how humanity proceeds.
Again it's a valid argument to make, but we can only deal with what we know - we will learn more about the virus as time elapses.
But what we did know at the point of the lockdown, was that the virus is more contagious that many others of its kind, and that unchecked it would probably infect 60% of the population - over 40m people. Given a death rate close to 1% (with that level of infection), that would mean 400k deaths, in a relatively short period of time.
Not remotely possible for a Govt to sanction that kind of policy.
How we move out of lockdown, and manage it before a vaccination is available, will be extraordinarily difficult, but not to have done something would have been negligent.
Agree, overall, it was impossible to act otherwise. But the lack of global cohesion in the response highlights the many perils of a world stuck between two phases, with the accelerator down and the gear in reverse. The political responses and confusion are more dangerous than any virus long term.
As for the virus itself, simply based on those i know who have it or have had it, including one very sad loss, the only thing that is clear to me is that its much more complex than anything thats come before it and our understanding of it appears to reflect that. The range of symptoms and length of impact it produces are mental.
(04-30-2020, 09:32 AM)HeathAyIt Wrote: I floated this conversation right at the beginning with a colleague - basically would we be better off letting it run its course, all things factored in. The wider issue for me is our absolute obsession as a race with trying to control what will ultimately prove the uncontrollable. The thread about this being a 1 in a 100 year event got deleted but the reality is this will be far from unique or the biggest challenge in the coming decades. Its an opening shot, not a freak occurence. How we learn to evaluate and process our responses will be a huge factor in how humanity proceeds.
Firstly, it's a difficult balance. It is controllable but at an ultimately unpalatable cost. The whole world would need to stay indoors for 18 months or more. The halfway house is almost the worst of all worlds. It's still uncontrolled, the mechanisms for controlling it are flawed, the science is inconclusive and people will be people.
Secondly, this is a very mild virus. It is relatively contagious but not particularly deadly. With a growing population, cities expanding, changing habitats, increasing temperatures, ecosystems dying that provide checks and balances it is only matter of time before something far deadlier arrives. Then, if the way this pandemic has been handled is any indicator, we're screwed.
Posts: 4,217
Threads: 169
Joined: Jan 2019
04-30-2020, 09:56 AM
(This post was last modified: 04-30-2020, 10:00 AM by The liquidator.)
Health over wealth mate look we all know we are fucked for years to come with tax I for one is not bothered putting my hand in the coffers as it as saved people from being destitute so that's why i dont give the government a hard time ......and to the people who are anti tory but are furlonged i just dont get it .plus we have brexit on the horizon so might aswell do it all together and struggle through it but having a massive devide wont help one bit .
(04-30-2020, 09:50 AM)billybassett Wrote: (04-30-2020, 09:32 AM)HeathAyIt Wrote: I floated this conversation right at the beginning with a colleague - basically would we be better off letting it run its course, all things factored in. The wider issue for me is our absolute obsession as a race with trying to control what will ultimately prove the uncontrollable. The thread about this being a 1 in a 100 year event got deleted but the reality is this will be far from unique or the biggest challenge in the coming decades. Its an opening shot, not a freak occurence. How we learn to evaluate and process our responses will be a huge factor in how humanity proceeds.
Firstly, it's a difficult balance. It is controllable but at an ultimately unpalatable cost. The whole world would need to stay indoors for 18 months or more. The halfway house is almost the worst of all worlds. It's still uncontrolled, the mechanisms for controlling it are flawed, the science is inconclusive and people will be people.
Secondly, this is a very mild virus. It is relatively contagious but not particularly deadly. With a growing population, cities expanding, changing habitats, increasing temperatures, ecosystems dying that provide checks and balances it is only matter of time before something far deadlier arrives. Then, if the way this pandemic has been handled is any indicator, we're screwed.
Some families really need to look how the family environment is done from now on ......especially the Asian community as they have 2/3 generations of families living together that's why they have been hit hard in this epidemic .
Posts: 3,032
Threads: 78
Joined: Jun 2019
Reputation:
22
(04-30-2020, 09:56 AM)The liquidator Wrote: Health over wealth mate look we all know we are fucked for years to come with tax I for one is not bothered putting my hand in the coffers as it as saved people from being destitute...
Well done, Liq.
This pandemic has created quite a lot of new-born Social Democrats. You (and they) are all welcome
Posts: 1,236
Threads: 71
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
3
In fairness Boris has us second top of the global death league. Im supporting him fervently to push us higher.
|