When will the lockdown get more strict??
#71
Some interesting points raised on here. IMO we are all going to get the virus, it's just about managing and controlling the infection rate. Our numbers roughly based on 3% of the population does mean approximately 2 million deaths which sounds awful, but over 2 years 1.2 million would be normal. Again it's important to see if CV19 deaths are separate and additional to the normal expected. I've not seen any data to confirm anything on normal last year v today's numbers. To try and simplify it 12,500 people normally pass away every week with or without CV19. We all need some numbers to work with. We all doing a lot of guesswork atm.
Reply
#72
(04-11-2020, 06:04 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Some interesting points raised on here. IMO we are all going to get the virus, it's just about managing and controlling the infection rate. Our numbers roughly based on 3% of the population does mean approximately 2 million deaths which sounds awful, but over 2 years 1.2 million would be normal. Again it's important to see if CV19 deaths are separate and additional to the normal expected. I've not seen any data to confirm anything on normal last year v today's numbers. To try and simplify it 12,500 people normally pass away every week with or without CV19. We all need some numbers to work with. We all doing a lot of guesswork atm.

Well it's looking like c7k per week attributed to Covid. How this works with other deaths is the question.
Reply
#73
While we are talking stats and ting. Some outlets are peddling a 10% death rate or other nonsenseical figures.

However they are not counting the numerous asymptomatic cases and all the other people who either have not been tested or have just isolated and recovered.

Trends based on Germany, who seem to be handling this extremely well, point to a more realistic approximate of around 1%..

That doesn't mean we shouldn't take it serious though because a scenario where everybody in the UK gets infected would be 650,000 deaths.
Reply
#74
(04-11-2020, 04:48 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: The figure of 250,000 was modelled by Imperial College London if we did not follow what other countries had done to flatten the curve. If we relax the rules anytime soon I cannot see without adequate testing of the public how it’ll stop the virus spiking again. The idea of opening schools for example before September will only put more people at risk. Fir example how do you keep a vulnerable  member of a family safe if their siblings are told to go back to school?

That's my point. We do have a lockdown - just not with the aim of eradicating the virus. So the study is not valid in this context, leaving aside it was modelled before we hardly knew anything about the virus.

If we don't go back to work and school before September, this country and much of the world would be bankrupt. The deaths that would cause when we can't afford to look after our most vulnerable, police our country, import medicines, food or fuel will make Corona virus look like a walk in the park. September just ain't going to happen - virus or no virus.
Reply
#75
(04-11-2020, 06:46 PM)HomersBelly Wrote: While we are talking stats and ting. Some outlets are peddling a 10% death rate or other nonsenseical figures.

However they are not counting the numerous asymptomatic cases and all the other people who either have not been tested or have just isolated and recovered.

Trends based on Germany, who seem to be handling this extremely well, point to a more realistic approximate of around 1%..

That doesn't mean we shouldn't take it serious though because a scenario where everybody in the UK gets infected would be 650,000 deaths.

Bang on.  That’s what I was saying on another thread (“Next Season”).  And 650,000 deaths would mean  6.5m in hospital which is never going to happen.  Therefore the 650k figure of deaths would be a lot higher as the NJS wouldn’t be able to cope.  It really is a fucking mess.  We didn’t do enough in the “containment” stage.
Reply
#76
The number of hospitalizations has flattened. This now needs to reduce.

Level of new cases is a misnomer, because more are being tested.
Reply
#77
Some of the figures quoted on this thread are way beyond what will come to pass.

Time will tell us.
Reply
#78
(04-11-2020, 01:23 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(04-11-2020, 11:17 AM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(04-11-2020, 10:47 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Herd immunity only works with a vaccine otherwise you’ll looking at hundreds of thousands of deaths in the U.K. We can’t (hmm) just letting it rip through the population

Herd Immunity explanation

You're suggesting herd immunity and exclusion are an either/or question. They're not. Therefore, the death toll you're headlining with is just not true.

We haven't got a vaccine and we don't know for sure we ever will have. What happens if it mutates quicker and more often than we hope? Even if we develop a 'vaccine' it will probably not prevent infection, but will reduce the severity to suffers - rather like the flu virus. There will still be deaths, especially among the vulnerable, and the virus will continue to spread.

Whichever way, it's not definite (although likely) we'll be able to develop any sort of vaccine, so we need a plan in case.

How are you realistically going to contain the virus inside the short time we have until the money runs out? You know that people will flout the rules and that is going to get more common as time goes on. Containment to the point of extinction is unlikely to work. Especially if the amount of asymptomatic carriers proves to be correct.

It's not about 'letting it rip' through the population, it's about focusing on giving the best possible care to the most serious sufferers. 
But consider your alternative. There's absolutely no evidence that 'lock-down' by itself can remove a virus once it's got to this level. It's never been done. So why are we doing it?

It's not about eradicating the virus, it's about giving us breathing time to bring down the death rate.

No solution is 'brilliant' and there will be victims, but we do need to do something. Relying on 'lock-down' , which has never worked before, whilst hoping a vaccine might be found is just doing nothing. 

You're painting lock-down as the caring approach and herd immunity as the callous approach. I don't agree with this hypothesis.

In the end, lock down with a view to waiting for virus extinction will fail and still have the same result - relying on 'herd immunity'.

All we can do is slow the growth in the short term so we can care for the serious sufferers. Which is what we are doing. Anything other solution is just fantasy.

Herd immunity is in conjunction with a vaccine. It’s not just let everyone get it over a prolonged period and hope for the best. 

My figures are not made up they were what was predicted by the same experts modelling that the government has been following. That’s one of the reasons they changed tack to lock down (debatable) as the death toll was predicted to be extremely high. 

I understand that the measures are to enable the NHS to cope and that the virus isn’t going away but numbers of infections should be minimised to the maximum over an extended period. Not just a shrug of the shoulders and say oh well we’ve got enough capacity in staff and ventilators now everyone back to work for example. 

Barely a week ago people were sneering (the usual ones) at Spain and Italy’s approach and we are on course to be worse hit than them. So at some point questions should be asked as to our approach.

We had a two week "start" on them and still messed it up.  It seems our leaders must have thought Italy were taking those measures for fun and we just sat back and watched it engulf us.
Reply
#79
(04-11-2020, 05:09 PM)strawman Wrote: Interesting (if you are interested in this kind of thing, or if you are bored enough to find this kind of thing) stats comparing the current year provisional registered deaths against the last 5 year average


Wk 13 W/E 27/3 11,141 deaths vs 5year average 10,130
Wk 12 W/E 20/3 10,645 deaths vs 5 year average 10,573
Wk 11 W/E 13/3 11,019 deaths vs 5 year average 11,205
Wk 10 W/E 06/3 10,895 deaths vs 5 year average 11,498


Make of it what you will, be interesting to see if this moves away massively from the 5 year average in the coming weeks, certainly an increase in the recent week

Spreadsheet available here ...

 https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationa...ndandwales
Yes but the reason that they are comparable and hopefully will remain so, is because of the measures taken. They are not a direct comparison. In all those previous years people were just living. If they were doing that now we would be dieing.
The 'only flu' brigade will hang on to these numbers to justify their 'over reaction' claims in the future. 
They would hate to lose face,  but trust me - it is complete bullshit.
Reply
#80
(04-11-2020, 10:12 PM)Swagbaggie Wrote:
(04-11-2020, 05:09 PM)strawman Wrote: Interesting (if you are interested in this kind of thing, or if you are bored enough to find this kind of thing) stats comparing the current year provisional registered deaths against the last 5 year average


Wk 13 W/E 27/3 11,141 deaths vs 5year average 10,130
Wk 12 W/E 20/3 10,645 deaths vs 5 year average 10,573
Wk 11 W/E 13/3 11,019 deaths vs 5 year average 11,205
Wk 10 W/E 06/3 10,895 deaths vs 5 year average 11,498


Make of it what you will, be interesting to see if this moves away massively from the 5 year average in the coming weeks, certainly an increase in the recent week

Spreadsheet available here ...

 https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationa...ndandwales
Yes but the reason that they are comparable and hopefully will remain so, is because of the measures taken. They are not a direct comparison. In all those previous years people were just living. If they were doing that now we would be dieing.
The 'only flu' brigade will hang on to these numbers to justify their 'over reaction' claims in the future. 
They would hate to lose face,  but trust me - it is complete bullshit.

Spot on, if we had just carried on as normal without any form of lockdown the daily fatalities would not be 8 or 9 hundred but in there thousands, we would pass those yearly comparisons in less than  a week. Comparing covid-19 to flu isn't a like for like comparison either, we have no vaccine or immunity to this where as the flu we have numerous vaccines and medications as well as herd immunity, take all those away and flu deaths would increase 10fold and we would more than like have to implement measures as we see now.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)